Former Commerce Secretary Gutierrez: H-1B visas are compatible with the 'America First' doctrine

Invest Insight
9 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 3, 2025
Former Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez joins CNBC's 'The Exchange' to discuss what he expects from Trump 2.0, how the president-elect will handle China and Mexico, and more.
Here to drill down on all of these issues former Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez. Mr. Secretary. It's great to have you back. Welcome
Do you want to kind of offer any context and some weren't sure if Trump was referring to actually the h-2b program
But either way on a couple of things where he could have gone
I guess you'd call it full MAGA the issue of the speaker and the issue of immigration
He's seems to be siding the other way
No, it's an interesting point because I if you think about the America first doctrine the question
Of course, the screen should be what is in the in America's interest?
What is in our best interest and I think the h-1b program is in our best interest
Do we want the world's best talent? Yes
So, you know
Opponents to immigration used to say it's not fair because we're taking people we're taking the high school people from countries
Well, we're thinking about America first. So I think it's very consistent
We're only talking about
65,000 visas out of potentially 30 million in that category
so I look the
The analogy of a sports team. I think is very appropriate
Do you want the best people on your team to begin to continue to win? Yes, we do
So I just think this is an objective issue that should be thought about objectively and not emotion
So I thought it was interesting on the Panama Canal
You think you might have some basis here for the criticism. Talk about that a little bit. Yeah, I think so
You know when the treaty was signed in?
1977 it was a different world. I don't think anybody can foresee back then that we would be in a in a geopolitical
rivalry and economic rivalry with China
Even in 1999 when the treaty took effect, so it's a different world and I think it's I don't think it's unreasonable
To demand that whatever happens in the Panama Canal does not
Go against the interest of the US
That is not an unreasonable demand or request and so I think the president is right, you know
It's not what's happening today
There is no evidence that there are that there's a military presence in the Panama Canal or in Panama
But the question is what will happen in 5 10 20 years the relationship in China and Panama is really just started in
2017 when China
broke diplomatic ties with Taiwan and
Opened up diplomatic relationship with the People's Republic of China
Yeah
So, you know we have to see in that context so in that context and as you've mentioned this Chinese company Hutchinson from Hong Kong
Operates two of the five ports in the Panama Canal
What should the US do should they basically take a tough line and say that that ought to be divested
Well, you're right
Hutchinson has two ports throughout Hong Kong of the five and
Everything to this day suggests that they are abiding by the rules. They operate the port obviously don't own it
so I'm not sure that that's an issue, but I think we have to
make sure that the
That the guidelines of the requirements
Look at what could happen in five years and ten years and 15 years
I think it operates three ports all five ports. So we need to look towards the future, but
You know, that's not an issue right now who operates the port
But we need to think about where does it go from here? Yeah, you know, we need to think about the future
So speaking on that point, I mean, are you concerned about the direction that Mexico is headed?
you know kind of broadly speaking between these issues these ties with Chinese between the security situation at the border kind of
Some of the problems that's causing down in the southern part of the US
They do have a new administration, but a lot of this has been festering for 10 20 years now
Yeah, I think this is something that we need to take up with Mexico not with China
And again, I think it comes down to Mexico. You're our neighbor
You shouldn't want something that impedes our national interest that goes against our interest
Regrettably a lot of what China does a lot of what they have done
Goes against our interests and and that's something that Mexico should be able to recognize the question of course is so what do we do?
What kind of a negotiation we put in place? What kind of an agreement do we put in place?
I think it'll have to be very selective by industry company by company, but
It's the right time to bring this up because we need to be looking at
What are the longer-term effects what can happen in the future? Yeah
Secretary Gutierrez, thanks for your time today and for kind of giving us a sense of where things might be headed this year
We appreciate it. Thank you Carlos Gutierrez
