Trump’s proposed $5 million Golden Visa aims to attract wealthy global investors, promising U.S. residency and a path to citizenship. However, the feasibility of the program is questionable, given the limited number of individuals who can afford it. Market analysis suggests the demand may be significantly lower than Trump's estimates, with competition from other countries offering more affordable options. Questions remain about whether the U.S. will require direct payments or adopt an investment-based approach similar to Europe. Additionally, strict financial scrutiny could deter applicants, particularly from China and Russia. While some crypto investors or corporate-backed applicants might qualify, high costs and regulatory concerns make broad adoption unlikely. The program’s impact on U.S. economic policy, sovereign wealth funds, and immigration trends remains uncertain, especially as other nations refine their own residency schemes.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
hi I'm Dong Seong welcome to Digging to
China where we explore China in depth to
review unique perspectives today let's
talk about something a little lighter
it's the weekend so let's keep things
relaxed back on February 25th Trump
announced a new golden visa program
designed to attract global millionaires
and the top talent the program costs $5
million and in return buyers get a gold
card which grants permanent residency
similar to a green card and a path to US
citizenship trump said this plan would
replace the current EB5 investor visa
program and take effect in March he even
claimed it would generate a massive
revenue for the US and help pay off the
national debt most golden visas around
the world don't lead to citizenship
countries like uh Portugal Spain and
Greece have similar programs but the
path to citizenship is complicated
trump's $5 million gold card does
include a citizenship option but the
details remain unclear there's also no
cap on the number of applicants whether
a million or 10 million people apply the
program stays open if a million people
applied that would bring in $5 trillion
trump even suggests that if 10 million
applied it would generate $50 trillion
enough to wipe out the $30 trillion
national debt and still leave 20
trillion for a US sovereign wealth fund
if Trump were a businessman pitching
this plan to investors he'd be laughed
at why because a solid business plan has
three key parts first it identifies the
problem what issue needs solving this
requires market analysis how big is the
market what's the growth potential what
needs aren't being met and what
obstacles exist second it explains how
the solution works and third it
highlights why only this specific team
can succeed what expertise or advantages
do they have of these market analysis is
the most critical how many people can
actually afford a $5 million visa it's
hard to determine because of financial
privacy but based on public wealth
reports about 4 million individuals and
households worldwide have over $5
million in total assets not cash just
total assets trump's assumption that 1
to 10 million people would buy this visa
completely ignores market realities a
proper market analysis consider current
numbers future trends comparisons market
share and conversion rates let's break
it down of the 4 million high net worth
household worldwide about 40% are
already in North America 25 to 30% are
in Europe 10% in the Middle East and
another 10% in Asia including Japan
South Korea and Singapore china's
numbers are harder to pin down would all
these wealthy individuals who want to
move to the US even if they did the
total pool of wealthy people wouldn't
increase the market would shrink now
let's compare this to other countries
portugal's golden visa requires just
500,000 euros how many people apply for
that annually trump hasn't done this
kind of comparison market share is
crucial other countries including Canada
and the European nations are competing
for the same wealthy immigrants if
Portugal charges 500,000 euros while the
US demands $5 million a tenfold
difference how competitive can the US
really be us Commerce Secretary Howard
Lutnaker claimed 250,000 people would
apply for the US Golden Visa but where
does this number come from for context
the EB5 investor visa requires an
investment of
$500,000 to $1.5 million in a business
that creates at least 10 jobs the
program has an annual cap of 10,000
slots with an approval rate of just 16%
that means out of 100 applicants only 16
get approved right now around the 9 to
10,000 Chinese investors are in line for
the EV5 visa so how did they come up
with
$250,000 applicants for Trump's golden
visa if the estimate of 4 million
households with $5 million in assets is
accurate the real target market for this
program is probably around 400 to
500,000 individuals since there's a
competition let's assume the US captures
60% of the market that's 200 to 300,000
potential applicants but not everyone in
that group will actually apply a
reasonable conversion rate might be
20,000 applicants would people actually
put up $5 million for this visa some
might take a $5 million loan using $10
million in assets as collateral before
China's real estate crash many Chinese
investors would have done exactly that
if Trump had launched this program
during his first term a significant
number of Chinese investors might have
participated but today many banks that
once issued such loans are stuck with
the bad debt another key issue the $5
million must come from legal income if
an applicant can't prove where the money
came from the US would take the funds
and denied a visa no refunds for Chinese
citizens legally earning $5 million is
extremely difficult as the saying goes
no one gets rich without the windfalls
and no horse gets fat without the night
grazing if you are just a salaried
worker following the rules making $5
million is nearly impossible and after
spending $5 million on a visa how would
you sust your lifestyle in the US that's
another major concern could big US
companies buy golden visas for talent
apple or Google could in theory purchase
them for top employees instead of
relying on the H-1B visa lottery but
would they not likely $5 million is
enough to open a new office in Canada
and hire multiple employees making this
an inefficient solution and if a company
sponsors an employes golden visa and
they later resign what then would the
startup founders buy these visas
companies like a Shen Yin DD Locking
Coffee and a bite dance could be
interested they have high valuations
they aren't publicly visited they
undergo regular audits without issue and
many founders or early employees hold
stock options worth over $5 million some
might convert that equity into a gold
card especially if tax incentives are
involved so who are the real targets
customers of this $5 million golden visa
it seems aimed at wealthy individuals
from China Russia and the Middle East a
few thousand people might be interested
but again in China most individuals with
over $5 million in assets didn't earn it
in ways that would pass US scrutiny if a
Chinese individual were to buy a golden
visa for $5 million and immigrate to the
US and if the Chinese government later
targeted them in the anti-corruption
crackdown issuing a red notice through
the interpool the US would happily keep
the money and send the person back so
these corrupt officials from China might
not actually dare to come so who else
might be able to buy a golden visa and
immigrate people in the crypto industry
could be potential candidates they have
income and for some inexplicable reasons
they often have a lot of money however
the legitimacy of their funds is often
in a gray area for example Singapore
previously used the Golden Visa to
attract a large number of such
individuals but once they arrived the
government started cracking down on
money laundering scrutinizing the
origins of their wealth leaving them in
an awkward situation right now the
situation is that everyone is talking
about it right could the amount be
adjusted will it be $5 million 4 million
$3 million or $8 million there's no
final confirmation yet and it's highly
unlikely that the US will simply ask for
a direct payment most golden visa and
investment visa programs don't work that
way instead applicants usually invest in
government designated funds in Europe
golden visa typically offer three
options one investing in a local
business this requires a relatively
large sum two buying into a government
designated fund this costs slightly less
and three in some countries purchasing
property is allowed you could buy a
house for a few hundred,000 euros but
this would only grant you a visa not
citizenship which is much harder to
obtain i expect that the US will likely
adopt a similar approach requiring
deposits investments in commercial
projects or contribution to national
funds malaysia's Malaysia My Second Home
program for example requires a deposit
of 500,000 or 1 million Malaysia ringit
malaysia is actually quite strict about
this if you deposit a smaller amount the
validity period is very short and you
must undergo regular reviews but if you
deposit a large amount like 5 million
ringit you get permanent residency
without any further scrutiny and usually
these government funds offer interest
and returns in other words when you
deposit your money they pay you interest
take Portugal for example its golden
visa program requires an investment of
€500,000 in a government fund with a
six-year lockin period during those six
years you cannot withdraw the money but
you can earn an annual return of 7% to
15% after the locking period you can
withdraw your funds while still keeping
your residency status moreover these
government funds can be used as
collateral if I invest 500,000 in
Portugal's government fund I can still
use that as collateral for a bank loan
and if something happens to me my son
can inherit it i believe the US will
most likely take a similar approach it
wouldn't just pocket the money the funds
will likely go into a sovereign wealth
fund with a lockin period during which
it will generate returns the US
government can then use the sovereign
wealth fund for operations using the
profits to offset national debt rather
than simply taking $5 million per
applicant and hoping to fill the debt
hole that way that's unlikely to happen
another factor in the US is that
individual states will likely have their
own specific regulations the federal
government can just collect $5 million
and claim the applicant as its own
responsibility that wouldn't work the
person will still have to be settled in
a particular state and each state may
have its own arrangements for this as
for China first of all China does not
have an exit tax for high netw worth
individuals this is quite rare the US
for instance impose an exit tax on those
who renounce their citizenship if you
immigrate and transfer assets you may
have to pay capital gains tax or other
fees but in China there is no exit tax
after all the rules are set by those who
benefit from them when Chinese citizens
immigrate they can transfer all their
assets through banks or other means
without being taxed this is a unique
aspect of China will China introduce an
exit tax in the future that remains to
be seen but in the future China may also
need to attract immigrants what many
people don't realize is that China
actually has its own version of a golden
visa since China's population is
declining rapidly it also needs to bring
in immigrants in China an investment of
$500,000 and three years of tax payments
can grant permanent residency china does
have a permanent residence permit which
allows holders to stay indefinitely as
long as they don't commit crimes or face
deportation however it doesn't grant
citizenship but that doesn't really
matter since Chinese citizen don't come
up with voting rights anyway the only
condition is that you must reside in
China for a few months each year if you
don't return for one or two years your
permanent residency status will be
revoked how many foreigners have applied
for permanent residency in China the
Chinese government has never released an
official figure however according to
publicly available data as of 2017 the
number of foreigners holding Chinese
permanent residence exceeded 10,000 for
the first time that's enough talk for
today time to kick back and enjoy the
weekend the Golden Visa debate is fun to
ponder but let's be real it's more of a
cocktail party topic than a serious
dilemma whether it's corrupt officials
crypto millionaires or just rich folks
hedging their bets there's always a
twist anyway something to chat about
over coffee cheers to the weekend if you
found this video helpful please like it
drop a comment below and hit the
subscribe button right here it really
helps YouTube suggest my video to others
i'll be back with more content soon
until then be well