"The Philosopher of Duty. Life and Ethics of Immanuel Kant."

History TV Epic
4 followers
6 Video ViewsยทDec 28, 2024
He always went to bed at exactly the same time, he never married, and his neighbors used his
timed walks to set their clocks to the precise time of day. Meet Immanuel Kant, one of the more
eccentric members of the philosophy profession, but also perhaps the biggest mind of the past
300 years. In our series on famous philosophy quotes, today we will talk about Kant's ideas
Kant says, act so as to treat humanity, whether in your own person or in that of another,
at all times also as an end and not only as means. Immanuel Kant, who lived from 1724 to 1804,
was one of the most influential philosophers of the past 200 years. And he is also the embodiment
of a philosopher who is so busy with his own thoughts that he completely fails to notice
the world around him. One of his favorite pastimes was to visit a friend, a Mr. Green. Kant would go
to Green's home at a particular hour, but he always found him asleep every single time. This
was a kind of ritual between them, so Kant would sit on a chair beside Green and also doze off.
A little later, a third friend would come along, find the two sleeping, sit down in another chair
and also fall asleep. After a while, more friends would come in, they would wake everybody up,
and then they would have a blast talking about philosophy, discussing, drinking coffee,
until precisely seven o'clock. At seven o'clock, everybody would get up and they would go,
each one to their own homes. The locals, who were used at this weird meeting, would know exactly
when it was seven o'clock, because it was the time when the professor Kant would pass in front of
their window on his way home. Kant needed this kind of regularity and could be profoundly unhappy
when something went wrong. One time, he was invited by an acquaintance to a trip to the
countryside. The friend took him along and they went and visited beautiful places, but they were
a little late when they came home. And finally, when Kant arrived at his home, it was past his
customary ten o'clock sleeping time. And he was so shocked and upset by this, that he swore to himself
never to go on a trip with another person to the countryside. Kant would be charming and witty,
his students wrote, but he would also be extremely strange. At some point in his life, his long-time
servant, a man called Lampe, left him. And Kant was suddenly alone, he didn't know how to manage
the household, and he found it very difficult to accustom himself to a life without his servant.
So he decided that he would have to forget the servant entirely. In order to achieve this,
he wrote little notes and posted them on the walls and on the doors of cupboards, saying,
we have to forget Lampe. One wonders if the wise man expected this to actually work. Kant
never left his hometown Kรถnigsberg, which today is called Kaliningrad. He never married,
he never changed his diet, and he died at the old age of eighty, famous, happy, and presumably
mildly bored, and his last words were, it's fine. In the course of his long and externally uneventful
life, Kant created some of the most important works of philosophy of all times. In his
Critique of Pure Reason, for example, he tries to find out what the limits of reason are,
what we can know with our reason alone, and how our thoughts relate to our experiences
from the world around us. But what we are interested in today are his ethics. Today
we are accustomed to the idea that we are all products of natural evolution, that humans are
animals like other animals. But this was not the case in Kant's time, and this was certainly not
something Kant would have agreed to. Kant thought that human beings are special because they have
an ability that no other animal has. And this ability is the ability to be autonomous, to have
one's own ideas about how to live, to be able to distinguish for oneself according to one's
own criteria which actions are good, which actions are bad, what is moral, what is not moral, and then
to act accordingly. And he called this autonomy. This autonomy is something that animals don't have
at all. If you have a lion that is hungry, and in front of the lion is a zebra, the lion will eat
the zebra. If you have an ant, and in front of the ant is a crumb of bread, the ant will go
and carry this crumb of bread away. The animals cannot resist the urges that come from their
nature, from their instincts. But human beings can. We can, for example, go on a diet. We can say
today I won't eat. And we can do that no matter how hungry we are, no matter how much we feel
that we are suffering doing this. We can force ourselves to do that. We can also starve ourselves
to death. There are people who have gone on hunger strikes for political reasons, and humans are able
to not eat until they die. This is something that no animal can do. In a more moderate context,
nobody can ever force anyone else to do anything. Yes, we have laws that forbid us, for example,
to attack other people, to kill people, to steal things. But we are voluntarily obeying these laws.
If you think about it, the law doesn't really take away your ability to steal something,
for example. You could still steal something and hope to get away with it, and many people do.
Or you could accept that you will get caught, but still go and steal that thing that you want to
have. When you obey a law, you obey it voluntarily, always. You are saying to yourself,
it's me. I don't want to steal. It's not the law that makes it impossible for me to steal.
If I really wanted it, I could do it. I would have perhaps some consequences, but I could perform
the action. If I don't perform the action, if I don't steal, then this is always due to my own
free decision to not steal. According to Kant, this gives human beings a special value that no
other creature has. We can replace things with other things. I can replace my car with another
car. If I lose a pen, I can buy another pen of the same type or of a different type, and I can
exchange money for things. I can sell something, or I can buy something with money. This even
applies to animals. I can buy a dog. I can buy a cat. I can buy a number of chickens. But according
to Kant, this is not the same for human beings. Human beings don't have a price, because they have
this special power to be autonomous, and this autonomy is so valuable that it cannot be seen
as being on the same level as all the other things. Human beings, because of their autonomy,
are something special that is above everything else. Kant calls this human dignity, this special
value of human beings, which is different from the price that other things have. Everything for Kant
has a price, but only humans have a dignity. Now, in the quote we saw at the beginning, Kant was
talking about means and ends. What does this mean? Let's say I have a pen that I forgot at a friend's
house, and now I want to have my pen back, so I will take a taxi and let the taxi drive me to my
friend's house, where I can pick up the pen that I forgot there. If the pen, let's say, has a value
of $100 and the taxi costs only $20, then it would be rational, it would be a good idea to take this
taxi and go there. But now, if the pen is only $5 worth and the taxi costs $30 or $40 because my
friend lives a little farther away, then it would be irrational. I wouldn't pay $40 to the taxi in
order to get my pen back that is worth only $5. If you think about this, you come up with a rule that
Kant wants to suggest, that the means, which is the tools that we use, the instruments that we use
to achieve something, must always be less valuable than the end that we're pursuing, the end in the
sense of the goal that we want to achieve. If what I want to achieve is to get the pen, then my means
of getting this pen must be less valuable than the pen itself. Otherwise, I'm doing something
irrational. I'm doing something that does not make sense. I'm paying $40 to the taxi in order to get
a $5 pen back. So Kant concludes that the means that are used to achieve some ends must always
be less valuable than the end. And now you can bring this together with the realization we had
previously, that human beings have a special value that is different from all other values of the
things in the world, because they don't have a price, they have a dignity, and the dignity cannot be
expressed in terms of price. Therefore, Kant now concludes, human beings can never be used as means
to some other end only, because this would be irrational, because human beings are so much more
valuable than every other thing. They are so much more valuable, not only in terms of an amount
of value, but they are in a totally different category. So we can never use human beings as means
to achieve another end, only as means. Acting in such a way that respects this rule, make sure
that we always respect the human dignity of others, and that our action is morally right.
But there is a catch here. If we are not careful, if we don't look at the details, we might understand
this as saying that human beings should never be treated as means. But obviously this is impossible.
When you take a taxi to go somewhere, the taxi driver is a means for you to get there. The same
with bus drivers. When I go to a restaurant, the person who is serving me the food, or the cook in
the kitchen, these people are means for me to get my lunch. And at this moment, when you are
listening to this video, you use me as a means to your education about Kant. So we are always using
other people as means in a society in which we don't do everything ourselves. We are always using
somebody else as means to our own ends. So is this therefore immoral? Are we not allowed to take buses
or taxis or to go to restaurants? Obviously not. This is why Kant says we should not treat others
only as means. But we can treat them as means if we also treat them as ends at the same time.
And how do we do this? When I take a taxi, I pay the taxi driver. In this way, I am treating him as
means, yes, to my own goal, but I am also giving him the ability, through the money I pay, to pursue
his own ends. So treating someone as an end means to give them the ability to pursue their own ends
as they see fit, which in the end means to exercise their own autonomy. The taxi driver
can exercise his autonomy after his eight-hour shift is over, and then he is a free human being,
he takes all the money he has collected, and he can pursue his own ends. And in this way,
the same applies for the cook and the waiter. And in this way, every one of us is at some point in
their lives the means to other people's ends. But also we make sure that we are all treated as ends
at the same time. When this is not the case, then we have a bad moral situation, when we treat others
as means only without giving them any ability to pursue their own ends. This is for example the
case with slavery. This is the case when we exploit workers, perhaps child workers in the third world,
that create cheap t-shirts for us to consume. And we don't care whether these children are able to
get an education or to pursue their goals. If we do that, then we are treating someone only as means
and not as an end. The same of course with crime. If a criminal steals something, he is treating the
victim of the theft as a means only, to his own advantage, but not as an end. So in this way,
Kant thinks that if we really take this seriously, this one rule alone, that we should treat others
as ends, is sufficient to give us a moral compass, to tell us how we should actually act in our lives,
so that we are morally good agents. If we follow Kant's advice, we will never sacrifice a human
being in order to achieve any goal. We will not sacrifice human soldiers, for example, in order to
win a war. We will not mistreat people in prisons, just in order to keep them away from us, so
that we can feel safe. We will not lie to someone else, in order to secure an advantage for ourselves.
Kant's categorical imperative, as this idea is called, is actually pretty demanding, if you think
about it. Look around at your everyday life and think how often you are actually using someone,
perhaps people you don't know, people at the end of some consumer chain, as a means only,
without making sure that you are treating them as ends and giving them the ability to pursue
their own ends. Just think how much better our world would be, if everyone acted following Kant's
idea. If we treated the soldier, the worker, the prisoner, the prostitute, the beggar, as ends,
and not only as means. Act so, Kant says, as to treat humanity, whether in your own person or in
that of another, always also as an end, and not only as means. Thank you. See you next time.
