Do We Live In A Simulation... | Professor Brian Keating

Steven Bartlett
3 followers
Dec 16, 2024
What is, just for people that don't know, what is the simulation theory and are we living in a
simulation? Great question. So the simulations theory was really conjectured by a British
philosopher, or he's actually Swedish, I believe, Nick Bostrom. He conjectured the following,
he said compute is getting so phenomenally powerful in just our recent time horizon.
So the notion that Nick and others have proposed is that if this is extrapolated
indefinitely into the future, whether or not that can happen is a question about planetary
resources, part of the reason Elon wants to go to Mars, and I do want to talk to you about Mars in
a bit. And that extrapolation leads inexorably to the conclusion that compute will be effectively
free and it'll be infinite. It'll be completely democratized, it'll be completely demonetized,
as I said, too cheap to measure the expense of computing, and it'll be everywhere in just a
short amount of time. Remember, the phone that we have, the iPad that you're using, these things
would literally be mythological witchcraft 80 years ago, and now they're commonplace.
And so the notion that Nick proposed, Bostrom proposed, is that that trend continues into the
future, that basically the capability of those computers would be to be able to model entire
planets, entire ecosystems, even cultures, communities, maybe even people themselves.
So let's take a parallel detour for just a bit. You're not seeing me necessarily,
you're seeing photons are coming into your retinas, right? Photons are packets of energy,
form of light, they travel at the speed of light, they have different wavelengths,
the wavelengths we call color. They're going into your cornea, getting bent a little bit,
then they're going to your lens, getting bent more, then they're going to your retina,
and they're getting detected on this basically a detector, just like a sensor in a camera,
which has pixels, except it has trillions of pixels instead of millions of megapixels,
or a few megapixels, and those are being transduced. The color gets transduced on
cells that are called cone cells, the intensity is rod cells, and those are getting transduced
into electrical impulses that go from the optic nerve right into your brain. And remember,
Andrew Huberman told you on the show, the retina is the only part of the human brain that's outside
of the cranium, it's outside of the skull. And so it's a part of your brain that's outside,
so it transduces it, makes electrical impulses, those electrical impulses then get conducted
like wires conducting electricity, and then those go into your brain and synapses in your brain and
the neural pathways in your brain can reproduce those. Now, you have an Apple Vision Pro,
I think I saw you with once, so that can, you know, kind of simulate, it could make very
accurate representation of me, a holographic perhaps, and you would want to reach out and
touch me. Now imagine instead of just the physical electronics of a headset, Apple Vision Pro,
you just inject the electrical signals into the brain. So that's plausible, it's just purely
physical material processes. Photons converted to electrons, get converted to neuron signals,
get processed in the brain. And so all you have to do is get that input sensory inputs,
and you can have a digital retina, a fake retina, and you just stimulate it, it goes into your brain,
they're working on that. Same with sound, sound is even easier, you put a little speaker in your ear
and you'd hear it. But, so the notion is that we could physically just be disconnected brains
in a vat, right? We could just be in this vast system, just bunches of brains, don't ask how
they got there, but we're all just receiving stimuli, and we're just being fed, I'm being fed
an image of you over there, you're being fed an image of me over here. I don't know why,
nobody knows why this would occur, but the computing power is there. If you think that
the Apple Vision Pro, if you were alive in 1971, you could not have necessarily predicted the Apple
Vision Pro. It was too far advanced from what we have, from what we had at that point in time.
But imagine it just keeps increasing at any rate you like, eventually there'll be a point
where every bit of information, every atom in the universe, every photon in the universe could
theoretically be simulated. Again, I don't know why this is, but it would be indistinguishable
from our reality, according to people like Nick Bostrom and others, that suggest this is so,
so that our existence is, we are essentially in a simulation. So the notion is that we're all
these characters in this literal simulation, run on some computing device, some hardware device,
that we don't necessarily understand at this point. And we're calling that God. Well, that's
how it's going to get to. So eventually you get to a point where if you could simulate everything,
then you would have to ask, there must be some simulator, right, there must be some master
simulator. So let's say I'm a simulation. Well, who simulated me? And then, oh, who simulated
them? And then who simulated them? So that's the recursion, that's infinite regress. You can't
actually get to a base level of, you know, a final simulator. And if you did, it would kind of be like
God. Like you're talking about this brain in a jar that's created out of silicon and oxygen and
whatever we're made of, but it's physically created by human beings. What if you can't pay the power
bill that week and, you know, you have to choose between unplugging your refrigerator or unplugging
the brain. Like, is that killing something? You know, like it starts to enter into the realm of
ethics and maybe even these concepts of a deity. What I've heard, and I find quite plausible,
is, remember I said the implication of having infinite computing is that you can simulate
everything in the universe. But can it simulate itself? So I want to digress into what's called
complexity theory. There are two different types of difficult things. There's like a complex thing,
like building an Airbus 320. It's very complicated, right? You can do it if I give you all the parts,
all the instructions, give you the right order, and I keep you energized. Like, anybody can follow
those instructions and make it. The Earth's weather pattern state right now is complex. There's no way
that you can actually create that. Like, you would need another planet-sized thing to create that.
That's called irreducibly complex. You cannot make it simpler and then build it up from simpler
and simpler things. Unlike an Airbus, you can build it up from smaller and smaller parts, and as long
as you follow the recipe, you know, if you follow the recipe for the Simons Observatory, you'll get
the Simons Observatory. But if you try to simulate, and it may be to simulate the weather, you do need
another planet. Like, we need another planet, just like the Earth, and then we'd introduce carbon
dioxide at a certain rate, and we'd see, is it really going to cause it? Like, that's totally
impractical, right? So, the question of these things is, is it really a simulation if it's not
a hundred percent? Like, you could make a very, very good weather simulation. We do have that.
But famously, they're only accurate for a few days, right? So, how do you build up, you know,
an accurate simulator? It'd have to be the same. So, in other words, do we need, like, another,
is there another universe where the simulators are that's equally complex to the simulation
creation that they made? And then, did they stop, like, did they get, are they made of silica? Are
they artificial? Are they? So, there are proposals that you could detect the presence. It's kind of
like you mentioned the Truman Show. How all computers work right now is on this binary code,
zeros and ones, five volts, zero volts. But, and that means that the world is fundamentally
discretized. It's broken into little chunks, like the screen on your computer or your iPad.
It's pixelated. In space, it'd be called voxels, volume elements. And so, you can have a large
number of them, but it's a big difference between a large number and infinity. To really have a
continuous, like, temperature is continuous. Like, go from zero degrees to a hundred degrees,
and there's every step in between. But in the simulated world, because you couldn't have,
you need an infinite number of computer power to simulate just from zero degrees to one degree.
Let alone from zero to a hundred or every possible combination. So, at some level, you'd see,
if you zoomed in really close on the thermometer, you'd see, oh, there's a little jump. So, you
could detect the presence of the simulator. It's more complicated. Actually, it's done using
astrophysical sources called gamma ray bursts and other things that have properties that are
seemingly incompatible with there being a simulation at the most distant and therefore
earliest moments in the universe. So, right now, there's zero evidence for it. Nick Bostrom will
tell you, and you should have him on, that, you know, that that's basically a cop-out and there
are ways around that fail-safe mechanism. If you love the DRIVERS CEO brand and you
watch this channel, please do me a huge favor. Become part of the 15% of the viewers on this
channel that have hit the subscribe button. It helps us tremendously, and the bigger the
channel gets, the bigger the guests.
