Jimmy Carr On Andrew Tate & Men's Mental Heath Crisis

Steven Bartlett
3 followers
8 Video Views·Dec 19, 2024
This idea of, you know, depression is essentially thinking about yourself too much.
You, last time we spoke on the podcast, you talked about...
I would say, yeah, sorry, that feels to me maybe a little bit too harsh. Because I think people
suffer with depression and that's a, it's a disease. And it's incredibly serious. And we
think of suicide as being something that stands alone. It's not, it's a symptom of a disease
called depression, right? So it's the, it's the permanent solution to a temporary problem.
You don't want to feel this way anymore, but actually you don't want to feel nothing anymore.
You'd like to feel better. So it's that thing of like, I don't think we talk about it enough,
but I think that thing of, you know, thinking about yourself all the time, I think it just
leads to a, can lead to a melancholy, a sadness. I think depression is maybe a slightly separate
thing. Not to nitpick, but it feels like that's a disease. And there's also a lot of sadness in
the world. And you're lucky if you're sad, because if you're sad, it's circumstantial
and you can do something about it. You know, are you depressed because you have a serotonin
imbalance in your head and it's a heritable trait? Or are you sad because your life hasn't worked
out the way you want it to work out? Well, if that's the case, the latter, you're in luck
because you can change that. It does feel like there's a bit of a crisis going on within young
men at the moment. And I think your new show on Netflix shines a light on many of the difficulties
that young men are facing. I was really excited to talk to you about this particular topic,
because I've been trying to arrive at a position myself on why so many young men appear to be lost
and suicidality has increased. And there's, you know, these new masculine influences
or masculine influencers that are really rounding up this cohort of young men.
Who are we talking about? Andrew Tate? Andrew Tate of the world.
Well, Andrew Tate's interesting, isn't he? Because who made the, I think John Mulaney
made the observation, Trump is a poor person's idea of what a rich person looks like.
Yeah, I've got gold taps. And I think Andrew Tate is like a 14-year-old boy's idea of what
masculinity might look like. And of course, nature abhors a vacuum and there's a real vacuum
for elders. Like we now, we don't learn how to shave from our fathers. It's a YouTube video.
And so you lose something in that bonding. So there's a big bit in the new show where I give
a young guy, an audience member, a pretty tough time. Like we have the talk and I give them advice
on how to be with a woman. And it's, I'm not wrong about anything. It's really funny and
it's really rude, but I'm not wrong about stuff. It's like, it's about consent. And it's,
I think it's really good because I've sugared the pill of the message because people don't
want to talk about it. People go, it's obvious what consent is. Yeah, not to 17-year-old boys
or girls. It's like, actually, what does that look like and how should that be?
So it's, yeah, it's a really fun routine. It's a really fun routine to perform, right?
What is it to be a man these days? Because it's quite confusing in terms, even the conversation
around like chivalry and understanding, you know. Well, people talk about toxic masculinity and
easy fix. Be a gentleman, be a mensch. That's it. This is done. Be a gentleman, be a mensch.
You know, a gentleman is never rude by accident. It's Christopher Hitchens line. Great. I don't
know. I mean, my thing about young men today, if I was going to give young men advice, it would be
get the right drugs and the real thing, right? In real life, live in real life, right? So why
young men are obsessed by video games, right? Obsessed. They're spending hours and hours and
hours online playing video games. Why? Well, that's a proxy for career, right? Video games.
You think about the levels of video games and what people do on video games. That's a proxy.
That's like a, it's a substitute for the career that they're not having. And then they spend a
lot of time, you know, fapping to Pornhub or YouPorn or whatever. And that's a proxy for sex.
And my thing would be George Orwell wasn't right. Our power won't be taken away from us by some
authoritarian master. We're going to give it away for cheap dopamine. And the cheap dopamine of
video games and online porn and living online is getting in the way of real life. So it's risk,
right? That's what we're not allowing young people to do because we're saying to young people,
you can't take risks in real life. We're helicopter parenting. We're not giving them
the freedom. How much freedom should you give a kid? As much as they can cope with,
right? Fourteen-year-olds used to be babysitters. They now need babysitters.
That's not good, right? So you should allow them more freedom in the real world because otherwise
the only place they get freedom is online. No freedom in the real world. You're not allowed
to go to the park and hang out, but you're allowed to do whatever you want online.
Well, that's a, that feels like a very bad social experiment.
That feels like a bad idea. It feels like we've inverted, you know, Maslow, this pyramid hierarchy
of needs and you go off food and shelter and warmth and all that. We've got all the bottom
stuff worked out in our society, right? We kind of can't see it. We're not grateful for that because
we can't see- The hot shower.
The hot shower. We can't see the third world and we can't see the people in the past having a tougher
time than us. So we take it for granted, but we worked out that stuff. They hadn't worked that
stuff out 200 years ago, but they had the top of the pyramid sorted. Everyone knew who they were.
They had their identity and they knew what their purpose was. Everyone knew who they were, what
they were about, and they were connected to the others in the group. And now we're kind of
free-floating individuals. We kind of worship the individual as if we can survive as individuals.
I always think of that thing of like, there's no such thing as a baby.
There's a baby and a mother, there's a baby and a father, baby and an auntie, but there's no such
thing as a baby because a baby on its own isn't anything. It's dead. It needs taken care of.
We're all still babies. We all need the connections. Yourself, sure, there's a lot of
yourself that's within you, but a lot of it is out in the world. It's connected to other people
and it mediates who you think you are. That's slightly missing from society where you live
online and you're a self-authored thing. You're just on the computer, on the screen,
and you're not connected and you're not taking risks. Taking risks is really important.
Is this in part due to the rise in atheism and agnosticism? I think we both, me and you,
lost our religious faith around the same age. I think it's a weird thing where
I certainly don't believe in the stories. There's two types of fools. There's people
that take religion literally and there's people that think it has no value.
Both idiots for different reasons. It works as a thing, religion. I miss it because the reason
the ceremony works isn't because God's pleased, it's because the people came together. I think
we look for things that are proxies for religion. Sometimes that's football, it could be
environmentalism because you go, I need purpose in my life. I need to feel like I'm adding value
and what a great cause. I'm going to save the planet. It's a big thing to think about. It's
got a religiosity to it but I don't think that's necessarily the answer. Some people do it with
politics. They think politics is going to be heaven. They're going to come up with some
perfect system. I think you're putting too much pressure on politics. First time I've ever said
this actually but when you just said I think I miss religion, I think I miss religion.
Nice wasn't it? It's a lovely thought as well when you lose someone that you love very much.
It's a lovely thought. I mean heaven is just, it's a lovely thought and I think in a way, in our
culture, fame and fortune has replaced heaven. It's the land of milk and honey and where you can feel
everything's okay. Everything's taken care of and it is good but it's not heaven. I don't
believe in an afterlife. I believe in the next life. So I don't think anything happens after
you die but I think you can have a next life, a very different life. So it's interesting you're
at this point of your life when you're thinking about well we might start a family. It's a whole
other life. It's a whole other, you'll hardly recognize yourself. You and your partner will be
saying what did we do? What did we do all day? Now we're not a pepper pig world or wherever you
find yourselves. This really just struck me that I do kind of miss religion but it feels like when
I lost my religion I put a backpack on, a backpack full of weights on and I think that's what the
responsibility and individualism is. I mean for me the loss of religion was a rush of blood to
the head. It was like oh I, this is my life and I need to make good on this and I need to live it.
The tragedy is most people don't have that kind of, they don't get to kind of follow their
their dream. If you love the Driver CEO brand and you watch this channel please do me a huge favour
become part of the 15% of the viewers on this channel that have hit the subscribe button.
It helps us tremendously and the bigger the channel gets the bigger the guests.
