The Mets Are Taking A Smart Risk
iTalk Studios
908 followers
The Mets Are Taking A Smart Risk
#mlb #baseball #sports
LG Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_LG
Amazon Store Link - https://bit.ly/iTalkStudios_FireTV
iTALK STUDIOS INSTAGRAM: https://instagram.com/italk.studios?utm_medium=copy_link
iTALK STUDIOS TWITTER/X: https://twitter.com/italkstudiosyt?s=21
iTALK STUDIOS SECOND CHANNEL: @iTalkStudiosExtra
iTALK STUDIOS LIVE CHANNEL: @italkstudioslive
VIDEO MUSIC CREDIT TO @mikhelvin AND @samuelkimmusic
Mik
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/3jaB7yS
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mikhelvin
Samuel Kim
► Spotify: https://spoti.fi/2vYKPBd
► YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/samuelkimmusic
► Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/samuelkimmusic
The Mets are doing a lot this offseason so far.
Not one Soto, not yet, but they're making moves, most notably with the pitching.
Trying to build back up their rotation since they're losing a couple of guys, starting
with Luis Severino who was able to snag the biggest A's contract ever.
Severino was a one year guy anyway, same with Sean Mania who hasn't signed anywhere yet
and so is Frankie Montas, the Mets' newest proven signing for a pitcher.
What I mean by that is the short term investment, low risk, high reward scenario they're going
for and it's pretty smart.
Instead of going after the biggest names on the market for pitchers, the Mets have been
getting guys on one year deals and what that does is add an incentive for them to pitch
really well because if they do, look what just happened with Luis Severino, they get
a nice contract.
That's a really good strategy, honestly.
It's safer, obviously, than giving someone like Corman Burns a seven year contract and
so Montas and his two year $34 million contract with an opt out after 2025 is the Mets' newest
low risk, high reward scenario.
But as the title of this video suggests, the Mets are taking a risk.
Not because of Frankie Montas, but because of the next pitching signing they just made
in Klay Holmes.
There will be at least one former Yankee joining the Mets this offseason if not one Soto, as
they just signed Holmes for three years and $38 million.
There's nothing too crazy at about $12.5 million a year, but that's not the risk.
The risk is what the Mets plan to do with Klay Holmes, something who's been a reliever
pretty much his entire career up until right now.
The only time Holmes has ever started was back in his first ever crack at the big leagues
in 2018 with the Pirates, and he was really, really bad.
It was only four starts, but still, not good.
He walked more hitters than he struck out in those four starts, his ERA was over seven,
and then as a full on reliever in 2019, his rookie year, Holmes was just straight out
bad and it'd be that way for the majority of his time in Pittsburgh.
And after 42 more innings with an ERA pushing five to begin 2021, the Pirates were happy
to trade the guy for a bag of chips, shipping Holmes off to the Yankees in exchange for
two players who are long off the Pirates now.
But at the time, obviously you can't really expect any much of a valuable return for someone
who hadn't shown any success at the big league level at that point.
But the Yankees obviously saw something in him, and after bringing him aboard and tweaking
some things like having Holmes ditch his curveball and lower his arm slot, changing his mechanics
up a little bit, Holmes became the best reliever in baseball, at least for a certain period.
He was that good.
And it was another funny example of the Pirates being dumbasses and having no clue as to what
they're doing.
But he definitely did leave the Yankees and their fans with a good taste in their mouth.
He wasn't awful in 2024.
I mean, on the surface, his ERA was 3.14 in 63 innings, which is almost exactly what he
threw in all of his seasons with the Yankees.
So he was consistent to take the ball, an overall good, but the issue is he just wasn't
really reliable enough as a lockdown guy.
He blew 13 saves, and by September had lost his job as the Yankee closer.
Well now he's a Met, and they don't have any plans for him to be their closer, but rather
moving him to the rotation, and honestly this makes sense to do.
At least in theory, and something to experiment with, especially with some recent examples
of teams doing this and having it pay off.
Renato Lopez was a starting pitcher earlier on in his career, had some good times, some
bad times, and ended up in the bullpen for a few years before the Braves decided to sign
him and turn him back into a starter.
And he was awesome.
Now he did deal with some injury issues last year, but he was so dominant in 2024, he became
an all-star for the first time, put up an ERA under 2, he was great.
Jordan Hicks, the guy who could throw 106 mile an hour pitches with sink, was mostly
a reliever until the Giants signed him on to be a starter, and he wasn't as great as
Lopez, but it was still something that worked fairly well, especially for his first year
doing it.
Which, you kind of have to expect some sort of a transition period, where they're not
going to be at their best, and I think this is the right way to go about Klay Holmes if
you're the Mets.
The thing about Holmes is, yeah, he might have some stretches here and there where he
was dominant as hell as a closer, but overall he's proven to be way too unreliable for that
role or any high leverage role on the bullpen.
Again, he can be lights out in those roles, but also completely collapsed, he showed that
way too much.
And I think if you're going to bring Holmes aboard like the Mets are, the best potential
value you can get out of him is turning him into a decent starter.
Will he be an ace?
No, probably not.
That shouldn't be the expectation, but I think Holmes becoming a decent number 3 or 4 level
starting pitcher is better value rather than what he was with the Yankees mostly.
Because as of right now, even if you wanted him to be a reliever, Holmes isn't going to
be the Mets closer, so he'd be what, your 7 or 8th inning guy?
And not really that promised to thrive in that role?
That doesn't seem worth getting him, but if you can turn him into just even a decent starter,
he doesn't have to be great, just decent.
I think he will be worth his contract for the Mets.
There is risk with it, obviously, because it can blow up in their faces.
What if Holmes is just straight up awful as a starter and now you have to hope he goes
back to being a good reliever?
That can happen too, but the way the Mets have been operating lately, getting guys like
Shamanaya, Luis Severino, and helping put their careers back on track, and then seeing
what other teams have done with this whole converting a reliever into a starter thing
and the potential that it has, I think the Mets are making the right call here.
Holmes definitely has the potential to do this.
He's a good sinker that can get him a lot of ground balls, that can help him rack up
innings, which again is mostly what the Mets are asking for.
Just be a good enough starter, and I think this will be the best bang for their buck
the Mets can get from Klay Holmes.
Let me know your thoughts, and thank you for watching.
