Are you a graceful loser?
No. Absolutely not. Absolutely not.
I'm like a Yankee fan.
My foot has gone through a number of television sets in my time.
I bleed like those guys out there do, the fans.
I mean, they hate to see a lose, and I hate to lose.
You take it personally?
Yes. Yes, I do.
What does it say about George Steinbrenner when the Yankees lose?
It says he's one of the worst losers in the world.
I don't think you're happy finishing second or happy getting to a World Series.
The goal is to win.
If I don't win, then it's not fun to be around.
So what's worse, 2007 or 2001, 2003?
You get to the World Series, but you lose?
Or not even making it to the World Series?
I mean, how do you rate losing?
It's all misery to you?
I just, I don't, I've never understood it.
You know, well, it feels better because we made it to the World Series and lost.
Why does it feel better?
You've accomplished something by at least getting to the World Series.
What did you accomplish? You've lost.
I want to win.
I've always had that desire from the day I was born, I believe I have.
I never liked losing.
But Peter O'Malley liked to win, Walter O'Malley liked to win.
You never heard their names.
Maybe not as much as I did.
See, it's the degree to which you want to win.
I believe you have to know how to win, and I just do it my way.
You look at the Houston Astros.
They have knocked you guys out of the playoffs four times since 2015.
This last time, decidedly so, in four games in the ALCS.
When you look at that organization, why do you think they're better?
I'm not going to make excuses.
They did go into the playoffs a bit healthier than us.
But like I said, they're a great team.
I don't believe they're doing anything that we're not doing.
They're taking a look at their roster and their team every season,
and they're making changes.
They're letting guys go if they have a good young option below to come up.
And we're going to be doing some of the same things, too.
They play better than us, as simple as it is.
They came up with the big hits.
Pitching staff did their job.
Played great defense.
That's what it really kind of comes down to.
How about losing?
No, I tried to do what I can all year to help this team out.
And when you come up short in any aspect, it never leaves a good taste in your mouth.
Just couldn't throw that last punch.
How far we've come from the George Steinbrenner days.
When the Yankees were the most revered and feared franchise,
and forget just baseball and all of sports.
They were the definition of winning.
They represented winning.
They represented pride and doing things their quote-unquote right way.
And for years, the Yankees and their fans could pride themselves on this.
On the fact that they have the most championships in sports history.
The most winning ever.
That they're number one.
And although a lot has changed over the years,
some things haven't changed.
The Yankees still make the playoffs mostly every season.
They still have a lot of money, some of the best players in the game,
and some of the faces of the sport.
But what separates the past Yankees who won championships from this current era
is a lot of things.
But one of them being pretty clear, at least to me, the biggest thing.
They just don't have the guts, the heart.
Aaron Judge came along in 2017 and changed the whole outlook on the New York Yankees moving forward.
This was their guy.
They'd go on to lose in seven games to the Astros,
who were proven to have cheated that year.
So, throw that excuse out there if you want.
But since then, the Yankees have done nothing but either shoot themselves in the foot
or fall lifelessly in the end.
In 2018, as you briefly saw in the intro,
after the Yankees won Game 2 of the first round against the Red Sox at Fenway Park,
Aaron Judge celebrated by walking past the Red Sox clubhouse blasting
New York, New York as a way to taunt them.
Again, this wasn't after a series victory.
This was after a Game 2 Yankees win that tied the series up 1-1 heading back to the Bronx.
It was far from over, yet here was Judge mocking the Red Sox.
And what followed was a complete mocking of what the entire Yankees franchise used to represent.
The Red Sox went on to beat the Yankees' brains in in Game 3 by a score of 16-1.
Brock Holt would hit the first postseason cycle in baseball history.
And after going on to win Game 4 and end the series celebrating on the Yankees' stadium field,
the Red Sox blasted New York, New York and their clubhouse.
The Red Sox whooped your ass on your own turf and then left with basically the rights to your own song.
And it was that moment, after Aaron Judge did that, and after all that followed it,
it showed that this era of Yankees players, as good as they may be,
just don't have that winning mentality.
2019, Yankees win 103 games in the AL East division for the first time since 2012,
and even go on to win the first game in Houston in their ALCS rematch.
And just when you think this may have been the tides turning,
the Yankees evening the rivalry and one-upping Houston,
the Astros win in a kick-ass gear,
beating them in six while all Roldis Chapman could do was smile.
The third lowest payroll in baseball, Tampa Bay Rays, then got a piece of the Yankees in 2020,
getting revenge and the last laugh on closer Roldis Chapman
after he threw over the head of Mike Brasso during the regular season,
hitting the game-winning home run in the decisive Game 5.
2021, Yankees limp into the postseason and get dusted by the Red Sox again in one game.
2022, the Yankees jump out as the best team in baseball for the first half
before falling apart and limping yet again into the playoffs.
They did take care of business in the first round to set up the long-awaited rematch with the Astros,
take four, and the fans were pumped.
All that just for their season to end yet again to the Astros,
this time in drama-less fashion, just a clean sweep.
Aaron Judge's MVP season amounts to nothing,
and so does Garrett Cole's Cy Young Award season in 2023,
with the Yankees missing the playoffs entirely.
But 2024 was going to be different.
The Yankees now had Juan Soto after trading for him from San Diego,
and Soto added a new element to this Yankee team in multiple ways.
For one, of course, the obvious, another elite bat next to Aaron Judge
that potentially makes this lineup one of the most dangerous in baseball.
But the other thing is the layer of guts and balls he added to this team.
Juan Soto isn't just a good hitter or player, but a winner.
He's been a winner from the get-go when he was 20 years old in the World Series with the Nationals,
and he's continued to show that nothing phases him,
not any pitcher, not any situation, no moments, nothing.
If anything, he seems to thrive more the more it matters,
and the Yankees need that, and through the regular season, they got that,
along with Judge putting up another historic season to rival his MVP season a couple years ago.
Now, a big talking point with the Yankees during the playoffs was their matchups,
their path to a World Series,
that it was easy for them, and the Yankees were basically being handheld to the World Series.
And would I say that?
No, I don't think beating any team, especially in the playoffs, is easy,
but would I say, especially in hindsight,
that who the Yankees ended up facing in the World Series exposed who they really are?
Yeah, I'd say that.
The Yankees started off with the Royals,
who had just clean swept the Orioles in the Wild Card Series,
dominating their lineup in Baltimore over two games.
But the Orioles, in a lot of ways, had that coming.
They didn't end the year very well, and neither did the Royals,
but Baltimore just completely fizzled out in the end.
It was an impressive couple games by Kansas City in their pitching,
but the Yankees clearly were the favorites for the next round,
and the Yankees went on to win that next round in four games.
But looking back, again, in hindsight, with what we know ended up later happening,
there were some big red flags for the Yankees in this series,
and throughout the whole playoffs.
They won Game 1, but very easily could have lost that game.
The Royals were ahead at one point,
and there was a blown call at second base late in the game
that ended up as the winning run for New York.
The Royals then kept the Yankees' bats mostly quiet in Game 2,
winning that game before losing the next two at home as the Yankees moved on.
But even in these two games back in Kansas City,
you can tell these games were more about the Royals failing to come through
and their lack of being able to win, rather than the Yankees being able to win,
if that makes sense.
The Yankees only scored three runs both games in Kansas City.
It's not like they dominated and out-slugged them.
They won Game 3 by just a run, and Game 4 by two runs.
Hats off to the pitching, but let's move on to the Cleveland series,
and then the World Series, and it'll all tie back together.
The Cleveland series was the epitome of a team in the Guardians
that had every shot in the world to win, but never was going to.
Even the two games they didn't show much life in,
Games 1 and 2, those were still kinda close.
It's not like the game was ever out of reach for Cleveland fully.
And then in Cleveland for Games 3, 4, and 5,
the Yankees couldn't have made it more clear that they didn't want to win these games.
The Guardians had them on the ropes multiple times throughout every single one of them.
They were well on their way to a winning Game 3 before blowing it,
and then having that insane comeback.
Game 4, they come back from a 6-2 deficit.
Yankees' bullpen is clearly imploding.
The game gets tied on this.
This is what gets Cleveland all the way back,
only for Kloset to blow it in the 9th, and even with that,
the game ended with the winning run at the plate for the Guardians.
Game 5, Guardians have the lead through 5 innings.
The game goes to extra innings tied.
Juan Soto comes through.
Yankees win.
Obviously, you credit the Yankees for these wins and coming through in big moments.
But as they won games like these, and the games that they won against Kansas City,
you can't help but think things go a lot differently if they play a better team.
The Royals were good, but not that good.
They had two separate 7-game losing streaks in the month of September.
The offense isn't great.
Cleveland was a good team, but they're in a weaker division with the Royals,
and have an even weaker offense than the Royals.
So, yeah.
I mean, the Yankees took care of the business they needed to take care of to win the pennant
and finally appear in the World Series for the first time since 2009.
But what ended up happening once they got to the World Series showed us that this Yankees team,
even with Juan Soto and winning the pennant, wasn't actually any different all along.
It was pretty obvious throughout the first two rounds, even in the moment,
that if the Yankees were playing really any other team,
they don't come out on the better end, or at least not in the way they did.
It probably ends up just like how it did against Houston and Boston,
that those teams wouldn't have let the Yankees slide like the Royals and Guardians did.
And because of this, because they played those two teams this year,
instead of the Yankees getting punished within the first couple of rounds
like we've been used to seeing for 15 years now,
it waited until the World Series and it was by the hands of the Los Angeles Dodgers,
a team that will get their own video, but a team clearly not like the Royals or Guardians.
This isn't just a good team.
This is a fantastic team.
It's a super team.
And not only does it have superstars, but it has players that know how to win,
superstars or not.
The Dodgers did exactly what the previous two Yankee opponents didn't.
The offense came up clutch, capped off by Freddie Freeman
taking the first cookie he sees from Nestor Cortez
to the first walk-off grand slam in World Series history.
The Dodgers stopped the Yankees from rallying late in Game 2.
The pitching dominates some more in Game 3 as Freddie continues to go deep,
shutting up what would have otherwise been a hostile Yankee stadium crowd.
And even when he thought, hey, maybe the Yankees have some magic,
just when this team started giving their fans hope by steamrolling to a Game 4 win
and jumping out 5-0 in Game 5,
looking to be the first team to ever force a Game 6
after being down 3-0 in the World Series,
the Yankee defense decided to suck harder than Mia Khalifa in her prime.
In the world of 2024, the Yankees began identifying themselves as the other New York team,
pulling a classic Mets and just begging the Dodgers to beat them.
Things that you can do and get away with against Kansas City or Cleveland,
but not the Dodgers.
A team that did what great teams do,
taking complete advantage of every Yankees f-up in an incredible Game 5 that ended the series.
This team was never going to let the Yankees get away with the mistakes they got away with in the first two rounds.
And again, there was a lot of talk even during those rounds
that the Yankees had a cakewalk to a World Series,
and looking back, there's some validity to that.
It's like Batman beating up on some random no-name thugs or C-list villains and then taking on Superman.
I don't think beating anybody in the postseason is fully a cakewalk,
but there is something to the Royals and Guardians being pretty obvious weaker competitions and threats
that if anything just exposed what a great team would do to the Yankees.
And that's what happened.
We were shown that even though at some point this Yankee team may have felt a little more special,
doing something that they haven't done in a long time like getting to the World Series,
they weren't really any different after all.
They're not that much different from the 2022 team that got swept by Houston.
Their downfall was just a little more delayed this year,
and we continue to get further and further away from the glory days of New York.
The face of the franchise, the best hitter in baseball, Aaron Judge,
continues to be a massive disappointment in baseball's biggest stage,
taking things to a completely new level this year.
He didn't really hit in the postseason of 2022,
but this year he added a whole new layer to his legacy.
It really couldn't have gone worse.
After yet another dominant historic regular season,
Judge fails to do what Jeter used to do, win.
And that right there is the biggest difference from then versus now.
It's simple.
The Yankees still make the playoffs most years.
They still have a lot of money and the best players and the faces of the game on their team,
but it's simple.
When the clock strikes October, they go pretty mute.
They still may have some moments here or there,
but there's always another team that has more guts, more balls, more heart,
and one that ends up with the last laugh.
And because of that, another season of failure in the Bronx is complete,
and another reason as to why there's no reason to fear the New York Yankees at all.
Let me know your thoughts and thank you for watching.