The Most AWKWARD And UNNECESSARY Contract Situations Are Getting Worse
iTalk Studios
908 followers
1.1K Video Views·Jan 11, 2025
Ah, that wonderful time of year where all these players agree to the amount of money
they will be making for the upcoming season while all the people who don't fully understand
how this works think these teams are signing them to entirely brand new contracts or whatever.
It's called arbitration.
When a player reaches a certain amount of years played, he can negotiate with the team
his salary each individual year.
This isn't like negotiating a new contract because of the fact they don't become a free
agent yet.
That doesn't change.
Just the amount of money in the upcoming year specifically.
It's a more fair way for pre-free agent players to make what they're worth if they're really
that good.
And I'll admit when some of those notifications came up with a team and player agreeing to
a contract, I jumped thinking it was a real contract extension only to realize what it
really was.
Like this one.
I genuinely for a split second thought Tarek Skubal, the best pitcher in the American League
last year, just signed a big extension with the Tigers before I read the rest.
So I'm somewhat guilty of this.
I know how it works mostly, but I still get blue balled a little bit.
But yesterday was the deadline for arbitration-eligible players and teams to agree on the 2025 salary.
So a ton of this stuff was going down, but you also have the deals that weren't agreed
upon.
And when deals aren't agreed upon, that's when things get awkward.
And ugly.
And not good.
And bad.
Which is where we are with multiple arbitration situations right now around the game.
Really quick as always, if you're part of the 56% of viewers not subscribed yet, go
ahead and hit the button if you enjoy the videos as arbitration is why players like
Juan Soto even before becoming a free agent was making a good amount of money per year
and it only went up because he continued to perform well.
Right when players make the league, they make the league minimum salary, which is in the
hundreds of thousands.
It used to be like $500,000, but it's gone up now.
It's like $760,000.
It's increased gradually.
But anyway, that goes on for a few years, getting paid that amount until they become
arbitration-eligible.
The salary yearly from there goes up into the millions and depending on how good you
are, it goes up a lot.
Juan Soto got paid $8.5 million by the Nationals in his first arbitration-eligible season in
2021.
Then that went up to over $17 million in 2022, $23 million in 2023 with the Padres, and then
all the way to $31 million in 2024 with the Yankees.
But arbitration, like I said, gets ugly and mostly awkward as hell.
Just the idea of it, when the two sides disagree on an amount.
Because what happens when that happens, if the team goes to a hearing with the player
and his agent, I mean, again, this is just the simple fact that a team is taking a player
they employ to a hearing to argue why they should pay said player less money.
It's just, it's very cringe.
And as you would expect, a lot of these hearings end up that way.
Players get offended and feel disrespected, etc.
But what makes it all the worse is the fact that the two sides are usually arguing over
like a few hundred thousand dollars.
Maybe it gets up to a million or two.
And in baseball context, that's of course really nothing.
It'd be one thing if the player wanted like, say, $10 million more or something.
But to sit in a courtroom and argue why you don't want to pay your own player $500,000
more is like telling someone you don't love them that much before going on a five-hour
car ride somewhere.
And it's no secret this hurts the relationship between the two sides and has the player eventually
going.
Now, of course, it has nothing to do with the player's teammates or anything like that,
or the fans, or nothing of that sort, obviously.
Teammates will always have their backs because, well, they're players too, and they all want
players to make money.
It's good for everyone.
So it's not that it affects certain parts of a team like that.
It's just more so the relationship between player and front office slash ownership, which
is important enough because, you know, those guys have the biggest say in what players
play for the team.
And again, those hearings can get pretty ugly because, remember, it's a hearing.
Both sides are trying to win, so on the team's end, they're literally going out of their
way to find ways to justify why their own player is not as good as he thinks he is and
that he deserves less money.
Here's why you don't deserve as much money as you think you do, even if it's for a few
extra hundred thousand dollars.
Back in 2018, when Marcus Stroman was in his last couple years as a Blue Jay, he went to
a hearing with the team over a difference of $400,000.
He wanted $6.9 million, that naughty son of a bitch, I know what you were doing, but the
team wanted to pay him $6.5 million.
An independent arbitrator ruled in the Blue Jays' favor, so he'd be making $6.5 million,
and Stroman immediately took to Twitter and said the negative things that were said against
me by my own team will never leave my mind.
About one hour later, he took back those claims, or at least addressed them, while also deleting
that first tweet, saying that he was just being real and isn't mad, is aware of the
business, and that it just opens your eyes going through the arbitration process.
He still loves the team and the entire country of Canada, and was apparently more upset that
he had to fly to Arizona and miss his Monday workout.
Whether that's all true or not, the bottom line is the hearing rubbed in the wrong way,
quite clearly.
And I purposefully put Stroman as the first example here, because a lot of your first
thoughts will justifiably be, it's Marcus Stroman, he gets offended over everything,
and yes, yes he does, but it's absolutely not just him when it comes to the arbitration
stuff.
Let's go to a big throwback, Shaun Casey, just about the opposite of Marcus Stroman,
someone who in his playing days was always mostly just a goofball, never angry or anything
like that, a fun dude, and just a nice dude overall, genuinely.
He's currently an analyst on MLB Network and has been for years, and he's basically just
your innocent but wild uncle, he's awesome.
That's basically how I know him, because I wasn't around during his playing days.
Well even he was pissed at the Cincinnati Reds during his arbitration hearing years
ago, where he was asking for $3 million while the team was only willing to go as high as
$2.7 million, even after he said he'd compromise at $2.8.
So they go through this process, and during a brief break during this 4 hour hearing,
Casey started a vent to his wife Mandy, who he wanted there to experience what the business
side of baseball was like.
And again, Shaun Casey, a guy who's never like this, was so angry at this whole situation,
he was finding it crazy they were even there at all.
According to another MLB Network analyst and former player Harold Reynolds, he said that
his teammate Julio Cruz told him regarding the arbitration hearing room,
Back in 1982, Pedro Guerrero was asked about the arbitrator who cast the deciding vote
against him in his lost case against the Dodgers after his 3rd place finish in the
1982 MVP voting, to which Guerrero reportedly said he was going to kill the arbitrator.
But to be fair, it's not like that was the only person Guerrero wanted to kill.
But arbitration really is all like talking politics, it brings out the absolute worst
in any person imaginable.
And the best latest example I can think of is Corbin Burns a couple years ago, after
he went to an arbitration hearing with the Brewers over $740,000, a guy who won a Cy Young
award a couple years before that, they didn't want to give him an extra $740,000.
Now Burns is another guy who is as far as I can tell drama free, seems just very normal,
calm, you'll see him smiling.
But after losing his arbitration hearing with the Brewers before the 2023 season during
spring training, after asking for $10.75 million and losing the case and getting $10.01 million
instead, Burns spoke to the media publicly about it and did not hold back.
So that just shows how this situation really does make anyone get angry, even the most
drama free like Corbin Burns.
But he went up in front of the media and blatantly said that his relationship was now hurt with
the team.
Here's more context.
The Brewers are already a team that doesn't really spend, so it's not like their chances
of keeping Burns long term was that great anyway.
But when this happened, I mean it was as clear as anything.
He was not going to be a Brewer for much longer, and he wasn't, he was traded a year later.
And with the latest wave of arbitration agreements, most are settled so a hearing never happens.
In fact, 18 teams this time were able to come to terms with all of their arbitration eligible
players by the Thursday deadline.
But that means there are 10 teams left to make up all 30 that have at least one player
they didn't agree with.
The Cubs and Red Sox specifically had one player they couldn't come to an agreement
with and... what are we doing?
And yes, I know it's actually 12 teams left for the final 30, 18 plus 10 is 28, not 30.
I just wanted to see how long you'd freak out before I clarify that.
Anyway, first off, Kyle Tucker and the Cubs.
He's asking for $17.5 million while the Cubs want to pay him $15.
Okay, you just traded for the damn guy.
And what's tricky about the trade is the fact that Tucker's only a year away from free agency.
So the Cubs might only end up with Tucker for a single year, which wouldn't be ideal,
obviously, to trade away valuable assets like they did to Houston for just one year
of Tucker.
He's a great player who will demand a lot of money on the free agent market.
So again, the Cubs keeping him long term should be a priority.
They just traded for him and are already saying they don't want to pay him an extra two and
a half million dollars.
Yeah, great way to start a relationship.
Like you're just asking for this to be a one night stand.
Maybe I'm stupid, but I really just don't understand the point in refusing to give your
newest now best player on the team an extra couple million bucks when that clearly is
nothing for the team.
Now, you can look at this obviously in multiple ways.
You can look at the player and call him greedy for wanting an extra few million when he's
already making a lot regardless.
This goes for every player I've talked about so far.
Any player that goes to a hearing with the team and wants some more money.
You can call them greedy.
Sure.
But I'm sorry, which side is the one with the owners that are worth money that goes
into the billions and owns teams that are worth billions of dollars?
I don't think the players should be painted in a bad light because in reality, by this
same logic, the owners are just as cheap as the players might be greedy.
I don't know.
I'm not telling you how to think and I fully myself don't think players can just get unlimited
money all the time, whatever, obviously.
But I think especially when you're a player of a certain caliber like Corbin Burns was
to the Brewers or Kyle Tucker has been to the Astros and now will be to the Cubs.
I just don't understand why as an owner and as a team with endless money compared to what
the players are asking for feels the need to make things really weird and uncomfortable
just to save a couple extra bucks.
I mean, what are the Cubs going to do with an extra two and a half million dollars that
they don't give to Kyle Tucker?
Again, not a hot start to the relationship between the Cubs and they're now clear best
player who they shouldn't prefer to have for just a year after trading away what they did
for him.
But then I have a situation I feel is even worse and that's over with the Red Sox and
they're one player who they didn't agree to a settlement with and will be going to an
arbitration hearing for.
And that's Jaron Duran.
Duran has only made the league minimum in his career so far so this is his first year
of the ability to get a lot more money in arbitration than he's been making and the
Red Sox are already, in my opinion, mistreating him and his situation.
He's asking for four million dollars, the Red Sox want to pay him three and a half million.
We're talking about a guy who just led baseball in doubles with almost 50 of them, led all
of baseball in triples, missed just two games all year because he called a fan a bundle
of sticks or twigs bound together as fuel, a word that can also mean a cigarette.
I think you get what I mean.
So he played every damn day, led baseball in plate appearances, at bats, provided elite
speed in defense, finished top eight in MVP voting, was an all-star, and get this, had
a higher wins above replacement, aka War, than Juan Soto.
Now I'm not saying he's better than Juan Soto, he's not, but according to that stat, because
he provided so much defense and speed along with his solid hitting, he was more valuable
than Juan Soto.
And even if you don't take that for face value, which I don't, you have to at least acknowledge
that he was up there with players like Juan Soto for adding value to their teams last
year.
So in other words, Jaren Duran was freaking incredible in 2024.
So despite all of that, the Red Sox are planning to look at Jaren Duran with a straight face
and tell him that they don't feel like he's worth an extra $500,000.
I'm almost at a loss for words here.
This makes absolutely no sense to me, it really doesn't.
Duran is, I'd say, the Red Sox' current second best player on the team after Rafael Devers.
Yet the Red Sox think it's okay or smart to go to war with him over $500,000.
Why?
Just why?
Why can't you just pay him what he wants?
What do you gain from winning that argument or lose by having to give him that extra $500,000?
It's like these teams are secretly being controlled and pressured by Mr. Krabs, and if they don't
abide by his preposterous cheap ways, he punishes them with death.
I'm not about to go real with that conspiracy theory though, because the world isn't ready
for it.
$4 million is nothing to a team, especially to a franchise like the Boston Red Sox.
What are we doing here?
Why are you going out of your way to hurt the relationship with one of your top players,
not just on the team, one of your top players, and all of baseball right now?
It's beyond me, I don't understand it.
You're actively hurting such a valuable relationship, and for what?
Same with the Cubs.
I just, ugh.
It'll be interesting to see how this all plays out.
Let me know your thoughts and thank you for watching.
