Is the Term "Chinese Crap" Racist?

FUNG BROS.
592 followers
34 Video Views·Dec 5, 2024
can the term Chinese crap be considered
racist or discriminatory when used in a
corporate setting we got to talk about
this Reddit post because a lot of ABCs
that work in product manufacturing are
wondering this question long story short
this girl works in product manufacturing
and she has a teammate on a project that
constantly refers to Chinese crap we
don't want Chinese crap and she said
that she heard it so many times with a
tone behind it that sounded racist rude
or angry even though it's like hard to
describe exactly what it is but
basically this guy who said it who I
believe was white had some feeling
behind those words and basically she
just had enough of it one day being
Chinese American and just said Hey
listen guys there's a Chinese person on
these projects let's not make this a HR
issue so basically she was debating in
her head whether she overreacted whether
she was being too emotional did she do
the right thing wrong thing and there
were so many different responses anyway
make sure you like subscribe turn your
notifications check out smile outu in
amazon.com right now and basically
here's let's just get into the comments
real quick somebody said when I was a
teenager and worked at a homegood store
I will never forget the woman to help me
find her items made in America none of
that Chinese crap it was peer One
Imports I believe that this person was
Chinese themselves this person said that
I was in a meeting once with particular
pricing strategy where a European guy
kept saying we don't want the Chinese
menu we don't want the Chinese menu
another Chinese American woman in the
room said let's use another term for
that and then a more senior white
executive followed up in a later in
email saying that we should not use
terms like that in a professional
setting and that was that so basically
people are confirming that this is quite
common particularly in product
manufacturing right and there's reasons
for this and we'll going to get into
those but also it's key here that a
European guy used it in Europe they may
not have the same sensitivities that
they have in America around race
relations right Point number two
somebody said the only people who will
think you are out of line is are non
asan sadly racism like this is SE normal
even in some Asian
spaces yes and no I would say that the
stereotype exists but I don't know I I'd
have to really see what it means like in
an Asian space to see this happen but I
do agree that these stereotypes exist
globally because these are from the 9s
2000s China did have a very cheap
manufacturing archetype stereotype that
and they still do make some cheap stuff
there or the the cheapest functional
stuff on Earth is still made in China
but obviously they have moved a lot up
Market over the years um Point number
four somebody said the people that use
that term are so far removed from the
process and means of production it is
easier for them to discriminate quality
based on country of origin than make a
far more accurate critique of companies
making cheap products from exploited
workers in places where labor can be
found for cheaper with lower tolerances
for specifications uh this person's like
sort of trying to explain it right here
I'll say this like we said it's true
China is the world's Factory there are
people there who do highly Skilled
Manufacturing work whether you saying
that it's cheap middle tier or high tier
across all three tiers for cheaper than
anywhere else on Earth with a lower
rejection rate now you can say that
those Factory workers are being screwed
and being treated like MPC robots in the
meat grinder there's even some people in
China saying that however it is what it
is right so basically what I'm trying to
say is like The Stereotype does exist
and it does come from somewhere but how
does that
that that truth first of all where's the
Nuance in it and second of all how does
it transfer over to the dehumanization
of Chinese people in the west or the
word Chinese right Point number five
this guy saying then man if you know
this guy knew a lot and he really uh is
very tapped in with Chinese
manufacturing then it's not inherently
racist so you have to take the context
went into consideration yeah yes and no
like I said it's a global stereotype but
it's not something that you know
you should use in a proper American HR
setting for sure um Point number six it
can be it's like covert racism for
example in the movie Back to the Future
doc scoffs when says oh no wonder made
in Japan then Marty coming from the
future reveres anything made in Japan so
it goes to show you that even in the
back to the future because doc was like
in the 1950 you know they were like
traveling through time it goes to show
you that at one point things even from
Japan were considered really cheap and
crummy right this is like when first uh
Chinese uh Japanese cars first started
coming in the early 80s people were like
oh those 10 boxes little crumble versus
like the ones where you know American
Steel is way heavier but then obviously
people started to see how those Japanese
cars never broke down and they were more
fuel efficient but it is true Japanese
cars have always uh at least prior in
the 1980s they were made with like much
less metal which theoretically did make
them crumble more and I mean like under
you know very certain specific
conditions but more people were willing
to take the tradeoffs right uh Point
number seven this saying it's a bit
racist but many even Chinese people
don't like buying Chinese branded
products themselves as it seem to be
cheaper and inferior in quality they
will actually pay a heavy premium in
China to buy foreign products yeah there
is some truth to this like we said um
somebody said for people who are 35 and
older there was a time when Chinese
Imports did absolutely mean cheap crap
when China was setting up their
manufacturing jug Juggernaut they were
producing the cheap stuff and the
knockoffs and people are just really
stuck in that mindset nowadays obviously
there still a lot of the low-end is made
in China but middle end and now even
some of the high-end stuff is made in
China however I will say only recently
has the high-end stuff been started to
be designed in China a lot of that
high-end stuff like the Assembly of for
example iPhones at a foxcon factory or
something that's even like sometimes uh
Apple Outsourcing it to Taiwan Taiwan
Outsourcing it to factories in mainland
China so it's actually like once you
really get into that it's actually super
complicated somebody said this sub is
just looking for for any reasons to
claim racism it's not actually racism
it's just describing where the product
is from China and the quality of the
product crap you guys are trying so hard
to make this racist China objectively
makes cheap quality things when are we
going to push the goal po this is
ridiculous not everything is racist holy
is somebody said you do understand the
difference between a person of a race
ethnicity culture whatever criticizing
uh basically out to stereotype all
products made by a group of people has
poor quality and by extension implying
that that people of that group are
incapable of making anything good ding
ding ding ding I think that that is the
most key comment right now a lot of
people say oh I'm just talking about
Chinese manufacturing quality oh I'm
talking about the Chinese government but
at the end of the day ultimately for a
lot of people not everybody they will
not be able to separate the words from
the people and I do feel like people
feel like not everybody obviously if
you're really like a Nuance thinker a
technical thinker you see the pros and
cons and you can weigh them out I do
think a lot of people think that Chinese
people are incapable of making anything
good and high-end maybe not good and
cheap because obviously 80% of
everything on Amazon is from China but
I'm saying that like the the cool things
like you know like that are high-end
like a like a car or like a phone or
like a music or like dramas or like
things that are considered like very
difficult to make I believe that people
think that China is incapable of
producing those things and I think the
truth is in the past they really have
struggled but they're moving up the
value chain very quickly but yes I
totally see where the stereotypes comes
from because stereotypes you could say
are earned more than they are just given
right so anyway guys here's my quick
thoughts on this all right so I'm not
saying there's not some truth in the
archetype that Chinese stuff is cheap
right and it was for you know a long
time but it's changing right now so
there's definitely a strong undertone of
racism when people say it so it's it's
not that there's nothing truthful to The
Stereotype that Chinese things are
quality uh are of low quality or
knockoff or cheap but it's just people
don't care enough or they have a vested
interest in freezing in that mindset
from several decades ago and not see the
Nuance in how things are so rapidly
changing in 2024 like we said it's a
global stereotype that chin China
probably earned in the past and it's
like crazy to say now but it's like
there's a lot of nuance in it I first of
all I think this girl is right for not
wanting to like have that thrown in her
face every day but it is true that it's
like man it's like so complicated cuz
even The Fakes now are like starting to
get so good like if you look at some of
the fake Rolexes coming out of China or
the fake cob 6 is it's almost like 9 out
of 10 quality 9.5 out of 10 AAA
quadruple a fakes so it's at some point
it's like if the functionality and like
the the uh durability is exactly the
same like what is a fake at some point
it's just no it's just not uh you know
what I mean um you know it is what it is
I think that's Point number three it's
good to speak up on it but you can't let
those words really Echo throughout your
brain all the time because listen it's
already like this in 2024 and it's
probably going to be this way for the
next 5 to 10 years if not more than that
so I think as Chinese Americans we
should speak up but not be like
tormented like tapping ourselves in the
head like ah everybody hates us
everybody hates our motherland or like
what it represents it's a threat to the
angos spere and they're trying to do
bricks and the bricks is going to
destabilize the US dollar and all this
stuff like because it just is what it is
like it's completely outside of um our
realm of control and also how people
process it right um but for example once
you understand stuff like you know the
mid to high-end Chinese EVS a lot of
them do look like the Porsche EVS to be
honest like I think they've taken heavy
design inspiration but they're also
great cars from like
from generally from if you read the
actual reviews of the Chinese EVS they
do I'm not lying they do knock off
Porsche like whether it's the Porsche
Cayenne EVS or the Porsche whatever EVS
or the Ferrari EVS they do knock them
off like more than they they technically
probably should is like for good manners
but it's like they also are good see now
you're starting to understand the Nuance
in this like fake bootleg culture but
it's just like inspiration and then also
that inspiration where is that going to
lead because you know all great art
starts with mimickry and then you know
it just takes time to build up the
muscles and go this way and that way so
it's like like I said it's not that
there's nothing to it but it just takes
time anyway you know I mean
like I don't know justes the new Hyundai
Santa Fe look a lot like a Range Rover
the EV one yeah it does I don't know and
somebody says uh also once you start
start to understand where China came
from and where it's going and also how
people in the West in the anglosphere
like that are more bought into Anglo
dominance or anglosphere dominance it's
like people feel threatened right now so
they want to emotionally throw like
extra weight behind their words and just
the fact that it is a real stereotype
that came from somewhere they're just
going to like throw extra oomph behind
it and you know that's just what it is
like it's going to be that way um I do
think if China's rise was a little bit
like viewed as like cooler and smoother
with more soft power it definitely have
less wrinkles than where does it stand
now you know what I mean where basically
they were just focusing on doing the
hardware work and the hard soft power
work and I mean uh hard power work and
they basically neglected soft power so
when you don't have a lot of soft power
but you're coming up in hard power it's
a little bit like how people View USSR
or like you know I mean when it's rise
it was like it's like a uncool takeover
whereas people tend to be a little bit
more acceptance of like cool takeovers
like when America overtook England and
then England obviously before that
overtook the Dutch for the world order
like it came with a lot of soft power at
the same time and U English capacities
and things like that so and movies and
stuff like that but it's just the
Chinese one of was more of like a
manufacturing like economic like Trade
Surplus thing so it's just really hard
to understand and then I just think that
lastly it's like Chinese men we almost
have to be like the most detached
technical people on Earth and it's so
crazy to say that because I know a lot
of people already stereotype us as like
hyper calculative like non-emotional
like some people say we're robotic or
NPCs but it's almost
like I cuz I just thought about this
issue so much and it's almost like
you're just going to have to accept that
everybody including other Asians
sometimes you're going to hear it you
know in a talk down way from the
Japanese and the Korean sometimes or
like you're going to in hear it in a
more like you're being mean to us
pushing us around taking us over as the
evil empire way from a lot of Southeast
Asians and I totally see where people
are coming from right Japan and Korea
they feel like Superior southeast Asia
they feel like bullied and it's like um
it just is what it is man because
everybody has their own perspective and
they're interested in like how their
lens is seeing it and you're just going
to hear it from everywhere but you're
going to hear love and and stuff from
everybody too so it's just man I just
think that for Chinese it's so easy if
you get if you think a lot about how
other people feel about you it's so easy
to give in the fact that we're meant to
like feel bad for being Chinese or like
China's rise is coming with so many
clunky uh sometimes ugly things you know
that are definitely not smooth and I
wish weren't that way but at the same
time it's almost like man listen once
you sort of realize things you kind of
get to this PL point to you're like man
it is what it is this is such a
fascinating life and such a
multi-layered life to live as like a
Chinese American if you really Embrace
both of those identities uh
simultaneously being American and being
Chinese and knowing like what all goes
into it anyway here's just uh I just you
know got some other takeaways beyond my
own real quick tone does matter not just
the actual words themselves for example
I remember growing up sometimes you'd be
like you know that Asian kid over there
all he's doing is technically calling
you Asian but there's so much negative
feeling behind that word that it is
unacceptable because even if you call
somebody like their ethnicity but with
the tone and the Cadence behind it and
the feeling and the emotion of course it
impacts it completely like colors the
connotation right Point number two ex uh
your experience producing anything in
China is going to be highly variable
right like a lot of people were saying
in the comment section you get what you
pay for or like maybe certain Chinese
factories when left to their own devices
without specifications definitely like I
said you got to be care you got to do
your due diligence when you're producing
stuff in China because it's true
sometimes you you know people are going
to upcharge you or uh you know what I
mean not I'm sorry not upcharge you but
like maybe skimp on the quality to get
more margin or something like that but
obviously there's a lot of people
producing really high quality stuff in
China too so it's highly highly variable
and this is a 2024 thing of course
everybody's saying that every thinks
everything made in China is like teu or
Sheen right nobody wants a car from teu
or Sheen right because a car you rely on
it it potentially could be fatal if you
pick the wrong car so and then there was
a lot of Chinese cheap EVS that were sub
10K sub 15K that did catch on fire in
some you know second or third tier
cities so like I said I'm not saying
that that stuff's not true but I'm just
saying that it's just not the whole
truth and yeah that's just where we're
at right now right um Point number three
China makes so much high-end Ultra
high-tech stuff right now and it's not
just the knockoff version of Japanese
things for example miniso miniso it is
knockoff in the sense that like they
said they had a Japanese founder but
they don't don't but they kind of brand
it like a little bit uh nicer version of
a Daiso but the company miniso is from
shenzen it's true because they knew that
like shanan branding nobody's going to
want to call it from like mini sh like
mini shun zun you know because it's just
that wouldn't work on a global basis
right and um I just think that China
does have a lot of solar panels now ai
Tech Battery tech you know drones EVS
etc etc and um yeah I just think that if
you look at I'm filming this on a DJI
osmo pocket 3 right now and it's like
finally to the level where it's like
most people's best you know travel
vlogging camera so like I said man
there's truth to this old stereotype but
it's changing but if you hate a group of
people or you feel some type of way
towards them you're not going to lend
them the Nuance of updating your
firmware pack or your stereotype
archetype pack of that group of people
um Point number four there was a lot of
comments saying it's a government scop
that people are falling for obviously
there's a lot of talk about that 1.6
billion doll budget that the US
government has for to turn people
against Chinese Goods or just Chinese
anything and that will lead to more
people talking trash about it you know
what I mean and it's like it is what it
is man but it's just like um
like I said before uh in my own hot
takes it's like on other groups will not
necessarily need to have this level of
like self-identity reflection because
it'll just either be an unknown group
like a lot of Southeast Asian groups to
be honest to America are just like
completely unknown in terms of what
their motherland is producing or not
producing and then like Japanese and
Koreans generally I do think they're
very sensitive about their image but at
the same time they can be because most
like probably most of the things that
people are going to say uh 70 to 90% are
positive right maybe outside of like
patriarchal things or whatever like
pressurized Society or something like
that so anyway Point number five
stereotypes are earned to some extent
but like I said it really comes down to
like how much you like something have
you ever seen how many red flags that a
guy will Overlook for a girl that he
thinks is gorgeous and I'm just talking
about most guys obviously not everybody
does this you know but like guys will
Overlook so many red flag that kick are
kicking them in the face for this like
gorgeous girl that they want to be with
and for a girl that they don't want to
be with maybe that their parents are
trying to set them up with and it's not
like um you know the look that they want
or the vibe the the archetype that
they're looking for they'll like pick
apart anybody and and girls do this to
guys guys do this to girls as well you
know and it just goes to show you that
that's like sort of the winds that sort
of like color these uh narratives that
flow this way or that way for example
the term going dutch was considered
negative in England if you guys know
about world Empires it was the Dutch and
then like kind of the Portuguese and
then it was the British and then the
Americans took it from the British and
potentially especially if you look at
the splits of Rayo the Chinese are going
to take it from the Americans okay so at
the time when the uh English were going
to war with the Dutch they came up with
all these terms such as Dutch wife Dutch
courage Dutch Comfort Dutch gold going
dutch that uh had negative connotations
because you wanted to vilify the group
that you were going to war with in in
this uh constant like power struggle
with so that's basically what's
happening to China right now but like we
said there's some truth to it but
obviously I thought it was good on this
Chinese American Girl to call it out but
I would also encourage her to really
look into it and be
like um arrive at a place where it
almost like doesn't really bother you
because we're living in the anglosphere
so it's almost like inevitable because
if you really understand this like this
uh tensions between like the next World
Super Powers it's almost like inevitable
to happen from the older Generations but
it's good to call it out but not
obviously get overly emotional for your
own mental health but obviously you know
depending on how comfortable the the the
the company wants to take it but I think
let's use another term for that or like
hey let's switch up the vocabulary of
how we describe things guys I'm I happen
to be Chinese American myself I'm not
comfortable with this I think that that
is a perfect Zone to be in where you're
being firm you're being real but at the
same time maybe you are not um you know
causing the whole system to go frantic
or Haywire that you're in right now over
something that yeah now hopefully you
like you you just understand where we're
at but still stop it where you can so
anyway guys long story short it is
racist uh and it does especially
depending on the tone and the feeling
but you
know it is what it is man so like I said
it's something that there's so many ways
to look at life there's a moralistic way
to look at life
and then there's also more just this
functional aspect of needing to get on
with your day I think it's just even
more important like to go represent and
and change Chinese stereotypes and let
people know that you're proud of being
Chinese as it is to stop the negative
aspects stopping the negative
microaggression comments important but
even more important to go rep that's how
I generally feel about it anyway guys
let me know what you think in the
comments section below I'm sure there
will be some arguing some people will
say well the stereotypes are well
deserved and they're earned and they're
not given and other people will say oh
my gosh I hate this this is so
disgusting the truth is guys life is
very complicated life is very layered um
that's my take I don't care you guys say
it's too down the middle whatever you
want to say because I can see it from a
lot of different sides but I think it's
even more important to represent anyway
guys let me know what you think in the
comment section below until next time
with the hop hop boys we out peace
