Three Michelangelos in Florence: Great Art Cities

Imperial Hands
20 followers
In this episode we look at three less well-known works by Michelangelo,
including a Pietà he made for his own tomb,
a controversial naked Jesus Christ created when he was just a teenager,
and a Bacchus rejected by the man who commissioned it for being too raunchy.
All three are in Florence, the birthplace of the Renaissance,
and a city which houses one-third of the world's most important works of art.
Michelangelo went to study in Florence at the age of 13,
so he is inextricably linked to the city.
Perhaps no more so than with his Statue of David,
the very embodiment of Florence and everything it stood for.
He wasn't the only genius in town.
Even before he was born, Dante Alighieri had written his Divine Comedy
and established the Italian language.
Filippo Brunelleschi had completed his Impossible Dome for the Cathedral
and kick-started the Renaissance.
And Lorenzo Ghiberti gave us the Gates of Paradise.
No other place can rival Florence for the sheer quantity of masterworks,
many of them still in the exact same site for which they were created.
It was the ruling Florentine merchant family, the Medicis,
and their untold wealth that funded this explosion of the arts.
And Michelangelo, as the star protégé at their arts academy,
would take advantage of their financial clout.
He was taken under the wing of Lorenzo de' Medici when he was 13,
for whom he created the Madonna of the Stairs
and Battle of the Centaurs when he was just 15.
Lorenzo died in 1492,
and then Michelangelo was taken in by the monks at Santa Spirito Basilica,
where he was allowed to continue his studies
and for the first time began dissecting bodies coming from the convent's hospital.
It is a myth that dissecting was done in secret.
He did so with the blessing of the Church.
The expertise he picked up as a teenager would carry through his entire career.
The Basilica di Santa Spirito houses this controversial sculpture by Michelangelo,
created in 1492 when he was 17.
The crucifix mysteriously went missing for 500 years,
and when a historian did find it, it was studied for a further 50 years.
Then in 2017, it was finally declared a genuine Michelangelo.
The church is designed by Brunelleschi,
the same architect who created the dome of the Florence Cathedral.
The exterior of the church, quite plain and simple in keeping with Augustinian principles,
hides a Baroque interior so extravagant
it is like seeing two different churches.
But the main reason to visit is to see teenage Michelangelo's 55-inch wooden crucifix,
sculpted as a gift to the monks.
Renaissance artists transformed the course of Western art history
by making the nude central to artistic practice.
But nudity in sacred art was mainly used to either represent
the natural state of humanity before the fall,
often depicted in scenes connected to Eden or Paradise,
or to represent the horror of lustful passions and vanity.
By this point, a naked Jesus Christ was unusual and even considered a bit shocking.
But this wasn't a case of blasphemy, as Michelangelo was a devout Catholic.
Christ's nudity or lack of clothes is actually something in the scriptures.
The removal of the clothing of Jesus Christ by Roman soldiers is mentioned in the Gospels,
but the question as to whether a loincloth remained is debated by biblical scholars.
From what we know about 1st century Roman crucifixions,
Jesus could have been crucified naked to maximise his humiliation.
Part of the crucifixion was humiliation, and that was heightened by public nakedness.
The crucifix was made to decorate the high altar of the basilica,
and the congregation would have only seen the front of it from a distance.
But now it is displayed in a side chapel, we can see it from all sides,
and observe Michelangelo's perfectionism.
When it was found in 1962, it was covered with dust,
and hundreds of years of bad paint jobs by amateur restorers.
Although Christ's pose suggests a search for classical harmony, he is unusually skinny,
lacking the muscular physique we know Michelangelo for, one of the reasons it was disputed.
The body is little more than an adolescent, Michelangelo's age when he carved it.
The bowed head is slightly older, and the hips and legs are anatomical perfection,
as Christ turns sideways.
It shows the moment of Christ's death, and his body rests as it would naturally in death.
The overall feeling is one of serenity.
The details, unlikely to be seen close up by the congregation, are extraordinary.
The matted hair, the spear wound, the dripping blood.
In 2017, now declared genuine, it was finally returned to the church he created it for.
30 years later, Michelangelo would sculpt another naked Christ,
and a theological theory for both sculptures is that the nudity of Christ
is sometimes seen as a statement about his unfallen nature.
After the artist's death, this statue was given a strange metal veil to cover his genitals.
It is still in place 500 years later,
perhaps still too shocking even for the 21st century church.
But before creating this, the young Michelangelo would get his first break thanks to a forgery.
The 13th century Bargello was a prison until 1859, and is now a museum.
It has the largest collection of Italian Gothic and Renaissance sculptures in the world.
A star of the collection is this life-size sculpture of Bacchus, the god of wine.
Still only 21, this was Michelangelo's first large-scale work.
Cardinal Riadio had commissioned the Bacchus for the garden of his grand new house,
but rejected the finished statue.
Why?
He had met Michelangelo under strange circumstances a few years earlier.
As a new artist struggling to support himself,
Michelangelo got involved in an art forgery,
selling a fake antique statue he had sculpted and then aged artificially.
The buyer turned out to be the cardinal, who realized it was in fact a fake,
and demanded a refund.
He did however immediately recognize the genius of Michelangelo,
and invited him to Rome to make a garden statue of Bacchus.
This Bacchus differs from what a classical god should look like.
The god of wine is often shown as an idealized naked youth,
even gender-fluid, but this version is an unidealized youth.
He is feminine and too soft and flabby.
Bacchus is sometimes portrayed as being a little tipsy,
but here he is extremely drunk.
His eyes are rolling, his mouth is wide open,
and although his body is in the traditional contrapposto pose,
which usually adds a sense of control and stability,
here it has the opposite effect.
Bacchus appears to be about to fall over.
Just look for a bit, and you start to see that as he leans back,
he appears to sway and to wobble.
To subvert the contrapposto pose,
and achieve that subtle sense of movement in marble is just astonishing.
Bacchus is dazed, struggling to keep his balance,
with his protruding belly softened by excess,
and can barely focus on the goblet of wine he holds in his hand,
which is tipping as if the wine will spill out onto us.
It is the kind of behavior we have seen at many office parties.
The statue is not typical of Michelangelo,
as being a garden statue it was designed to be seen in the round,
whereas most of his works were made for architectural settings,
and a particular viewpoint.
The satyr, in half-goat form,
is gleefully enjoying every moment of Bacchus's drunkenness,
and takes the opportunity to steal some grapes,
as he skulks behind the god.
His hidden position encourages the viewer to walk around the statue.
One interpretation is that this is in fact Michelangelo's critique of overindulgence,
a moralistic Christian take on a pagan story,
in keeping with the Renaissance puritanical approach
to the god of wine and earthly pleasures.
If so, it was just too realistic and not antique enough for the cardinal,
and in the end he rejected Michelangelo's sculpture.
In 1572, Bacchus was bought by the Medici family.
The humiliation over the rejection didn't affect Michelangelo's meteoric rise,
and a year later he was commissioned to carve his first and most well-known Pieta,
a work that would make him the most sought-after artist in Christendom,
at the age of 23.
He was a young optimistic artist when he sculpted his world-famous Pieta in Rome,
but an exhausted and unhappy man in his seventies when he created this,
his last sculpture,
which some scholars say he tried his best to destroy.
Nowadays housed in the Opera del Duomo,
once the workshop and the centre of operations
for the construction of Florence's cathedral and bell tower,
from 1296 to 1436.
Today it is a museum with an incredible collection of over 750 works of art,
covering seven centuries of history.
Pieta means pity or compassion.
It is a popular theme in Christian art and typically depicts just two figures,
Jesus Christ and his mother the Virgin Mary,
supporting his dead body after he was taken down from the cross.
However, experts have debated for years whether Michelangelo's last sculpture
is a Pieta, a deposition or an entombment.
The presence of the other figures argues against it being a Pieta.
A deposition typically shows the dead body of Jesus Christ
being taken off the cross by Nicodemus,
as Mary Magdalene and the Virgin Mary look on.
And an entombment places us at the tomb of Christ,
where his body is being prepared for burial,
often surrounded by Nicodemus,
Joseph of Arimathea or Saint John and the Virgin Mary.
Being Michelangelo, this could be a combination of all three.
Most of the figures are obvious,
Christ, the Virgin Mary and Mary Magdalene.
The fourth is debatable.
I am inclined towards the theory that the fourth figure is probably Nicodemus,
and this is why.
The sculpture was not commissioned by a client
but rather created by Michelangelo for his own tomb,
and it is almost certain that the face of Nicodemus is a self-portrait.
It is not the first time the artist added his own face to his works.
Most famously, he did so in The Last Judgement,
where San Bartolomeo is shown holding his own flayed skin
with Michelangelo's face on it.
And even his last painting had a hidden self-portrait.
If we briefly go back to Caravaggio's entombment,
we see that he has not only based his Christ on Michelangelo's Pieta
but has also transposed the master's self-portrait as Nicodemus
to his own painting.
Nicodemus was an early follower of Christ
who was present at the crucifixion.
He has long been associated with sculptors
due to the legend that he carved this wooden crucifix
shortly after the resurrection.
Artists including their own portraits of Nicodemus are not uncommon.
These artists are not just identifying with the sculptor Nicodemus
but also showing their own personal identification with Christ's sacrifice.
Titian did something similar,
adding himself as Nicodemus holding the dead Christ's hand.
Nicodemus's devotion and tenderness
are intended as a reflection of Michelangelo's own devout Catholicism
and he is upholding his faith,
literally the corpse of Jesus Christ,
for all of us to see.
Unusually, all three surrounding figures
attempt to steady Christ's lifeless body,
giving the statue a dynamic energy
and a classic triangular composition
which really emphasises the weight of Christ's body.
And yet after eight years of intense work,
at the age of 80 years old,
he walked away.
This wasn't out of character
as the perfectionist artist left many unfinished sculptures.
The story for years was that he was so unhappy with the statue
that in a moment of frustration he tried to destroy it.
But in 2019,
art restorers found no evidence of hammer blows
debunking the widespread myth.
In fact, as Michelangelo noted
when he first received the 2.7 tonne block of marble,
If you look at the work today,
it is hard to imagine that anything is wrong
as it looks so harmonious.
That is, until you realise that Christ only has one leg.
It is believed that Michelangelo intended the other leg
to lifelessly hang over the Virgin's lap.
But it was seen as too intimate,
perhaps even romantic,
and so to avoid confusion about his intentions,
Michelangelo removed Christ's left leg,
intending to carve a new one
from a different piece of marble and reattach.
Here we can see the hole in the groin
where Christ's new leg would have been attached.
After Michelangelo's death,
another artist, Tiberio Calcagni,
restored the work and reattached
the limbs of Mary Magdalene,
the Virgin's fingers,
Christ's left nipple,
Christ's left arm and elbow,
and Christ's right arm and hand.
You can clearly see here
where Christ's left nipple was reattached.
The only thing that was not reattached
was Christ's left leg.
To this day,
the missing leg is one of art's great mysteries,
and no one knows what happened to it.
When Michelangelo died in Rome
on February the 18th, 1564,
at the age of 88,
he was buried in the Santi Apostoli Church in Rome.
The artist, however,
had expressed his desire to be buried in Florence,
not Rome.
And 20 days later,
in the middle of the night,
the Florentines,
led by his nephew,
stole his body
and had it smuggled out of the city,
hidden in a bale of merchandise.
He was then taken to Santa Croce Church
in his beloved Florence,
where his tomb is to this day.
Michelangelo Buonarroti
was a difficult, complicated
and ultimately disappointed man.
We can only hope
that in his last days,
the Church gave him the kind of spiritual support
that he gave to Christ
in the guise of Nicodemus.
