A History of European Art : s1e11 Early Renaissance Sculpture in Florence

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
11 Video Views·Sep 26, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis lecture examines how early 15th-century Italian sculpture acted as the catalyst for the Renaissance. By studying Roman ruins and classical anatomy, sculptors like Ghiberti and Donatello pioneered realism and perspective, establishing the technical and stylistic foundations that would later define Renaissance painting and broader European art.
Good morning. I'm going to speak today about the sculptural foundations of the Renaissance.
I think it's very interesting to recognize that the first really dramatic steps in the creation
of the new style called the Renaissance were taken by sculptors, not painters. At the end of
the last lecture, we briefly discussed the meaning and implications of Renaissance. And by the way,
I said that it's not principally a stylistic term. Sculpture took the lead in this artistic surge,
and we need to ask why. Now, we've talked again and again of the influence of Roman art and Roman
architecture on European art of later eras. And perhaps it's time for a really quick reprise of
that subject. Consider that Roman architectural innovations, including the use of the arch,
provided the model for Romanesque architects, and that Romanesque architecture provided the
starting point for Gothic architecture. That the relief sculpture decorating marble sarcophagi
provided models for figure poses and for style, not to mention technique in later sculpture.
That culturally, Christianity assimilated much of the Roman tradition, and that since Rome was
the home of the papacy, there are constant references to and borrowings from Roman art.
That Charlemagne borrowed the ground plan of San Vitale in Ravenna for use at his palace
chapel in Aachen because of its imperial and religious associations. That manuscript illuminators
searching for a model for the imaginary portraits of the four evangelists seized upon the Greco-Roman
portraits of classical authors. Now we have to remind ourselves that the Renaissance was born
in Italy in part because that was the center of the Roman Empire, where the most complete and
impressive physical remains of the ancient artistic achievement were to be found. And
because the major patronage of Renaissance art came from the Roman Catholic Church,
also centered in Italy. So early 15th century sculpture was bound to reflect Roman sculpture,
which was the model right at hand. Early Renaissance sculpture was often used to decorate
architecture as Roman sculpture had been on Roman architecture, for instance on bronze doors or
marble relief carvings on architectural friezes. Since artists of the early 15th century were
trying to portray the human figure convincingly in space, and sculpture is by definition
three-dimensional, it was logical, even inevitable, that sculpture in the 15th century took the lead
and that painters followed that lead. There were several great sculptors in the early 15th century
in Italy. Filippo Brunelleschi, whose everlasting fame is as an architect, was, as we shall see in a
moment, an exceptional sculptor before he decided to concentrate fully on architecture. He was one
of the seven entrants in a public sculptural competition, which in itself a public competition
attests to the great importance of sculpture at this moment. The competition in 1401 was for the
second, the design of a second set of bronze doors for the baptistry adjacent to the façade of the
Cathedral of Florence. The baptistry has three entrances and already had one set of bronze doors
from the early 14th century by another Pisano, Andrea Pisano, that were completed in 1330. Of the
seven entrants in this competition were Brunelleschi, the finalists were Brunelleschi
and Lorenzo Ghiberti. All of them were assigned a single subject, the sacrifice of Isaac, and they
were given some bronze to work with and a year to work and told to go off and compete, prepare
their competition panels. We have both the panels by Brunelleschi and Ghiberti, the finalists,
today still extant and in the Bargello Museum in Florence, which is the sculpture museum there,
and we're looking now at Brunelleschi's version of the sacrifice of Isaac. 1401 is the date for
both of these pieces. Let me describe for a moment the startling attitudes and design and composition
that Brunelleschi arrived at in his panel. It is full of movement in the central part and the upper
left. In the center, on an altar, we have Isaac kneeling in a quite angular pose, held firmly by
his father, who is about to sacrifice him. The knife is ready to cut his throat and he is about
to sacrifice him when an angel rushes in from the left-hand corner from this circle on the
quatrefoil design. The circular corner rushes out of that space and stays his hand by grabbing his
wrist, physically stopping the sacrifice. Below, we have a donkey. They have accompanied Abraham
and Isaac. They are understood to be on a lower plane, on the hill or on the mountain, and the two
attendants are minding their own business down there while this great drama goes on above. And
the ram, which will be the sacrifice to replace Isaac, is seen here in the middle left ground.
It is the physical activity of this that is so startling, the abruptness, a kind of near
brutality about it. And that is stressed in the angular pose of Isaac and in the strong sweeping
robes of his father, of Abraham. This is ahead of its time, you might say, in its forcefulness.
Ghiberti did the same scene in quite a contrasting fashion. He's moved the altar over to one side
and he's placed Isaac kneeling on it, facing forward. We don't see him. He's on both knees
rather than in that one knee, one foot angular pose that we saw in Brunelleschi. So we have a
kind of torso, and one which is extraordinarily classical, by the way, very classical. That is
to say, Ghiberti has looked at classical sculpture and has taken the impulse from Roman art. His
father, though dramatic, I mean, look at the drapery sweep back here just as the knife pushes
forward, but it is also graceful. It is conceived in one long curve, and the drapery, the clothes
of Abraham are tight curves on the body. He is fully focused on this, and the angel who comes
out to stop this stops him not with a physical grasping of the arm, but a gesture, and we may
imagine a voice to cease this, but it is not the physical directness that we have in Brunelleschi.
The mountain here is more stylistically, and in a sense completely, rendered with a rock that
climbs all the way up at the left side, and the two attendants and the ass are here at the left
side, again unaware of what goes on on another part of the mountain. There's a technical matter
here as well that should be mentioned, and it undoubtedly played a role in the fact that the
competition was won by Ghiberti. Brunelleschi had made his panel by casting the figures individually
and fusing them to the door. They are soldered, essentially, onto the door. Not Ghiberti. That's
a single panel cast in bronze, modeled and cast in one piece. I'm sure that when the judges saw
this and they realized that this would be a tremendous technical achievement and make the
realization of the doors a much more compelling and perhaps an easier matter, they were
impressed by that. Let me show you an aerial view of the huge building of the famous Cathedral of
Florence with its dome, and this is the façade, of course, beside the façade. A bell tower, Campanile,
which was designed by Giotto, by the way. It's sad to leave that fact out. He was also an architect,
and in front of it, in front of the west façade, is the baptistry, this polygonal building which had
three entrances to the baptistry. Here are the doors that I'm going to show you now. Ghiberti's
north doors, his first set of doors when he won this competition for the baptistry. It took a very
long time to achieve this commission, over 20 years to realize it. Not that he wasn't doing
other work in the meantime, but it took a whole workshop of people to realize this. All I want
to point out, basically, here is that you have some, I think, 28 panels here, and that all of
them use the quatrefoil design that we saw in the two competition pieces. The subject is the life
of Christ. In addition, there are four panels devoted to the evangelists and four to the
fathers of the church, the theological fathers of the church. I'm going to show you only one panel
from this set of doors, and it stands stylistically for the rest. Again, this quatrefoil panel,
which is gothic still, was a given by the commission, and it had to be attended to.
The doors all have the same appearance. Each of the scenes has to be set in and fit in that
quatrefoil, which is not always an easy case. In the case of the flagellation, which is the subject
here, the flagellation of Christ bound to a column in the center, the artist is able to give a
almost exactly symmetrical composition. The two who are whipping Christ have their arms
pulled back in symmetrical fashion, and there are two other figures whose heads are apparent
just behind them. He fills the corners, the cusps of the quatrefoil, by tucking the architecture
into it, like a little stage platform and architectural top to it as well.
This door and these 28 panels were such a success that Ghiberti then received a second commission,
without a competition, for the remaining set of doors for the third entrance to the baptistry.
These are the famous east doors, as they are now. The doors were all moved around in part because
of the fame of each set. It meant that it was moved into the most prominent position,
which was the east, and so this ended up on the east. These also took a quarter of a century or
more, 1425 to 1452. Totally radically different from the earlier doors, because the 28 panels
have given way to 10 panels, and they're square. They're pictorial in shape. They are not
gothic quatrefoils instead, but now they emulate a picture kind of surface. The new doors,
with these 10 panels, five in each valve of the door, were much larger, of course,
than the previous panels, and allowed Ghiberti to develop a pictorial style of relief sculpture
with remarkable illusions of architectural and landscape space. They're completely gilded,
which makes them incomparably beautiful and splendid. There are 10 scenes from Genesis,
reading from the top left, across, and down. They include, and I'm just mentioning a couple of
scenes or subjects within them, the creation of Adam and Eve through their expulsion from Eden,
and the Cain and Abel story, and other stories of Abraham, and stories of Jacob, among other
subjects. The two panels I will show you are top left, the story of the creation of man,
and the third down, on the right, the story of Joseph. Let us start with the creation of man,
the first scene, for obvious reasons, in this series of scenes from Genesis.
We have, and I will describe it to you, because we have a continuous or simultaneous narrative
here, different scenes in the same unified panel. Lower left-hand side, we have God
come down to earth, creating man, giving him a hand up as he creates him. In the center,
in one of the most beautiful passages on the doors, Adam reclines here, asleep, and Eve is
pulled from his side. You remember, created from a rib, but in this case, drawn from the side of Adam
by a very, very gentle gesture of God taking her arm, almost like welcoming her into the world,
into Eden, pulls her forth. Unfortunately, as we all know, there was a temptation and a fall.
It's hidden over here in the background. He uses a low relief and smaller figures to suggest that
distance, and Adam and Eve and the serpent are here. There's the serpent around the tree
in the background on the left-hand side. Because of that, of course, they are expelled. God,
this time in a great swirl of circles up here, is pointing toward the gate. Through it comes an
angel in a great robe through this very, very severe gate. He is driving Eve in the foreground
and Adam behind her out of paradise. Again, Eve is an astonishingly beautiful and classically
conceived figure. Joseph and his brothers is the other scene I want to show you, and it is
most extraordinary for its architecture. But I'll say more about that in just a second.
It, too, tells a story, and it tells it in many parts. Joseph, I remind you, was the youngest of
Jacob's sons, and he was the favorite son. The eight older brothers were jealous, so they sold
Joseph into slavery up here, the upper right, in the distance on a mountain. But it's meant to be
far away and long ago, as it were. It puts it in another place and time, and they are taking him
from the well in which they had thrown him, selling him into slavery. He was sold to slavery
in Egypt, where he became a servant of Potiphar, an official of the Pharaoh, and so successful that
he was given charge of the household of Potiphar. He interpreted Pharaoh's dreams after that,
which helped to avert famine in Egypt because they stockpiled the grain, and as a result he
became governor of all Egypt. Famine in other countries, however, had continued and compelled
other peoples to come to Egypt to buy grain. Joseph was in charge of this process as governor.
Jacob, his father, had twice to send his sons for grain, and they did not recognize Joseph
when they arrived, though he recognized them. And the second time, he had a silver cup that
belonged to him, hidden in a sack of grain of the now youngest brother, born after Joseph,
Benjamin, and who had in turn become his father's favorite. Well, here on the left-hand side,
they're inspecting the sacks of grain as they're taken out, and in Benjamin's sack,
ah, they find a silver cup, and so the authorities are accusing them of theft. Here is poor little
Benjamin, who's going to be accused of theft. Here are his older brothers, who are pleading,
and quite vehemently, on his behalf and for their father's sake, to release him and to pardon him.
Joseph, seated up here, does reveal himself at this point, pardons the brothers, reveals himself
to them. One of them is bowing in supplication to him. Now, the most dominant thing here is this
astounding arcade, a double arcade, really, an architectural invention, though it has some
parallels in ancient architecture. He's really invented it here. In all the panels on this set
of the doors, we've seen that these simultaneous scenes are going on, and that's happening here
as well. For instance, one of Joseph's brothers looks at this lady carrying grain over here,
makes a nice little visual play across, but it also frames the entrance into this area where
people are bringing out grain in great sacks. This is an astonishing achievement, both in the sense
of architectural rendering and invention, architectural perspective, the sense of
illusionistic atmospheric perspective in the distance, and the clarity of the storytelling
in a very complicated scene. I'll turn from the gates of paradise, which, by the way, have been
known as the gates of paradise since the 16th century, when Michelangelo is said to have said
that they were worthy to be the gates to paradise, but there may be a pun here. The area between the
cathedral front and the front of the baptistry was known as the paradise because you entered to
get baptized, which was a necessity to enter paradise, so there could be a pun going on here
as well. I'm turning now to the art of Donatello. The work that I'm showing you is St. George.
The St. George as you see it today is in the Bargello, the sculptural museum. It is in a niche,
but the niche is a copy of the niche that it used to be in on the exterior of the Orsanmichele,
the guildhall for which it was made, and so it's shown in this copy of the niche, and below it
is a relief sculpture by Donatello as well. This was finished about 1415. The greatest Florentine
sculptor of the 15th century was Donatello, Donato di Nicolo Bardi, known as Donatello.
He is probably the most influential visual artist in Italy in the 15th century. He apprenticed with
Ghiberti. He worked on the preparation of the doors for the baptistry, the north doors, but
his artistic temperament is quite different. He was a technical genius in both marble and bronze
and an expressive genius, but one hard to categorize, sometimes enigmatic but intelligent
and endlessly inventive as well. I want to concentrate on the George here for a moment,
on this remarkable figure, because there was nothing quite like it in terms of a single image
of a powerful human renaissance, I want to say, figure, humanistic figure up until this moment.
He embodies in his head and in his pose courage, intelligence, a distinct individuality,
a distinct humanity, and he is forthright. He stands there as a guardian, and George,
of course, is often invoked as a guardian figure. By the way, this was the niche owned by the
Armourers Guild, and the Armourers Guild chose him as their patron saint. He once held a sword,
a real sword, made by the Armourers Guild, but it's disappeared. He once wore a real helmet.
I'm glad it's disappeared, because it would have concealed part of this great
head that we have here. The work is in marble, and it has this essentially a long triangular
pyramidal composition from the firmly placed feet with the shield in the middle, right up to the
head. Nothing breaks the contour. All of the energy is inside, as though ready to burst out.
Vasari in the 16th century, the artist, art historian, said that there was a marvellous
suggestion of life bursting out of the stone. Beneath him is a relief. The relief is that of
Saint George, and he is rescuing the maiden from the dragon. The maiden is to the right.
This in stone, but a relief which is much worn and yet still quite remarkable for its pictorial
subtlety and the shallow carving in the background, which is really unprecedented.
This flattened relief, as it's called, is his invention and his means of suggesting
atmospheric effects. This is where Ghiberti learned the sculptural illusionism that we've
already seen in the Gates of Paradise. Briefly, I will show you the Feast of Herod.
It's in the Baptistry in Siena. Baptistries are always dedicated to John the Baptist,
and this scene is the beheading of John the Baptist, or his head being presented to Herod.
I show it to you principally because there is in it a perspective system,
and you sense it both in the long lines of the tiled floor and in the arcades, one behind another.
There is in the far distance the head of John the Baptist already on a platter, on a salver.
Here in the foreground, it's being presented to Herod in response to his promise to Salome,
who's still dancing here as the head is presented to him. There is a kind of shrinking back from
the center. All the figures move left and right away, as though the horror of this scene had
caused this sudden emotion. It is a perspective system in which a tremendous amount of emotion
is infused. The most famous work of Donatello is probably his David, created in the 1430s,
but difficult to date more exactly. In fact, for such a famous, renowned work of art,
we know very little about it. We don't have an exact date. We're not sure who commissioned it.
The Medici owned it at one time. It was seen in their courtyard, but we don't really know
that they were the original commissioners. It is bronze. It was done, I'm going to presume,
in the early 1430s. That will be my guess on it. It has been called, quite didactically and
long-windedly, something like, the first life-size, freestanding, fully in the round,
bronze, male nude statue since antiquity, which may sound impressive as a catalog, but is really
just a list of qualifiers. It wouldn't matter very much if the sculpture weren't any good.
Aesthetic qualities it has. It is sensuously modeled, sinuously posed, superbly cast in bronze,
a great technical achievement. Senuous in what way? Well, in the imitation of adolescent flesh,
for one thing. Sinuous, there's an abstract line which dominates it. Let me show you the
back view of the figure. That's quite apparent, the serpentine line in it. David has been shown
here after he's brought down the giant Goliath and decapitated him. That's the huge head underneath
his left foot. And David became one of the protectors of Florence. Not a patron saint,
but a protector, and symbolically important. Remember, David was a shepherd boy, and therefore
small, adolescent, and he did turn down the offer of armor when he went to fight Goliath. But why
he should be nude is not entirely clear. If he were totally nude, it would suggest that Donatello
was borrowing the nudity of classical heroes for his biblical character. But he is not totally
nude. He's got hats, and he's got a hat, and he's got boots, and that almost disturbingly calls
attention to his nudity in an unclassical way. His appearance is also, at least to modern eyes,
and I think to 15th century eyes, effeminate and androgynous. And we don't have one convincing
reason for this. Let me show you the detail of the head of Goliath, and beautiful gilded chasing
of the head beneath his feet. Quite touching, actually. Homosexuality has been raised as
Donatello's as the reason for this. There were rumors, gossip, that Donatello was homosexual,
and the fact that it's a young boy and an adult man's head under his feet could play. But remember,
it had to be acceptable to the Medici or whoever commissioned it. So to make it that personal
doesn't quite answer the question. What seems quite certain is that no similarly sensuous,
seductive, strangely erotic sculpture or painting had been created in Renaissance Florence before
David. It is curious, a little perverse, but one of the most unforgettable creations of the century.
I want to spend a moment with an artist who doesn't get the attention he deserves. Luca
Della Robbia, who was born in 1400 and died in 1482. Everyone knows his name or the family name.
He is also one of the great sculptors of the Florentine Renaissance, but he doesn't get the
general applause that Donatello does. And this relative neglect is in large part because he made
many glazed terracotta sculptures, which were very popular art then and now, and are sometimes
slighted as decorative art. Luca invented the means of applying the fused lead and glass
compounds used by potters to his own terracotta sculpture. And then his family managed to keep
the process secret for a couple of centuries, running a highly profitable business. And many
people, Triantic Roadshow, many people still call any sculpture in that medium Della Robbia's.
So his own stone sculpture is less known and less appreciated. But there is where the proof of his
genius is, and he deserves the prize in that area. And we have only to look at his most famous and
memorable achievement. Indeed, we only have time to look at it. It is a cantoria, which means,
not very well translated, singing gallery. It is a choir gallery for musicians and singers.
In the cathedral, and it was one of two for the Cathedral of Florence, went over a baptistery,
excuse me, a sacristy door at the same moment Donatello did one, which went over the other
sacristy door. But I'm dealing with Luca's here, done between 1431 and 1438, and today moved into
the museum of the cathedral. This choir gallery is a marble gallery, 17 feet in length, which was
placed over the door to the left-hand sacristy. Singers and instrumentalists would have performed
from this perch. Let me describe it as you look at it here. The decoration consists of 10 panels,
we see eight, there are two on the ends, depicting children as musical genies, really. The eight
square panels are in two levels on the front and then one rectangular one on each end. The front
panels, as you can see, are separated by pilasters above and brackets below, and the horizontal bands,
there are three of them, one, two, and three, are inscribed with the text of Psalm 150, which reads
in part, praise ye the Lord, praise him with the timbrel and dance, praise him with stringed
instruments and organs, praise him upon the loud cymbals, let everything that hath breath praise
the Lord. Luca offers us young instrumentalists. Let me show you a detail of his trumpeters, with
some young dancers cavorting below them, wonderful trumpets stretching the whole width of the panel.
Dancing boys, dancing in a circle, who sing as they dance, and what extraordinary modeling this is,
and what complete command of this shallow space, very convincing that these figures are occupying
that space. And then the end panel, with these singers, the older boys, the trained choir, whose
faces Luca had obviously observed closely and perceptively. Perhaps he'd been a choir boy
himself, but in any event, he had looked at them and he'd watched them sing, he'd watched the way
they form their sounds, he'd watched the strain of some of them, he'd watched the boredom of others,
or perhaps he is listening, he seems to be covering his ear to hear himself better.
The unsurpassed charm and complete evocation of youthful music-making here is timeless,
and his skill at rendering adolescent fleshiness is equal to Donatello's and the Bronze David
without the erotic undercurrent. The delightfully contrasting personalities among the musicians
never pales, it just delights you to look at it over and over. Visual arts have often tried to
express the qualities of music, and have seldom achieved it, as well as Luca did in his singing
gallery. Thank you very much for your attention.
