Neolithic farming device in Greece 6,500 BCE, thousands of years earlier than thought

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
Forget super-civilisations and megacites. Forget the megaliths and the great temples.
It's often the small stuff that tells us what really went on in the past and
shaped the arc of the human story. Little bits of flint, for example.
Little bits of flint are probably the most telling pieces of evidence as to what human
beings have been up to throughout all of prehistory. But today we're looking at particular
little bits of flint that focus our attention on what is probably one of the most profound
revolutions in all of human existence. I'm Michael Bott.
And I'm Rupert Suskin.
We're the prehistory guys with more news of old stuff.
Old stuff. And it doesn't come much better old stuff than this old stuff. Tell us, Rupert,
about the study that's kicked off our thoughts on this. We do have thoughts on this.
We do have thoughts. We do have thoughts, yes. It's really exciting, actually. It's a
multinational team of researchers and archaeologists have come up with evidence for
threshing sledges in Greece 8,000 years ago or so. Why is this important? Well, it's important
because this is at the time when farming was really kicking off in Greece and beginning to
move west. And what is a threshing sledge apart from anything else? I've got to be honest,
I've never heard of one before this paper. But the fact that people in the early stages
of farming had got it together that the need for large scale threshing, so basically separating
grain from stem of crops, that they have found an actual tool, a machine, and they're using animals
to do this. Animals as traction. It's a thing that we've talked about in the past. We'll talk
about it again today. But it is, it's a significant discovery that they've made over there.
I mean, don't get us wrong. I mean, we often give the impression that we know quite a lot,
you know, and that we've got some of the fundamentals nailed down, enabled us to,
you know, talk over the top of it, you know, to bring context to the stuff. But I have to say,
I think this one knocked us for six, because we're thinking, how can we talk about the movement of
farming from Mesopotamia and out of Anatolia and the Levant and across the Aegean to Greece and
beyond without knowing of this particular bit of machinery, which would have made a profound,
which must have been fundamental to the ability to reap the harvest, the ability to create surplus
and to feed people in such a way that, you know, populations begin to expand. It's quite
something. So we'll probably park that, you know, the profound bit of the conversation
maybe till a little bit later. So hang around for that.
But in the meantime, there's some nitty gritty about this research.
I mean, where does it start from, the research? Where do you get the impression, you know,
that what kicked this bit of research off? What were they looking for, do we think?
Well, when you start looking at micro blades, so early sickles, for example, we do know that
flint was used widely, make flint blades and glue them into whatever sort of handle you
want to be using, different shapes were available. And so when you're looking at different types of
blades and their different uses, I think what flagged things up for people was the rare occasions
when they would find a variety of blades, some of which were not sharp at all, some of which had
clearly, they had a different purpose. And it was the knowledge of threshing sledges. I don't know
why I find that so difficult to say. Threshing sledges. We've known about these. They were still
using them up until, in fact, there are probably some places in the world where they still do,
but they were being used up until very recently, just because of modern machinery, that it's more,
you know, it's quicker and more efficient to use the modern machinery. But they were still using
threshing sledges very, very recently. We're talking decades ago. So our knowledge and
understanding of threshing sledges is extreme. So being able to recognise that some of these
little blades were clearly not cutting blades, it looked as if they had come from this sort of usage.
So that was the game changer, really, to push back this use of machinery, I'm going to call it
machinery, to that far back in Greece. I think that was what kicked it off, isn't it? Am I right?
Yes, I think so. And the other thing is that what seem to be very, very fine points,
that's a bit of a pun on what we're talking about. But what we know as archaeological
fine points is the distinguishing factor between how you can distinguish between,
distinguish what a piece of stone has been used for by looking at the wear signature on the blade
or wherever it is on the stone. And being able to distinguish the wear characteristics of a piece of
stone attached to a threshing sledge on the bottom is distinguishable from a piece of flint that's
been attached to a sickle for cutting. Before we go any further, I think we should probably
describe a threshing sledge so that there's a kind of visual thing. I'll put a picture up,
but maybe some kind of description I think is appropriate as well.
I think the easiest description is, imagine a flat board and on the underside of the flat board
you have embedded lots and lots and lots of stone blades. And they're not sharp necessarily,
they don't need to be sharp. All they need is to be able to crush the grass, the crop.
Agitate it, that's a good word. When you're dragging it across. So they would have been
pulled by cattle. I suppose they could have been pulled by very strong people, but no,
pulled by cattle. I think in some cases they were pulled by people. It's just a question
of what you've got available. Horses, donkeys, whatever. Indeed. Yes, in fact,
any beast of burden you've got to feel sorry for them. But it's just dragging the board
with all those little blades across the top of the grasses and that would separate out
the grass seeds, it would separate all the grain in theory. Is that a good enough description?
Yeah, and then make it available for winnowing or separating out on a good windy day.
Yes. Separating out the seeds from the chaff. Indeed. The wheat from the chaff.
Such a familiar phrase, the wheat from the chaff. I mean, I suppose it's biblical, isn't it?
That's where it gets embedded. And yet such a phrase is such embedded in our minds and yet
we've forgotten how fundamental it is to our existence, certainly as the way we are today.
We rather take for granted the process of the creation of bread and other side products.
So I think the other aspect of this is that previously it had been assumed that the threshing
sled or the use of it was a later development in Europe, you know, 2,000 years later than this
discovery or than this research proves. So I think the surprise in all of this,
or one of the surprises, I should put it that way, is that this way of doing things
lands or is apparent in Greece, in Thessaly, at this time so shortly after it is known that the
Neolithic package, the first farmers in other words, arrived in Greece, you know, from across
the Aegean. I mean, the first record that there is of Neolithic settlement in the Aegean is on
Crete, I think 6,800, 6,900 BCE. And here we are on the mainland and, you know, the fact that this
has been worked out from several different sites gives you the impression, oh, this isn't a one-off,
this is already common practice on the mainland so few years after we know the first settlements
arrived in the Aegean, which tends to tell us that the threshing sledge would have been part
of the whole Neolithic package coming over from Anatolia and the Levant.
Do you know, it raised a really big question for me in that a little while ago when we were
talking about early farming and a team of researchers had done a lot of number crunching
and had come up with a statistic that one man, if he worked hard for three weeks at harvesting time,
if one man worked hard for three weeks, he could gather enough grain to feed his family for a year,
family of four was how it was calculated. And this made me think, whoa, hold on,
this makes the gathering of grain quite a lot more efficient. So if threshing sledges were a thing
back then, just how much grain could you have gathered as a group of people at harvesting time?
You know, that suddenly the possibilities for feeding a lot of people change significantly,
don't they? So I mean, in brief, I mean, quoting, I think, from the paper itself, it says the
findings shed light on the diffusion and evolution of Neolithic farming systems from the nearest
east to Europe, suggesting a complex interplay of technological transfer, adaptation to new
environments and socioeconomic factors in agricultural development. There should have
just read that off and well said at the beginning would have been sorted. What we are bypassing,
though, for the moment are the technical aspects of this paper and of this research, because
they're quite deep, quite technical. And I'll show you some pictures of blades. And it just
boggles the mind, the ability using these techniques to be able to discern use where
one sort for another. These times, it says by integrating traditional use where analysis
with quantitative methods, the study provides a more precise understanding of the wear patterns
associated with threshing sledges. Yes. It has to be said that you have to take your hats off
to the people who were doing this research, because when you look at the detail in paper,
what they have analysed on a macroscopic and microscopic level, how they've analysed the blades
and how they could tell the difference between a blade that had been used for cutting, for example,
that's quite obvious. But then the blades underneath it had always been in contact with
essentially the ground and just being dragged along. And the different wear patterns to discern
those differences on very small blades a lot of the time. It's impressive work, it's got to be
said. Yeah, hats off and kudos to Niccolo Mazzucco, who's the guy in charge, the lead author on on
this. I'll put up a sidebar. It'll tell you a little bit more about him. So hats off to him.
So what else can we say about this? There is so much we could do a whole,
we could do several programmes on this. And I think it'll probably underline when we go back
to looking at Mesopotamia, we talk about Gobekli Tepe to Stonehenge. If we're talking about the
agriculture in the first place, you know, very early, you know, with 8000 BCE, pre-pottery
Neolithic B, the timescale we're looking at, you know, for us, it really focuses on that
transition point, you know, when do people start transitioning from using wild cereals
to domestic cereals? What happened? Who was it invented the threshing sledge?
Hats off to him. Yes, absolutely. And also, another point that's, that's worth bearing in
mind is that it's only in the last few years, I think 2018, Jane Gastra from UCL and her team,
they showed that ankle bones in cattle had been used for traction in Eastern Europe. So Bulgaria,
Romania, places like that. And there was a big question of what was the traction? You know,
because okay, you know, the animals were being used for dragging things, but was it timbers?
Was it this? Was it that? And now you have a very solid reason for what the animals may have been
used for. And that's quite significant, I think.
One thing I did want to mention before we finish or start wrapping up is that what's remarkable
is that there's a small sample size to this, there's a small sample size to the whole study.
And in relationship to the number of sickle blades that have been found, the number of
stones that relate to the threshing sledge is pretty tiny by comparison, you know, so
working on a small sample, sample size, and it sort of just brings to my mind, well, maybe that's
why not a lot of fuss has been made about the threshing sledge as a thing because the evidence
is actually fairly slim. I think it's, the evidence is good enough to be able to state
the existence of threshing sledges way back to, into the pre-pottery Neolithic.
But we don't know enough about them to be able to state that categorically. It's one of those
areas where you've got to take your, where you've got to respect the problems of archaeology in the
field. The sorts of stones that we're looking at here, whether it be flint or the other stones
used on the bottom of a threshing sledge, is that they're completely unremarkable.
Yes. Yeah.
With a sickle blade, you've got half a chance in the field of having your eye in and recognising
it as a bit of worked flint. With a threshing sledge stone, easy to toss aside, I would have
thought, and especially as the finding of them seems to be relatively random, I'll tell you what,
I would have thought, you know, if they were going to find a threshing sledge it would come
in a sort of, there would be a bundle of flints and stones of this sort all in one place if one
had been left somewhere. But the thing is with the threshing sledge it's less likely to have been
taken back to the settlement that they related to. So they're probably still out there in the
wilderness or on the threshing, wherever the threshing floor was away from the settlement.
A sickle blade would have been found in settlement contexts because they're taken home. They'd be
more personal objects with need for attendance and sharpening on an almost daily basis. Well,
during the harvesting time anyway.
That's a good point. And there's another point that I think is interesting actually and that's
because this is integral to, they call it the secondary product revolution. This is when people,
so we'd got past just killing animals to eat them. We had started using them for their secondary
products. Now whether that was milk or wool or traction, the thing is that there was a reason
for keeping animals for different purposes. And the side effects, I don't mean side effects,
what do I mean? Secondary products, byproducts. Thank you. That's the word. The byproduct side
effects. One of the byproducts from this is that we're talking about a time when people were making
wattle and daub houses. And so if you've got all your grain together, you've got all your hay
together for threshing, that when you've extracted all the grain, what you're left with is straw,
which is, there you are, you've got building material. You mix that with that. So the fact
that you've got in this one thing of extracting your food from a situation, you've now got
building materials as well. Okay. Food for the animals at the same time. But it's an interesting
aspect of that, that it would make the creation of building material more efficient as well.
Well, yes. I mean, it's a phase shift in the whole sort of agricultural economic condition,
I suppose, when you've suddenly shifted from where you're making a bare living out of stuff
to something where you're actually producing byproducts as well. The ability to settle and
focus your lives or build a settlement or community around this activity becomes much more
a real prospect. Yay. So threshing sledges, who knew?
We didn't. Maybe we're the last. I don't know. And yet, like I said about sorting the wheat from
the chaff and the mention of the threshing floor, it's quite a biblical thing. If you do a search
on YouTube for threshing sledges or threshing floor or that, you're likely to come up with a
something from a biblically themed YouTube channel as anything else. In fact, I haven't
found any. They all seem to be religious based. Yeah. So maybe we're, you know,
we're breaking the mould here, Rupert. Maybe we should mention threshing sledges a lot more.
I think we should. And I think we probably will. Once I get used to saying it a little bit more
clearly, yes. Yeah, yeah. I mean, another byproduct of the threshing sledge and the
concept of the threshing floor is they've got to be circular. How often, you know,
how much do circles come up? Honestly, you're opening a can of worms there. Opening a can of
worms. Yeah. So what possibilities lie there? I don't know. And how would we go about relating
the two? That's a subject for another day, perhaps. So until that other day, I think it's
time to sign off. If you enjoyed this, please do give us the thumbs up, like and subscribe,
in other words. We've got a Patreon page, which we have got a beautiful and lovely community of
people who help keep our act in order. Other metaphors are available. Yes, wonderfully
supportive. So it'd be great to see you there. And of course, the whole Gobekli Teped to Stonehenge
project, which we've embarked upon, needs your support. Links in the description below.
Anywhere you can find to support us would be most welcome. And with that, it's time to say
bye bye from me. Bye bye from me. We'll see you again soon. See you.
All right. Threshing sledges.
Where will we get? Where will it take us?
