Lecture 9 (The Greek Polis: Athens)

Historical Identity
26 followers
3 Video Views·Aug 18, 2026
This is an educational series entitled "The Foundations of Western Civilization," presented by Thomas F. X. Noble, professor and historian at the University of Notre Dame, Indiana. This series covers the dawn of civilization in Sumer to the present day.
Produced by The Great Courses
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello once again and welcome to the ninth of our lectures in this series on
the foundations of Western civilization. In our last lecture we talked about
Sparta, one of the most famous and important of the Greek poleis. In this
lecture we turn to Athens, surely the most famous, the most important, in lots
of ways the most interesting of the Greek poleis. Now we saw in talking about
Sparta that a very orderly and therefore a very stable system was
created. When we turn to Athens we can forget about that. Order and stability
are not words that we would use if we talk about Athens. We can actually say
that what the Athenians did is proceed in orderly fashion from crisis to crisis.
That probably captures the Athenian system and the Athenian situation as
well as anything. The great story in Athens is basically this. It is a shift
of power from a relatively small number of eupatrids. Eupatrids are well-fathered
people. I'll tell you what the word means. Pater in Greek means father, as pater means
father in Latin, as Vater is father in German, as father is father in English, as
père is father in French, as padre is father in Spanish. That, by the way, is a
little lesson on the Indo-European family of languages, how we can see one
word that is so similar across a range of languages. But that doesn't help us
understand Athens very well. Back to the story. Athens had been run by well-
fathered men and over a period of about two centuries political power was
shifted to the demos, to the people as a whole. What people? That'll be part of
our job to explain. What people indeed. But we move from eupatrids to the demos.
Now with the luxury of hindsight we can see in Athens what seems like a very
orderly process that has almost an air of inevitability about it. The Athenians
marched forward to create a democracy. The process perhaps seems natural to us
because we admire democracy and we suppose that others would share our
admiration for democracy and therefore we assume that the Greeks would have
shared our admiration for democracy and that that's what they'd have done. They'd have
said, well we have a job to do. Let's create democracy. Rule by the people is what democracy is.
But ancient writers, as a matter of fact, were not positively disposed towards
democracy for the most part. A little later in this lecture we'll have
occasion to see why that would have been the case. Democracy was messy, it was
turbulent, it was unstable. Ancient writers didn't think that democracy was
necessarily a good thing or the thing towards which political evolution ought
naturally to tend. It is probably safe to say that at no moment during Athens'
long political evolution did any leader say, sort of wake up one morning and say,
I have an idea. Let's invent democracy. Let's have a democracy. Though the system
became more and more democratic. There is something ironically accidental about
the creation of Athenian democracy. As Athens' leaders responded to problem
after problem, crisis indeed after crisis, they accidentally stumbled upon a
democratic system. So let's observe that evolution over a period of time and see
how exactly it worked itself out in the great polis of Athens. In the seventh
century BC, much of the Greek world experienced a brief period of what the
Greeks themselves called tyranny. Now, tyranny didn't mean bad guys. It meant
something like a strong man who was a popular leader. In other words, the word
didn't necessarily carry negative connotations. It was a sort of a strong
man who was a popular leader. The two cities that in the seventh century, quite
interestingly, escaped tyranny were Athens and Sparta. What was generally
happening, again if we think back to those tensions in that generative period
as the Greek dark age was giving way to the Greek archaic period, we talked, for
instance, you may recall a couple of lectures back about the emergence of the
hoplite, the ordinary soldier as opposed to the aristocratic man on horseback. And
if a city is going to ask ordinary people to serve it and perhaps to die
for it, may very well have to give them some share in the political process. Well,
there was a great deal of social strife, a great deal of social contention in
Greek town. And in some towns, the popular classes, the popular group who felt that
they had been insufficiently rewarded for their contributions or had
not been permitted to participate in the system would bring forward one of their
own as a great leader or they might rally behind an aristocrat who sort of
turned into a popular leader in the town. So tyranny spread across much of the
Greek world. And this popular contention might have had economic roots, might have
had political roots, it may have been rooted in the demographic pressures that
we have talked about already. What is interesting then is how did Athens
respond to this period of political contention as compared, for example, to
Sparta. So everywhere else in the Greek world, or almost everywhere, tyranny. Sparta
creates the Lycurgan system, which we talked about in our last lecture. In Athens,
the process works a little differently. In 621, a man by the name of Draco was
empowered in Athens to codify the laws of the city. Now, he did this and he posted
them on tablets in the Agora, the Athenian marketplace, this big open square
that I referred to again in the previous lecture. The law code was extremely harsh.
Draconian is still a word we use for very harsh laws. But it represented a
very interesting and important concession to those who opposed the
arbitrary rule of the Eupatriots. Aristocrats could basically rule at their
pleasure, at their whim. In some ways, they really only had to answer to one
another and not to anyone else. Making Athens' laws public was to establish,
in principle, not yet, truth be told, in fact, but in principle, the idea that
Athenians would henceforth be governed by laws and not by men. It may occur to you
to ask, well, didn't men make those laws? And didn't some men have more power than
others? So, didn't the law still provide the opportunity for the powerful to rule?
The answer, excuse me, the answer, of course, is yes. But the principle was
established, that with a law as the public business of the people. You may recall,
we had mentioned that very same point several lectures ago, or a couple of
millennia ago, depending on how you look at it, in Mesopotamia. Publishing the laws
didn't relieve all problems. Ordinary Athenian farmers still suffered cycles of
boom and bust, of boom and bust. Remember, Athens has become a trading state. Farmers
are always subject to the vagaries of the weather. They are subject to the
vagaries of prices for crops. If there's tremendous amounts of cereal grains, for
example, produced in the Black Sea region at one time, the price of Athenian grain
goes down. If there are failures of crops elsewhere in the Mediterranean world,
let's say, on the coast of North Africa, the price of Athenian grain goes up. So
farmers were suffering cycles of boom and bust. This generated problems. And
there's another interesting group of people in Athens who have problems, and
that's precisely the merchants. If Athens is going to be, as indeed it was, a great
merchant city, it's going to attract large numbers of people who are fundamentally
living by commerce. But these are not local landowners. They are not necessarily
people with long traditions in the city, long rootedness in the city, family
connections in the city. They are not. Simply, the old, wealthy, landowning
eupatriots. What will be their place in this new Athens? They are responsible for
generating a great deal of its wealth, but they really don't have any place in
the system. In 594, the Athenians appointed a man by the name of Solon. To
this day, we still think of lawgivers as Solons. They appointed a man by the name
of Solon, a eupatriot, a man from a very old, old, important family, as nomothene,
as lawgiver. He was given an opportunity, really, to make a whole series of legal
provisions to try to introduce some reform into the Athenian system. Now,
Solon was an interesting person in lots of ways. He was a moderate. He was a
person without personal ambition himself, as far as we can tell. He didn't seek to
make himself famous. He didn't seek to aggrandize himself. He didn't seek to
line his own pockets. After, he was able to do this because he was wealthy enough
to sustain it, after he passed his reforms, he left Athens for 10 years, because he
wanted the system to work without him there to pull the strings and push the
He wanted the system to work for the Athenian people. So what kinds of things
did he do? He's got wealthy landowners who really don't want to share power.
He's got merchants who haven't quite found a place in the system, and he's got
farmers who are suffering from economic cycles of boom and bust. So what's he
going to do to help these people out? One of the first things he did was he
abolished many debts and debt slavery. One of the things that happened to large
numbers of farmers, and of course many farmers face the situation today, you
borrow this year to get your crop in the ground, and boy you hope that you can get
that crop back out of the ground and harvest it in the fall and have enough
money, A, to pay your debt back, and B, to put something in your pocket for
yourself until next spring when you put your crop in the ground again. Well, if
the crop fails or if the price falls dramatically, you fall into debt. And in
Athens, when farmers fell into debt several years in a row, they could
actually be enslaved by those to whom they were in debt. And some of these
Athenians had even been sold overseas and enslaved. So Solon puts an end to
debt slavery, and he actually sort of bought back a certain number of the
people who had been sold away. He changed the basic qualifications for office
holding and for voting in Athens, from birth to wealth. At first you may say, gee
that doesn't seem like such a big change, changing from birth to wealth,
distributing the right to hold office, the right to vote for office holders. But
what Solon did was actually very clever. He created a system that we could call
timocracy. That is to say, division of political power according to wealth.
Plutocracy is a system where the wealthy rule. You know, the golden rule, whoever
has the gold rules, that's plutocracy. Timocracy is to say, according to a scale
of wealth, you have power, you have places in this society. One of the things
he did is immediately equate the wealthiest of the merchants at the very
top of the system, because of their wealth, with the greatest of the
landowners. He built a place in the system for them. And so then right on down
a scale. Basically he created four classes by wealth, but he divided up then
political participation according to wealth, and he found a way to build the
merchants in, and he found a way even to mitigate some of the old powerful
families who were a bit less wealthy than some of the other old powerful
families. You might wind up with less power under Solon's system than you had
previously. He created a council of 400 that set the agenda for the assembly of
all Athenian male citizens. Now, that's interesting. That is exactly the
opposite of the system it's part of. Here in Athens, a relatively small group
chosen amongst the population as a whole, not men over 60 or something of the
sort, a relatively small group set an agenda, but the large group, the assembly
of all Athenian citizens, got to say yay or nay. Now, it's true that the
assembly was not accorded early on much initiative, but nevertheless they had
the opportunity to vote on issues put to them by a council of 400. Well, Solon
institutes this system, fairly moderate actually. Solon was also a bit of a poet.
He wrote a poem talking about how he was like a great bird. He put one wing over
one party and another wing over the other party. Both parties were, in the
generation after Solon, angry about what he had done. Some felt he had gone way
too far. Some felt he hadn't gone nearly far enough. It's an interesting thought.
I mean, if you were a politician and you had people on both sides of you who
disliked you equally, might that be a hint that you've done about the right
thing? Well, I don't know. I'll leave it to you to decide that. But there did
remain problems. Not all of the difficulties, not all of the stresses in
the Athenian system had been addressed by Solon's reforms. And as a result,
around about 560, the lower classes elevated a man by the name of Peisistratus
to a very mild form of tyranny in Athens. He really left most of the existing
institutions in place and ruled alongside them, even ruled through them. He
didn't really supplant the institutions, so he wasn't quite a tyrant in the
7th century Greek sense. He certainly didn't have the kind of domineering
power that some of those tyrants had had. He and then his sons after him
dominated the Athenian political scene for about 40 years. What did Peisistratus
do? In the first place, he respected most of Solon's system. He didn't really
change Solon's system dramatically, but he did redistribute some land. You see,
one of the interesting problems with Solon's system, Solon put an end to
debt slavery, and Solon bought back certain numbers of people who had been
sold into slavery. But if you bring back a former farmer and you don't give
him any land, what's he to do? He becomes part of an urban poor. He becomes part
of a permanent underclass. So one of the things that Peisistratus did was
mildly to redistribute land. How many times historically has land
redistribution been a fundamental issue of people who are or who see themselves
as reformers? Peisistratus did some other interesting things too. He
inaugurated a whole series of festivals in Athens, the great Panathenaic
Festival, about which we'll have more to say in later lectures, for instance.
He initiated massive public building projects in Athens. The first great set
of public buildings in Athens were built mainly in the time of Peisistratus.
Now, he did this for a number of reasons. At one level, it was boosterism.
He was really trying to make people proud of Athens. He wanted Athens really
to be something and to stand for something, and that was important. He was
trying in a certain way to get people to focus their loyalty on the city and
not on their particular class, their particular economic group, their
particular geographical area, their own partisan interests. But there's another
side to this. This led some historians actually to speak of an Athenian New
Deal. Somebody had to do the work of building all these buildings. And as you
had this increasing underclass, and you couldn't redistribute enough land to
take care of all of them, you could put large numbers of them to work, basically
at state pay, to build these buildings. So these then, in the time of Peisistratus
and of his sons who came after him, were some additional measures that the
Athenians envisioned as ways of sort of siphoning off some of the political
tension in the Athenian system. Eventually, the Spartans allied themselves
with a number of Eupatrid families in Athens and threw out the Peisistratid
regime. The Spartans had had enough of this regime. It looked a little bit too
democratic to them. It looked a little too unstable to them. It just might give
other people, like members of the Peloponnesian League for instance, funny
ideas about politics. What the Spartans wanted is a nice, stable Athens in the
hands of a bunch of rich old men who wouldn't disturb the situation very much.
Well, there's a wonderful law of unintended consequences in politics.
What happened is a Eupatrid, a real blue blood, a man by the name of
Cleisthenes, was elevated to power and given the opportunity to make some new
reforms. But Cleisthenes was on the outs with a lot of the other Eupatrids. He
really wanted to introduce some fairly moderate reforms. They were going to
block him at every step of the way and say, you know, we've had enough of all
this reform business. We don't want anything more. So Cleisthenes was sort of
drawn to do a great deal more than sort of ever he would have dreamed probably
at the beginning and certainly a whole lot more than the Spartans ever
envisioned when they thought they had thrown out exactly people like this.
From Cleisthenes to Pericles, let us say then from about 510 BC down to about
450 BC, over a period of about 60 years, two generations let's say, full
democracy emerged in Athens. Or we can say the Athenian democracy became as
fully democratic as it would ever become. How did that happen? Well, Cleisthenes
as I've indicated was very much disappointed with the Eupatriots. So he
turned to the Deimos. He turned to the Athenian people. He began to build the
people into the Athenian system in a much more decisive way than ever Solon
had done. And even where Peisistratus had done this emotionally, psychologically
and to a degree economically, Cleisthenes began to do it institutionally. He
began to build the Deimos into the system. He created, for example, a new
council of 500. Now it was divided up into groups of 50, which formed a kind
of a rotating executive committee that sat for a month at a time. The way he
developed this council, it's actually very, very complicated, but there's a
very simple idea underlying it. It's quite interesting. People then in Athens
spoke of the plain, the coast and the hill. Now these were shorthands. The plain
was the plain of Attica, the great farmland. The coast meant the port, meant
the merchants. The hill meant the uplands, the bad farmland. What Cleisthenes
did in a way was gerrymander the political structure of Athens so that he
took a group of people from the plain, a group from the coast, a group from the
hill and made them one group. Then another group from the plain and a group
from the coast and a group from the hill and made them one group. He made 10 such
groups. And then each of these groups could choose 50 members annually for the
council. Now what he was trying to do was break down local interest, break down
family interest, break down occupational interest and make people cooperate, make
them think about Athens. Posistratus, remember, had the idea of doing this by
making Athens beautiful, make something to be really proud of. Cleisthenes said,
no, I got a different idea. I'm going to build an institution that makes people
cooperate. He opened virtually all offices to almost all men. Remember
Solon's timocracy, Solon's system of arraying political participation by
wealth. Cleisthenes opened up virtually the whole system to almost all men. There
remained a few political disabilities. We'll see one or two of them go away
here in 10 or 20 years or in just a couple of minutes depending on how you
want to look at it. But essentially men could now vote and men could now hold
office. Cleisthenes introduced something else very interesting too. One of the most
distinctive features of the Athenian system, ostracism. Now we know what
ostracism is. We ostracize somebody we don't like and we won't talk to them and so on.
Ostracism worked a little differently in Athens. Ostraca is the Greek word for a pot
chart. Once a year the Athenians were bid and come to the Agora and they could vote.
They voted by writing a name on a pot chart. If a sufficient number, several
thousand, if a sufficient number of votes were cast, then whoever got the most votes
had to leave Athens for 10 years. Cleisthenes' idea here was that anybody who really
angered the demos, either by doing things that were foolish and stupid on the one
hand or by doing things that were damaging to the interest of the people on the
other hand, would get their comeuppance by being thrown out. Obviously you didn't
campaign for ostracism but people might and people did get ostracized. So
ostracism, pot chart-ism is actually what the word means from the ostraca.
After Cleisthenes there were some additional reforms that came into the Athenian
system. For instance, from 490 until 478 the Greek world fought a massive war with
the Persians, a war in two great phases. We'll have something to say about those
Persian wars in a couple of later lectures. For now I simply want to say that it was
the Athenian navy, finally and above all else, it was the Athenian navy that won
the war. The lowest class citizens in the state, the ones who had been left at the
bottom by Solon, the ones who had really not been quite fully incorporated by
Cleisthenes, were the rowers in those ships. They found a great leader in the
Athenian general, we would actually say admiral, Themistocles. Themistocles then
managed to get laws passed through the Athenian assembly essentially to make
the lowest class, represented by those sailors, fully able to participate
publicly and politically at Athens, to vote, to hold office and so on. So in
crucial respects then the last sort of pieces of the Solonic and Cleisthenic
limitations were knocked down. Now in the 460s and 450s Athens experienced a
period of leadership by two men, Ephialtes and then by Pericles. Ephialtes
and Pericles together removed in many respects the last vestiges of
aristocratic privilege in the Athenian system. They did basically two things, a
number of things, but two I think are particularly important. First, they
stripped the old Areopagus of all its rights of judicial review. This is a body
not unlike the ephors in Sparta. It was a body of Eupatrides who could sort of
pass judgment on the constitutionality of measures passed by the assembly. It
remained as a kind of an institutional break on the full operations of the
Athenian assembly. So the last review powers of the Areopagus were struck down.
The second thing they did is they introduced pay for public service. Now this is often
for us in contemporary America a controversial issue. Should we do it at
all? Do we pay our legislators too much money? Should we pay them less money? Do
they have the right to vote themselves racist? We get very heated up about this
issue and we should. That's fine. But there's something very fundamental about
paying people for public service. If you did not do it and if you were an
Athenian or you were an American living right now, only the idle rich could serve.
Only the idle rich, not even the working rich. Because if you're a person who has
to get up every morning and go to your job, you can't for months at a time,
weeks at a time, months at a time, or maybe even more or less permanently over
a period of year, simply give up everything you do. So pay for public
service is also in critical respects a democratizing force. We get to about 450
and as a result of one crisis after another, virtually all men can participate,
virtually all men can vote, and there are no checks on the system such as
wealth, if I'm not wealthy I can't afford to serve, or an old aristocratic body
serving as a brake on the law. How did the system actually work in practice? Well,
the Athenian system had a very weak executive. The executive officers, they
were called archons. Archon in Greek means a ruler. There were three of them
elected every year. They were relatively weak. They weren't powerful. They weren't
as powerful, for example, as the kings at Sparta. The critical institution at
Athens became the assembly. It was here that the ordinary Athenians could
participate and from all indications we have, indications in the Greek historians,
indications in dramas, indications in surviving speeches from some of the
great Athenian orators, debate was vigorous in the assembly. People really
did speak. They really did argue. That's important if we want to think about a
democratic system. It's also true to say that there was a danger of demagoguery
in Athens. A demagogue is a leader of the people, and the word does carry a
slightly unsavory connotation. The assembly was, certainly its critics said,
too easily swayed. It was too changeable. Now that produced a situation that also
means that there was really no continuity in Athenian policy, or at least
constitutionally, there was no necessity of continuity. Remember, the Spartan
system was designed in a sense to ward off change, to make change almost
impossible. The Athenian system could accommodate change, but what it couldn't
do very easily was put the brakes on change. We'll have occasion in a couple
of later lectures to see some of the consequences, some of the implications of
that fact. For now, I just want to remark it. Athens was freewheeling and wide
open, and that's a good thing. But Athens was freewheeling and wide open, and
that's not such a good thing. There's two stories here, good news and bad
news. For whom did the system work? Well, for Athenian citizens. Who's that? Adult
males with two Athenian parents. Perhaps 10% of a population of 400,000 people. So,
for whom did it not work? Well, it wasn't for women. It wasn't for medics. Medics
were resident aliens in Athens, people who had come there to work, people who
had come there as merchants. It didn't work for slaves, who became increasingly
numerous in the Athenian scheme of things. So, for something like 10% of the
population, this was a remarkably democratic system. For almost everybody
else, it was not. How was it financed? Well, after the Persian Wars, some of the
Greeks, led by Sparta, simply wanted to go home. War's over, that's that. Some of
the Greeks said no. There remained Greeks on islands in the Aegean Sea and on the
Ionian coast, on the western shore of Anatolia, who are still under Persian
domination. Let us go and free them. Athens led that party. For a period of
years, there was much cooperation among the groups of people who went to
liberate the Ionian Greeks, and then in 454 BC, Athens turned this sort of
voluntary association into an Athenian Empire, and the Athenians collected with
a vengeance tribute from that empire. Allegedly, that tribute was
to pay for the military cost, the naval cost, of fighting the Persians. In point
of fact, it went into the pockets of Athenians. It paid their politicians, for
example, and it built those glorious buildings like the Parthenon. The Athenian
system was also paid for by slave labor. Slavery was less prominent, less visibly
prominent, less structurally prominent in Athens than in Sparta, but it was
nevertheless an important component of the system. Who defended? Pericles did, the
great leader, in his funeral oration in Thucydides' Great History of the
Peloponnesian War, the wars between Athens and Sparta. And we'll turn to
Thucydides' history and that oration in a later lecture. So I want to pause for the
moment and say that almost everybody criticized Athens, attacked Athens. Plato
and Aristotle, for example, said that what was wrong with Athens is it did not
bring the best men forward. They said government should be by hoi aristoi, the
best. Aristocracy is not by a bunch of people born privileged, but in the Greek
sense aristocracy is ruled by the best. Plato and Aristotle said it never happened.
Democracy is not going to bring the best forward. An anonymous treatise written by
somebody called the Old Oligarch said that what was wrong with the Athenian
system was that it lacked deference. It lacked deference for the great and the
good and the important citizens. It was changeable. It was subject to demagoguery.
You never knew what they were going to do next. Here was this call for stability.
Thucydides gives us many examples of folly, cruelty, perversity. He really was
giving the concrete examples of the kinds of changeableness that the Old
Oligarch, that Plato and Aristotle and others had commented on. Thucydides
simply parades the follies of the Athenians and invites us to reflect on
and he does this despite being actually in the end favorably disposed to Athens.
What must our verdict be? Athenian democracy has after all, as I've suggested
in earlier lectures, fired people's imagination for two and a half
millennia. The Athenians demonstrated what a democracy might be. It remained
for others to show how it might work and for whom it might work. Now I said that
the polis is a political and a social institution and we've talked a little
about Sparta and Athens as political and social institutions. I also said the
polis is a cultural institution. In the next several lectures we'll reflect a
little bit on the kind of culture that a polis makes.
