Weaving Stories: The Threads of Myth and Archaeology in Ancient Greece #RealArchaeology

Ancient Explained - History Clearly Understood.
17 followers
14 Video Views·Dec 2, 2024
Well hello everyone and welcome to my library. If you're new here, hi, my name is Chintzy Dubois
and I'm very excited today to be part of the Real Archaeology online conference. Thank you so much
Flint for including me in this. Obviously I am not really an archaeologist, I study more ancient
history and classical literature, but part of my research for my thesis at the moment is on weaving
and storytelling, which is why I thought it'd be really cool to look into the internet connection
between how stories can lead us into archaeological discoveries and discussions as which, and how
storytelling and archaeology can coincide. So the first time we meet Helen of Troy is in book three
of the Iliad in her chamber. Iris takes the form of Laodice, which is Paris's sister, and finds
Helen quote, weaving a massive double-layered cloth in dazzling colours, patterning upon it
the many troubles, tests and tribulations that Trojan horsemen and bronze-armoured Greeks
suffered at Ares' hands because of her. Helen of Troy weaves into textiles that which the poet
of the Iliad, Homer, spins into poetry. The pair tell the tale of the Trojan War, one in situ,
the other ex situ. Helen is an emblem of the poet and a predecessor of Homer, according to his text.
Through him, we are told, it was a woman who documented the tale of the Trojan War before
the famous male poet did. But her text, i.e. her textile, is not oral but visual, and made of more
organic material than his song, and thus did not stand the test of time. Nagy claims the parallelism
between poetic narration and pattern weaving is a matter of metaphor, one which is embedded in
the narrative of Homeric poetry. Paul de Manin, Blindness and Insight, uses the apparent relationship
between Helen's tapestry and the Homeric bard to comment on the sameness of oral and visual arts.
Quote, the self-reflecting mirror effect by means of which a work of fiction asserts is by its very
existence, its separation from empirical reality, its divergence as a sign from a meaning that
depends for its existence on the constitutive activity of this sign, characterizes the world of
literature in its essence. I like when people sum things up nice and easily for me. Weaving and
textile manufacturing have been analogous to storytelling for centuries. Tales were woven
into tapestries whilst tales were sung alongside them as they were constructed by groups of women
whose voices, like the tapestries they made, deteriorated and vanished, leaving no archaeological
trace aside from the tools that they used. But in a rather poetic tandem of events, we can recapture
that which is classified as archaeologically invisible through stories and uncover the details
of textiles from the ancient world through glimpses of them that we see in stories that they may have
once told. The etymological and metapoetic link between weaving and text is extensive throughout
Homeric poetry. Though Homer never directly links weaving to poetry, he does employ the image of
weaving words to describe intellectual activity such as effective rhetoric. Odysseus, Nestor,
and Menelaus weave wiles and words, as does Athena, who is the only woman throughout the
Homeric texts who is depicted as weaving metaphorically. We never see Athena weave,
despite being the creator and patron of weaving and the loom. However, we do hear of her weaving
skills. In the Iliad Book 5, for example, she is said to remove her ornately woven peplos,
which she made herself, with her own hands. The connection between weaving and poetic
is made more explicitly by Homer through the scenes of Calypso and Circe, who sing whilst
weaving. He makes a further connection between weaving and storytelling through Helen's tapestry,
detailing the story of the Trojan War. The representation of the poet and their meter as
a woven song is an image firmly implanted in the works of Greek lyric poets, and Aristotle
observed the mechanical parallels between the poet and the striking the strings of their lyre
with their plectrum, and the weaver the strings of their loom with their shuttle. Sappho also
calls Eros a story weaver, and Callimachus wrote of, quote, the story woven on a staff. Pindar
employs weaving as a metaphor frequently throughout his odes, though examples of
weaving as a poetic metaphor reside notably in his Menian Odes. Quote, quickly now, sweet lyre,
weave out this song too, and, quote, as he wove his words, an unthrowable wrestler in speech.
Additionally, the etymology of text comes from the Latin textus, meaning framework, structure,
method of plaiting, web, or woven fabric. Nagy goes even further with this connection,
arguing in his book, Homer and the Classic, that the noun homnos, meaning hymn or song of praise,
one usually to the gods, derives from the verb root hyph, as in hyphenaean, weave. But what is
left of the women's work, both mythologically and archaeologically, is minimal. Women's work
in history and text is largely invisible. Whilst we are told that Helen wove of the Trojan War,
the contents of other tapestries within Homeric texts, such as those of Penelope and Andromache,
are primarily unknown. Some scholars have argued that Penelope's shroud for Laertes
may have been a story cloth, considering the length of time she spent weaving it.
Similarly, the flowers of Andromache's tapestry may have mythological connotations,
but no more details are given. In Emily Wilson's translation of the Iliad, she claims Helen weaves
in dazzling colours, which, for anyone familiar with the text, is a rather novel approach.
Others, such as Fagles, have famously translated porphyrios, purple, as dark red,
crimson or purple, rather than dazzling colours. The ancient Greeks didn't describe colours the
way we do. Their words weren't intended to detail precise shades of colours. Instead,
the words for colours covered wider ranges, because the ancient Greeks were more interested
in the impression a colour made. Their words aimed to capture elements of colour, such as
its saturation, its movement or poetic nature. For example, the colour of Achilles' hair,
xanthos, is popularly translated into blonde or golden, for simplicity. But the word xanthos
describes that which is reddish-yellow, blonde or auburn. And when the word xanthos is applied
to horses, it can translate into either sorrel or cream-coloured. Now, purple dye in the ancient
Greek world is also deeply significant. The history of shellfish purple, or Tyrian purple,
or royal purple, dates back almost 4,000 years. And just like xanthos, the colour ranged from
anything from different shades of violet to freshly dried blood and purple-red. Hence why
many translators choose to translate it as crimson, for simplicity. Tyrian purple was one of the most
precious dyes with a supreme reputation, and was thus reserved for the robes of the elite.
In his Natural History, Pliny the Elder details the procedure of dyeing royal purple in the Roman
Empire, and it reads as follows, quote,
Next, 500 pounds of dye stuff, diluted with amphora of water, are subjected to an even and
moderate heat, by placing the vessels in the flue, communicating with a distant furnace.
Meanwhile, the flesh, which necessarily adheres to the veins, is stimmed off, and the test is made
about the tenth day, by steeping a well-washed fleece in the liquefied contents of one of the
The liquid is then heated till the colour answers to expectations.
While Wilson chooses not to describe Helen's tapestry as purple,
she does not shun the colour purple entirely. Later in the poem, in Book 22, Andromache also
weaves a double-layered purple cloth in the text, which Wilson translates as such.
Both Helen and Andromache's tapestries are parallel to one another,
and are described as diplika porphyroreos. Whilst porphyroreos means purple,
porphyroreos can also mean gleaming, glittering, or shimmery.
Homer famously calls the sea wine-dark in colour, but sometimes he also calls it purple.
Porphyroreos as a word describes a mix of brightness and movement, as well as the colour purple.
As Wagner-Hazel explains, we see purple dye in the clothing of high-status individuals,
who wear it in epic poetry, such as Agamemnon, Achilles, Nestor, Thoas, Odysseus, and Telemachus.
In the Iliad, Achilles is said to bring with him purple-coloured textiles from Thessaly,
and Agamemnon wears a purple mantle.
Similarly, it's believed purple played a huge role in the Panathenaia.
The Panathenaia was an Athenian festival celebrated every June,
over multiple days in honour of the goddess Athena,
who, it is important to reiterate in this paper, was the patron of spinning and weaving.
During the festival, a peplos was pattern-woven for the Great Presentation to Athena at the
Great Panathenaia, and according to detailed descriptions in ancient sources, the peplos
was purple, and we know from sculptures and paintings that the peplos depicted the
The Appendix Virgiliana Kairis details how, during the festival,
the Athenian ship of a saint adorning a pattern-woven peplos of Athena was rigged to the
mast of a ship as a stylised sail, and that was paraded on wheels along the route of the
Panathenaic procession.
It is said that this peplos was dyed of a purple so deep it appears like the colour of red.
Now, all this purple talk may sound like a tangent detached from archaeology,
but this is where weaving, storytelling and archaeology intersect.
First, let's look at the gleaming element of purple, which is an adjective also employed
when describing the gleaming of women's linen, as well as gifts, including metalwork and
textiles.
This gleaming, whilst poetic, also reflects the archaeological reality of the colour,
thanks to its production.
Tyrian purple comes from the secretion of sea snails, and this stinky and time-consuming
process was as significant to the ancients as mining for gold.
In fact, in visual art, when the sheen of gold could not be represented appropriately,
it was marked by the colour purple for both its gleaming nature and its status.
Murex was extracted from the mollusks whilst they were still alive, before the Murex was
exposed to sunlight, during which it changed colour.
However, this took a very long time, as for every gram of dye, up to 12,000 mollusks were
needed.
The colour was less produced after the fall of the Byzantine and Roman empires, and it
was completely lost to history by the 14th century.
It was only thanks to experimentations in the 21st century that the technique for extracting
this colour was rediscovered in just 2001.
During the extensive excavations in the palace of the Qatna complex in Syria, excavations
noticed patches of brown staining on the floor of a high-status tomb.
After chemically extracting the stain, they discovered the presence of brominated derivatives
of indigo and indirubin, with its source likely being that of a hexaplex trunculus, i.e.
sea snails.
Right on an archaeological site, they discovered the renowned Tyrian or royal purple that was
mentioned by Pliny.
As James et al. explain, the loci of several of the purple-coloured extracts were associated
with the presence of precious artefacts.
Naturally, the textiles decayed, but they believe the pigments found were sediment extracts
of the remnants of royal purple used to dye those fabrics.
What's more incredible is that they found the ghosts of those fabrics.
Conducting microscopic hand-sorting of sediments collected from the tomb floor, the team discovered
thousands of millimetre-sized fragments of textile, identifiable from weave patterns,
with many of them exhibiting traces of colour.
Further, X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy showed that textile fragments were
preserved as fossilised gipsum replicas.
That being said, this isn't to say that the myths accurately always portray the archaeological
reality of ancient weaving practices.
Something that we see painted on pottery but less so mentioned in ancient texts is the
collaborative nature of textile production.
Whilst unnamed women or enslaved women are described as weaving in groups, such as the
seven women skilled in all crafts Agamemnon bargains Achilles with as a peace offering,
or the fifty enslaved girls spinning yarn in Alkinois's palace, and the enslaved Cydonia
women who craft the ornately woven robes for Hecuba, named women such as Penelope, Calypso
and Circe, Andromache and Helen are presented in a way that suggests they're working alone,
particularly divine women.
But weaving in the ancient world was far from a solo craft.
Textile manufacturing was a long and intensive labour.
Depending on the size of the cloth being woven, the loom might well be over a metre wide,
and for weaving a peplos, most estimates put the width of the loom as 1.45 to 1.85 metres.
Spinning and weaving experiments conducted by researchers have attempted to calculate
rough estimations of how time-consuming these practices were in the Mycenaean textile production.
Using records from Linear B tablets, the researchers could see that every woman was
expected to deliver one piece of cloth which was either of the quality of a teapar, which
is 21 kilos of raw wool.
As a test, Nosh used the Scandinavian Experimental Archaeology and expert spinners and weavers
to estimate what one person could spin.
They found out that one person could spin an average of 20 metres of thread per hour.
If these estimations translated over to Mycenaean women, over a 10-hour workday, it would take
one woman 1,950 hours or 195 days to produce just one teapar, and that would be using a
30-gram spindle.
But if they were only using a 5-gram spindle, that time would increase to 700 days.
Carr estimates that for a family of three free adults and a child and two slaves, the
adult textile production would take 38 to 47 hours of work a week.
Now teapar were not decorative and were required in mass amounts, meaning tens if not hundreds
of women and children were required to work on them.
I recently heard Emily Hauser speak about her upcoming book, Mythica, in which she talks
all about how ancient women and archaeology intersect.
In her paper she delivered, she specifically spoke of Calypso and the incongruence between
her textile manufacturing ability and the historical reality of such a production output.
Hauser pointed out that in Book 5 of the Odyssey, Calypso, who allegedly worked alone, constructed
a sail for Odysseus along with clothes in just a four-day period.
Yet the estimated time for one woman to produce a sail using a weighted loom is four years,
let alone the time it would take for her to produce the clothes for Odysseus as well.
So we can only imagine how many theoretical women and children would have been needed
to produce enough sails to launch a thousand ships.
But if it had just been Calypso in charge of the production line using her scale, it
would have still taken 10 years, 11 months and two weeks and six days to produce a thousand
sails, which is a lot.
To translate that into real life with real people, there was a lot of weaving going on
in the ancient world.
But that's everything for today's mini little lecture on weaving and storytelling.
I really hope you enjoyed it.
Thank you so much again to Flint and everyone for organising Real Archaeology.
I really enjoyed being part of it.
I hope you enjoyed the paper as well.
And if you're interested, I talk all about dark ancient history and mythology and the
stories from it.
So if you're interested, please consider liking and subscribing.
And if you're also interested in technically my more personal PhD research, I do have a
third channel where I have a plan on lots of little videos I'm releasing on there.
So if you have any questions, you're interested, I will leave a link to that channel down below
because that's all launching soon.
Thank you so much again for listening.
And remember, be happy and healthy and books save lives.
So keep reading.
