JUMBOs, Jupiter Mass Binary Objects. Over 500 of them were detected in the Orion Nebula by JWST. But where did they come from? How did they form and why are they in binary pairs? My guest has a good guess about it.
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
one of the most interesting discoveries
that's been made by the James web Space
Telescope is the analysis and discovery
of jumbos Jupiter Mass binary objects
these are objects with roughly the size
and mass of planets like Jupiter maybe
even down to Saturn some are larger that
are in the Orion Nebula what's really
strange is that about 9% of these are in
wide binary orbits where you've got two
objects with roughly the mass of are
orbiting around each other and since
their Discovery astronomers have been
absolutely puzzled at how you could get
such a thing do they form in place that
doesn't make sense are they ejected from
existing star systems that doesn't make
sense my guest today has a third Theory
my guess is Jessica Diamond she is a
master student at the University of
Sheffield and she conducted a project
with Dr Richard Parker on the photo
evaporation of stars at an explanation
for jumbos in other words these Jupiter
sized planets were actually once Stars
maybe even more massive than the Sun and
being around so many enormous bright hot
Stars wore them down sand blasted them
away bullied them to become much smaller
objects and that would explain how you
could have binary Stars which is very
common ending up being binary Jupiter
sized objects so if that possible
solution intrigues you enjoy this
conversation with Jessica Diamond
Jessica can you give me a sense of how
we first learned that these Jupiter Mass
objects exist in nebula like the Orion
Nebula yeah so I mean we know that
objects that are substellar so Brown
dwarfs planetary Mass objects such as
rogue planets they exist um but
two astronomers Samuel Pearson and Mark
mcran were doing
a um Research into the Arion nebula
cluster into the trapezium cluster
within the Orion Nebula and they did a
near infrared survey using the James web
Space Telescope on their near cam so
near infrared survey camera and they
used a range of filters in order to try
and see extremely low mass objects and
they found what appears to be these 540
planetary Mass objects and of these
objects 9% they thought were found in
wide binaries and this came as a
surprise because way fewer high mass
binary systems tend to be
found and they found that they weigh
between 0.6 to 13 times the mass of
Jupiter now now there were hints that
these things were there before that
right observations had been made with
Hubble and other infrared instruments
detecting them but but web sort of
improved the detection limit yeah
because web is designed to be more
sensitive than past telescopes that
we've used it can use a wide variety of
filters and wavelengths in order to view
new objects and reach better depths yeah
so we've got these observations of these
objects
and like if we were to sort of see them
here in the solar
system is do we have a an analog so in
terms of size like I said they are about
0.6 to 13 times the mass of Jupiter so
this is around a little bit bigger than
Saturn around Jupiter size to 13 times
Jupiter size so that's pretty big uh
bigger than any planet in our so system
but a lot smaller than the sun like
bordering on on brown dwarf size and
mass so Brown dwarfs have a limit and
their Mass limit is less than or equal
to 0.08 times the mass of the Sun so
this is their upper limit so their lower
limit is a lot lower and kind
of borderlines everything kind of
overlaps and if there're and so the
lower limit of of a brown dwarf would be
around 10 Jupiter masses so there is
that small overlap there right yeah um
PE people always ask me like you know
when would Jupiter turn into the sun
right and you know only if you could
find like another 80 Jupiters and masch
them all together can you finally get to
like the smallest possible star so it's
I mean I I think it's it's kind of
amazing that that these things have have
been discovered because they really are
tiny as omally speaking compared to the
other kinds of things that are in these
nebula you know you you know whenever I
do astrophotography I have to do a very
short exposure on the trapezium part of
the or nebula because it's so bright
there's so much going on there so we've
got these objects and and the sort of
the really intriguing Discovery was this
idea that that yeah 9% of these are in
wide binary so so give us a sense of of
like what is a wide binary
so we view objects in binary systems and
we have what's called
multiplicity which is when we view
different types of stars and substellar
objects which are in binaries triple
quadruple continued systems and we call
them separations is how far away they
are
so we have we have a function for these
and you can see you would assume that
the bigger objects would be the ones
that are really far apart from each
other because they're so big they can be
orbiting a center of mass and still stay
in these binaries and the smaller the
object gets the smaller the you would
assume the binary separation to be but
because we found these objects and these
objects weirdly appear to Peak their
binaries appear to Peak within a type
binary sort of distribution their
distributions are between 25 and 390
astronomical units H right right so like
way out beyond the orbit of Pluto in the
solar system yeah um like binary stars
are very common I mean we we see them
and the and as you say you know the
multiple star systems like this is very
common and I think the mechanism for how
you get a binary
star is fairly understood that you that
you've got or you know maybe
maybe now there's a big argument I don't
know but but that that two clouds of gas
separately form orbiting each other and
you get the star especially in the wide
binary format so why were the jumbos
these Jupiter Mass objects in a binary
configuration wide binary why was that
considered so
surprising well like I said with the
objects so we have brown dwarfs and you
see brown dwarfs in binaries but their
binary Mass fraction is low and and
there also a SE there's also a
separation of around four astronomical
units for these Brown dwars and if
you're thinking of objects that are even
smaller than brown dwars you would think
that they would have even
smaller separations but they don't in
terms of the research that Pearson and
McAn found a year ago huh so so if you
sort of have this Continuum of
stars or two objects that are orbiting
around each other and you're comparing
their masses you get this they get the
less massive they are the closer they
get to each other oh they should essenti
they should yeah right and then you've
got these outliers that are way outside
of this typical distribution curve that
should be getting in this direction and
and so I mean I guess did they find
anything that that fit the curve or were
they are they almost like too close to
you know could they not distinguish them
I think it was so hard even to
distinguish them in the first place
because it's
2023 that this information was released
2022 when they did the survey so it's
just um crazy
that this could be a thing
and yeah there might be smaller binaries
but these this actually hasn't really
been looked into much yet so Rogue
Planet binaries isn't as far as I know a
big topic right right and and and I
think you know when I think about how
even with telescopes like Tess
astronomers are still arguing about
whether or not this star or that star is
a is a binary you know an eclipsing
binary or whether it's just one star and
that's a star so to try and sort of
figure out oh no these what looks like
this one little blob in the Orion Nebula
is actually two Jupiter Mass objects
orbiting each other within an
astronomical unit that sounds like
tricky work to try and sort out so let's
let's go back and talk about the wide
binaries and not speculate on the on the
close binaries so so then what were the
proposed mechanisms for how you might
get these wide
binaries
so the most common theory would be that
they form like a star and like you said
earlier with star
formation uh if they formed like a star
there would be this missing mechanism
that would caused such low mass
formation of these objects we some brown
dwarfs we can't even consider that they
form like stars because of how low mass
they are so for starlike formation dense
regions of gas and dust in a nebula that
are gravitationally bound are
susceptible to collapse and you have
What's called the opacity limit for
fragmentation and the minimum for this
is 10 Jupiter masses
so it's hard to expl explain how objects
could form like stars if their mass is
less than 10 Jupiter masses or even even
slightly above because that is the
minimum opacity limit and in Pearson and
mcan's paper they say that there would
be a missing ingredient if it were to
form like this so that would be one way
but it's
still it's not been too looked into and
it's hard to imagine how such low mass
objects could form like stars so then we
consider Planet likee
formation planets form around
diss in diss around stars and this
happens while the star is forming as
well and there's What's called the corre
theory which is how we thought that are
planets in the solar system formed but
this is hard to explain planets that are
have a mass that is greater than several
Jupiter
masses so if this was the case it is
possible that these Jupiter Mass objects
could have been violently ejected and
this is because star forming region have
many dynamical interactions because
they're so close to other stars that if
say a star passed them by a binary
passed them by this could cause the
whole formation the planetary formation
system to be disrupted and a planet
would be rejected but this raises the
question of then how how could these be
binaries in this case right you can get
one no problem but two orbiting one
another that sounds like a very delicate
operation and if you get
9% that starts to defy
comprehension and in such wide binaries
as well it's um it's a mystery so we
also consider Brown warar formation
and there are quite a few theories of
brown dwarf formation because again they
fall into this substellar category that
we we didn't know for sure that brown
dwarfs existed we had no concrete
evidence until
1995 so this is also such a new topic
because and so there are so many new
formation theories coming out so we have
you know the classic star-like formation
planet-like formation for brown dwarfs
we have
um binary
ejection and then this other Theory
which is our
idea is this theory of photo erosion
that was suggested by Whitworth and
zenica in 2004
H so and this is the heart of your paper
the one that sort of had me triggered me
to reach out and and scheduled this this
interview because it was a you know I I
have been reporting on these jumbo since
their Discovery and it's it's very much
be you know either they formed in place
or they were rejected and they found one
another both of those seem really weird
uh but that's all we got but it's got to
be one of those two but you're proposing
no actually it could be a a third way
and it's pretty weird pretty
cool yeah so these were um written about
actually a few weeks ago in the New York
Times and they were described as Stella
victims of Stella bullying which I
thought thought was a really interesting
way of putting it yeah I I think I
described sand blasted is the way I had
been describing it but but so what is
the mechanism this photo erosion what's
going
on so photo erosion is a process that
firstly you have to be near massive
stars so these are O and B type stars in
terms of spectral type and these OB
stars have H2 region and these are
regions surrounding the star with
ionized hydrogen and they're highly
turbulent regions so our theory is that
stars that might have been forming
nearby these massive OB Stars can have
their cores compressed by an ionizing
shock wave while the outer layers are
simultaneously blown away which then
keeps the core Compact and small while
there are no outer layers anymore
because they've been evaporated by the
turbulent winds from the OB
Stars wow so so and and I mentioned that
earlier on right like the the trapezium
is such a difficult place to take a
picture of because there are so many of
these bright hot stars that are just
overpowering the area so what kind of
energy flux is going on in this region
were you able to calculate
that so that is something that we didn't
pay too much attention to because we
were looking at
how close are the jumbos were the data
from the jumbos were to these regions
what we did was we calculated the radius
of the H2 region and by calculating the
radius we were able to then plot the
radius around these stars and plot their
location in the onc and then plot the
jumbos on top and see do these jumbos
actually fall into the H2 regions of
these massive stars and that's how we
came to the conclusion that it's very
possible that this could have they could
have formed within this region and that
could have been the reason that they've
been
rendered failed stars or uh like brand
dwars well I I think about um like the
Eagle Nebula you know the Pillars of
Creation this famous structures these
pillars these are an example I don't
know if photo evaporation is the is the
term but you can they're being blasted
Away by these bright hot stars that are
nearby that are causing this almost
comet-like appearance of these remaining
regions of of you know molecular
gas um is sort of and so you're saying
that around every one of these really
hot Stars there's this sphere of
influence that is you can't withstand
having any of this material nearby and
that when you map out those overlapping
spheres of influence from all of those
really hot stars that catches a ton of
these jumbos inside of statistically
speaking statistically speaking yes but
also there is a number in one of the
equations
that if varied ever so slightly it can
cause the H2 regions to be plotted a lot
smaller so there are still some that are
falling into the region but some that
fall outside of the region so this is
why with a paper like ours while it's a
great and interesting idea we would need
to embellish it more and provide further
simulations and that would be something
that maybe led to some more some more
not evidence but conclusive ideas of
whether this was a
possibility right right and so based on
this idea what was the precursor object
what was the jumbo before this um sort
of bullying
process so what we did was we we weren't
sure we thought maybe it would be an M
dwarf type star for example but when we
plotted the separation distribution
against all the separation distributions
for the different types of star so we
put on a type G Type M type and brown
dwarf distribution and then we plotted
the jumbo Separation on top of it that
we got from the pon and mccan paper and
then we saw that the
jumbo Peak peaked in the same place as
an A type Peak so we thought it could
have been cause of a type stars but then
we also plotted the masses of a type of
cores of all types of stars against the
jumbo core
masses and found that they peaked in the
same place or they overlapped in the
same place which meant that we actually
think that these could have been cuse of
a type stars that were forming within
the region of OB type stars and had
their again
cores compacted and outer layer Stripped
Away right and an A type star I'm sort
of doing my OB ifying anyway that's
that's like more than massive than the
sun right yes yeah yeah so you've got
stars that started out more mass than
the Sun and yet we're we're photo
evaporated down to something that is a a
fraction of the mass of the Sun
something more like Jupiter or even
Saturn purely by being too close to the
real monster
Stars so the biggest
stars they bigger the bigger the star is
the quicker it evolves onto the main
sequence because of how massive it is so
even though this is a star forming
region and All Stars might have started
to form at the same time because these
massive stars accrete Mass so quickly
they go onto the main sequence a lot
quicker than these lower Mass Stars so
they're already have their massive H2
regions which means that they kind of
can affect the other stars within their
vicinity no
matter
how how much they compare to
the OB star so a is after B but even so
a Stars will take longer to evolve onto
the main sequence than an OB star so
that's why even though they are bigger
than the Sun they could still
form these
uh planetary Mass Jupiter Mass binary
objects so so what do you think the
implications are for the stars that were
smaller and less massive than the a type
Stars
that is a good question and it could be
that they
form there there could be even lower
Mass binary systems there could be even
lower Mass rogue planets out there that
we just cannot find because we even
though we have this amazing sensitivity
now there's so so many objects and the
only reason we're able to find them is
because they're in Star forming regions
so they are so new
and they're still thermally emitting
infrared
radiation so they could form even
smaller binaries that we can't see like
maybe what we talked about
before I mean it's really interesting
that I mean I think when people consider
star
formation it's considered this sort of
separate thing like okay A Star is
forming in you know here's how he star
forms it gets his protoplanetary disc
here's how this process goes it gets
outflows of gas it moves through the
different phases of being a protostar
into a main sequence star and then it
lives out its life and then it dies and
whatever but but yet stars form in these
nebula these star forming regions and
this environment sounds like it's
playing a larger and larger role in the
outcome of the
Stars down down the road maybe you know
it's the sort of nature versus nurture
debate right at the galactic scale yes
so I mean this is where stars form uh
they form in Star forming regions and
there is such a competition you could
say in terms of how these Stars these
substellar objects form in terms of
competitive accretion and all sorts of
theories um they're just they have all
of these dynamical interactions but
that's what
causes what we see and something like
that could have been what caused how our
sun got to be on its own and created our
solar
system they're just random dynamical
interactions that occur because they're
turbulent Dynamic
regions right but but then it wasn't up
to just the amount of material that the
sun had to work with the amount of the
precursor elements from Supernova that
had gone off nearby that a big role
would have also been just the overall
conditions of the star forming nebula
around us and the influence of the of
the bully stars that had got rolling
before the sun was able to accumulate
its
mass so there's a lot of yeah theories
on how our solar system formed that is
um going slightly off topic but it's
very interesting and I I know what
you're referring to in terms of um the
process that it would take and how we
get so
lucky in quotations in order to have
been near such massive stars that could
have provided us with all of the key
Necessities for what we have today yeah
yeah as always it always gets more
complicated than we than we thought um
shouldn't be surprised so now I let our
patreon community know that I was going
to be interviewing you and I've got a uh
a few questions that I'm going to be
getting to uh this one comes from Kerwin
what are the estimated ages for the
jumbos and the rogue planets that we've
actually found so do we have a sense of
how old these things
are so because they are in Star forming
regions we assume that they're
relatively young because they
are forming in these regions and they
are still giving off heat and the old
the you the longer you leave an object
the cooler it's going to get over time
so because we observe these using
infrared we can assume that these are
relatively young because they're still
giving off infrared
radiation yeah right okay um now you
know one of the other interesting
discoveries that have been made Fairly
recently is just this idea of of rogue
planets but not associated in a nebula
they are just floating around and we see
them through gravitational
microlensing and and other
ways so I mean is I mean I don't know if
you can answer this question but you
know is this how we get rogue
planets in terms of the method that I'm
yeah yeah that the rogue planets that
we're
finding would we think that they are
these jumbo they or that they are
essentially sandblasted stars or that
they are that they formed in place
through some other mechanism or they
were
ejected I think that it's a possibility
it would depend
on I think where we found them but also
it would depend on how old they are
because when you have things like micro
lensing and direct Imaging they're
they're able to image objects that are
not necessarily new whereas what we're
finding is we've been able to detect
them because they're in these star
forming region
um
so it could be that this is how rogue
planets
form but it would be I think it would be
more likely that they are ejected from a
system
because uh if they're on their own as
well that and this like I've been saying
with the dynamical interactions if
there's any sort of interaction with a
nearby star or neighboring
protoplanetary disc this can cause
planetary ejection
and I think that that would be the most
common way in terms of forming rogue
planets we didn't really consider we
didn't really look at rogue planets as
opposed to the
jumbos um and then people also haven't
really considered Rogue Planet binaries
yet either well and that's what I was
going to ask you like if we find wide
Rogue Planet binaries then maybe back to
that original mechanism
this mechanism of erosion yeah that you
know that that some small percentage of
the Rogue of the rogue planets we find
out there are these leftovers from the
the nebula as opposed to the all of the
ejected planets and so on so one thing
that's important is that these Rogue the
these
jumbos currently we think if they formed
in the way that we think they did you
would only only be able to find them in
Star forming regions with massive stars
there are star forming regions that
don't contain massive stars and you
wouldn't expect to see them there oh
interesting okay yeah right so that's a
way to find to find out whether or not
you're on the right track so that is a
very interesting um idea for sort of a
next step is to look in another star
forming region with massive stars and
see if James web can find something like
this there was one search into a star
cluster recently but I couldn't find
online if it had massive stars in it
so I couldn't say if that was a sort of
concrete uh they said that they didn't
find anything but I don't know because
what we're suggesting is that they would
have to form their massive stars and our
paper hadn't come out before their's had
right yeah I I feel like there were some
observations done of the star forming
region in the large melenic cloud and
they had been looking for jumbos and but
it was it's too far away so um so and
this question comes from billions and
billions of stars can rogue planets be
suitable for life if there's no tidal
heating from an exomoon or a binary
Planet so
I mean never say never but I don't think
so right um I think we're struggling
enough to find life on exoplanets that
revolve around other stars similar to
the sun smaller than the Sun bigger than
the
Sun these rogue planets I think probably
one of the key keys of life is the what
the what the star has to provide in
terms of of heat and we know that when
we're looking at our solar system and
exoplanetary systems we have something
called The goldilock Zone and this is an
important part because it's a certain
distance away from the star that the
star provides a natural amount of light
and heat and radiation where the planet
can use that to its
Advantage but if you're too close you're
you don't really have an atmosphere
evaporates or your planet too hot and if
you're too far away it's too cold to
sustain life so I think that if you were
a rogue planet and you
were just on your own and you
occasionally came near a star unless
there was some way that you could create
heat in the future
without a star system then I I don't
think that life could be found on these
roow planets I hope you're enjoying this
conversation with Jessica diamond we
took a bit of a side tour rabbit hole
into Jessica's other work not the jumbos
and photo evaporation this was sort of a
insight and led to a bunch of research
but in fact Jessica's main work is to
think about Galactic panspermia what is
the way that organic material could move
from star to star and we have the
discovery of omua and borisov two
objects in the solar system that came
from elsewhere there's a lot more going
on when you think about the four and a
half billion years of the Solar System's
history how much material has made it
into the solar system and played a role
in the evolution of life on Earth so if
you're interested I've got a much larger
conversation that is available for free
over on our patreon all you have to do
is just follow us for free on patreon
you'll get access to this interview as
well as all of the other additional
material that we provide to the free and
paid members on patreon and I'll put a
link in the show notes can access that
uh a question I always ask my my guests
uh Jessica what are you obsessed with
right
now in an astronomical sense or anything
but but sure yeah yeah I mean all right
well I think
that what we just spoke about in terms
of finding life on other planets I think
that exoplanetary studies and this I
think the thing that I would most want
to go into in terms of my research is
sort of the formation and um evolution
of these planets you know from the start
how they've formed because we we have
these theories but we can't consider our
theory that we made of the solar system
to
be our main Theory because there are so
many exoplanets of different shapes and
sizes that we would have never
considered using our our
planetary theory of our solar system so
it would just be so interesting to be
able to go into research to do it how do
these exoplanets form how do they evolve
what are their atmospheres like how do
we study their atmospheres using
observational equipment like transits
and direct Imaging and just being able
to kind of Deep dive into the world of
Planet formation evolution exoplanets
it's probably something that I'm
currently obsessed with because I'm also
applying to graduate schools at the
moment so um yeah it's something that's
yeah well well good news there's there's
a a ton of people asking those same
questions that need some help so uh you
should be able to be able to apply
yourself to the task Jessica thank you
so much for taking the time to chat with
me today and and good luck we'll be
watching to see as as more jumbos are
found and and people attempt to either
confirm or deny uh the the ideas that
you're proposing I hope you enjoyed that
conversation with Jessica Diamond I'm
going to give you some additional
resources in a second but first I'd like
to thank our patrons a special thanks to
Abe Kingston Adam Schaefer Andre gross
Barry Lake Roofing David Gilton and
David matz Dennis elberty Dustin cable
James Clark Jeremy murn Jim Burke Jordan
young Josh Schultz Paul roorbach Science
World rec.org
spider.io Steven caki Steven fer Munley
and Vlad chiplin who support us at the
master of the universe level and all of
other supporters on patreon I've done
plenty of interviews about jumbo and
rogue planets in general and I really
love this kind of story and this is
exactly the thing that I was hoping to
see from the James web Space Telescope
sure we want to be able to see the kinds
of processes that we understand and
watch how they evolved and see what
happened in the early Universe this is
all great but to see a genuinely new
kind of object in a place that was never
expected before
and watch as the mystery unfolds in real
time as people propose different ideas
and we watch as these ideas compete in
the realm of sort of scientific
discovery this is how a scientific
consensus gets formed you know a lot of
the ones we come after the fact and see
and accept the scientific consensus but
in this case we see something genuinely
interesting we watch as different people
propose different ideas they argue about
them different papers come out and
eventually 10 years down the road 20
years down the road there will be a
scientific consensus and all the
implications that hold and you're
watching this process happen in real
time this is how science works and I
hope you're as entertained by it as I am
all right we'll see you next time