How NOT to Rapier DUEL! Alatriste (2006) Rapier Sword Fight Reviewed

Ancient Edge
3 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 22, 2024
Alatriste is a 2006 Spanish epic historical war film directed by Agustín Díaz Yanes. Here we look at how good one rapier sword fight was from the movie.
Shadowversed
Greetings, I'm Tyranth. That's Shad. He wants to walk in today. Yep, there we go.
Tyranth?
Yep.
I'm a ninja.
Yep, a maul ninja to be specific.
Well, it's because I'm holding a maul ninja sword.
Well, are they technically maul ninja? What is the definition? We need to set our definition.
Okay, okay. So tactical falls into the maul ninja territory.
See how it's like very minimalistic ninja. Posing in cringe ways with swords
is maul ninja territory. That's why I had to do the whole, you know.
I'm getting the vibes that this is like the falchion categorization. A lot of things fall
into it because when I look at maul ninja weapons, they actually, you can't hold them.
This is just a terrible grip.
So, well, that's the interesting thing because the large majority of maul ninja weapons are just
really badly designed swords, right? But some, I do wonder about, are they actually that bad?
Well, these ones are kind of on that edge because these are like,
you can get these on eBay, Amazon, all these different places. It's just like a little
scaled down katana. Worse.
Well, this is the thing, right? So, United Cutlery, they like to send us some stuff for
review. And one time they said, all right, are there any things that you're interested in?
And I requested a couple of interesting things like their Grossmesser and stuff like that.
But on their main website, Bud K, I saw these and I was like, I need to just find out.
We need to put some of these to the test to see, are they as good or as bad as we might presume?
So, United Cutlery, they did send us these, and this is kind of a review slash exploration
of some of the cheapest sword-like objects you can buy. These are like, what,
50 bucks or something sometimes?
These are obviously different brands, but these are like mass manufactured. You can get these
anywhere. A lot of people pick up this sort of thing as like their first ever introduction into
swords, which is sad. But I don't want to lump all of these in together because there are some
that are kind of in that tactical category, but I would consider it to be valid blades,
like the leaf blade. That would fit, that would look exactly the same as these.
Well, here is the thing. I have a bit of a confession. I like the look of this one.
So do I.
Sorry. He likes the look of it. He's whatever. I like the blade.
That's why I like it.
I like the blade. You didn't say that. I said that. I like the blade geometry on that one.
I actually really like how it has this kind of extra kind of, uh, finger hold to get more
control and you can choke it up a little bit and then you can choose to go down.
I'm not a fan of how little it is, but it means that they can go a bit chunky on the side
and I'm interested to see how durable it is now. And for a short sword, this is deadly.
Well, this one is a little bit interesting because this is actually what you would
kind of get when you get the eBay ones.
It still has that feature I like, but it doesn't look as nice.
It looks cheap and terrible. This one actually looks like they've kind of taken that,
but made it a little bit nicer. It has kind of a stonewashed blade,
which I like. We have that nice curve. Uh, the geometry isn't terrible.
It looks like a fang or something. And then it's got the fake race skin underneath the wrap,
which is, it's a nice touch for a mall ninja weapon.
The question is though, for being more, I'll take that one back. Thank you.
And I saw what you're trying to do there, Tyrone.
I'll have the terrible one.
Yes, you get that one. I'm giving you this one. So the question is though,
I feel like I need to be dead pooling.
I know, right? These are one of the ones that unironically you can draw from a back
scabbard without any issue. In fact, they did come with scabbards.
They did.
I mean, you know, for, for the price, it's good that they come with something.
And so, you know, the tactical kind of plastic thing,
this one is actually made for a shoulder strap.
Yeah.
Your arm, can you reach it?
You're doing Nate's arm draw method.
Got it. My shoulders may have, may or may not have gotten in the way.
I don't think this would fit around my armor.
Just try it anyway. Everybody wants to see you try it.
Can you just hold it there? All right. All right. And so if I was like,
you need it, you pulled it down. You're supposed to keep it in the same spot.
Let's try this again. I'm sure you can manage.
Hold on.
All right. I'm like, yeah, yeah. So these are,
you don't need a special scabbard for the back carry on these.
I mean, just back scabbards in general, kind of stupid, eh?
Shut up.
You want to get into some cutting and testing with the mall ninja?
Do you actually think that?
I don't care.
Because if you do, we need to have a debate and it would be exclusive video.
I genuinely don't care. I don't care. I just said it to piss him off. Look at his face.
We have a different exclusive video we're planning to these, right?
Now we are going to be testing it. We're going to do some destruction testing,
but what we also going to do, depending if these break or not,
for the exclusive video,
and this is for our wonderful supporters here on channel memberships,
Patreon, subscribe style player.
We're going to smash a sword into them and see if they survive that.
But that's it. They might already be broken based on our standard stress testing that we do.
Now they came with an average edge.
Yes.
Tyranth has done something.
I did something you shouldn't do. I use one of the camping sharpeners.
You know, the ones that you can just like a pull sharpener.
It's like one of those stay sharp knife things, you know,
and that actually has sharpened it a little bit more than what you would get factory.
Yes. Because they were basically blunt and it's like, there's no point in this.
Something we should mention is both of these blades are actually made of stainless steel,
which obviously
is a complicated subject.
It is.
Because being shorter blades, they might perform tolerably with stainless steel.
Yes. I'm just going to say this as kind of a blanket statement,
just in case anybody's curious about that statement.
If your sword is stainless steel, you probably shouldn't use it as a sword.
We actually have a dedicated video discussing sword steels.
I'm not sure if it's out before or after this video right here,
but if it's already out, check it out.
If not, stay tuned. It'll be out because we go into a bit more detail.
Now, stainless steel is interesting because it does form pretty hard carbides on the edge,
but just means it doesn't do really well with large stresses that can fracture the blade.
And when it comes to swords, they will snap.
Which is why being a shorter blade, it might be all right.
I think this will be able to cut through most things until we actually try to destroy it.
Then we'll probably break it.
That's how this is probably going to play out.
But in terms of just basic utility, this is handy.
This is a...
What are you laughing at?
This whole Mole Ninja.
Yeah. Yeah.
It's very Mole Ninja.
All right. I think that's enough of the preamble.
Let's get into cutting.
I was a Mole Ninja once.
I confess that.
All right.
We all pass through it at one point in our lives.
Tyranth was...
He is still in that phase.
Okay.
He still likes the anime and...
Oh, I love the anime, but he is like...
He buys the anime outfits.
Let's get to cutting, guys.
What is that thing that you own?
A Hayori.
I'm conflicted.
Okay. You haven't cut anything yet.
No, no, no.
But I'm deciding how to...
What's my plan of attack with this type of weapon?
Because holding it lower, it's going to give more tip speed.
More weight.
Okay. A bit more power.
Yet people, I think, are going to naturally think it's like...
This gives a lot of control.
But I think it's going to cut much worse holding it like this.
So I'm going to start with like...
Like this.
Just a worst case scenario.
And I predict I'm going to probably have to put in more muscle to get through.
But I'm going to do a light, low-powered strike.
Just to see...
Essentially trying to let the blade do all the work, right?
Hang on.
Okay, okay.
So that was really low effort.
That was just like...
But surprisingly, I almost got through.
Well, it's sharp.
It's a sharp bit of steel.
For five minutes.
I did say you got a surprisingly sharp edge on this.
Yeah.
All right. Try this one, Chad.
All right. The other one?
Yeah.
Same go.
That was very different.
To see what a...
Like the vast...
Sometimes I think people
assume cutting through pool noodles is just super easy because we make it look easy.
But they can be surprisingly tough to cut through
if the sword isn't up to scratch.
Well, that one has a lot going against it.
Not only does it have a thick spine,
it doesn't have a sharp edge.
And the geometry, I think, is pretty trash as well.
Yeah. This is a fatter blade.
The edge angle is wider.
And it is not as sharp.
And so just doing same low effort.
I need to now focus.
If I was to focus and actually, you know, I can get through it.
But this is...
I'm feeling scooping.
It is not a...
See, look at that. Yeah.
And good luck.
See, not a chance.
I want to see if you can get a horizontal cut.
And look at this.
The tactical wrap is already coming loose.
See all this up here?
It's already...
That's actually a bit dangerous.
But I am holding it over the thing.
Yeah, Tyrenth, I want to see if you can...
Good luck, mate.
This is...
I told you. I was like, what?
I was just not far enough.
Yeah, you were out of range.
That's pretty nice.
I told you. I was surprised.
I think it's this aggressive curve.
And that tip is...
It's quite nimble at the tip.
Look, the curve isn't actually helping it that much.
But it's sharp.
The edge angle is more narrow on this.
And it has a taper.
Oh, actually, not real bad.
It's a thinner spine.
You want to try and cut into Charlotte?
Because we'll compare.
Because this is also just sharper.
Like, I will give you props.
Yeah, I'll give you props for even getting a cut on it.
This is...
That is terrible.
That's like forcing...
All right, so this is the good one we're finding.
But have a go at that, Tareth.
I have to put in.
Yep.
So much strength.
I feel that cord wrap moving there.
It's like an abacus now.
All right, well, this one, even for being a cheap piece of crap,
is still not worth your money as a cheap piece of crap.
But the other one...
Is not too bad.
We're finding...
Well, we'll continue with this.
But Tareth did get a horizontal cut with this.
Yes.
So I just need to show you that...
That was bluntness.
That was a bad part on the...
Like, come on!
The thing went flying!
Yep, yep, yep, yep.
Since we're...
That's like hitting it with a baseball bat.
Yep, I agree.
I still did one.
That's not a cut.
That is a cut.
I'm counting it.
That is...
Tare.
This is a piece of crap!
Oh, now it's too floppy.
Yes.
All right, you want to do some water bottles?
No!
Piece of crap!
Doesn't count.
Bust.
You see, at this point, I'm actually confident in this blade.
This blade is fun.
It's easy to cut with.
And bear in mind, it's cutting well with being so short.
Like, this is effortless.
Look at that.
And that's just like wrist.
This is not like needing a lot of difficult technique to...
To do this, right?
This is...
Who would have thought we liked one of the Mall Ninja ones?
I know!
You want to go?
Yeah, I'll have a go.
Even the handle.
Like, it's not as bad.
Like, the other one actually just felt like...
This one, it's got a softer wrap on it.
Yeah.
So it's actually not too terrible.
Effortless.
This is fun.
This is a fun little...
Like, if I bought this, I would just go out and just do some little cuts all the time.
This is fun.
With how well it's performing, it's also pretty deadly and dangerous.
We're finding this is a very effective cutting short sword.
All right.
Did you want to do some more?
Did you want to go destroy them?
Well, we need to find out how good the steel is, okay?
You put a sharp edge and a good angle and geometry on any bar of steel, it's going to cut well.
All right.
Now let's find out if there's any level of quality to this.
Look, some of the wrap is coming a little loose, but not as much as the other one.
I think it's just the design of the wrap.
They're literally just wrapping it around the steel.
So it's going to come loose.
Tested how well they cut.
Let's find out how good the steel is.
Going to start with our standard stress test.
See if the blade warps.
And look, we've seen swords warp with only a couple of hits on this wood test.
These should perform much better because they are smaller,
which means less leverage and overall less stress on the blade.
But we will find out.
Oh, that hurt even through the glove.
I think this took a set.
Really?
Yeah, come and have a look.
I mean, I don't know why I'm so surprised.
Stainless steel.
So yeah, it's trash.
It's subtle, but take a look down the blade.
Yep.
Tiny little bend.
Yeah.
Man, that's sad.
That is sad.
I mean, not sad that this is broken.
I don't care.
I'm talking about sad as in the performance wise.
Do you want to do the little fang one?
Yep.
I'll do the fang and then let Tyreth have a go.
How did that one feel?
Better.
And she held up.
Well.
No set.
Interesting.
I wonder if it has any sort of tempering or heat treat or anything like that.
Because this one, the way that that took a set
makes me just think that this is just literally just a bit of stainless steel.
They haven't done anything to it.
Put an edge on it and send it out.
Not hardened.
Because you have to be pretty soft to bend like that.
Especially at that length.
Oh, that is.
That is sh**, man.
It doesn't feel nice, does it?
About the set.
In fact, you might have corrected the set a little bit.
I think I corrected it.
I'm more surprised at how respectable of a cuts those are.
Okay.
Yeah.
That's fine.
So far.
Yep.
All right.
Let's see how well the edge holds up to some real abuse.
So the fang took more damage than the...
That makes sense because it's a keener edge.
It is.
You're actually right.
It's a much thinner edge.
But in terms of the damage, it held up respectably.
Yeah, that's not bad.
Like spring steel romance men katanas kind of hold up like that to those strikes.
That one didn't take as much damage, but it has a much thicker bevel.
It's a hunk of steel.
Also, stainless steel is generally a bit tougher.
All right.
Should I have a go?
Ah, you have a go.
Another day, another door.
All right.
Starting with the terrible hunk of steel.
Nothing.
Eight strikes on the edge.
All right.
Little fang.
Man, that's hard.
Yeah.
Well, because there is no grip on this.
It is just a rectangle piece of steel.
It twists in my hands and I can't generate that much power.
But I mean, that's reasonable.
That is reasonable.
That held up okay.
You could resharpen it and get some use out of it.
Some of these didn't.
It actually chipped up here, which does indicate it's got a harder edge, but it's robust.
That's a lot of abuse that I am surprised that it's handled so well.
So I'm surprised the other one actually handled that so well, but it's thicker.
This is just a piece of steel, man.
I'm whacking just a hunk of steel against a hunk of steel.
It's got a really thick edge.
So that's one of the reasons it's surviving.
But it did take that set.
These surprised me.
Well, this one not really, but this one did.
This one surprised me.
This one here, I don't recommend.
No.
I do not recommend that.
These are crap.
Cuts like junk.
This.
This, okay.
I have to preface it as like, if you're in the market for something very cheap,
that's just a bit of fun that you're not expecting.
Like this performed okay.
It's still stainless steel though.
And I don't recommend stainless steel.
It performed well for stainless steel, really well for stainless steel.
And I think it did, but because of the size, like, because it's so small,
the vibrations on our stresses and impacts like that, not as intensive.
Okay.
If this had a longer blade, I reckon it would have snapped.
Yeah.
So this one here is a black Ronin.
I want to make sure we mentioned the exact one
because I don't want you to go out and buy some random one.
We might have an affiliate link for it.
Okay.
It'll be in the description if we do.
Now, there is one thing that I'm desperate to find out,
but this video has already gone long enough.
And we've been able to establish how good it is.
Okay.
So we're going to save that for exclusive content.
And one thing that I really want to know and find out now
is how well it can take an edge strike.
But to really find out which one has the harder edge,
we're going to do edge on edge against each other.
And then we also have a classic Maw Ninja sword that we've done edge on edge.
Let me get it.
It's an old one that we...
Just to show you guys that not all Maw Ninjas are the same.
Because this is a previous Maw Ninja type sword that I got
that we classically use for edge on edge.
And take a look at how the edge is looking on this.
Well, that one isn't even that...
Like it's got a very soft steel.
It's a very soft steel, but it's got a full tang.
It's got a screw tang and it's got G10 scales.
That's all reasonable stuff.
So I don't hate this one.
Yep.
So we're also going to smash these new Maw Ninja swords
against our old Maw Ninjas.
See what survives in exclusive content,
specially made for our supporters.
So those are people who are supporting us on
Subscribestar channel memberships,
YouTube memberships,
as well as Patreon and Player.
Because it's only thanks to you guys that we're able to keep buying stuff.
Because actually...
No, these ones were sent to me.
I bought this one with my own money, right?
But we're able to invest in videos like this,
higher production value, multiple cameras,
higher editing, all that stuff.
Thanks to you guys, we're able to keep going.
So thank you everyone.
And if you want to help support us,
all you need to do is become a supporter on any of those platforms.
Links in the description.
And you get all this cool exclusive content.
All right.
So I actually do recommend this...
Recommend's a strong word.
It's fun and it's cheap.
This Black Ronin version that we've got in here,
this one particularly, wasn't the worst thing.
Would I personally buy it?
Maybe.
It's fun.
If you're into this, maybe.
That's as far as I'm going to go.
Maybe.
It's a self-defense sword.
Just get it.
Get a sword, mate.
It cuts well and it's low profile.
It's concealable.
Yeah, stop giving the UK people ideas.
All right.
I think that's all.
Maul Ninja.
Not always terrible.
Yeah, but look.
Maybe people want us to review some real Maul Ninja swords.
I like their spiky, overly flamboyant messes.
Well, that sounds like a terrible day.
But until then, you can check out the videos where we react
to some of the most crazy Maul Ninja swords right here.
There's a video.
Check it out.
Hope to see you there.
And also hope to see you in exclusive content.
