(Ep. 122) Beware Hidden Agendas in the Student Loan Industry | Student Loan Planner

Trust Channel
6 followers
1 Video View·Nov 19, 2024
With so much conflicting information out there about the student loan crisis, it literally pays to have some healthy skepticism when asking for guidance on your specific situation. Listen in as I share the five types of groups who you should be slow to trust when it comes to their advice on your student debt.
Hey, everyone.
It's a bit ironic to start off with this in a episode
titled Beware of Hidden Agendas in the student loan industry,
because one of the things I'm going to talk about in the pod today
is just how like temptations and certain revenue streams
can often like influence people to give advice.
It's not in your best interest.
With that said, I do want to tell you about something that I think
could really, really help anyone who has been waiting around
to refinance their federal student loans.
First off, you know, we've made our advice more conservative about refinancing.
We've said if you owe less than one point to five times your income
and you work in the private sector and your finances are in good shape,
then you'd be a good candidate to refinance.
One point to five debt to income ratio means take your federal student loans
and divide by your income.
If that number that results of that number is less than one point to five,
then you're a great candidate to refinance and get a lower interest rate.
Now, obviously, with the interest freeze going,
interest rates on federal student loans have been zero percent.
So it's been a big conundrum for a lot of people to say,
you know, should I refinance now and lock in a low interest rate
or should I wait and get this zero percent interest benefit
with the federal loans?
And this just take my chances in September when the rates start again
to just see what I'll get at that point.
The exciting thing I want to share with you is now I think that
if you have federal loans that you know you want to refinance,
now you might not have to choose.
I have no idea how long this offer is going to last.
It might expire a couple of days after you listen to this podcast.
It might expire a couple of months after you listen to this podcast.
I'm not sure because it's a limited time offer.
But Common Bond is giving people a deal right now,
some people a deal that apply through our links right now
that you can get zero percent interest for six months
and then you can get a low fixed rate after that.
And you can qualify for the student loan planner cash bonus as well,
which is 300 for 50K to 100K for refinancing.
And then it's 1050 when you're refinancing more than 100,000,
as long as you apply through our link,
which is studentloanplanner.com slash Common Bond
to see if you can qualify for this.
You just put in your information.
You're going to get a prequalified rate estimate
that's not going to impact your credit score.
It's just going to give you whether or not you could qualify.
And if so, what would it be for?
And then you have to click claim this offer
when they show you the zero percent intro APR.
What that basically does is it's going to give you that zero percent,
which matches the federal subsidy.
And then it's going to give you a low fixed rate after that.
So a lot of people I'm seeing get even something in the threes
for a fixed rate for a 20 year term.
Not everybody's going to get that right.
It's going to depend on your credit and your profile and everything.
But this is such a good deal because you could refinance it now
and get the zero percent interest to benefit while locking in a low
long term rate just in case there is inflation.
And then in September, when the intro zero percent APR rate expires,
you can refinance again if you want with a different company
and get maybe even lower interest rate.
And if you refinance with a different company,
you might even get an additional cash bonus while getting a lower interest rate.
So this is a really, really fantastic deal to qualify.
You have to include at least one federal loan,
and it is subject to state rules.
And, you know, I have to say terms and restrictions apply, right?
I think this is one of the most unique and interesting refinancing deals
I've ever seen.
You might say, how are they doing this?
My guess is they're charging
maybe a little a slightly higher amount on that fixed interest rate.
You're locking in post September just ever so slightly.
And they're sort of gambling.
I think that you are not going to go and reapply to refinance
with someone else once that intro zero percent APR period applies, right?
If everyone reapplied, they'd probably lose a lot of money on this.
We know that that our people are a little bit more informed than the average bear.
So I think that this is a great deal to see if you could take advantage of
if you need to refinance federal student loans eventually.
So go again to studentloanplanner.com slash common bond to apply.
Enter your information.
It's very straightforward.
You'll get your prequalified rate check.
And then if you want to pursue whatever they offer you,
then they're just going to do a hard credit check,
which is a very minor impact on your credit score.
It's essentially like opening a credit card.
So it's really not anything to be concerned about.
So really awesome deal here to get a zero percent APR intro rate
plus over a thousand dollar cash bonus.
And just to make sure that you get that cash bonus
whenever you're refinancing a six figure amount,
just make sure you reach out to our team and help at studentloanplanner.com
before you actually sign the paperwork.
But just because that way,
we can make sure that you're being credited to studentloanplanner
because the way the bonuses work is a portion of that bonus comes from the lender.
And then the other five hundred dollars,
if you refinance an applicable amount comes from studentloanplanner.
We just need to verify that you came through our link
to be able to give those cash bonuses.
So really interesting deal here.
I hope a lot of people at least apply and see if you could get it.
If you have federal student loan debt and if you have private student loan debt,
obviously you might find a better deal elsewhere.
If you have private student loans, you're trying to refinance another time.
But all the refinance ladder at play lock in a 20 year fixed rate,
zero percent APR, and then that really low fixed rate for 20 years.
If inflation happens at all,
you're going to want to pay the absolute minimum on that balance.
And if inflation doesn't happen and rates are about the same as they are today,
then you'll be refinancing again
to an even lower interest rate and getting even bigger savings.
So pretty exciting.
Keep in mind, if there's any chance that forgiveness might be a better path for you,
you might want to get a plan from us to make sure which way or the other
that that should go.
And obviously, if you know you're pursuing student loan forgiveness,
this is absolutely a totally irrelevant section of the episode for you today.
You can skip ahead.
Obviously, if you're still listening, you didn't.
So we'll talk about other things in terms of conflicts of interest
in the student loan industry.
But I thought that was a particularly interesting offer.
And like I said, it's probably going to expire,
I would think pretty shortly after you hear this.
So studentloanplanner.com slash common bond to apply or obviously
you can go to studentloanplanner.com and apply directly on our website.
So let's get into the meat of today's episode.
Hello and welcome to another episode of the student loan planner podcast.
Today's episode was supposed to be an interview of someone
in the student loan industry who strongly opposes
going for student loan forgiveness in most any situation.
I'm pretty bummed because the person just canceled the interview
essentially by wanting to remove a question
after we provided a pre-show list of questions as a courtesy.
So we'll give someone a heads up of things
we're going to talk about on a show for interview.
But we're not going to like limit the questions to that.
And we're also never going to agree to take questions off
because you want to you do not want to be asked about student loan forgiveness
because it doesn't suit your brand.
So I'm a little fired up about this today.
And that's why I thought we would talk about the title of today's show
is going to be beware of hidden agendas in the student loan industry.
So we're going to talk about this.
And it's not something that means anybody's a bad person.
I'm not saying that at all.
I simply want to have honest and open dialogue
so that you can get the best information to make decisions for your student loans
for you and your family that are in your best interest.
That's the only dog in the hunt that I have.
OK, now I have a complex of interest, too.
That would be impossible to not admit to that
because everyone has complex of interest no matter what.
And so we're going to talk about that.
I'm going to call myself out first for what those complex of interest are
before I ever think about talking about anything or anybody else.
Anyways, I just want you to know that when we have guests on the show,
one of the things I'm committing to for you to have a show
with the highest level of integrity possible is we are not going to be a fluff show.
We are not going to ask people softball questions
and we are going to ask people tough questions,
especially when they're giving advice out there that, in our view,
is something that's really costing a lot of people a ton of money.
We're going to talk about the offending question that the person
that we were going to interview today requested to be removed from the interview list.
Pretend you have a chiropractor who owes $250,000 from their education
and they earn $50,000 a year with little upside for their salary.
And that circumstance, would you support them pursuing an income driven repayment plan
and pursuing 20 year forgiveness or would you recommend against it?
So I want to talk about this particular case because I actually had a case early on
in my business when I was doing student loan consulting for the very first time
where this really hurt someone.
Advice that is sort of every man type advice does not apply to every man or woman.
It doesn't apply to every person.
You know, when you're going to provide advice in a broad brush stroke,
you have to admit that sometimes that advice isn't going to fit certain people.
And that's not really great for attracting media attention.
That's not great sound bite driven kind of actions to take.
Let me explain what kind of pain this situation caused for a chiropractor.
So this this was a real life chiropractor couple that I absolutely love.
They're great people.
They were some of my first clients.
And they came to me each with about $250,000 in debt.
And they were both earning about $50,000 a year.
They were super fans of an organization
that says to pay down your debt no matter what at all costs.
They believe their debt was evil, that they had signed up for it,
that they had made a dumb decision taking up the debt
and that they had a moral obligation to pay it back.
Now, there's nothing wrong with that opinion,
because an opinion is just something that somebody believes.
You know, we live in a free country.
If you want to have that opinion about your student loans,
that you have to pay them back.
That's great. That's your opinion.
You can make an argument that that doesn't is not backed up by the math.
But if that's your opinion, that's fine.
But what I get concerned about is we just did a survey,
a mental health survey of our audience.
We're going to talk more about it in an upcoming podcast episode.
But it was shocking.
It was shocking.
Nearly, I'll just say this, nearly one in ten people in our audience
has considered suicide due to their student loan debt.
And the number of people that feel shame and guilt
and stress from their student loan debt, it's enormous.
And everyone is looking for what is the way out?
What is the way where I won't feel guilt and shame?
And where how can I live my life?
How can I break free from these chains of debt that I sign up for?
And certainly if you have $30,000 and you make twenty to thirty thousand a year,
there's a lot of things you can do to say, you know what?
I want to be rid of this debt.
I want to remove this obstacle holding me back.
That's a good kind of approach to take.
I think that's great advice for most people.
But this couple, I've showed them the numbers.
I show them how forgiveness made the most sense with their debt to income ratio.
I showed them how they could save for retirement, put money
into their tax bomb accounts, et cetera.
And they still said, you know what?
We just feel so called to doing this loan strategy of paying down our debt
because we're so we've so bought into this approach
that that's what we're going to do instead.
And so they put over 30,000 or 40,000 dollars, I think, into their loans.
It might have even been more than that.
It might have even been half of their income.
Half of it was about half of their take home pay.
So they did that.
And over a year's time, their debt went down
from about 250,000 each to about 240,000 each.
And they did a follow up consult with me about a year or two later.
And they really sound very frustrated and defeated
because they'd made a ton of sacrifices.
I think they even lived with their parents for a while.
They they put off having kids.
They put off owning a business.
I think they put off just a lot of big life decisions, trips
they wanted to take, funding, retirement, et cetera.
And they were like, why did we try to do that?
Why did we try to do that?
Well, you know, what were we thinking?
Attempting to make that big of a sacrifice and have our debt change so little.
In that case, it was because their debt to income ratio was five to one.
From experience, I know that, you know, if anything doesn't go
according to plan perfectly, according to plan, that plan
tends to fall apart and fail.
And when you're, you know, deciding to pay your loans and to that degree,
you're also choosing to not put money away into retirement savings,
into buying a house and to starting your business, et cetera,
because you're focused only on your debt.
And unfortunately, I think that there's businesses out there
that care about other things than finding you the absolute best strategy
to eliminate your student loan anxiety.
There's lots of people out there giving advice on student loans.
We're by no means a pure organization.
We have conflicts of interest, too.
So we're going to try to manage ours.
You can be the judge.
So let's talk about before I say anything about other organizations
or any other companies or anything,
then I'm not naming any organizations or companies in this podcast, too,
by the way, and this is all just my opinion.
So if somebody gets upset hearing this, this is just my opinion.
Thank goodness we can all have our own opinion, right?
So let's talk about student loan planners, conflicts of interest.
So we make money when people hire us for consults.
That's a conflict of interest.
If somebody wants a quick one sentence answer,
you know, we are incentivized to say, well, you know, you should sign up
for a consult.
And and sometimes maybe that goes a little bit faster
and we get to the answer pretty quickly.
And they're like, well, shoot, why did I pay money for that answer?
That's a little bit of a conflict of interest.
I think usually you need to do your due diligence.
You need to have a long conversation and not make it a two second conversation
when you're talking about a major life decision.
And I would say, generally speaking, you know, our reviews,
I think we have like a four point nine six out of five star review rating
right now among our clients that are viewed us when we do get three star reviews.
It's usually something like, well, I kind of already knew that.
Finding out something, getting something confirmed that you already knew
for at least a somewhat reasonable fee is something that's kind of good.
For example, one time somebody tried to sue us because we without naming them
said that we thought someone doing certain kinds of things was it was a scam.
So this person was charging thousands of dollars to help people set up
basically nonprofit organizations that were operating out of the same location,
I think, is their companies.
And in our opinion, that's fraud.
And in our opinion, charging people thousands of dollars
to do that is not something that's legitimate.
And so they threatened to sue us.
And then, you know, I didn't think that they had a case.
But you know what?
I definitely hired a lawyer just to double check and and to make sure
that it wasn't going to go against us.
So, you know, worst case scenario, I think that that's a conflict
that I can live with, that sometimes people are going to pay us for advice
and they find out that they're doing about everything they can do.
The good news, though, is actually that's only about 10% of people
that hire us is about 90% of the people we find significant savings
or just find something in general that they weren't thinking of,
which in and of itself is going to pay for the consult and multiples
when that happens.
So we also have an incentive to make things
a little bit more complicated than they probably could be sometimes.
So I find in our consults that about people are willing to suffer a lot of pain
if it means they can make their life simpler, which kind of makes sense,
because I find people are willing to sort of pay
pretty much up to about $5,000 a year
if it means avoiding having a really complicated student loan plan.
So in other words, if we can file a joint instead of separate
and it's going to save us less than less than $5,000 a year all in,
a lot of people are just going to say, well, you know what?
I'd rather have a simple life.
I'd rather just pay a little more of my student loans
and just have a strategy that just kind of makes sense to me a little bit more.
It makes something that feels a little more stable, right?
Sometimes we suggest people do the married filing separate
and community property states and equally split their income
or amend their tax returns or, you know, have one spouse on pay
and other spouse on repay because there's a financial
mathematical reason that would save them several thousand dollars a year to do so.
And we are all about making sure that we don't miss anything
because we want you to save every dime possible.
But sometimes if we're guilty of something,
we don't necessarily want to have a consult be completed
where it's like, well, we didn't find anything right.
So we have we have an incentive, therefore, to like try to find savings.
And sometimes the savings that we find require people doing things
like filing taxes separately or amending their tax returns
or doing a double consolidation where they have to send in multiple
consolidation applications so that they can get their parent plus loans
onto a more advantageous repayment plan, like 10 percent of their income
instead of 20 percent.
So you could argue that maybe student loan planner has an agenda
against everything being simple because it's bad for business.
You know, I think that we try to do our best finding every loophole
that we can find to save you as much money as possible.
But somebody can make that argument.
And, you know, I think that that's something that we would want
to defend ourselves against.
Maybe we also have an agenda against Congress
eliminating the income tax bomb, because then that would mean
that fewer people would need to hire us for a consult.
Or maybe maybe we just have an agenda against student loan debt being canceled
or interest rates being set at zero percent long term
instead of something that allows us to still have a need to refinance
people's loans.
These are all real conflicts of interest.
I can say that I want what society decides on student loans.
We'll maybe say if we think something would have a lot of negative
unintended consequences or not when somebody is discussing student loan reform.
But we'd like to try to stay out of the what should be conversation
in terms of student loans, because we really like to talk about what is
and how can we save you money?
Because that's something that's helpful, I think.
Whereas the political conversation around student loan debt
is generally something that's better left to people that you vote for,
people that represent you.
Those are the people that, you know, I like to make the decisions
and we kind of like to just respond to whatever the the rules are.
So think about like an accountant.
Most CPAs are not like out there pounding the table being like,
we got to cut taxes or we got to raise taxes or we got to make this tax code
this 50 percent more complicated.
So I'll get more business right now.
The CPA, a good CPA, keeps his or her opinions to themselves
and just sort of says, how can I save my clients money
and how can I do the very best job that I can?
So that's kind of the way I look at this stuff.
But let's talk about the complex of interest around like cancellation,
interest rates being lowered, student loans getting more simplified.
If you did set interest rates to zero percent,
the New York Federal Reserve has really interesting research paper
looking at the effect of subsidized student loan amounts on tuition,
on what happens when you allow lower interest rates on student loans.
What is the effect on tuition at schools?
So what the research finds is that for every additional thousand dollars
of subsidized student loans, the schools raise their tuition by six hundred dollars.
So in other words, the student receives some benefit
in terms of lower interest costs by having the subsidized student loans.
However, the schools eat up the majority of that benefit pretty quickly.
Because they realize that their consumers are now less price sensitive
because the tuition is not rising as much
because the student loan interest is more subsidized. Right.
And so if you set interest rates to zero percent or even three percent
or something that's not a somewhat market based interest rate,
the issue with that is without any regulation, if you had regulation,
that'd be one thing, right?
That would be you could make a strong argument for saying, well,
you know, we want to have more affordable student loans by saying
we're going to only allow the schools to take out up to 150 percent
of their students earnings five years out.
Like that'd be kind of an interesting thing, right?
Zero percent interest with max borrowing of of 150 percent
of the five year average class earnings.
That'd be real interesting system.
But nobody's talking about that.
So if you just took zero percent interest rates without changing anything else,
then you would probably have runaway inflation.
And within about four or five years, all of the benefit of that interest
rate reduction would be totally eliminated for people that have not yet
entered school.
I get that it would have a tremendous benefit for people
who already have the student loans,
but it wouldn't help anything in terms of the long term problems
without, you know, talking about that in the context of having regulation.
Same thing with canceling student loan debt.
It would be a wonderful thing for our audience.
The majority of our audience is in strong support of canceling
some level of student loan debt.
However, only one third of our audience supports
canceling all student loan debt, according to a recent survey we did.
That's kind of interesting.
I think people in general want to pay back their student loan debt.
I don't think that people want to feel like they can't pay it back.
I think people, generally speaking,
want to feel like they accomplished paying off any debts that they have.
And, you know, if somebody does support cancellation,
it's because you kind of feel like the system's unjust.
And it is, again, it's like if you cancel all student loan debt
with no regulation on the pricing of schools,
the problem is there that regardless of whether you're progressive
or conservative, it's going to cause a lot of problems.
Because if you're a progressive, then you're worried about
the crowding out effect of canceling student loan debt,
which would be very expensive,
especially if there's no caps on what people could borrow.
Well, that would crowd out investments in fixing climate change.
It'd crowd out universal pre-K or paid parental leave or fixing pensions
or something like that.
Maybe having access to Medicare one day.
You know, you do have at least some level of policy decisions
you have to sort of choose between.
And so I think we could cancel student loan debt.
I think that that would help a lot of people.
But we would need to have some regulation on the pricing of schools.
Similar things with making student loan repayment simple,
like making income driven repayment, like one plan, a lot more easy
to understand, a lot fewer exceptions for things like filing taxes separately
to really streamline it, having it just be automatically done.
People just automatically signed up for income driven repayment
from their tax returns.
The problem is, is are we really going to trust the organization,
the Department of Education
that made student loans extremely complicated to make it simple?
Or will them trying to make it simple make it even more complicated?
So what I mean by that is look at the Trump tax cuts.
They claim that you could do your income taxes on a postcard.
And some people can.
But for a lot of business owners such as myself, our income taxes
now we're way more complicated.
If you're a dentist with your own private practice,
then you probably are having lots of detailed conversations
with your CPA about how to qualify for the one ninety nine eight deduction,
which is a deduction that you can use to write off up to 20 percent
of your business profits.
You can't do it if you're a service organization,
unless you make under a certain amount of adjusted gross income.
So it's like super complicated.
What what the heck did I even just say?
You have a promise.
Hey, it's going to be simpler.
And then it's like not necessarily simpler for a lot of people.
So anyways, the student loan planner has conflicts.
You're right to have healthy skepticism.
But consider this with refinancing student loan refinancing,
our advice has become more and more conservative over time.
In other words, we told fewer and fewer people to refinance their loans.
And that's because of real reasons,
because we think it's in the best interest of our listeners
to be careful about refinancing because you cannot undo it.
So we used to say two to one debt to income ratio.
In other words, if you owe two times your income or less
and you work in the private sector refinance, it's what we used to say.
But then we tighten that up.
We said, really, it's more like one point five to one
because one point five to one is like a little more conservative
just because what we found is, well, actually, you can file separately for taxes.
You could save for retirement savings.
You can do a lot of things.
And maybe somebody that, you know, has a two to one debt to income ratio
would be better off going for forgiveness.
That's kind of why we tightened it up.
And then we saw the pandemic interest in payment freeze on student loans.
We saw President Biden talking about eliminating the tax
bomb on student loan forgiveness, expanding access to public service
loan forgiveness, right?
We saw all these conversations and we kind of thought, well,
maybe we should make it a little more conservative.
So now we're kind of telling people one point to five
to one debt to income ratio or or better or lower.
And then maybe you could refinance if you're in the private sector.
I think it's very defendable to refinance with a with anything
less than a two to one debt to income ratio.
I think if you have a strong view about what's going to happen with inflation
or where your income is going to go or just having the desire
to have life be simpler and not have to worry about filing
your income based certifications every year, I think there's a lot of reasons
why you could still say, hey, you know what, I'd rather refinance. Right.
But I'm very, very sensitive to seeming like we have a conflict of interest
on our refinancing advice, because we do have a conflict of interest
of people refinancing and sometimes when they maybe shouldn't. Right.
So that's why I try to be probably a little bit too conservative
in telling people not to refinance.
I think that's probably true.
I think I do err on the side of caution when it comes to that,
because our incentive, our hidden agenda is not to get someone
extremely angry at us that refinances when maybe they shouldn't have.
That's something just to think about.
Like, I think probably a lot more people would be better off
paying off their loans than when we tell should sometimes.
Now, I will say this.
When we started doing student refinancing with student loan planner,
our bonuses on average about $300.
Now we are the first company to offer maximum student loan refinancing
bonuses of over $1,000 with every major national lender.
That's true. Check out our website, studentloanplanner.com slash refi.
You're going to find every major national lender on there.
Ernest, SoFi, Laurel Road, Elfi, Common Bond,
Credible, Splash Financial, LendKey, they're all on there.
That's really awesome.
And the reason why we have those maximum bonuses of $1,000 or more
is because we pay out approximately half of that out of our own pocket
because we take less in advertising commissions.
Meanwhile, we're battling out there against big companies
with way bigger budgets that have gamed Google search.
And for example, there's a big company out there that ranks higher than we do
for student loan bonuses when they actually don't even offer them.
They have literally they have an article about student loan bonuses
and what they are, and they talk about how they don't offer them.
And then they say, well, you should never you should never go
and refinance your loans just for a bonus.
You should focus on getting the lower interest rate.
Well, it's like, well, yeah, but like, dude, if we have every single
one of the companies on your website listed on our website
with a big cash bonus and you don't tell people the truth,
which is that you don't want to lose advertising revenue
by being extra generous with your readers.
You just want to retain it all so that you can hire the best strategists
and the best reporters and writing all these really great articles.
But then just retain all the money for yourself.
So I do hope you see that we everything we do,
we try to go to bat and do the right thing for you.
We try to be the most consumer friendly company anywhere
when it comes to giving student loan advice.
So that's a lot of talk about hidden agendas with other organizations.
And I didn't want to seem like a hypocrite for calling others out first
before talking about ourselves.
So let's talk about some other folks now.
So I'm going to give you about five different categories of of groups
just to talk about what the hidden agendas are, in my opinion.
So the first category is companies that put their brand first
that are super anti debt.
They made their names by being this.
And it's not just one organization, either.
It's multiple organizations.
They made their names by being this way.
And sometimes these groups like to say outrageous stuff
that gets a lot of attention.
It's actually a genius strategy, right?
It's like the only bad news is no news kind of thing.
If you say something outrageous, it gets your name in the media.
It makes it reminds everyone that you're an expert.
It's good for business to say things that are controversial.
It's not good for business to say, well, it depends. Right.
I mean, that's not a you want to kind of make people upset or angry or tribal.
There's a huge incentive to do that.
A group can have an agenda, by the way, while still being a great group of people
by being a decent group of human beings that legitimately care about others,
but also having a conflict of interest, right?
Those two are not like inseparable.
Somebody that sells whole life insurance can be a great person.
They can also be highly conflicted and giving you advice
where it serves their interests financially more so than yours.
It doesn't have to be black and white where somebody is all bad or all good.
There's sort of this shade of gray for really everyone, I think.
And so you obviously want to not live your life being in suspicion of people.
That's not healthy, but at least have a healthy dose of skepticism.
So here's my frustration with the brand first people.
So this this is people that, in my opinion, tend to put
having a consistent brand messaging over making sure the advice
they give out is the best for an individual.
Dead advice that centered around paying off your credit cards and personal loans
and avoiding car leases doesn't always apply to student loan debt.
It's a different animal.
No one's going to allow you to pay a percentage of your income
and work for a not for profit organization and have that credit card debt
forgiven after 10 years of payments.
That's that's not a thing with any other kind of debt in existence
besides student loan debt.
Why is that the case?
Because student loan debt by and large is the only kind of debt
that's basically owned by the government.
There's literally no other kind of debt out there that's quite like it.
And when that is the case, there's a huge political incentive
to do things that make voters happy, right?
You're no longer trying to maximize profit on your loans.
What you're really trying to do is maximize voter happiness
so that you get reelected as a politician making the rules.
That's kind of the point.
So there's these major groups out there that bash student
loan forgiveness in any scenario.
And I just don't think that's intellectually honest.
So a lot of these groups will repeat misinformation
without getting informed, more informed about the issue, about PSLF
not being something you can rely on because they'll give an example
of a couple of people who had their application processing delayed
or they'll say, well, only only 500 people got it.
Well, you know, when you discourage people who are eligible
for benefiting from it, you're harming people, not helping them.
The reason that today's scheduled interview didn't happen today
with someone from a major organization that's anti-debt
was because they didn't want to be asked a specific question
about loan forgiveness, despite giving out tons of advice to people saying,
don't trust it, don't do it.
It's a terrible thing.
You have to pay back all your debt.
You have a moral obligation to pay it back.
And I agree that people should not do loan forgiveness
in a lot of circumstances.
You should not do a job if you
if you're just doing it for PSLF alone, that's not smart.
However, when someone qualifies anyway,
why would you discourage them from pursuing it?
So, for example, if you actually look at the data
instead of just repeating whatever media narratives that suit your messaging
in November 2020, which is the most recent data available,
the success rate isn't 90 people or 500 people that have qualified.
It's over 6000.
And the acceptance rate went from one percent.
Now it's three percent of the people who applied.
And keep in mind, all of the people who applied early on literally applied
because they didn't know they didn't qualify.
That's the definition of the adverse selection bias.
And it's statistical sample.
If you don't know that, you don't know you're going to apply.
Right. All the people that knew they didn't apply, didn't apply.
Only the people who did not know they didn't qualify applied.
And before 2020, basically, you had to essentially be a unicorn
person that had a best friend that worked at the Department of Education
to have figured out how to get qualifying loans from before 2020
because you need 10 years of service and PSLF.
The loans from before 2010 were bank guaranteed loans under an old program
that specifically were not included in the PSLF program.
If your loan servicer had told you, you know, in the mid 2010s
that these loans didn't qualify, yes, you might have been able
to consolidate them and get them on a direct loan program that did qualify.
But the loan people and the servicers really screwed up.
I want to say that they really did screw up.
But even then, you still would not have been able to get forgiveness
on time after 10 years of payments.
So we've talked a lot about this in other episodes where like
the idea of PSLF not being real is a myth because it is.
And the reason people are getting denied is because of very specific reasons
about how Congress wrote the rules and also didn't want to upset the banks
that didn't want to have all their loans forgiven from before 2010.
And so, you know, one of our negative podcast reviews
actually says that I don't call out servicers enough.
I blame the media and that's terrible.
I should be calling out the servicers.
I'll talk more about the servicers later.
The PSLF program was designed in a very flawed way,
but it's going to fix itself rapidly over time.
And when you have organizations out there
that are scaring people away from doing student loan forgiveness,
it's because you care more about your brand than you do about someone's finances.
You should be able to say, hey, maybe certain people in certain situations
can consider going for forgiveness,
but it's not something that you should bet the farm on.
It's something that you need to make sure you're taking care of your finances.
It's something that we prefer people paying down their debt.
But if you've done a careful analysis and you've made sure that you qualify,
then, yeah, sure, maybe you can consider it.
But I just don't think it's OK to prioritize your own political beliefs
or your own brand messaging over someone's financial well-being.
So, for example, if you have an oatmeal company
and, you know, you're going to believe that dairy is bad in every circumstance.
But what happens if you find that for certain consumers,
dairy milk is actually better for them?
I don't know. I'm just making something up here, guys.
I'm not I'm not a milk expert, OK?
That would be like telling somebody kind of using like one misleading
talking point to basically say, well, if you don't have oat milk,
like it's going to be really bad for you.
You've got to do oatmeal.
Well, that's prioritizing your own brand sales and your own brand's fame
over doing the right thing.
So it kind of reminds me growing up and going to different kinds of churches.
So you'd sometimes go to the church that had the altar call,
all emotional based approach to faith.
And then you had the dissertation level like sermon that was super cerebral.
Like it's kind of good to have a balance.
Like when you're talking about personal finance,
you kind of want to have a balance of a plan that's OK with you emotionally
and you can get behind emotionally and it makes you feel good.
With also it not being a bad plan mathematically.
Right. So you want to have a balance of both.
So beware of student loan advice that puts brand value and brand
messaging ahead of your financial interests.
So the second big group you have to watch out for is
folks that use student loan advice as a lead generation tool.
So refinancing student loans is a big way to make money.
And there are groups out there that give free student loan consultations.
I can't believe I'm saying that on air because, you know, you're going to
maybe I'll go use them right.
Wow. Free student loan consultations.
Why would they give out free student loan consultations?
Why do they do that?
Well, let me tell you why.
It's because in most cases, a borrower, especially a borrower
with a six figure loan balance who refinances his or her student loans
is worth a lot more to a company
than a couple hundred dollars or a few hundred dollars if they refinance.
Particularly if you don't give out any bonuses at all.
It's kind of not hard to figure out what we might get paid for
for student refinancing because we can give a thousand dollar bonus
on a hundred thousand dollar loan in a lot of cases with our refinancing partners.
So, you know, you might make maybe a couple thousand dollars on a
on a two hundred thousand dollar loan.
Whereas if you told that person to pursue forgiveness
and you charge for your services, maybe only make a few hundred dollars.
So you can literally forex your profit by telling that person to refinance instead.
So you might say, well, oh, that's baked into their business model.
You know, they might tell, you know, every one person they say to refinance.
They tell one person not to.
Well, sure.
But if you have a conflict of interest that large,
obviously you can't trust that advice because it's like, oh, it's free.
And then I'm going to tell you to refinance way more than I probably should.
Right.
And so these kind of groups that that offer the free steel and consulting,
they don't give any bonuses for refinancing.
And it's really designed to be a funnel for pushing people
to their specific suit on refinancing links.
Kind of a thing that I don't agree with.
I like charging for advice where we try to give the absolute best advice possible.
And in paying for that advice, you know that that's what we're trying to do.
We have a obligation to try to give you the best advice that we can
for how we think truly you should go about paying back your student loans.
What are some other groups that give student loan advice as a lead generation tool?
Well, there's insurance people who might make thousands of dollars
selling you a disability insurance or life insurance policy.
There's advisors, financial advisors that are afraid of looking incompetent
because they want to sell you financial planning.
And there's nothing necessarily bad about that.
I mean, I wish we had a lot more student loan literacy
among financial advisors and insurance people.
There's a lot of great insurance people.
I know there's a lot of great financial advisors that that use student
loan knowledge as a tool to convince you to hire them
for something squishy like financial planning, when it's something
that's like super needed for most people, that people should pay a lot of money for
for a good financial planner.
A lot of times, like the best financial planners are the ones
that are the most humble, too.
I mean, a lot of the financial planners out there that we have a lot of success
in working with, they know that their job is to be the quarterback
of your financial life and not necessarily to be the long snapper
to make an analogy there. Right.
So student loan planner is a very specialized, you know,
we're the field goal kicker when you need the extra point. Right.
Like we do something very specific.
We give student loan advice specifically to people who have high five
and six figure balances.
A lot of times they'll say, well, instead of me trying to be
the offensive line and the defensive line and the kicker and the punter
and the quarterback, you know, a lot of these folks say, well, I'm going to know
enough about what the specialist does that I can be extremely helpful.
But then I'm going to kind of outsource some of that to groups
like student loan planner. Right.
Now, I'll say if a financial advisor has got some designations,
has done a lot of research on student loans, listens to a lot of I know
a lot of financial advisors listen to our podcast.
So if that's you, then, yeah, you probably can give great student loan advice.
So it's just something to be aware of as a student loan borrower, though,
that, you know, you don't want to necessarily
just trust someone's student loan advice
that's using it for another purpose and sort of using it as a means to an end.
And the end might be you hiring them for some sort of service.
So it's like, well, they might give you student loan advice that you might.
It might be the right advice, too.
But you want to just double check, especially with a group
probably that exclusively does something and you're paying them specifically
to accomplish or give you a plan on a specific topic.
So the third group of the hidden agendas that I would like you to be aware of
is the never pay for student loan advice people.
And so these really kind of come in three different flavors.
Number one is the servicers.
So a lot of the student loan servicers, you know, will say things
like you never have to pay for student loan advice.
Think about it this way.
They kind of have to say that because if they don't say that,
then they look even less competent than we already know that they are.
If you look at the lawsuits against the loan servicers,
a big part of their defense in these lawsuits is typically
that they do not have any legal obligation to give accurate
and good advice on student loans.
So with their PR people, they say, don't pay for advice because we can advise you.
That's what the Department of Education pays us to do.
But then their lawyers, when they have lawsuits against them, say, well,
our advice is not to be trusted and it's not supposed to be accurate.
So like it's like the IRS and the government provide a free file service
for filing your taxes, but they don't necessarily do a good job of promoting it.
It's not something that they really communicate very much about.
And so you might spend more time in frustration and research
trying to find that free file option,
or you might just go pay $80 for TurboTax and be done with it quickly.
I mean, the servicers, it's kind of like they don't pay their people
to give specific individualized student loan advice.
They pay their people a hourly wage to handle as many calls as they can
in a call service and a call center environment.
And that's not conducive to getting accurate student loan advice.
That's correct. It's just not.
So that's one group of the never pay for student advice people.
The second group of the never pay for student loan advice
people is nonprofit or consumer advocate groups.
And here is where I need to say that just because somebody might have
an agenda or an alternative agenda to finding the absolute best
student loan plan for you possible, it doesn't mean that they're not doing
fantastic work and that work should not be celebrated to the extent
that it's really helping people,
especially people that are lower income can't really afford
to pay for a service from a company like ours.
I have nothing but respect for consumer advocate groups, nonprofit groups
that are helping student loan borrowers.
I think they're doing wonderful work.
They are certainly allies in our mission of helping student loan borrowers.
Hopefully they see us as an ally, but I think maybe sometimes they don't.
So I think that what could be a headed agenda of a consumer advocate
or a nonprofit student loan advocacy group?
I think some groups, some might have like a bias
that for profit companies can never be a force for good
or can never be something that is necessary or helpful
when it comes to student loans.
I think that there's so many, you know, abuses that have taken place
by for profit groups against student loan borrowers
that I understand why they feel that way.
I understand why they're extremely skeptical of any for profit group.
But I think that in our case, I think that we actually do
a really good job of helping people in a way that really matters
for a lot of folks because we're for profit and because I own the company.
It's not VC backed.
It's not owned by some sort of outside investor or anything
that has an incentive to maximize profits.
Luckily, I get to call the shots, which means that I can run the company
the way I want to, which is to try to make it the most consumer
friendly company in the student loan industry, period.
So here's an example of what I mean by why this agenda
might not necessarily help you thinking that you should never have to pay
for student loan advice from what some of these consumer advocate groups say.
If you were facing some serious allegations,
would you go to a legal aid group or would you use the public defender
appointed to you if you could afford to pay for legal help?
Generally speaking, the answer to that is going to be no, right?
You would try to hire the best person.
You try to hire really competent help, somebody with a really good track record
and somebody who has a lot of time to spend or more time to spend
helping you specifically.
So a lot of the public defenders out there have massive numbers of cases
per lawyer, and when you hire a private attorney, one of the benefits
is not that necessarily the public defender is any less competent.
It's just that the public defender might have to be helping 100 people
where the private attorney might be helping a tenth of that.
And so obviously, they have a lot more time to defend your case
and prepare for trial and not have an incentive
to just seek out a settlement, even if you might be innocent.
So if you think about it, you want to generally hire the best help you can
the more serious the situation you find yourself in, unless you can't afford it.
And if you can't afford it, what generally happens?
Services tend to be rationed based on how many resources are available.
So, for example, that's why you have the public defenders
having so many people that they're helping per lawyer,
because the state or local government only pays for X number of public defenders.
And they are obviously under resourced, underpaid.
There should be more public defenders.
But there are not.
And so therefore, folks who cannot afford to pay for that help
get assigned the help that is available, which because it's not
there's not a sort of market based incentive to hire additional people rapidly.
Then unfortunately, we have a problem where people are not getting the help that they need.
I will say that nonprofit student loan help groups answer a ton of questions
and they're doing so much good work out there, but they can only answer so many
because you if you're relying on donations
instead of being able to charge for your services, where you can hire
additional consultants to answer people's questions, you're not going to be able
to answer as many questions that way as you could otherwise.
So I think that that's one thing to think about is like, I think our clients
have a lot more access to our consultants can ask a lot more personalized questions.
You know, obviously, the ability to have hour long conversations
about their specific student loan situation, whereas if you are
working with a student loan like consumer advocate group,
you're going to be limited into how much detail you can go into.
So the third group is Reddit.
This is in the category of the people who say don't pay for student loan advice.
This is like my third big group.
And within that group, there's like these three different flavors.
So the Reddit, you could just say Reddit slash forums slash strangers on the Internet.
So one form I posted a lot on back in the day is something called the Bogleheads Forum.
It's named after the founder of Vanguard.
A lot of the people on the forum give fantastic advice, but it's kind of like
people, I would say, like people that like to do their own stuff,
like to kind of manage their own portfolios, like to get DIY advice
about everything, right? Do it yourself advice about everything.
And a friend of the family asked me a complex question about estate planning.
So I thought I would post about it on the forum and see what people said.
And I didn't really appreciate this answer at the time.
But one of the respondents said, dude, this could result in a six figure
or even seven figure estate tax penalty.
This person needs to stop cheaping out and hire someone who's a professional
who's going to take more than five minutes to write an answer.
And that makes a lot of sense.
So it's kind of like, can you get quality advice on the Internet forums?
Absolutely.
Can you get answers to questions on those forums
and avoid paying for our help in many cases? Yes, absolutely.
I think, though, that the agenda on a lot of these forums is,
I guess people want to be recognized as experts.
People want to be valued.
People want to kind of self actualization is the highest need
in the Maslow's hierarchy of needs, right?
So a lot of people get some sense of self-worth
by being known on forums as somebody who is super amazing, famous,
liked by all these people, right?
I think that's why if you look at like what happened with Wall Street bets,
I think that's why a lot of the people who had millions of dollars invested
in some of these meme stocks,
I think it's why a lot of these people couldn't bear to sell a lot of those gains
is because they just simply got so much self-worth from being famous
from involvement on these forums.
So I think that that's kind of one thing you want to be a little cautious about.
It's just get answers from Internet forums for sure.
But realize that they're not going to have any responsibility whatsoever
if their advice is wrong and they're giving you answers.
They're typing out in a couple of minutes that may or may not be accurate.
So fourth big group of groups with hidden agendas is uncles with strong opinions.
This could also be aunts with strong opinions or parents with strong opinions
or sort of friends of friends or people at family reunions.
I mean, just basically this is like anyone that wants to tell you
how you need to manage your student loan situation.
Usually it goes something like this.
I paid my debt back in the 1980s when I went to school
and you should have to do that, too.
You know, sometimes this kind of situation can be politicized
and you can see resistance,
especially among boomer generation folks to doing student loan cancellation
because they feel like they paid their debt back.
And so you should, too.
But we know that in the 1970s and 80s, like dental school is like 5000 bucks.
And now it's like three, four or five hundred thousand dollars.
There's a whole lot of reasons that are too complicated to get into, probably
because we don't have that much time in the show today.
But what is the hidden agenda for people who say,
well, I pay my back, my debt back and you have to pay it back, too?
There's a little bit of like a hazing kind of thing, right?
It's almost like you need to prove yourself because I did it.
And so you should have to do it.
So I think part of it is maybe they view it as fairness.
Like, well, why should their taxes be raised to pay for your student loan
forgiveness when they pay their loans back? Right.
So there's some of that.
I think another part of the agenda here is feeling like I think self-esteem,
maybe like I did it.
And that's why I am a great person.
And then you should have to do that to prove that you're a good person.
Really realize that this is no one's business, but your own.
How you pay back your student loans is literally your business.
And that's it.
And you're maybe if your partner or your spouse or something like that,
who's someone who's affected by it.
But the uncle with an opinion is not going to pay back
your student loan debt for you.
Going back to the earlier example, the national brand or the personal
finance expert that tells you you always have to pay back your student loan debt
and makes you feel guilty when you're not doing that or if you're not doing that
or calling you stupid or dumb for decisions that you made.
They're not taking responsibility for taking this burden from you.
There is definitely some value in that kind of approach
from like a self-help perspective, because you can pay it back
and you can take control of your debt that way.
And it does work for a lot of people.
But the thing is, is it doesn't necessarily have to be what
that's doesn't have to be what works for you.
You are an individual.
You are a unique person with unique life circumstances and goals
and desires and wants and stresses.
If that's not good for your mental health to put that burden on yourself,
you should absolutely not feel like you need to do something
just because somebody that sounds very authoritative and loud
is telling you you have to do that.
And the other thing, too, is I probably am a very sensitive person.
Like, I hate kind of feeling like somebody thinks I'm not a good person.
I mean, I probably like don't have super thick skin
when it comes to taking criticism in public.
And so I think that probably a lot of people are that way,
you know, just in their personal lives.
Like, you don't want to feel like you're a bad person. Right.
So when somebody who you respect or admire says like, well,
you're an idiot for going to X, Y, Z program,
or that was really a dumb decision, don't let other people make you feel bad.
I mean, it might be true that it was not a smart decision.
You know that like you're not an you're not an idiot.
Like, you know, if it was a smart or bad decision
to make the degree, the choice that you made.
And a lot of times people incorrectly assume
it was a bad decision to go to their degree program,
because you know what we also found in our survey that we did recently?
We found that about only about two or three percent of people
right now in our community are unemployed.
That's staggering.
OK, two or three percent of people being unemployed
basically means almost everybody that wants a job has a job right now.
Is that true for the working class people in West Virginia?
You know, who whose communities are really struggling
because there's not this great path forward because the factory closed up
and or the coal plant shut down? Right.
If you think about it, if you can pay your student loans like an income tax,
then there's like no limit to what you would pay for that that degree.
I mean, like, because if you're just going to pay it as an income tax,
if you can get near certainty, you're going to have a really stable job.
That's that's worth it.
And so the fifth and final group that you have to watch out for
with hidden agendas is the schools.
So the schools is any university or college association or higher ed
trade group that wants to steer the conversation away from them at all costs.
It's kind of like, look over here, look over here, look over here.
Punch in the face because zero percent interest.
Great. Canceling student loans, better income driven repayment plans,
limiting the tax bomb. Awesome.
Not awesome.
If you're a college university ever talking about what they freaking charge,
it's absolutely true that access is extremely important to higher education.
It is the the path or the best path, the most guaranteed path,
I should say, to upward mobility and upward financial success
and improving generational and racial inequity in America.
It absolutely is.
Education is a wonderful thing that that helps make society
a more just and equal place.
The problem is, if we're not going to talk about cost,
we're talking around the issue and not talking specifically about how to fix it.
So it's like, you know, we're talking about, I don't know, trying to lose weight.
We're not talking about tracking your diet and cutting what you eat
and going to the gym frequently.
We're talking about, I don't know, just what kind of organic juice
is the best one to buy or something.
Those are all important things.
But you got to talk about root cause.
You got to talk about root cause, and that is the cost of education.
And so the school's agenda is don't ever talk about the cost of education.
Let's talk about anything else when it comes to student loan debt.
But just don't ask us about why we have so many administrators on staff.
Don't ask us what we're doing with the revenues that you pay us.
In fact, one of the students at NYU Dental School actually asked.
I get texted some really awesome things anonymously from people.
And they texted this question.
They asked their school about
why were they being charged a multi-thousand dollar instrument fee
when they were literally not able to use their instruments this year
because of COVID-19?
And the response was basically bleep you.
I mean, that was from the school.
The school is basically saying questions about student fees
is a main campus concern, and the school dentistry will absolutely
not respond to this request.
It was such a hostile answer for such a reasonable question.
And it just shows you how scared the schools are about anyone
figuring out what they're doing to people and realizing that they are every bit
as greedy as the Wall Street banks that got us into the 2008 crisis.
The schools absolutely need to be regulated, but they will absolutely steer away
from that conversation as much as they possibly can.
There you have it, folks.
Big hidden agendas in the student loan industry.
You got to be careful.
Look out for your own interests and just at least have a little bit
of healthy skepticism about anybody you talk to and say,
this advice could really help me.
But is it the best advice for me in my specific situation?
Obviously, Student Loan Planner tries to be that place.
And thank you for listening to today's show.
Anyone who is super opposed to student loan forgiveness or big national,
you know, student loan experts or something that are anti anything that we suggest,
you're always welcome in the Student Loan Planner podcast.
Just know that we're going to ask tough questions and we're not going to sugarcoat
stuff, and it's just it's not going to be a fluff show
because we have to talk about the real student loan crisis that's out there.
And it's not as simple as saying we'll just pay it all off
because it's getting worse and worse out there.
And every year that becomes harder and harder to do
because of how broken the system is.
So thank you for listening to today's show.
Have a wonderful week.
