How to Parry with a Sword - Edge or Flat?

Ancient Edge
3 followers
3 Video Views·Nov 19, 2024
Some practitioners of HEMA and other armed martial arts insist that the edge of a blade should not be used for defensive purposes, and a few even advocate avoiding blade contact altogether. But is it really a matter of parrying exclusively with either the edge or the flat? How about certain angles that fall in between? How about situations, techniques, and intended outcomes that favor one over the other, but not all the time?
Ah, the old debate. Should you parry with the edge of a sword or with the flat? I'm going to give you
a simple straightforward answer. Are you ready? It f***ing depends.
This has been the subject of many heated debates which I've also partaken in in the past on both
sides of the argument and there are many good points to be made in favor of avoiding direct
edge-on-edge contact, but it bothers me whenever people claim that the edge was never ever used
in a defensive action.
All right, so first I'll discuss some historical evidence and then I'll show
practical aspects of sword fighting mechanics to illustrate points. First off, it can be difficult
to identify battle damage on archaeological finds with certainty. You have to distinguish
them from damage that happened after the deposit, so damage from corrosion or from improper excavation
and later handling, etc. If you look at these examples, you can see how it might be difficult
to distinguish battle damage from corrosion damage as these are not very well preserved.
Also, not every preserved sword was actually used in battle and in some cases you may not
be able to see signs of repair. For example, look at this Bowen Bear here made by Quinn Waterfield.
Would you be able to tell that this had extensive edge damage and was then repaired?
This is what it looked like after I did the abusive testing, so this was pretty bad. You
wouldn't really be able to tell that this has been repaired. In some cases, we might even be
looking at blade shapes that were originally different from what you now have. There are,
however, much more clear-cut examples, no pun intended. Like for example, on this Dane Axe here,
you have massive notches that very obviously are a result of edge-on-edge contact. Also on
this complex Hill Sword here, you have notches on the strong of the blade that come from parrying
with it. There's an interesting article published in the Journal of Archaeological Method and
Theory in 2020, which I'll link down below, that examines Bronze Age swords. They tested replicas
made by Neil Burridge, by the way, and compared them to what they saw on original finds. They
found different types of edge damage, some of which results from impacts against a spear shaft
or a socket of a spear, some against a shield, some against another blade. And overall, they
found evidence of blade damage that results from deliberately seeking blade contact. And that is
in spite of the fact that they were used in conjunction with shields. Because sometimes
the argument is made, if you use a shield, you don't want any contact between the swords. But
in fact, there are good reasons for why you do want to. I'll get back to that later.
If you look at the historical manuscripts that deal with sword fighting, the German
sources in particular, have a concept called Frazetzen, which is displacement. The problem
with that is it has several different meanings. Displacement can either mean a passive defense,
you're either statically blocked to stop it or perform a deflectional parry to redirect it.
The other meaning of displacement is an active defense where you strike it aside
and break the attack with a counter-hue. Displacements are sometimes explicitly
discouraged in the manuscripts, although Joachim Meyer's interpretation of Lichtenauer's
advice to not parry is not quite so strict. Now I haven't found any mention of blade damage
in the manuscripts. I'm not aware of any instance where they explicitly tell you,
do not use the edge for displacement to not damage your blade or anything like that.
The point generally of discouraging displacement is that you don't want to be the one who ends up
simply defending. You want to force your opponent to do nothing but displace in a passive way,
because then they don't threaten you. If you're not threatened, you can just keep pushing the
offense and eventually you'll win. If you think about it, even if it's considered ideal to not
perform static blocks or other passive displacements, they might happen anyway if
your goal is to put the opponent in a position where that's the only option. If we look at active
displacements on the other hand, which by the way are not discouraged, they rely on stopping or
redirecting the blade by cutting into it. Now this happens with the blades not contacting each other
perpendicular. So not like this, but rather at an angle. So it could be like this, where it's
partially on the edge, partially on the flat. That's a lot less destructive to the blade,
but it will still cause edge damage. Make no mistake about it. The manuscripts often don't
specify whether or not you should perform a displacement with the edge of a flat. It just
says displace it. But there are some instances where it is indeed very clear. For example,
Meyer talks about displacing with the long edge. And keep in mind, in the same source, it also
tells you to set this aside with the flat of your sword. The Glasgow Festspruch tells us to
displace a hue to the head with a messer with the long edge above. So that is clearly an edge parry.
Degrassi also mentions an edge parry. Talhoffer, while describing combat on horseback, actually
shows both. There's one picture that clearly shows an edge parry and another one that very
obviously shows the flat being used. When fighting with messers, you see explicit flat parries.
And here the nagel or nail guard comes in handy. Because if I catch a blade on the flat
and it slides down, the nail is what catches it. In fact, that allows techniques like
defending against the cut with a thrust. But there are also unambiguous cases when you're told to
put the spine of your blade against your arm and parry this way. So you can then go ahead and
grapple the opponent's arm. You can only do that with the edge if you're supposed to put
the spine against your arm. If it had told you to put the flat against your arm, and you could
still do this. You can still perform the same thing with the flat, basically. The difference
is if you do it with a flat, it's going to slide off. If you do it with the edge, it's going to
bite into your edge. And that may very well be the point here. Because now you've stopped that,
you're controlling the opponent's blade, you make sure it doesn't go anywhere,
now you can grab and counter. And that can be quite useful. I recently ordered two short swords
from Cult of Athena, which were on sale because they had blemishes, but they have very nice sharp
edges. So we experimented a little bit with those for a demonstration. If you just push,
I try to hold against it, he's already on point. So you would just have thrust from here. If I do
with the edge, let's again just push, this is much easier for me to hold against it. He's not on
point. I can actually push it over here. Whereas as soon as I do this, my structure is weak. Of
course, with a shorter blade, the dynamics are a little bit different. But one thing I can do
is try to support this with the thumbs. A little bit awkward with the gauntlet here. I'm really
trying now to defend myself, all right. It wants to collapse. Now if I catch it higher up here on
the strong, I have a better chance. So here, but with this guard, of course, it's dubious. Now if
I do it this way, much easier. So do it again. This, I can actually stop and now they bind.
They bite into each other. I can actually move it over here and then release and counter. I cannot
do that with the flat. And we can already see edge damage from this, unfortunately. If I do
a false edge deflection, that's better for the blade. So if he comes in for a cut and I do this
kind of defense, the blade is fine. Do it again. Boom. Because this is what happens. If you watch
and hold it out, this is what happens. I hit his flat. So I don't actually go edge on,
but I go edge versus flat. The Messer, for example, it has a nail guard. So if he strikes at me
and I catch it on here, now it slides down, the nail catches it. Now I can do something, right.
So that's a different story. So he cuts at me from this side. If I want to move off line,
I want this to slide off so I can counter at the same time. Whereas if I did it this way,
it wouldn't happen. So if he cuts down and I want to, you know, this, it's going to stick.
In fact, now I'm in trouble. So there are situations where you do need to use the flat
because you're trying something else. You want a different effect. Now he has the heavier blade,
which gives him an advantage in the bind. But even so, if we start out in an even position,
so let's just do both flat. This is completely even. As soon as I use my edge against his flat,
I have a structural advantage here. Whereas if I try that with the flat, he can easily hold against
it. Now I engage my edge. He didn't change his level of resistance. So let me make sure to try
to let me not move it at all. Okay. So I can't really do much. Now, as soon as I engage my edge,
you see what happens? Immediately it pushes over. So this is just a stronger position. In the bind,
this really makes a huge difference. If I try to push here and he gets an overbind on this,
just by subtly tilting his wrist, basically, now I'm on point. I need to do something about this.
All right. So he could just thrust now. And if he does, then I need to bring this over here.
So, and this is again, where the fact that the edges bind, this makes a difference. This is what
you don't really get with blunts, especially with synthetics, but also with blunt blades. They just
slide all over the place. If both cut forward, which is pretty common with a variety of swords
to get a bind, guess what? They're going to be damaged. And this is what you see in a sparring
a lot. Yeah, exactly. So, and you'll see quite a bit of damage here, which, yeah, it sucks.
That is a lot of damage, even from just this. Not doing it, even at 50% force. So you can imagine
how much this would suffer from actual fighting. But, well, what can you do? You need to survive.
And afterwards, you can just regrind it and fix it that way. So over time, chances are the blade
would become narrower. In some cases, you might not see it. If they regrind the entire thing,
you may not necessarily be able to see that the blade was originally wider.
But I suspect that probably happened quite a bit. And of course, it also depends on the type
of blade and the grind. This one here didn't take quite as much damage. Because you see,
it's a little bit thicker toward the edge. Even here, like on the flat, you can see it too.
So damage to the blade in combat is just unavoidable. This is something that's easy
to overlook. And personally, I have to work on this a lot more as well. If you're fighting
with sharp blades, you know, in history, in a life or death situation, you want to do whatever
you can to control the opponent's blade. Because if your opponent's sword is free to go wherever,
there's a good chance that you may receive what's called an afterblow in a HEMA tournament.
Sounds harmless, but in real life, it means you get crippled or killed as well. And working edge
on edge in the bind gives you this kind of control. If the two blades meet with enough force
to cut notches into each other, they will stick quite a bit at that point. So you can use that to
control your opponent's blade, wrench it around, and make sure they can't immediately attack to
another opening. The research on bronze edge combat I mentioned earlier also seems to indicate
that they use the swords this way to maintain edge contact until they're able to find a way
to attack safely to an opponent's opening without leaving themselves exposed. And then you have to
keep in mind that real life combat doesn't neatly follow the rules. You know, even if the rules make
perfect sense, and if you train using certain techniques because they're effective and because
they keep you safe, that doesn't mean everything always went according to plan. There's, for
example, what I like to call the oh-shit parry, where something has gone wrong, say your opponent
has outmaneuvered you, and all you have time to do is just use your blade passively as a shield
and, you know, just to prevent yourself from getting caught. Because I'd rather take a notch
in the blade than one in my head. For those last moment passive displacements, it can be more
beneficial to catch it on the edge because you simply have mechanically more resistance here.
You can withstand more pressure in this direction than you can in that, because the wrist isn't as
strong in this direction. So if somebody pushes here or here, this is going to be much harder for
me to hold against than this way. But there are situations when you end up doing an oh-shit parry
with the flat. I've done that in sparring, where the only thing I could do last moment was basically
to put the flat almost directly against my body and use it as sort of improvised armor, almost.
When I sift through the historical manuscripts, I keep finding examples of both
edge and flat defenses. Oftentimes it's not specified, and with the active defenses,
it really depends on the angle and the technique. But it's very common to see a counter-hue that
stops the opponent's blade by cutting against it, which, depending on the angle, can be either
edge versus flat or edge versus edge at an angle. This is what you see quite often. This is really
not an either-or discussion. It's both, depending on the situation, depending on what you're trying
to accomplish. Whether you want to perform a deflectional parry or a hard block makes a huge
difference for this, depending on where you want the opponent to go. Do you want to obtain a bind
or not? Insisting exclusively on either one or the other would limit options and impoverish
the swordsmanship. Anyway, hope you found this interesting, and thanks for watching.
