(Ep. 166) What to Know About Recertification on an Income-Driven Plan
1 Video View·Nov 16, 2024
Lauryn Williams, CFP®, CSLP®, sits down with fellow consultant Meagan Landress, CSLP®, to talk in detail about student loan recertification and PSLF waivers. If you’re worried about self-reporting or recertifying your income and how this whole process works when you’re on an income-driven plan, this is the episode for you!
Welcome to another episode of the student loan planner podcast today. It is girl power day
You've got me Lauren Williams and my fellow female consultant Megan Landris
And we are gonna be talking all things recertification and PSLF waiver
So if you're worried about recertifying your income and how it's gonna work if you're on an income-driven plan
Stay tuned for just a second
And also if you got lots of questions, which everybody does about the PSLF waiver
How it works what we need to be doing what we should be thinking about. We're gonna cover it. Let's take it away Megan
How you doing today? What's up? I'm looking forward to our conversation today as always
I think we're always excited to kind of digest some of this really complicated
Technical information to bring it to you to help answer your questions that you might have. Thanks for having me join you
It is always fun when there's more than one
Let's kick it off by talking a little bit about
Self-reporting on income driven repayment plans. So people probably like what what does that even mean?
How do you self-report with an income driven repayment plan? Yeah, so that that is literally never
Really been an option
Except for you know alternative documentation technically when you update your income on an income driven plan
you can submit alternative documentation, which usually is in the form of a pay stub or some kind of
Confirmation of your your income which could also be a signed statement. This isn't totally foreign, but it is more
Easy to do at this point because of this kovat forbearance that we're in is is kind of our rationale
but right now
within student aid gov if you were to go and recertify or
Apply even for an income driven plan right now. It will give you two options
It'll allow you to usually it used to make you
Link back to your most recently filed tax return through the IRS data retrieval tool
That's always been the case
Now it gives you a second option to self report your income for the income driven repayment application
So that's something interesting because again usually it had to be a little more structured or formal
So you could choose to do either
Have you actually seen the language for this Lauren or had had clients talk to you about it?
I have not seen it as of yet, but I've seen it in in our set to this situation
We do a lot of back office sort of things to make sure we're up-to-date on everything
But I have not seen it in a consultation when you're doing your actual ID our
Application that when you get to that step two part of things
It's gonna say income information and there's a button where you can select our report my own income information
So that's how it looks as you're going through the actual process
Yeah, that's exactly right. And like you said this does expire
according to student aid July 31st
2022 now some language or technical language just to be aware of is if you do self report
It's gonna ask you for your gross income
So the that's the the language that they use but usually when you update your income or you link back to a tax return
It pulls through your adjusted gross income from your federal tax return
1040 so that's something to be aware of that. They're asking for gross income
Usually if it's reported, you know through the tax return it's taking AGI
So just maybe keep that in mind. I don't know how
Important that language is exactly but it's it's something that I've noticed
Yeah, do you think it's like a typo that like we know that the the federal government is not perfect
So somebody might have put the wrong thing there
and it's also hard for people to know what their AGI is but if you put gross income and they calculate a payment based on
Gross income and you're maxing out your retirement plan. This is not gonna work in your benefit. So
Self reporting is not like the cool fun thing to do to get the lower payment per se
You could actually mess it up and end up with the higher payment, right?
Right, and I think it's done for ease because a lot of folks just don't know what adjusted gross income is
I mean that is a tax term
So if you're not sure how to derive adjusted gross income
I think that's why they have gross income put in there because it's just simple like what is your salary or what is your gross?
Income most people know that right out the gate
That's my assumption for folks whose tax return for whatever reason just has not been able to pull through
I've been telling folks to put adjusted gross income. I don't think that's unethical. I don't think that's lying
I think that's what would have literally pulled through on the tax return if they were to use that option
By no means am I saying lie on this document or this this option?
Absolutely, not do not lie
but I think if you know exactly what your adjusted gross income was for this prior tax year 2020 or
2021 if we have that exact figure, I think it's okay to go ahead and plug it in there
I think that's a perfect segue into our next topic because so many people are like, ah, it's a new year
It's time to do taxes, but also usually I have to recertify my income
So which tax return should I be using and what are they gonna ask me when to recertify my income?
I I'm so confused about what's happening. Like I'm excited that I don't have to pay my student loans at least until May but
What's gonna happen with my recertification?
right
gosh recertification like this has been I think the bane of our
Recently too because it's so because we do a lot of planning off of when someone has to recertify and it's continuously been
Changed or altered because of this kovat for parents
but their most recent language on student aid gov says that you will not be required to recertify your income before
Payments restart. So as we know payments have been extended to May 1st
So no one's going to be required to recertify before then
Then it goes on to say in the earliest you could be required to recertify is November
2022
They pushed this again
Originally, or you know, I think last time we did this actually Lauren it was saying August so they pushed this again to November
2022 likely because they pushed the extension since the last time we chatted
So what does that mean so that that means if your normal recertification is anytime before November
2022 or sorry any month before November for this year then
You are not going to have to update your income it will be your recertification will be postponed
One year for 12 months
Let's maybe talk about an example if you want to maybe set the stage Lauren
Well, yeah
The first thing I want to say is that your income being postponed is not the same thing as your payment being postponed
What's gonna happen is your pre kovat income driven repayment amount is what is going to kick in in May and
Then you won't be asked to recertify until
2023 so in this example your current recertification date is showing as October 1st of 2022
That's gonna be pushed out to October 1st of 2023 in May
You're gonna have whatever last recertification you did which was probably pre kovat assuming that you did not do any
Certifications during kovat you're gonna pick up where you left off from that time going forward
Now what people want to know is like when it is finally time to recertify
Am I gonna do Mary filing jointly Mary filing separately if this is all being stretched out for such a long period of time
Maybe I can get away with filing jointly this year if I need to file separately overall for my student loan strategy
So what do you think this person should do in this situation Megan?
yeah, so filing separately is always a strategy or is a strategy we talk about if
Borrowers are married and this is because when we file taxes separately if we're on pay as you earn or
Income based repayment or income contingent repayment these plans allow you to exclude spousal income from your payment
So it's a lot of times a really
great planning strategy to try to keep our income driven payment as low as possible, but
Filing taxes separately can sometimes not be as tax advantageous to us as filing taxes jointly
So, you know the discussion we have in our planning sessions is you know
Does the savings that we reap by filing separately in our payment?
benefit us enough to
cover the cost of what it is to file separately or what the difference is between joint and separate for our tax filing and
So if we are filing separately because it does save us enough
overall
Do we need to file separately for 2021 taxes now because thinking about this same scenario?
This person their old payment is gonna kick in starting in May and it's gonna go all the way until October 1st
2023
so with that being said
When they update income October 2023 the most recent tax return at that time would be
2022 actually, so it wouldn't be 2021
The one that we're about to file here right now
So in this scenario, it could maybe make sense to go ahead and file taxes joint
Take advantage of maybe the the more positive
filing joint status from a tax perspective because it's not going to impact your payment until
2023 but at that point we do we would have already had another tax return that we could have filed separately for
So in this example
I would say
Might make sense to go ahead and file taxes jointly if it makes sense from a tax perspective to do so
For 2021 and then pick back up with filing separately
Starting 2022 taxes. Is that what you would say as well?
Yeah, that's definitely what I would say in this situation and this is why strategy is so important as thinking about you know
What am I going to do to maximize?
The
Efficiency and the cost related to paying my student loans back
We've had a really cool opportunity to optimize things over the last year and a half
But now that things are kicking back in you're gonna have to be more active in your strategy
But there are tons of things you can do to make sure that you are, you know
Optimizing your household income optimizing your financial plans overall and like you said this this Mary fouling jointly in this particular situation
We're deciding could save you a lot of time save you some money on taxes and be just a more efficient way to go about
life
one of the things that I've seen in this whole recertification situation though has been
people like well, I'm still confused Lauren because my date says
2022 so you're telling me that they're saying we don't have to recertify by until November of 2022
But when I look at my file or I look in the student a dot-gov website, it says March
2022 and I'm I'm confused because I think I should turn in my paperwork
They even say on the student a dot-gov website that you may still see a recertification date
That is earlier than November 2022. So they're they're giving us this warning that hey, we haven't figured it all out yet
This is actually what we're going to do. So don't be alarmed when you look at your aid summary
We are working to get everything updated. We thank you for your patience. Look at them being nice to us on the student a dot-gov
Right
If your recertification date falls between now and November 2022, it will be pushed out one year
So they put it there. We're not making this stuff up. This is what student a dot-gov is telling us, right?
One other thing to note. So if you're asking how do I figure out with my where my recertification date is?
Anyways, you could give your your loan service or a call. That's an option
I know that's probably a very unattractive option because you might sit on hold for a bit or you can go to student a dot-gov
You would log into your account there and what you want to look for
Underneath my aid so you'll see you can click on the drop-down where your name is towards the right of your home page
Click on the drop-down click on my aid and then there will be you know, some details that pull up about your loans
The language it should say something to the effect of you know loan details where you can click on the loan details
It'll pull up a list of your loans
Then you can click on each individual loan for additional loan details on that specific loan
So go ahead and do that find just one of the loans click on the loan details again
And it should tell you your ID are
so ID are for income driven repayment
Anniversary date or it'll say
Recertification date something like that and it it'll tell you the month and the day and the year of your recertification
So again, remember if it's still before showing before November 2022
Student Aid has advised that they are working on getting that pushed back 12 months
If it's already showing 2023 then you can you'll have a very good idea of knowing like when you'll have to update in
2023 so that's how you can find your recertification date if you don't already know it. I might double-check it anyways
Since they have made adjustments to recertification
Dates and anniversaries during this kovat forbearance. It's possible. It's not what it used to be
So maybe go go and double-check even if you think you know it
This is all super duper great news. And if I'm a listener on the other end, I'm like, okay. Thanks Lauren and Megan
You've made it so clear for me. You have quelled my anxiety
I am feeling much better about my overall student loan situation and I know what to do leading into
recertification
However, there are some other people who are pretty anxious right now and we've been getting lots of consultations related to this subject
so let's transition to talking a little bit about the public service loan forgiveness waiver and
Some of the things that have come up because you know news is unfolding every day
We're learning new things every day. There are updates happening all the time and we've got a couple for you
and yeah
so we're gonna continue to talk about the PSLF waiver because
Literally, we've we've been stalking the student aid gov website on like question frequently asked questions like additions that they add to the website
Because we think this is such a huge opportunity
Like they definitely underestimated how many people that this could change, you know impact or help
So we want to try to get the message out there to so many people on how we can best take advantage of this
PSLF waiver
one big thing that we as a team have been
toying with the language on or kind of wrestling with with planning strategies on is
The fact that you can consolidate your loans
to take advantage of this PSLF waiver
Which some people might have to because they have those FFEL loans or the family federal
Education loans or Perkins loans that previously have not been eligible for PSLF
so that first requirement to getting those eligible for this PSLF waiver is
Consolidation. So that's why this of course is relevant to start off
But then we started to learn that there was specific language on student aid gov. I'm just gonna read it verbatim
We've talked about this a little bit already, but I want to make sure the language is pretty clear
So it's one of the questions under student aid gov the PSLF waiver
Information site says how many payments can I get if I consolidate loans with different numbers of qualifying payments?
And Lauren, how many times do you talk with someone who has different payment counts for different loans towards PSLF?
OMG, then I would say like 99% of the time we have seen someone even if it's like a difference
I actually the client I had yesterday was
74 and 75 like half of the payments were 74 and half of them were 75 and it's like
How did I do all of these loans the exact same thing and and one payment is missing?
sometimes it's much more egregious where it's like 55 and 72 or something and
There's no reason rhyme or reason for it and they're they're they're confused about it
so common reasons why this can happen just so you are aware are
graduating with different classes of loans in the sense
let's say we had undergrad loans and we have graduate school loans and maybe we took a year off between undergrad and grad well
undergrad loans those loans
Already had a grace period after your first undergrad graduation
So that six month grace period would have lapsed you would have probably entered repayment for a period of time before you went back to grad
school
Fast forward to graduating from grad school your grad school loans did not have that six month grace period
so the grad school loans will continue to have the six month grace period where the
Undergrad loans may not so if you think you entered repayment and let's say we did not consolidate right after school
If we thought we entered repayment on all of our loans after graduate school like right after grad school
We may not have because the undergrad loans were eligible to enter repayment right then but the graduate school loans were not
So that's a very common example that we see where if someone did not consolidate
They have a larger payment count on their undergrad loans, maybe five to six payments more than their graduate school loans
So that's one example
And then you know just of course the the similar like thought process as if we did go to school at different periods of time
But we went into repayment on our older loans for periods of time before school started back up
So those are some pretty common reasons why we see
Payment count differences
But then of course there's the other times where it just doesn't make sense to us like a direct
Consolidation loan having two different payment counts. Like how does that happen when it is the same consolidation loan?
Unsubsidized the subsidized loans like what?
It is crazy. It's just like unbelievable. So let's go to the language then I'll read
What it says here about
So it's how many payments can I get if I consolidate loans with different numbers of qualifying payments?
That's the question. It says as long as your repayment history overlaps for each loan
The consolidation loan will be credited with the largest number of payments of the loans that were consolidated
for example, if you had 50 qualifying payments on one subsidized Stafford loan and
100 qualifying payments on another subsidized Stafford loan and you consolidate those two loans
You will receive 100 qualifying payments on the new direct
consolidation loan
Megan what does this mean? Is this like a huge deal excellent or is this like man? This is just okay news
So it can be a huge deal and why that is
Well one that this would be very frustrating if we had one loan that had half the payment count of the other
For maybe seemingly no apparent reason. So let's say, you know, this person didn't even have
you know weird breaks in our
schooling or in our payments like this this just doesn't make sense if you've
Supposedly been in repayment on all of your loans from the get-go. So this consolidation
Conversation could fix that if the PSLF waiver like them going back and reviewing your payment count won't fix it automatically
But where we're starting to see this as a really interesting planning
situation is when let's say we went to undergrad in
2010 we
Graduated made five years of payments went back to school for two years two or three years for grad school
Borrowed again
We have you know another couple years of payments before we went into the kovat forbearance
Well, if we worked in public service that entire time frame
So for our undergrad payments or for even grad school if we went to grad school multiple times
If we had always worked in public service while we had made payments historically with the normal PSLF rules
Those older loans would have a much higher payment count towards PSLF where our newer loans, of course would not have
It wouldn't have had a chance to have that same payment count so they didn't exist before then
But they would have in this example would have overlapping payment history
So let's say they were in repayment all at the same time, you know
2018 2019 before kovat happened they have overlapping payment history
So what we have literally been seeing is people consolidating their loans with this situation
Their undergrad and their grad school loans just going ahead and consolidating now and getting credit for what the oldest loans
Payment count was even though those grad school loans didn't exist
But does that make it sense how I'm explaining that so far?
Yeah, totally makes sense. But I know people are just like mind-blown like wait what how is this possible?
So basically if you if you're not catching what she's putting down
Nor we're catching what she's throwing if you will then
Five years of payments on some older loans now
all of a sudden you got these new loans you typically on those new loans would have to do 10 years on those loans and
Five years from now the old loans would have gotten forgiveness because the the total amount of time that needs to be made on each
Loan is 10 years. So you would have two staggered amounts of time that you're doing this whole public service thing
instead you're doing a
Consolidation and you're catching all the loans up to the same place and some loans that wouldn't so basically you're shorting the amount of time that
You're gonna have to continue on in public service and shortening shortening the amount of time until you get public service loan forgiveness
It is a game changer. Yep. You know, we're not sure if this was intended. We don't know if it was
thought through
No take backs because we've literally seen people getting the credit and getting that some folks have gotten immediate loan
Cancellation, even though again the older loan or that sorry the newer loans that they had couldn't have existed for 120 payments yet
But this consolidation kind of loops them into the rest of them. So it's it's very interesting very unique
It could help someone
Accelerate their PSLF timeframe dramatically. So this is something that we're we've been keeping an eye on we've been
You know looking at text files for to make sure that this is actually how it's playing out and so far from what we could
Tell it is
This is a big deal. This is why we wanted to talk about it again today
So this is a super cool opportunity to have available to you
If you are a part of the public service loan forgiveness system and you're trying to figure out
You know how to get access to the waiver and how the waiver might be helpful to you
You've got tons of loans that are in different situations
This could be a great opportunity, but a key piece of this is going to be overlapping payment
So, can you talk about how overlapping payments work Megan?
Yes
the first sentence that this Q&A has is as long as your repayment history overlaps for each loan the
consolidation loan will be credited with the largest number of payments of the loans that were consolidated so
Overlapping payment history. This is very important in our minds
we're thinking that this means we had to at some point been in repayment status at the same time as
Those older loans for the newer loans
I would not implement this or I don't we don't think it would be applicable to
a situation where someone maybe just graduated from grad school like this month and
They go ahead and consolidate all of their loans from undergrad that were five years ago
For example, and they had payment history on those prior loans
Reason being we don't have payment history yet for that brand new loan. So
what we've been talking about is
Checking to make sure that you do see on your federal file or just in your payment history that you were
Approved for an income driven plan or you were approved for a repayment plan in general
At the same time as your other loans being approved for a repayment plan as well
That we think is overlapping history
if you want to be extra safe you can wait until payments resume in May and
You know make a payment May or June so we know for sure we have
Overlapping payment history on all of our loans
so that's some of the language that we've been wrestling with to like as far as like how technical are they gonna get with that but
I think those two
characteristics would be important to keep in mind either were approved for the repayment plan for all of the loans at the same time at
Some point in history and or if we wanted to be super safe
Make sure we make a payment here coming up in May and then maybe look at the consolidation
Does that make sense Lauren that makes sense
PS
dear federal student aid
student a gov
office of Department of Education
However, you'd like to refer to yourself, please feel free to clarify and make it easier for us
Because we're working diligently on behalf of borrowers over here. Mm-hmm. So last but not least
We wanted to talk about a letter that many borrowers have been getting as they go through this consolidation process
And it's super duper scary. So Megan catch us up on what the letter says and
What borrowers should not be worried about?
Yep
So a letter that we're getting a lot of people reaching out to us for is something that comes from Fed loan servicing
has Fed loan servicing at the top and the US Department of Education at the top and
Then the like blurb at the top right says, are you sure you want to consolidate your loans?
so basically the gist of the letter is
You know saying hey, there is an important update on October 6 2021
The Department Department of Education announced a change in the public service loan forgiveness program rules that for a limited time
May allow you to get credit for payments. You've made on loans that wouldn't normally qualify for PSLF
This waiver period is temporary and will end on October 31st
2022 to gain more information on this limited waiver period including any actions you may need
To gain access to these benefits visit and then it gives you the the web link for student aid gov slash PSLF waiver
Now as you go through the letter, it continues to talk about how you may
Want to leave the direct loans out of the consolidation if you already have direct loans
Because they are already eligible for PSLF and then payments will count from the consolidation towards PSLF
So basically it's saying and this is true for historically
how
consolidations worked but
consolidation used to erase payment history for PSLF
Again, that would be the case without this PSLF waiver
So the language in the letter is describing that there have been temporary changes to PSLF until October
31st 2022
So how we're kind of tackling this question or this worry about you know, oh my goodness
Are you sure that the payments prior to consolidation are going to count?
towards PSLF is we refer to the specific language again on that same web link the
student aid gov slash PSLF waiver
where it outlines which PSLF requirements are waived and it shows us what's changed and
Unchanged since October 6 2021 it lists out the normal PSLF requirements and what?
Changes are in effect until October 31st 2022 and one of those bullets
Specifically says that past payments made on loans before consolidations
Count even if you were on the wrong repayment plan
So this confirms that past payments made on your your consolidations
Will count until October 31st 2022
So for example, if we were consolidating
October 2023 like next year, then this would not be the case
This is only limited to this PSLF waiver period but that is what we're pointing to just for confirmation on
this not negatively impacting your PSLF payment count for for any payment count that you might have prior to now and
So this is exactly why the waiver
Exists in my opinion is because they didn't make it easy and they're still not making it easy for borrowers to
Easily understand what they need to do and how to do it
If the paragraph literally starts off like hey just so you know, there's this special situation
But also we're sending you this and we're gonna scare the crap out of you in the next paragraph by sending you the language that
Is not really relevant right now
Yeah, yeah
This is literally why the waiver exists because so many people got misinformation or confusing information on the front end
Way back in 2007 that they didn't get a clear opportunity despite having been in public service for the last 10 years
So thanks, but no, thanks for this letter
Right. I know don't worry. Don't worry. It's okay to consolidate there is
documentation and we are seeing people
You know, like I said actually consolidate and reap the benefits of consolidating loans in that situation
Yeah, so we're continuing to monitor all of these like technical questions
So if you do continue to have questions about this, you know, you can reach out to our
Info at studentloanplanner.com email. We'll do our best to try to answer any like general questions that come in through there
Of course if you want to walk through your specific situation
Talk through all the pros and cons for what we need to be doing with you specifically then definitely, you know
Look into scheduling a consultation with us. So our team we've collectively worked with over
7,000 people now
So 7,000 cases, so we've seen a lot and we can help you navigate your situation specifically
So if you feel like you need a little more specialized or specific help
You could schedule a consultation with us through our website on the help tab that we have
But any anything you want to add Lauren before we close out this podcast episode of us going through some technicalities again
Nope, I think you nailed it. Don't be afraid of all the different intricacies. Just get help if you need it
We are here for you. We hope you enjoyed this podcast
This has been another episode where Megan and I have shared all the gems until next time
See you later. See ya

