Disaster! What U.S Space Force Revealed About NASA SLS Will Shock You While Starship...

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
480 Video Views·Nov 14, 2024
cancel the SLS that's right I said it
and honestly this phrase is no longer
just a sentiment shared by Aerospace
enthusiasts it's now a rallying cry
echoed by prominent agencies influential
figures and major Publications even the
US space force has voiced concerns the
end of NASA's space launch system may be
closer than ever amid this shift
spacex's Starship with its rapid
progress and impressive capabilities is
emerging as the key to sustaining the
Artemis program so what are these
agencies and Publications saying about
the SLS and what might Artemis look like
without NASA's Flagship vehicle join us
on today's episode of great SpaceX to
dive into the latest development
surrounding SLS and the future of
Artemis as the launch of Artemis 2
approaches in less than a year questions
around NASA's Readiness and program
costs are intensifying the Artemis
program while ambitious in its Vision to
return astronauts to the moon has been
bogged down by skyrocketing expenses and
lengthy delays Artemis 1 alone required
nearly a decade and tens of billions of
US dollars to complete a troubling
precedent as NASA gears up for the next
phases the space launch system intended
as NASA's Flagship rocket for lunar
missions has become become an emblem of
these inefficiencies burdening the
program with its high costs and
extensive infrastructure needs since its
Inception SLS has been under scrutiny
for its enormous cost complexity and
limited launch capabilities developed in
conjunction with the Orion spacecraft
mobile launch systems and proposed lunar
Gateway the SLS is envisioned as the
backbone of the Artemis program however
even some of NASA's closest partners are
now questioning the value and necessity
of this colossal system recently Colonel
Douglas Pentecost of the US space force
expressed doubts about the sls's
relevance for defense or commercial
purposes noting it's a capability right
now that we the dod don't need his
remarks suggest that within the
Department of Defense there's little
interest in leveraging the SLS for
Missions due to the availability of more
cost-effective Alternatives Christina
chaplain former assistant director at
the government accountability office has
voiced similar concerns she highlighted
sls's production inefficiencies stating
I don't see the cost going down at this
point to be competitive chaplain pointed
out that the SLS lacks the streamlined
Factory style production of private
sector Rockets resulting in cost
overruns with little chance of economic
Improvement without the manufacturing
efficiency seen in companies like SpaceX
sls's Financial sustainability remains
dubious the question of sls's future
viability has led to speculation about
whether it should continue space
journalist Eric burer has even even
suggested there's a 50/50 chance that
SLS will be cancelled arguing that there
are other ways to get Orion to the moon
this sentiment is shared by media Mogul
Michael Bloomberg who recently
criticized the Artemis program's
Financial approach Bloomberg argued that
SLS is a colossal waste of taxpayer
money with its cost structure including
23 billion for development and $4
billion per launch outstripping NASA's
initial projections one of Bloomberg's
most pointed criticisms is that even if
the SLS does become fully operational it
isn't capable of delivering humans to
the Moon independently in his words it
isn't even powerful enough to actually
get anyone to the moon at least not in
its current configuration this forces
NASA to rely on additional components
such as the Starship human Landing
system by SpaceX to complete the lunar
Mission furthermore the sls's costs are
exacerbated by other infrastructure
expenses including the ml2 mobile
launcher which has ballooned from an
initial estimate of 250 million to 2.7
billion dollar the sls's Orion module
has encountered issues returning from
emis 1 with a damaged heat shield that
has set NASA Engineers back as they
scramble to resolve the problem this
coupled with delays on the lunar Gateway
and uncertainties surrounding the
upgraded SLS block 1B variant adds
another layer of concern the lunar
Gateway which which NASA intends as a
staging point for lunar operations has
faced criticism for its high complexity
and its questionable compatibility with
spacex's Starship hls the very
spacecraft designed to transport
astronauts from the gateway to the
moon's surface the ml2 mobile launcher
initially envisioned as a
straightforward solution for the SLS has
spiraled in cost currently totaling
around 2.6.7 billion with no firm
completion date its contract has logged
over 850,000 overtime hours over the
past two years reflecting just how
intricate and timeconsuming the process
has been these accumulated setbacks and
cost overruns are taking a toll on
NASA's timeline and budget further
delaying artemis' objectives and risking
public confidence in the program in
sharp contrast to sls's limitations
spacex's Starship presents a more
streamlined and coste effective path to
the Moon unlike the SLS which is
Expendable Starship is fully reusable
promising substantial cost savings and
faster turnaround times its ambitious
design allows for inorbit refueling
enabling long-distance lunar missions
without the need for extensive expensive
support infrastructures like the lunar
Gateway with rapid advancements in
testing and development Starship is set
to potentially redefine human space
flight SpaceX has made significant
strides in recovering and launching its
super heavy booster using the mechazilla
system a revolutionary setup that will
support starship's Mission Cadence
recent developments in Starships
vertical landing and payload capability
suggest that it may be ready for lunar
operations by 2026 aligning with NASA's
planned emis missions Bloomberg
summarized starship's potential
succinctly stating a reusable SpaceX
Starship will very likely be able to
carry cargo and robots directly to the
moon no SLS Orion Gateway block 1B or
ml2 required at a small fraction of the
cost with this in mind Starship offers a
compelling alternative to SLS
particularly as NASA faces growing
pressure to find more financially
sustainable approaches the challenges
facing SLS underscore a need for NASA to
reconsider its approach to the Artemis
program given the substantial
Investments and limited flexibility of
the SLS it may be time for NASA to lean
more heavily on private sector Solutions
specifically those offered by SpaceX
utilizing Starship as a primary launch
vehicle could streamline artemis' goals
cutting down on expenses and eliminating
unnecessary logistical components like
the Gateway embracing a partnership with
SpaceX and leveraging starship's
capabilities would enable NASA to
achieve its lunar objectives faster and
more cost effectively this approach
would allow Artemis to focus more on
resources on Mission critical
Technologies rather than maintaining a
high cost infrastructure centered around
the SLS as NASA faces the Dual pressures
of rising costs and increased
expectations a shift in strategy may be
essential the decision to keep SLS or
replace it with commercially available
options like Starship could ultimately
determine the long-term success of
Artemis if you agree that NASA should
stream line Artemis by adopting more
efficient Technologies show your support
by commenting scrap launch system and
share this update to spread awareness of
spacex's exciting journey toward making
lunar missions more accessible and
sustainable indeed if NASA's SLS and
Associated systems are removed from the
Artemis program the program would
undergo significant transformation the
first major shift would likely be the
end of the two rocket launch approach
instead a single rocket would carry the
crew to the Moon facilitate landing and
then lift off from the lunar surface to
return home this all-in-one vehicle
would be none other than spacex's
Starship hls it's a streamlined approach
that arguably should have been the plan
from the get-go for Starship hls to
carry out these tasks certain upgrades
would be necessary to optimize crew
transport from launch if tasked with
bringing the crew back to Earth the hls
would need additional features such as
heat shields and flaps for safe re-entry
currently SpaceX is refining The Landing
process for Starship and they have over
a year to fully Master it before arus 3
following this any necessary design
adjustments can be made to further
optimize the spacecraft alternatively if
SpaceX prefers to minimize changes and
maximize reliability they could
substitute NASA's system with their own
Falcon and dragon Vehicles possibly
involving a falcon heavy in this
scenario Falcon heavy could launch a
Dragon capsule with the crew Rendevous
with the Starship in lunar orbit
transfer the crew and then wait in orbit
to retrieve them for the journey home
essentially following NASA's existing
process but with spacex's more
cost-effective technology a third option
could see Starship completing the entire
journey to and from the Moon bringing
the crew back to Earth orbit where they
would then transfer to a waiting Dragon
capsule for re-entry and Landing each of
these options avoids Reliance on NASA's
vehicles and would likely be more
feasible and reliable than the current
setup if NASA is genuinely considering
canceling the SLS a swift decision is
essential we're nearing the end of 2024
with less than a year remaining before
emis 2 and under 2 years for emis 3
early preparation is critical even with
spacex's rapid progress late decisions
from NASA could prevent timely design or
operational changes causing delays
delays could impact the US's position in
the lunar race as China also accelerates
its lunar Ambitions ultimately the
decisions rest with NASA and
organization once at the Forefront of
lunar exploration but now facing
challenges due to inefficiency NASA will
oversee and manage the program while
SpaceX handles the missions execution
this approach could be the key to the US
regaining its lead in lunar exploration
what are your thoughts on the matter
feel free to share your perspective in
the comment section down below otherwise
folks that's about it for today's
episode thank you so much for tuning in
and as always this has been Kevin from
great SpaceX until next time keep
looking up
