Elon Musk Finally Revealed Why Boeing Starliner FAILED: NASA Fixed Contracts?

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
7.6K Video Views·Jul 25, 2024
SpaceX creates a monopoly destroys
competition and is the reason many
companies can't catch a break these are
the dramatic claims floating around the
Aerospace industry but is there any
truth to them long answer short not
really spacex's rain is more about
NASA's fixed contracts and the
occasional stumble of other companies
like in with their Starliner Fiasco and
no it's not just gossip Elon Musk
himself has spilled the beans on why
Starliner didn't quite hit the mark so
buckle up and join us as we dive into
this topic on today's episode of great
SpaceX indeed when mentioning NASA's
fixed contracts Boeing and starlander
come to mind as the biggest
disappointments in recent years despite
receiving almost double the funding
compared to SpaceX in the commercial
crew program Boeing's performance has
been less than Stellar awarded the
contract in 2014 and aiming for a 2017
launch Starliner first crew flight only
took off on June 5th of this year those
seven years were marked by stagnation
and ongoing issues with their vehicles
this not only caused significant delays
for both Boeing and NASA but also led to
substantial Financial losses with just
one crew flight to date start Starliner
achievements pale in comparison to what
spacex's dragon has accomplished keep in
mind that mission was a test mission
meaning Starliner has yet to receive
launch certification or fulfill any of
its CCP contract obligations they've
only a few years left to complete the
six required missions what's more
embarrassing despite a successful launch
Starliner encountered numerous problems
during the test mission to this day NASA
and Boeing have not managed to bring
their spacecraft and astronauts back
many even suggest that NASA should send
Dragon to rescue the stranded Starliner
astronauts NASA chose two contractors
for the CCP to maintain selection
flexibility and avoid Monopoly however
Boeing's shortcomings have undermined
NASA's strategy leaving them reliant on
SpaceX and dragon this situation is
particularly humiliating for Boeing a
giant of last Century's Aerospace
industry musk even remarked the CEO of
an aircraft company should know how to
design aircraft not spreadsheets I
strongly believe that all managers in a
technical area must be technically
excellent musk also added Boeing has
been on a gradual decline in this
Century their systems still reflect
outdated Styles no longer suitable for
present times true Engineers are likely
few while bureaucracy continues to grow
on the contrary some might think that
Elon Musk knows nothing about
engineering however a look at everyday
astronauts video shows otherwise as he
smoothly explains everything about
Starship with such a leader it's clear
why SpaceX leads the Aerospace industry
this is just one example of why even
without preferential treatment SpaceX
continues to secure valuable contracts
in any field competition is always
crucial in the Aerospace industry
companies compete for markets and launch
contracts which Drive economic benefits
and enhance their positioning as the
leading Aerospace agency NASA acts as a
dealer creating projects and contracts
then selecting the most suitable
contractors for many years NASA has
focused on fixed contracts meaning
agreements with constant prices this
benefits NASA by simplifying the
awarding process and avoiding future
complications with fixed contract s
contractors must deliver everything NASA
requires within the agreed price if they
go over budget those companies bear the
additional costs instead of seeking
extra funding from NASA typical examples
of fixed price contracts include the
commercial crew program contract the
Artemis contract and the National
Security space launch contract which
although not from NASA is quite notable
once awarded companies must develop
their vehicles and adhere to the launch
schedule set by the issuing agency
however this contract type can make
competition challenging for companies
with fixed prices they must manage costs
carefully and meet deadlines without
seeking additional funding which can be
a significant hurdle for NASA while
competition is always encouraged the
reality is that they prefer not to waste
costs they need to choose the most
reliable vehicle and organization for
their missions in this regard SpaceX
stands out as a top Contender known for
its high reliability and frequent
successful launches this is why SpaceX
has secured numerous significant
contracts that other companies covet
beyond the major commercial crew program
and emis contracts SpaceX has recently
won several notable agreements for
instance they secured the issd orbit
contract worth 843 million us a
satellite launch contract from NASA and
Noah value Val at 11 12.7 million a
rescue space mission research contract
worth
267,000 and the usf's nssl phase 3
contract totaling up to 5.6 billion US
from contracts worth just a few hundred
th000 to multi-million and even billion
doll deals SpaceX consistently
demonstrates its dominance while large
contracts might be expected from such a
leading company even the smaller
contracts reflect significant progress
for SpaceX for smaller companies
securing these contracts would be a
major breakthrough despite this many
companies criticize SpaceX however they
fail to recognize that this situation
stems from their own weaknesses and
diminishing competitiveness but before
we get into all of that make sure you
leave a like share the video and
subscribe to our channel to keep up with
spacex's development Journey you know
small companies often face significant
financial challenges a notable example
is Astra space which experienced a
severe crisis after multiple failures
and was eventually forced to shift to
the private sector another case is
Sierra space despite their promising
Dreamchaser project they have yet to
deploy it there are likely many other
companies in similar situations in
reality these companies still have
opportunities but they often fall short
this is evident in the nssl contract ini
phase three of the contract running from
2025 to 2029 was planned to include two
lanes Lane 2 was designated for high
demand tasks suited for large companies
like SpaceX or Ula while Lane one was
intended for smaller companies with
simpler requirements however the recent
announcement for Lane one revealed that
the contract was awarded to SpaceX Ula
and blue origin the reason no launch
service provider was able to meet the
requir re Ms for Lane one this
highlights a gap in capabilities rather
than a lack of opportunity for major
companies their performance often fails
to match their potential and the
opportunities they receive this is
evident not just with Boeing as
discussed earlier but also with current
giants like blue origin and Ula who face
significant challenges blue origin for
example has yet to launch any vehicle
into orbit leaving them at a
disadvantage compared to SpaceX recall
that in 2021 when SpaceX was awarded the
aremis contract blue Origins sued NASA
alleging favoritism however their
lawsuit overlooked the fact that their
lack of progress was the real reason
they were not selected meanwhile Ula
known for its iconic Rockets like Atlas
and Delta has struggled to keep Pace
with newer models such as Falcon 9 and
Falcon heavy their latest rocket the
Vulcan faced significant delays and only
completed its first launch Miss this
year as a result Ula has lost its
primary market for launching government
payloads to SpaceX in contrast to others
SpaceX consistently demonstrates
exceptional reliability with the Falcon
rocket system SpaceX has conducted over
360 launches boasting a high success
rate among these Falcon 9 has become the
most frequently launched vehicle in
recent years additionally these Rockets
are capable of landing and being reused
a f few organizations can achieve this
capability significantly reduces
development and launch costs creating
formidable competition in the industry
following the Falcon generation SpaceX
is now focused on developing Starship a
rocket with unparalleled capacity and
potential and notably it can be fully
reused musk envisions a future where
Starship launches cost as little as $2
million us a strikingly low figure this
position SpaceX with a significant Edge
in any competitive landscape with a more
reliable and costeffective vehicle it's
clear why NASA and other companies have
little reason to overlook SpaceX in
summary the US Aerospace industry is
grappling with the unfortunate reality
of declining competition however it's
important to note that this situation is
not directly attributable to SpaceX the
current companies are simply struggling
and failing to Showcase their capab
abilities instead of criticizing SpaceX
these companies should focus on
reforming and enhancing their own
systems as for SpaceX they should simply
keep doing what they're doing their
success is a direct result of their own
capabilities so there's no need for
concern they will maintain their leading
position and continue to be the US's
Flagship in global competition if you
agree with this perspective please
respond with yes in the comment section
down below otherwise folks that's about
it for today's episode thank you so much
for tuning in and as always this has
been Kevin from great SpaceX until next
time keep looking up
