It's Embarrassing! Boeing Starliner to Launch CARGO Mission Only, Elon Musk LAUGH...

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
3 Video Views·Nov 11, 2024
launching cargo only that's Boeing's
latest strategy to salvage its Starliner
spacecraft while it awaits certification
a major setback for the vehicle built by
an organization famously touted for its
safety standards that SpaceX must also
adhere to so can Boeing's Starliner
survive with this new approach is this a
sign it may never carry astronaut again
should NASA consider dropping this
vehicle from its contract and how has
Elon Musk responded let's explore these
questions in today's episode of great
SpaceX it's now been nearly 2 months
since the cruess return of Starliner
cft1 Mission and the issues are still
under investigation with little progress
reported this uncertainty is echoed in
NASA's recent crew mission updates for
next year leaving Starliner future
schedule in limbo the reason is clear
Starliner still hasn't achieved crew
launch certification but while the
launch timeline remains unclear one
thing is certain the losses continue to
mount years of delays due to testing
issues pre-launch setbacks post-launch
complications and now yet another delay
for inspections have all contributed to
a staggering Financial toll in the
second quarter alone Boeing reported a
$125 million us loss from pre-flight
delays bringing total losses from
Starliner to a shocking
$1.85 billion and this figure doesn't
even account for the additional costs of
the cft1 delays and the current
investigation keep in mind that $1.85
billion is part of Boeing's total $6
billion loss indicating the depth of the
crisis the company faces with all
systems facing challenges Starliner
appears to have no straightforward path
to resolution in response Boeing has put
forth a last resort strategy to keep the
project afloat the company is
considering a Starliner cargo mission to
the ISS a shift to Cargo only flights to
generate Revenue while the spacecraft
awaits crew certification Yes you heard
that right cargo not crew in theory
launching cargo only missions could be a
reasonable approach for Boeing as cargo
missions involve less risk and could
help maintain Starliner operational
momentum however in practice this
solution is far from straightforward
first there's the issue of Hardware
Boeing currently has only two Starliner
capsules one of these was recently used
in the cft1 mission and it's now
undergoing issue checks and being held
back for NASA's certification review
making it unavailable for other missions
the second capsule is seemingly ready it
successfully docked with the ISS in May
of 2022 however Boeing initially
designated this capsule for Starliner 1
assuming they received as a
certification if Boeing diverts it for a
cargo Mission it could further delay
Starliner 1 this leads to a second issue
Boeing mentions a cargo Mission as a
means of offsetting costs but is a
single Mission sufficient given the
indefinite timeline for starliners
certification Boeing might be forced to
run additional test missions resulting
in further delays it's unclear whether
one cargo Mission would be financially
adequate to counter the losses Boeing
might argue that if one cargo Mission
isn't enough they could schedule more
but this raises the question is a single
capsule capable of supporting multiple
missions without impacting the Readiness
of Starliner 1 this dependency on a
limited number of capsules could create
a cascading delay effect challenging
Boeing's ability to maintain its
commitments it's important to remember
why Starliner was created in the first
place with $4.5 billion US in NASA
funding Boeing's commitment was to
complete at least six crw flights to the
ISS not cargo missions shifting Focus to
Cargo could make people question its
purpose and Boeing's reputation after
all how does it reflect on a $4.5
billion dollar investment if the
spacecraft is primarily launching cargo
moreover NASA's confidence in Starliner
ability to handle these missions is
uncertain with dragon already conducting
three cargo missions annually and northr
Roman's sickness regularly resupplying
the ISS NASA's resupply needs are well
covered additionally Sierra space is
Dreamchaser is expected to begin
operations next year raising further
questions about the necessity of using
Starliner for cargo this idea of
converting Starliner to a cargo vehicle
has sparked widespread reactions musk
founder of SpaceX which operates the
dragon spacecraft commented there is no
logical purpose to Starliner given that
NASA plans to deorbit space station in
about roughly 5 years musk's point is
significant Starliner delays aren't just
a financial burden they're also causing
scheduling setbacks even if Boeing
manages to secure certification under
the troubled cft1 Mission Starliner one
likely wouldn't launch until at least
the second half of 2025 from there
Boeing would have a mere 5 years to
complete the remaining five missions a
challenging Prospect and that's assuming
Starliner 1 can even launch on time
which remains uncertain with the dubious
timeline Boeing's proposal to convert
Starliner to a cargo vehicle raises
serious doubts about its ability to f
fill crude missions within the iss's
remaining operational years musk's
criticism of Starliner purpose seems
increasingly valid adding to the
skepticism Boeing has openly stated it
will not engage in any more fixed price
contracts a move that implies an
acknowledgment of their struggles recent
reports even suggest that Boeing might
be considering selling Starliner
altogether if true this would likely be
the most disappointing outcome as it
suggests Boeing's motivation to launch
cargo is merely to keep Starliner
functional not to meet NASA's needs
given this scenario some might argue
NASA should recover the 4 and a half
billion it invested in the project as
for potential buyers some speculate that
blue origin could step in as they
currently lack an orbital capsule this
pairing might make sense for blue origin
but it raises questions about star
liner's ultimate value and purpose
regardless of what lies ahead Starliner
Journey has been fraught with setbacks
its Mission seems increasingly
misaligned its rope map flawed and its
potential limited rather than prolonging
the project why not consider
cancellation if you agree respond with
cancel it in the comments section down
below don't forget to like share the
video and subscribe to our channel for
more updates on spacex's development
Journey with Boeing's Starliner facing
ongoing challenges it seems likely that
spacex's Dragon will continue to serve
as NASA's reliable partner for the iss's
remaining years unlike Starliner dragon
has consistently demonstrated its
capabilities completing 10 success crew
missions including a demo flight and
maintaining a Flawless track record in
fact spacex's Dragon will play a
critical role in the upcoming crew n
Mission which is set to bring home two
astronauts who were originally meant to
return on Starliner this highlights
dragon's reliability and importance in
compensating for the setbacks caused by
Boeing's spacecraft looking ahead
dragon's contributions will only grow
NASA has confirmed at least five more
crew missions for Dragon to the ISS
likely more as the St starlander issues
persist additionally SpaceX is slated to
maintain its steady pace of ISS resupply
missions averaging three cargo flights
annually with a record of 30 completed
cargo missions to date Beyond its
current roles Dragon was also selected
by NASA for the critical task of
deorbiting the ISS a challenging
assignment that reflects both the trust
in and the honor granted to spacex's
spacecraft as we transition into the
posts era dragon's involvement will
extend even further with anticipated
roles in supporting new commercial space
stations like vast Axiom and starlab
these stations will likely rely on
SpaceX for launches and dragon for crew
and cargo operations reinforcing its
position as a central figure in the next
chapter of human space flight NASA's
goal of fostering competition in crude
space flight has faced significant
setbacks largely due to the ongoing
issues with Boeing's Starliner while
NASA recognizes the crucial role that
spacex's Dragon plays they initially
aimed to support multiple providers to
reduce dependence on a single company
this was evident in their decision to
select two contractors a decade ago to
ensure choice and flexibility however
Starliner challenges have not only cost
NASA time and Financial Resources but
have also strained scheduling for
Missions to the ISS despite these issues
NASA appears committed to keeping
options open the agency may continue to
support Starliner development possibly
by facilitating cargo only flights in an
effort to sustain the program in the
meantime NASA is also turning its
attention toward Sierra space's
Dreamchaser Dreamchaser has completed
its preparations and shows promise as a
viable competitor to Dragon yet the
vehicle faces a key obstacle its
Reliance on ula's Vulcan rocket which is
currently dealing with delays should
vulcan's launch issues remain unresolved
dreamchaser's entry into service could
be delayed leaving NASA with limited
alternatives for resupply Missions
despite the uncertainties the arrival of
Dreamchaser could represent a
much-needed boost to competition in the
sector potentially driving further
Innovation the end may be near for
Boeing's Starliner ironically every
attempt Boeing makes to salvage the
spacecraft seems only to bring it closer
to its unceremonious finish if Starliner
initially intended to support the ISS is
phased out before the ISS itself retires
it would Mark a significant setback for
both Boeing and NASA's objectives now
with limited options Boeing faces the
challenging task of moving forward with
the substantial weight of these setbacks
the upcoming decision from NASA on
Boeing's cargo launch request May
determine Starliner fate this could
either provide the program a last
Lifeline or be the final push that
brings down Boeing's struggling
spacecraft Venture well folks that's
about it for today's episode thank you
so much for tuning in and as always this
has been Kevin from great SpaceX until
next time keep looking up
