Biblical Archaeology From the Ground Down: Arch of Titus

Archaeological Artifacts
165 followers
#Archaeology#archaeological artifacts
Welcome to our episode of Biblical Archaeology from the Ground Down, presented by Bible Interact
and hosted by Dr. George Sparks.
Join us as we explore the fascinating world of the Bible from leading experts in the field
of archaeology.
Hello, everyone.
I'm Dr. David Graves, an experienced biblical archaeologist and CEO of Electronic Christian
Media.
I'm here today with another exciting episode on our Archaeology Discoveries channel, where
we discuss important archaeological artifacts related to the Bible.
Thanks for watching, and be sure to like and subscribe to our channel.
Well, welcome.
This is Biblical Archaeology from the Ground Down, sponsored by Bible Interact.
I'm your host, George Sparks, and my special guest is Dr. David Graves, and Dr. David Graves
received his Ph.D. from the University of Aberdeen, Scotland, and has been involved
in teaching the Bible and archaeology for more than 35 years.
He has taught at Oxford University, England, Liberty University, School of Divinity, provided
tours of the Ashmolean and the British Museums, traveled extensively throughout the Middle
East, has been involved in the Mount Ararat research, he has excavated at Qumran, the
Temple Mount, and Shiloh in Israel, as well as Tel El-Hammam in Jordan.
For over 10 seasons, he has been involved in excavating the Dead Sea Scroll Caves and
has authored many books as well as publications.
Welcome to the program, Dr. David Graves, and today you've got a PowerPoint to present,
and we're going to look at the Arch of Titus, and this has to do with the Romans' domination
over the First Jewish Revolt, right, and this is what's on the Ark, which was behind me
right here.
We've got a few artifacts to share, and so this is going to be a really cool program,
so people, you want to stay tuned and watch this.
So, Dr. Graves, we're ready if you need to put up your PowerPoint.
Oh, great.
Good to be with you, George.
We'll take a look at the Arch of Titus, Host Disabled Participating Screen Sharing.
Well, I'm being a real knucklehead today, it looks like.
Let me see what's going on here.
We usually have that preset, but here we go.
Great.
Okay.
So we're going to talk about the Arch of Titus today and the Temple Menorah, material from
my book on the New Testament, Archaeology of the New Testament.
That's what it looks like when I was there in 2012.
I had a beautiful day, and we didn't have a lot of Taurus mulling around.
I think it was because it was so hot that day, it was pretty warm, but I got a good
shot of it.
There's the books, the Archaeology of the New Testament.
So I have a full description there with all the footnotes, all the receipts that you can
investigate for more details.
Well, the Arch of Titus is in the Forum in Rome.
This is the image of it here.
We'll talk a little bit more about that.
It's located at the highest point on the Via Sacra.
So that's the road, runs right through here.
This is what it looked like in 1821.
It was restored during the pontificate of Pope Pius VII by Giuseppe Valadier in 1821.
So it's been there for a very long time.
They've done some restoration on it, which is a good thing.
It has the depiction of the menorah, the table of the presence, and the two silver trumpets
as they appeared in the temple in Jerusalem in 70 AD.
We'll talk a little bit about that in a moment.
What prompted me to talk about this today was I was on Facebook, I have a Facebook group
that I belong to, and somebody on that post had posted a photograph from the inside here,
this side of the inside panel of the Arch of Titus, but they stated that it was the
Arch of Constantine, which is this arch, it has actually three arches, and it's further
up the hill here on the Forum in Rome.
Initially, and there's my photograph of the Arch of Constantine, you can't get to it today
because it's got a fence all around it, so he wasn't able to stand in there and take
that photograph there of the inside of the arch.
Now, what threw me off was I knew that there was a relief on the inside of this arch,
but the roof has a beautiful mosaic on the top of it of the arch that the Arch of Constantine
doesn't have.
So I thought, something's wrong here, and I said, have I made a mistake thinking that
this is the Arch of Titus and was Arch of Constantine or something?
So I went back to my books, and this is actually what the Arch of Titus looks like from the
inside as you stand between the arches and you look up.
So we've got a panel on this side, and this photograph here is taken from the other side
of this arch as you're walking this way through the arch.
So we have the menorah, mosaic, not mosaic, but relief here on the right, and then we
have a relief here on the left with the horses, and this is the one that was posted on Facebook
stating it was the Arch of Constantine, and I said, that can't be because I remember how
this top of the arch looked.
So they put a whole bunch of information about the Arch of Constantine, but showed the wrong
picture.
So if you really want to know what's going on, stay tuned to our channel, and you'll
get educated and learn a lot and help you with the misinformation that's being foisted
upon you on the internet.
This is the photograph that was posted on Facebook.
You can clearly see here the relief of the horses, the chariot, and the emperor, and
then you have this beautiful rosette relief at the top.
Here I am standing in front of it in 2012.
It's the Honorific Arch of Titus, constructed by Titus' younger brother Domitian in AD 81
in commemoration of Titus' victories in Jerusalem.
So it was built by his brother Domitian, but it was in honor of his brother Titus.
So the story goes, of course, everybody knows that in 70 AD the Romans come through Jerusalem,
they conquer Jerusalem, they take and destroy the temple, and they cart off all of the artifacts,
all of the temple back to Rome.
Well, actually, we'll look at that in a little more detail.
There's a bit of a journey that they take.
It's the oldest surviving example, also a Roman arch.
Folks probably didn't realize that, that this one here is the oldest.
Well, the Arch of Constantine dates to about 320-something, I think, 321 AD.
I'll have to go back and look at the exact date, but it's a couple of...
It'd have to be Byzantine.
Yeah, it's a couple of centuries later than when this one was actually built.
It's not as elaborate, not as beautiful.
So inside of the Arch of Titus, depicted here, the two impressive panels with reliefs
are on either side of the arch.
It depicts Titus riding in a chariot accompanied by the goddess Victoria and the goddess Roma,
the goddess of Rome.
There's a marble bust here of Domitian that was taken in the Louvre.
So the first, as I mentioned, depicts the riding on Titus in a chariot.
The second one is the Romans' procession carrying the spoil plunder from the Second Temple
in Jerusalem, conquered in 70 AD.
So here's a close-up of it.
Folks can notice it behind George there.
He's got a nice clear image of it behind.
Here we have a reproduction that was made from the photograph that's now in front of
the government buildings in Israel.
And it's quite large.
I think it's something like six feet tall, so they've blown it up.
So it's a depiction of the menorah as portrayed as it was in the temple in the first century.
So we get an idea they didn't have cameras and photographs back then.
But here we have craftsmen and artisans giving us a picture in relief of what the menorah
looked like.
It stood in the temple.
As the Romans are carrying it off, you can see the poles.
They're carrying it on some kind of a stand.
Here's the poles right here.
Here we have the standards, Roman standards here and here.
And then here we have the two silver trumpets and the table of showbread.
So this is the side where this particular relief is located.
There's the menorah, again, a close-up of it.
And there's the table of showbread right here that they're carrying.
You can see it here.
And now Yarden argues that the depiction of the menorah stands is the actual Jewish
carrying frame as derives serving both a permanent furculum and pedestal.
However, Kleiner and Franer are skeptical of that view.
They prefer to think of it as a specially constructed Roman carrying pedestal or platform.
The Romans constructed to carry the artifacts off due to the decorations of an eagle and
sea creatures that are typically Roman.
However, I would argue you need to also remember that the altar in the synagogue in
Sardis also depicts an eagle and two lions on either side of the altar in the synagogue.
So just because we find those particular images doesn't necessarily mean that they were done
by the Romans.
The Jews also assimilated those ideas, Roman ideas, into their own iconology.
It's called syncretism.
Also displayed in relief are the two silver trumpets, as I mentioned, in the table of
the presence.
It's interesting that the names have been given to the two silver trumpets by the Israelites.
They called one Israel and the other one Jericho.
So these objects were originally gilded with gold with a blue background.
There's another photograph of it.
It's a little clearer, a little high resolution.
It's hard to get a good photo of it because it's inside the arch and the light is not
always that good.
So this one's a really, really well done photograph.
We can clearly see the table of the presence there and all the different elements of the
Romans carrying off the artifacts.
Now here's a reconstruction, digital reconstruction, showing the Arch of Titus, the menorah
panel, as it would have originally been depicted in color.
But we know it was in color because we found the pigments, they found the pigments still
on the inside of it.
So I guess people don't realize that a lot of these were actually colored in antiquity.
So that's something that we now know.
They were painted and colored.
So that gives you a pretty good idea of what it looked like.
There's a menorah, table of the presence, and the silver trumpets.
And there was a Latin inscription in brass, which read, or bronze, which read,
The Roman Senate and people to deified Titus, Vespasian, Augustus, son of deified Vespasian.
And that's what it looks like, a close up of it there.
And so in 129, Emperor Hadrian rebuilt Jerusalem as Elea Capitolia, or Capitolina, had its
own temple to a god, the Roman god Jupiter, Capitolinus, built on the site of the remains
of the Jewish temple.
The Romans built their temple on top of the Jewish temple, the Temple Mount, dedicated
to the Roman god.
And then the Romans attacked Qumran on the way to Masada, the ones where the Dead Sea
Scrolls were located in the caves around that.
And of course, we know the story of the two year conquest of the top of the fortification
of Masada, Herod's fortification there.
There's a bust of Hadrian.
The Essenes, as I said, hid the Dead Sea Scrolls in the caves and the cliffs before they had
arrived.
The revolt ended with the fall of Masada fortress in AD 73.
So that's when this fortress here fell to the Romans after two years.
The treasures of the Jews, according to Procopius, with Titus, the son of Vespasian, together
with certain others, were brought to Rome after the capture of Jerusalem.
There's the text if you want to look it up in Procopius' Vandal Wars.
And this is the Temple of Peace where those artifacts were brought to Rome after they
were captured in Jerusalem.
The Vespasian put them on display there, the Temple of Peace.
In AD 455, Genesic, the king of the Vandals, he took the temple vessels in the sack of
Rome, so they lose them.
And then in AD 534, Belisarius brought the temple items to Constantinople, then called
Byzantium, from Carthage.
According to Procopius.
And when Justinian became aware of the items, he sent everything to the sanctuaries of the
Christians in Jerusalem.
So they come back to Jerusalem, according to Procopius.
So he gives the account of the travels of the artifacts.
I'll go back.
One thing to notice here is that there isn't any representation of the Ark of the Covenant.
So I think that's notable.
If the Ark of the Covenant was still in Jerusalem and carried back to Rome, then there would
have been a depiction of it, I'm sure, on one of these reliefs.
But what's interesting from archaeology is that after 70 AD, there's a rise in gold
coinage.
So some people have speculated that the Ark of the Covenant was disassembled and melted
down to make gold coins to pay for the armies.
And these are all that's left in Jerusalem when the Romans showed up to carry back to
Rome.
Again, that's hypothesis.
We're not certain, but it seems to give some archaeological correlating evidence that perhaps
they dismantled, boiled down, melted the gold and made coins out of it, carted everything
else back to Rome.
So that's a little of an overview of the Arch of Titus.
I think it's really, really significant because we get to see what the menorah looked like
that was sitting in the temple in Jerusalem at the time of Jesus.
And that's pretty cool, if you ask me.
Some questions, George?
Well, that is pretty interesting because being represented as what is taken out of
Jerusalem, and that'd be after the fall of Jerusalem in 70 AD, except the fall of
Masada, like you already stated, was 73.
So the revolt didn't really come to an end until around 73.
That's right.
And then the Arch of Titus was built by his brother in 81.
So you could say maybe another eight years later after Masada.
Somewhere there, eight?
No, maybe not.
It was in commemoration for what his brother had done.
And we know that Titus was the one in charge of the conquest of Masada.
So we know he was active in that time period.
So it all fits together.
And then you're not very romantic about the Ark of the Covenant.
Aren't you supposed to tell us that it's buried somewhere underneath the temple or maybe a
cave around Jerusalem or somewhere down by the Dead Sea?
And don't tell us that somebody melted it down to make coins.
Oh, my gosh, man.
That's just devastating.
No, I know.
Terrible, terrible.
Or you said it's probably melted down before that?
No, I think it was melted down at the time of when they took the temple, of course, they
had access to it.
That's assuming, of course, that it was still there in the temple in Jerusalem at that time.
There's speculation as to whether it survived, whether it was rebuilt.
That's a whole other debate.
It is, but people are always going to...
It's always a fun discussion.
Rather, what do you want to do with the Ark?
Some people, what do you want to call it, the second coming have to have the Ark back
in the temple and the temple's got to be built again.
Of course, that's off the subject, but when you're in this kind of arena with the menorah
and the silver trumpets...
Now, let me ask you this.
Is that menorah the same menorah that they used in the tabernacle during the time period
of Shiloh?
Probably not.
It probably looked different.
The one that we have in the tabernacle, that one appears to have had a different kind of
base to it, more of a triangular base and more of a candelabra.
I'm not trying to stump you.
I'm just wondering if, because I honestly don't know, because I think people would
assume that one was the one that was made in the wilderness during, what do you want
to say, Iron Age, one late Bronze Age, Moses and Joshua, then the tabernacle.
And then, of course, you got a number of...
You talked about the pharaohs mentioned in the Bible, such as Shushak, and then you got
the Assyrians, the Babylonians, the Greeks, the Persians.
Well, what we need to remember is that we're talking here about the second temple period.
When you go back to the first temple period of Solomon, there was actually a number of
menorah that were in Solomon's temple, and they were created differently from the one
that we had described in the wilderness with the tabernacle.
So I think they were recreated.
Whether this one was one of them from Solomon's temple, it's unlikely.
They would have rebuilt it.
One second, because if we're looking at the time of Moses or Joshua, people are going
to, I believe, like a culture is going to make items from that time period.
I mean, we're not going to find ruins of a plane in Gettysburg.
That wouldn't make sense in archaeology.
So we're usually going to find certain types of technologies and also styles of pottery.
So this is just the point, and this is why I got in the showcase, because this is an
Iron Age lamp, and this would be similar, a similar type, not exact, but a similar type
of lamp that would be used during the time period of Moses and the conquest under Joshua.
Would you agree with that?
It is a different, but basic shape.
So I would imagine that if this is the case, and this is what they're used to looking at,
and this is the lamp, then if you had a menorah, you probably had something like this mounted,
maybe at different levels.
It may be tilted.
And so in my mind, now when we get to the Roman period, because of course, lamps change.
And I'll use this one for a representation, if you don't mind.
And hopefully people can see this.
Is it okay?
Does it get blurry?
No, in front of you, it's good.
Okay, so you can see the candelabrum here.
In a way, it looks very similar in some respects to the one that's on the Arch of Titans.
And I think what we're looking at on the top looks more like lamps like this.
Now, I don't know about here, you know, I've seen debates about the base, and I think you
mentioned that.
Is that base from the second temple period, or was that designed by the Romans so they
could have it in the procession, more decorated, whatever their case might be?
All right.
But antiquities, we discussed this before we got going.
I don't try to sneak stuff in.
But antiquities, I don't know if you can see this right here, but you mentioned the
during the time period earlier had that base on it.
There's like on a stand, like a tripod stand.
And here it is right here.
You can see, well, if you can't see it, what I'll do is I'll add a picture when we edit
so you can see a close up.
And of course, it's worn, but you can see the tripod stand right here.
Yeah.
Now, George, another thing that I didn't put a photo up, I probably should have, is that
in the first century, there was a bird house discovered in Jerusalem where on the wall
and the plaster, there was the etching of a menorah.
And it has like a tripod style base on it.
So whether the person whose house that was in, some argue that it was the house of the
priest who was very close to the Temple Mount, whether he knew what the menorah looked like
with a triangular base.
And as you have stated, and some have argued that that was a sort of a Roman platform that
was created to carry the menorah, and that's still debated.
There's a number of depictions of the menorah that give us an idea of what it what it looked
like.
So the top part, at least we know, likely represents what was in Jerusalem in the Temple
period.
People think we don't got a lot to do.
We argue about the base.
What about the base?
Is there anything better to do?
I don't know about that base.
But anyway, in antiquities, if somebody was to purchase an antiquity, now, I don't recommend
this at all because a menorah lamp would cost something like this.
Probably, I would imagine if this hit the antiquity market, it would probably go for
at least $4,500, depending on the market, or more, $4,500 or more.
All right.
So the thing is, it has to be a menorah.
And in the Jewish tradition, the menorah will have to have the base.
If it doesn't have the base in the design, as you see it displayed in an antiquity, it's
just a candelabra.
It's not a menorah.
I see this during the Byzantine period where they have, it looks like some would say it
was a menorah, but technically, it's just a candelabra because it doesn't show the base.
Now, why is this important in antiquities?
Well, if you just have the candelabra, right, and it's not the true menorah, it's not worth
as near as much.
It could probably go for hundreds more than thousands.
And now, another thing that is so rare that you talked about, and so unique, is that really
before the destruction of the temple in 70 AD, it was not ethical to make pictures or
drawings or sketches of the utensils that were used in the temple because they were
sacred according to their traditions.
Sure.
So for it to be in a priestly house is extremely unique, especially a house that was destroyed
during the first Jewish revolt, which would be before the first century.
So ideally, then that was on the wall before the Roman siege.
And it's also in a Jewish house.
And it's in the west side, I believe, where we also have the wall.
It's called the Wall Museum.
I think it's W-H-O-L.
And now we have also in this museum, it's very, very close to the Burnt House Museum.
Very, very close.
You have what scholars, even Dr. Rittenmeyer, believes it was probably the house of a high
priest, maybe Annas, his relatives, Caiaphas.
And if you go to Jerusalem, it's a must see.
And if you're not aware of it, because you're thinking about the Burnt House, nobody really
talks about it.
As Christians, what do we mean the Burnt House?
But it's absolutely fantastic to see because I don't think the Burnt House was not restored.
But the house of Caiaphas, I'm going to call it the house of Caiaphas, but the house of
the high priest is basically a mansion at that time period.
What they could, they restored it.
I think Dr. Rittenmeyer also assisted in the restoration.
And he made some claims.
Once again, we'll use the word hypothesis.
I don't want to be off the subject.
But since we're talking about the Candelabrum, the Menorah, the Temple, the First Jewish
Revolt, the Burnt House, is that in the restoration of these ruins of these first century houses.
And we also, we already talked about the process of conservation with Dr. Lane Rittenmeyer
when I worked together with him at Shiloh.
That's correct.
He's an expert in conservation and has worked in Jerusalem on many sites and contributed,
as you say, to the preservation of the high priest or the priest's house.
I don't mean to be, if I'm looking down, that's because your picture's down here
in my screen.
So it doesn't look like, hopefully I don't look like I'm falling asleep or something.
I got to remember, you got to look at the little light right here.
But actually, our pictures are, and then I got a big screen right here.
So the picture can be up here.
So I could be up here looking.
But anyway, so if people are wondering, what is that guy doing?
That's what's happening.
And plus, I got my notes over here.
Back to the house.
Go ahead.
Oh, I just think what's also really interesting about this relief is the two trumpets that
we see, because not often do people talk about the trumpets that are blown, the silver trumpets
that are pictured here in front of the table of showbread.
So I think that's kind of interesting.
That is, and I didn't know they had names.
Israel and Jericho.
Yeah, yeah, they've named them.
So some of the sources indicate that.
I thought they called, like, after the columns, like Yaquim and Boaz, like the columns in
front of the temple.
Solomon's Temple, yeah.
Well, see, they name everything because it's the same as Solomon's Temple.
They did the same here with the two trumpets.
So all of this, by the way, this lamp here, this would be around fourth century.
So once again, it was made after the temple destruction to remind the people of the artifacts,
the utensils used in the temple.
That's what this was as a remembrance.
Yeah.
And once again, it's going to be, basically, it was made during the Byzantine period.
Yeah.
I didn't pull up some of my oil lamps, but there's actually some of them that have a,
the way they're designed, you can see that one of the, it has, it looks like three Vs,
but the top one is the top lamp on the candlestick, and it's actually the wick.
It's the nozzle of the oil lamp itself that you light.
So it actually shows that one of those
lamps in the division is called, they're called candlestick lamps,
but it's a different design and they're Byzantine as well.
So the menorah is very important in, the menorah is very important in
iconology in the Byzantine period, right from the first century all the way through.
Now, that visit also brings up a point about, there was a debate among scholars,
critical scholars in the New Testament studies, that Jesus would teach in the synagogues.
And there were those that believed the first century, there were, I guess at one time,
at one time they believed that there were no synagogues.
Some critical scholars, not all, I said some,
believed that synagogues were not built until much later.
So if it mentioned the word synagogue, that Jesus would go to the synagogue,
it would be more like an acronym in the text.
But now we know that that's not necessarily the case.
However, when synagogues are built after the Jewish revolt,
after 70, we start to see menorahs also being displayed in the synagogues.
Now this one, I believe, now it was not found in situ, all right?
And it's a museum piece.
It's extremely rare.
This one's extremely rare.
And it's been displayed, and we talked about a number of different synagogues.
And one locally for maybe like five years.
And then it was sent back to the museum.
I just happened to have it.
And this is heavy.
This is really heavy.
So I'm going to try to attempt to show this to everybody.
You're going to turn off your background?
I don't know if I can drop it like this.
Can I?
Let me see if I can.
If not, you just lean back.
I think you'll be okay.
Wait a second.
No, I'll get it.
I'll get it.
What you're trying to say, I'm not that tech savvy, but there we go.
See how that is?
Also, when we look at synagogues, usually synagogues are made out of the local stone.
So if it's in Galilee or the Golan Heights, it's going to be usually basalt.
Now, if somebody's got money, then you might have limestone or a combination of two.
You go to, is it a Capernaum?
Capernaum, you have the foundation of the first century synagogue, possibly the one that Jesus
taught at.
And it was basalt.
And then you have the fourth and fifth century synagogue on top of that original base.
So the base is basalt, but the fourth century synagogue is limestone.
It's beautiful.
Absolutely beautiful.
But if we want an earlier synagogue, let's say earlier synagogue, one that is built
somewhere around the Golan Heights area.
Why?
Because the stone is basalt.
And basalt is basically volcanic lava.
Yeah.
It's not a very pretty stone and it's extremely heavy.
And remember, this is early in the morning and I'm 65.
So do you got your phone just in case you gotta dial 9-1-1?
I'm ready to go here.
This thing is heavy.
Let me see if I can angle this down a little bit so people can see this.
Oh, there you go.
So here's a rare opportunity.
Now, look, this is the menorah from a synagogue.
So this is probably fourth century.
So 1600 years old.
And it's cut away.
See, it's been cut away.
Yeah.
It was probably either the capital from a column or the base of a column.
And the column would sit on top.
Make sense?
Yeah.
All right.
And now look at, this is what we're talking about right here.
It has to have the base.
And this is actually from a synagogue, an ancient synagogue.
So everybody, if you couldn't see the lamp, this one,
a very rare opportunity to actually see a menorah from a synagogue.
Okay.
All right.
Well, it's time to go.
Thanks everybody for your time.
I appreciate it.
Doctor, thank you very much.
Everybody have a great day.
