La France abrite la 4ème forêt d'Europe avec 17 millions d'hectares, soit 31% de sa surface. Formidable réserve de biodiversité, la forêt est notre poumon vert. : c'est le 2ème puits de carbone après les océans. Mais notre forêt souffre. Elle est en danger, menacée par les effets du réchauffement climatique. Les sécheresses à répétition fragilisent les arbres, ralentissent leur croissance, la hausse des températures hivernales favorise le développement des insectes et parasites du bois, les incendies se multiplient... En 10 ans, la mortalité des arbres a augmenté de 80%, et la capacité de notre forêt à stocker du carbone a diminué de moitié. La forêt est affaiblie par le réchauffement climatique mais pas seulement. Aujourd'hui des pratiques forestières, comme la monoculture, sont remises en question, accusées de fragiliser la forêt. Les équipes de LCP sont allées sur le terrain auprès de celles et ceux qui chaque jour constatent le dépérissement de nos forêts, et qui cherchent des solutions pour enrayer le phénomène. Comment réinventer la forêt, la sauver pour qu'elle nous sauve ?
Un magazine de Marion Becker, Vincent Ferreira et Ilana Azencot
Chaque mois, LCP le Mag vous plonge dans l´application des lois, les grands dossiers d´actualité qui font débat à l´Assemblée nationale ou les coulisses des campagnes électorales.
[Music]
it is a precious asset our
green lung a
biodiversity reserve with its 17 million
hectares the French forest is an
essential link in the fight against
global warming it is the
second carbon sink after the
oceans but our forest
suffers
it is in danger threatened by the effects
of global warming by
repeated droughts and the speed
of these
upheavals in 10 years
tree mortality has increased by 80%. their
growth has slowed considerably and
the capacity of our forests to store carbon is
decreasing a
major challenge how to reinvent the forest
save it so that it saves us
[Music]
in the heart of the Côte d'Or north of
Dijon the domain of Jie a forest of
great being present here since the
last glaciation 10,000 years ago
so here it is here with our
colleagues that we still spotted
a lot of dieback on the massif
so that's why we wanted to tell you
[Music]
showin there are really a lot of
leaves missing at the top on the branches they
are all red they have really
suffered there and there are lots of
dead branches in the ha foot finally you can
see that it is not going to improve during the
season next what and less t
leaves less chance that it
will start again in
spring Lilian du banc and Brigitte
Musche are specialists in
climate change at the National
Forestry Office after another scorching summer
they come to see the
damage which is hard to to live it is
still that we see beings there
mainly who have been there for
generations of trees hundreds
of years well which were able to grow very well
here and there we see that it is no
longer possible what things really
started in 2018 but have only gotten
worse since the beings no
longer resist heatwaves and especially
repeated droughts the soil is so dry
that they no longer have enough water to
bring the sap up by their leaves we
see that in a few years it
only takes a few years for a tree
that took more than 100 years to grow to
die and there it is therefore the tree which dies
it is the welcome which could make
a certain number of species it is the
carbon that it was capable of storing
because a large tree like that you have to
imagine it with all its leaves it
can really capture carbon there there
it is almost capturing more and then
anyway when it dies it will
release this carbon we see that the wood
is, let's say, prey to the elements and
well it degrades and we will have
difficulty recycling it to make
furniture for example so it's really
finally it's more than a double penalty
it's a penalty for all the
roles that trees play
in the ecosystem and for us
humans too a hell of a cushy
plot almost all of the trees will
die and that's what's hard for us
is if there was a species well there
it is a species because there is a
particular disease but no there with
climate change drought
heatwave the whole entire ecosystem is
not adapted to this climate and that's what
we see the
consequences of which a few kilometers
further on another species is attacked the
spruce trees die one after the other
decimated in a few months by an
insect we see see that it is in progress
yeah h at the same time with the heat
which is there at the end of September the conditions
are met for them to
attack this insect ah there it is the
scolite there it has dug its gallery to
laying eggs is very small eh it's 2
mm long and then the Hop larvae which
feed by eating uh the part
of the wood which is just under the corns and
the small larvae are there all
white he all white so they
with the heat which still they
will continue their growth et cetera
and as winter it is no longer
cold enough to freeze them and
make them die they will attack
other spruces
next year look at the lar which falls
there it is completely infested and
why do the scolits develop
as much as that uh they are favored by
the temperatures and there they should not
be as active as that at the end of
September and the trees they are too
stressed they are no longer able to defend themselves
and so there it is There are really
few things we can
do, weakened by the drought, the
spruce trees no longer have enough resin to
defend themselves here again, the whole
plot will
die, we are very worried about the future,
we foresters because Well, we
see the trees that are
dying, finally every day with our
colleagues we are in the forest and what we
see is the attack of
climate change and from year to year it gets
worse. it's like a snowball
which grows and which
[Music]
grows the forest is weakened by
global warming but not
only today
forestry practices are called into question
accused of weakening the forest like
monoculture for economic reasons
to develop the wood industry and
make it profitable in certain regions
entire massifs have been planted with a
single
species when the trees of these
linear plantations reach
maturity they are all cut down at the same
time leaving the soil bare that's the
cut is what happened in
Morvent the problem it started in the
70s that's when exactly uh
the the state estimated that the
trade balance for the forest was in
deficit therefore encouraged to plant to
plant a lot of softwoods by
all means needed softwoods it was
necessary to make wood with softwoods
the material was for softwoods and
so little by little it was very
very quickly so there is a takeover
by the investors which was quite
terrible on the Morvant and the
Morvend owners no have not
exonerated of reproach they are
also eager to sell their forest Lucienne has been
a pioneer for 40 years she has been fighting
against the intensive exploitation of the
forest it is really a spectacle of
desolation which well there is a cut
of any population on the entire plot
we passed with the big machines it is
the very example of what is happening in
Morvent and elsewhere it is that in fact
there we cut down deciduous forests we
could very well have thinned out or done
something else cutting it should be
a final decision it is when we can no
longer do otherwise we make a
coupprince but not when we have other
solutions the one we
affectionately nicknamed Morvent became
the face of this fight to save the
traditional forest the representation of
what is a beautiful forest here when we
fought for the domain of my hand
me chain I immediately liked it what
they said is Lulu's chain
because this chain I first of all
say that my hundred games that it be
placed at the foot of this chain it is
magnificent and it is truly the symbol
of the fight for save the domain from
my hand it's my whole story
since my childhood they are not even here
the industrialists wanted to make the
forest of Montmain a monoculture of
pine trees let's imagine here this beauty of
the forest completely in raesin a
monoculture of douglasse it's is terrible
you have a forest there is nothing
living
underneath so Lucienne created the first
citizen forestry group of women
and men who come together to
buy the forest and manage it
sustainably together they were able to save this
area and you know the forest is
not
simply a product of it is not a
product of consumable wood in abundance the
forest is also for the soil the
quality of the soil for water it is very
linked to
biodiversity we say ah B yes,
climate change is sure
to exist, but the monocultures of
pica plants if the spruce trees had been
planted mixed with leafy plants and
everything, we wouldn't have to
clean up everything, I blame the
forest policy in place at the ministry
because to our elected officials because the laws
are voted by our deputies by our
senators and what are they doing
what are they doing until now
what is -what they do in the face of C
the climate impact what are we
trying to do to go uh to
limit this to 82 years its revolt and its
commitment remains
intact the ecologists have been fighting for
years against the monocultures and
couprase to allow forests
to better resist
climate change an idea which is starting to gain
ground among certain foresters
like here in
Nièvre we can look back on the past what
has been done, these are
plantations which date from between 40 and 60
years old yes then it's errors until
as long as it has the mortalities we did
n't say that it was errors because
it was a scheme that worked which
was profitable but today
obviously well there you go we know that we
are more correct so
it is important to take this into account and
then it is up to us to evolve now I
also recognize that the ecologists have
helped to evolve have participated in
changing mentalities it is a good
thing but today we are at a stage
where the Foresters have become
aware of certain things and the idea
is perhaps rather to be
in the discussion and in the exchanges
rather than systematically criticizing
everything Alexandre couvenant manages the forests
of small private owners on this
plot to cut down the 30 hectares of
poplar and
brakes the trees have almost all
died from drought or from a
calariosis fungus only the chains are
spared clear cutting is not a
choice that's it, it's
something that has been undergone, eh, but it's certain that we
would have preferred to do a
thinning cut, eh, because that's what we
normally do,
uh just to make
the most of it. the trees of the future and then
eventually harvest timber and
currently it is not possible
the intervention is too risky for the
loggers so Alexandre called on
a
feller it is a job which is very
dangerous when there is dry wood and
therefore we need robust B material
and even if we find that it is big but
it is the only way to be able to
exploit this type of
wood this wood should not have been harvested
that in 20 years it has lost all its
[Music]
value there are only the few
softwoods which will go to Syria but
it is really anecdotal otherwise the
brake will go into firewood and
the
poplar will be transformed either into
panel particle or
OSB possibly
paper faced with this situation Alexandre
is
helpless, although he diversifies his forests, he
works in an irregular manner with
several species of trees of
different sizes which harvest little by
little, they are still sick
today while wanting to do for the
better we are sure of nothing it's really
terrible what al to adapt it's a
certainty knowing which essence m with
certainty it's impossible so we're going to
do tests we're going to try to
believe it it's difficult yes or it's
sure it's difficult because
obviously we believe less in
what we do so we want to believe in it
but we know that as much as our
predecessors have, that's it. plant he did
n't ask the question and it went to the
end he worked in the forest as he knew how to
do it and it worked today well
even though we ask ourselves a lot of
questions we are sure of nothing we want to
do for the best we are sure you're welcome
so there it is it's very it's it's
it's not easy to
[Music]
live the sector no longer has the choice it
must adapt and find a balance
between economy and
[Music]
ecology in
Auvergne even the fir tree, although
endemic, no longer resists
climate change is happening very quickly
too quickly on the scale of
the tree Christian and Chantal have inherited
several small plots of
forest VO are still in the process of
dying there and it
actually gains dieback in fact this one
also it is
C advised by their
forestry cooperative on this plot of one
hectare the couple decided to cut down
all the diseased fir trees to
replant other
species there is
more far away there is Douglas fir so
leOM we see it he took it well
it's a Paris on
the future it's
a we n not an exact science that's it and
so we have to try we have to
innovate we have to mix it we must
use all the cultivation methods that
exist to know which one at a
given moment will come out on top and
will allow us to have a beautiful forest for
our
future generations on other plots of fir
C foresters of the cooperative have made
a choice different there is not a
solution there is not a single solution
when we arrive in front of a stand and
and and I was going to say we can propose
things to the
owners either in fact to harvest
because the owner is afraid for the
rest of his population and legitimately
is in fact to do a thinning
so the solution that we put in place
with the owner was to
harvest only the dry wood in the
hope that the fir trees that are there
can still continue to
progress a little little and then bet
a little bit of future on them despite
these are the effects that we know of
global warming we will have fewer
strains which will pump the water and therefore
those who are there we hope that they will
benefit from it the best possible it will
rain less but SS there are less of them
sharing the water we hope that it
will be a solution which will
allow them to get through the course after what we
also tried to do is to
keep as much as possible the mixture
of essences some essences that we had
as an accompaniment we favored them we
see we have a being a chînne a châignier
here perhaps it is perhaps this one
which will be an asset for the future on
this
plot in France 75% of the forest is
private and it is very
fragmented more than 2 million
owners own less than one
hectare no regulations are
imposed on them because below 25
hectares everyone manages their forest as he
wants he will have more needles we are
unfortunately in the owner period the
forest owner remains
completely in control of his house so we
offer things to the owners
as we have seen today but
we will never impose anything on him
therefore an owner who would like
to put a single species it is and that it
respects the regulations it would be
free to do so but it is no longer what
you currently advise it is
generally never what we advise
unless the plots are
really very small and in which case the
fact of putting several species
could really complicate the
future management of the
plot it also means that we stop
the
coupases we are not going to put an end to the
couppras regular smart is a
completely valid method of silviculture as
the irregular smart is a
completely valid method of silviculture and
as we have told you a lot
today we must not put all our
in the same basket so we are
certainly no longer going to do
harvest cutting on dozens and tens
of hectares like that could have been done at one
time that would undoubtedly be
bad advice to
forest owners SAU imp passe sylvicol due for
example to dying stands
but a stand which grows
normally we will support it and if
there are harvests to be made we will rather
divide our harvests than do it
over dozens and dozens
of hectares if the forest no longer manages to
adapt on its own how to
help it we find Brigitte the
geneticist from the ONF near
Dijon, we can see very clearly that he
had a problem and I even wonder if he
hasn't left again, he left since
the last rains, she is piloting the
Giono project, an assisted migration program
for scientists introduced
trees that did not grow
naturally here and so we recreated
strips in which we planted
we came so there are chains
but they are pubescent chains yes
it's stinking so that's it is small
chains pu lowering we can clearly see there there
are small hairs and these hairs there they
serve to
less less suffer the less lose
water here is less suffer the dry air so
it's really an interest it' is a
chain that comes from the south of
France from Provence and so
it's a really interesting track
for us here and for this species in
particular the pubaissant chain we have
done the migration well insist so
it's a species which is present in
the south of France and which was
brought here by human hand
with a warming if it
had been much much more
progressive it could have in several
thousand years tens of thousands
of years potentially
naturally reconquering the north of France but
that's not the case we submitted a project
they also planted cees Lebanon from
the forests of the
Luberon put back come on so we help
nature to do what it would have done
classically and We need to take
everything we know so far
from the science of the arts of
forestry and reinvent
something new to continue to have
a forest that provides all these ecosystem services.
ONF has also developed ios of the future
on small plots, it is testing
exotic species which were not
present in France until now,
on this one they planted calocèdre,
it is therefore a conifer which looks a
little bit like to a cypress or a tuyaa and it
is native it is native to the
west coast of the United States California and
which in original conditions shows
very good resistance to
drought while being in
altitude conditions has some snow,
winter, extreme cold, these are
species about which we do not
necessarily know much and which have not been
widely introduced in France and
Europe and therefore we need reference
both on the survival rate and on
growth on wild game and
resistance to
water stress there is no question of
playing the sorcerer's apprentice the species is
closely
monitored we potentially always have
a risk for biodiversity and that is
why we introduced these species
experimentally and we are going to
look at how it interacts with
the surrounding ecosystem and in particular
the problems of invasiveness which are the
major problem of exotic species.
Then we are not going to cover the forest with
caloframe but it is part of the
panel of species that we will be able to propose
on a slightly larger scale than half a
hectare in a few
forests between the
decline and the new species
in 50 years the face of our forests will
evolve our landscapes will change but
if we have, as we plan, a me TER
anization of the forest further to the north
eh we are going to have a
Mediterranean forest so trees which
are going to be smaller too so we
really have to expect
smaller trees and less wood production
far from this forest of the future
in Morvent Lucienne and her
association also try in their own way to
preserve the forest and its biodiversity
good Lucienne you find it how your
forest finds the stumps beautiful look
if it's beautiful it doesn't hinder exploitation
and what's more it's is the wonderful biodiversity
what in 20 years Lucienne and the
forestry group have bought 20 forests 350ar in
total which they entrusted to
tristus the expert manages and exploits the
trees because the forest is not under cover
it also has a role
look we then here we apply a so-
called irregular smart treatment it is
in fact it is a forest management which
must respond to economic
and ecological interests so we seek to have
on this forest different species
maintaining the species which are
present in particular the H the chin there is
work there is a little softwood and
we are looking to have a structure of the
population that is to say small trees
medium large and very large
trees so economically of course if
it is viable it can bring in - be less
money in the beginning but
gradually it will bring in money
and that is a model that is
transposable so for us it is a model
that we try to transpose to all
forests in France it's
maritime bread it's fir it's it's it's
oak not long ago for them
it's the only way to have
more resilient forests in the face of
climate change they would like this model to
become the norm and I frankly, I
'm amazed to see the result and
I'm glad to have participated in that,
what I say to myself, but you didn't waste your
time when you fought, you have to send
a message that's still optimistic
because if we start saying everything is
ruined the forest is starting to get sick
the ares are all sick the plantations it's
not clear if they're going to hold up or not B it's
still pretty terrible we ca
n't do without the forest it's not
possible but if the G says in 50 years
temperature increase of 4
degrees whether it is softwood whether it is
hardwood my opinion there will be more
weapons that is clear but then it is
terrible to think that because
future generations, children and everything,
but how can we live in
a sterile world? I don't want to believe it.
I say that all
together we can move forward. What I say is
that we have to do as little harm as possible
[Music]
here is helping the forest to regenerate by
itself to adapt
genetically preserving its soil its
diversity of species and therefore its
biodiversity so many challenges to save
the forest so that it continues to
store carbon and remains our green lung