"Socrates has been charged by the citizens of Athens of impiety, of corrupting the youth, and in preparation he must go to the porch of the King Archon. There he meets his friend, Euthyphro, and they converse about the serious charges filed against Socrates, and the serious charges Euthyphro intends against, surprisingly, his very own father. Socrates senses that his friend has little idea of the consequences of this action, and that his youthful haste may lead to a miserable and penurious future, and that his friend has pondered little of this drastic action.
The dilemma faced in life when our child or relative or friend is going seriously astray is, How do you tell them? How can you get through to them? Simply shouting, STOP, YOU FOOL, usually does not work, this usually only swells their pigged head. You so wish you could them to think through what they are planning to do a little bit more carefully.
Getting people to think through the problems they face in life is the purpose of Socratic dialogue, indeed this is what make moral philosophy and theology meaningful. Rarely do people listen, rarely does Socratic dialogue work, and more often than not, Plato’s dialogues are failed Socratic dialogues.
We will compare and contrast Euthyphro’s story to a recent story of a family whose father engaged in violent insurrection in the nation’s Capitol, neither of whom listened to reason. But in the end, we cannot be sure what the proper answer is for Euthyphro."
Today, we will learn and reflect on Plato's dialogue, Euthyphro, which is a story of a
young man who refused to listen to Socrates, and this is compared to a similar, recent
story of a family who was divided by actions taken in the recent capital riots.
You may ask, how can we benefit when we ponder the Platonic dialogue of Euthyphro?
This dialogue discusses a young man with strong convictions that is convinced that he is absolutely
morally in the right with what he plans to do, but what he plans to do will greatly harm
his father and his family's reputation, and he refuses to listen to the cautions offered
by Socrates.
This play is, in essence, a warning to us that we should carefully consider the difficult
decisions that all of us face during our lives.
We always like to quote from the works we are discussing.
At the end of our talk, we will discuss the sources used for this video, and my blogs
that cover this topic, please.
We welcome interesting questions in the comments and in the description.
Sometimes these generate short videos of their own.
Let us learn and reflect together.
Socrates in his trial has been charged by the citizens of Athens of impiety and of corrupting
the youth, and in preparation, he must meet with the court officials in downtown Athens.
There at the court, he meets his friend, Euthyphro, and they converse both about the serious charges
filed against Socrates and the serious charge of murder Euthyphro intends to file in court
against, surprisingly, his very own father.
His father's slave had murdered another slave, so the father had bound up this murderous
slave and thrown him in a ditch while he searched for a diviner with whom to consult on how
he should punish this slave, and after a day or two in the ditch, this slave died.
Socrates senses that his friend has little idea of the consequences of his action, and
in his youthful haste, he may make a decision that would lead to a miserable and penurous
future, and that his friend has pondered little of this drastic action.
Meanwhile, the friends and students of Socrates were upset that he spent so much time conversing
with Euthyphro when he should have been working on his speech for the jury, but Socrates simply
said that this dialogue with Euthyphro was preparation for his trial, as was all his
philosophical arguments up to that moment.
The dilemma all of us face in life when our child or relative or friend is going seriously
astray is how do you tell them?
How do you get through to them?
Simply shouting, stop, you fool, usually doesn't work, so you wish you could get them to stop
and think through what they are planning to do a little bit more carefully.
A very similar story happened to a family that was torn apart because the dad participated
in the insurrection during the Capitol riots on January 6th, where there were many ugly
words and threats.
After the riot, the FBI printed pictures of many ordinary citizens they wanted to arrest
because they participated in the mayhem that caused the death of both police and at least
one protester.
Most of these insurrectionists had no prior criminal record, although a few did.
Quoting from People Magazine, but I'm leaving out the last names,
Like much of America, young Jackson watched the January 6th U.S. Capitol riot unfold on
TV in horror, but he was more horrified than most people.
I think it was Fox playing.
They were live screening the riots at the Capitol and rushing in.
My mom said, your dad is there.
As federal authorities later began to comb through videos and online postings to identify
those who breached the building, Jackson reported his father's presence at the event
to the FBI and shared an earlier statement made by his father, warning him,
If you turn me in, son, you're a traitor and you know what happened to traitors.
Traitors get shot.
And Jackson said, if you were to write down that quote and give it to anyone ever, it
would never be okay.
He said to the reporter, my father said, choose a side, choose a side or die.
Returning to Euthyphro, Socrates decides he must try to persuade Euthyphro.
He proceeds his efforts with patience, with kindness, avoiding criticism, avoiding lecturing.
He compliments when he can.
When reading the Platonic dialogues, we must avoid jumping to obvious conclusions.
Sometimes there is no right answer.
Perhaps Euthyphro was right in his decision.
We will discuss this possibility at the end of our discussion.
So, Socrates addresses Euthyphro, Socrates, By the powers, Euthyphro, how little does
the common herd know of the nature of right and truth.
A man must be an extraordinary man and have made great strides in wisdom before he can
have seen his way to this.
And Euthyphro, Indeed, Socrates, he must have made great strides.
Socrates says, I suppose that the man your father murdered was one of your relatives.
If he had been a stranger, you would have never thought of prosecuting him.
And Euthyphro says, Well, I am amused, Socrates, that you are making a distinction between
one who is a relation and one who is not a relation.
For surely the pollution is the same in either case.
If you knowingly associate with a murderer when you ought to clear yourself by proceeding
against him, the real question is whether the murdered man has been justly slain.
So Socrates thinks that the real question is not whether the murdered man has been justly
slain.
We immediately doubt the chances of success by how condescendingly Euthyphro responds.
I am amused, Socrates.
Surely the gods in the audience suspect already that he is guilty of arrogance and hubris.
The case against his father is fairly weak according to the standards of ancient justice.
A field laborer quarreled with and killed a domestic servant and his father bound him
hand and foot in chains and threw him in a ditch while he sent for a diviner to tell
him what to do.
And while waiting, the guy in the ditch died of cold and hunger and chains, as Euthyphro
puts it.
Socrates does not argue the guilt of the father, that the father bears guilt is understood
and unquestioned.
But what about the decision of the loving son?
We must all make difficult decisions in life, whether we should divorce an unfaithful spouse,
whether we should help out a wayward grown son one more time, and whether to place an
aging parent in a nursing home or not.
In these decisions, motives matter.
Equally virtuous people can make different decisions in very similar circumstances, and
the opposing decisions could be both moral decisions.
What matters most when we make these difficult and often life-changing decisions is how we
make these decisions, whether our motives are pure, whether we use proper moral criteria.
What decision we make is critically important, of course, but this is a private matter between
ourselves and Jesus, and others should resist the temptation to judge us.
So what's going on here?
The ancient world is not our modern world in more ancient times.
In ancient Athens, judicial cases were heard in front of juries of 500 Athenians.
There were no rules of evidence.
These cases were public debates at fixed times.
The mob decides.
His father could be exiled or executed.
There were no prison sentences.
There were no prisons.
What would happen to his mother, to his siblings, to their servants?
What is absolutely certain is we do not know everything.
The Son is only telling us what he chooses to tell us.
The Son is impetuous.
That we know.
We can surmise that his father is impetuous.
He is probably guilty of the same faults he finds in his father.
What sort of quarrels has he been having with his father?
Were there hurts for which he seeks revenge?
So Socrates dangles the bait.
Good heavens, Euthyphro!
And you have such a precise knowledge of piety and impiety, and of divine things in general,
that supposing the circumstances to be as you state, you are not afraid that you, too,
may be doing an impious thing and bringing an action against your father.
And Euthyphro responds.
The best of Euthyphro, and that which distinguishes him, Socrates, from other men, is his exact
knowledge of all these matters.
What should I be good for without that?
And the fish bobs a line, and Socrates then tries to set the hook.
So he asks his friend, Euthyphro, exactly what is piety and what is impiety.
The first definition that Euthyphro offers is piety by example, since he knows that what
he is doing is pious.
It serves as a good example of piety, so why bother with definitions?
Besides, we all know that Zeus himself bound up his father Cronos because he wickedly devoured
his sons and punished others in his family, too.
So Zeus can be impious, why not I?
So Socrates succeeds in getting Euthyphro to admit that the gods in Mount Olympus fought
and cheated with each other like men who are immortal, and that examples of piety do not
tell us what makes all things to be pious.
For an example of the immortal Greek gods behaving badly, all ancient Greeks would have
heard the story of the War of Troy recited dozens of times at religious festivals, and
that we hear about in the Iliad and the Odyssey.
First Zeus allowed Paris, Prince of Troy, to select his choice for the most beautiful
goddess, and he chose Aphrodite when she promised him the hand of the most beautiful woman in
the world, Helen, who was, unfortunately, the wife of the Achaean king Menelaus.
But that didn't bother them.
The goddess Aphrodite then put into motion the actions that resulted in the Trojan War
by helping Paris kidnap Helen, and he brought her to Troy to be his bride, and thus condemned
to death many Greeks and Trojans, and caused the sacking of his city Troy, and all of this
for what?
Just for passing passionate pleasures for just one man, Paris.
Returning to the dialogue, when he's pressed for a definition rather than examples by Socrates,
all Euthyphro can answer is that piety is that which is dear to the gods, and impiety
is that which is not dear to them.
He's pressed further, and Euthyphro said that he believes that all the gods would agree
that murderers should be punished.
Socrates reminds him that his father's victim was himself a murderer in chains awaiting
judgment, but that the crime was that he was not treated humanely, and he asks him, how
can he be so sure that all the gods would be unanimous in their praise of his prosecution?
Right about now, Euthyphro is probably asking himself, what sort of friend is this Socrates?
I'm looking for agreement and affirmation, and all I get is arguments?
Euthyphro complains, our arguments, wherever they stand, seem to turn around and walk away,
so like many, Socrates frustrates me.
This dialogue is significant because Socrates would later be condemned to death, and be
forced to drink the deadly hemlock, for impiety towards the gods, and for misleading the youth
of Athens.
Socrates then notes that if they were going to work that definition, they could say that
something would be pious if all the gods saw it as pious, and something would be impious
if all the gods thought that, but that most of the life in the middle would be muddled,
which leads to an important question, do the gods love that which is holy, or is things
holy because they are loved by the gods?
You might think this is a valid question for the ancient Greeks, but it is not an issue
for Christians.
Don't we believe that God is love?
But as the dialogue demonstrates, whether we seek to employ God to serve our own selfish
egos and interests is as much of a moral problem today as it ever was.
So what is Christianity?
That we should love God with all of our heart, with all of our soul, with all of our mind,
with all of our strengths, and we should love our neighbors as ourselves, which is a definition
of piety that dwarfs Euthyphro's lame attempts, and when we keep this in mind, when we gaze
on the face of Jesus never turning away, this selfless love is the lens through which
we should see life.
When we turn away from this two-fold love, our personal morality is nothing more than
an alternative truth of deception.
And going back to the dialogue, there is more back and forth, and Euthyphro tries another
definition.
Piety or holiness could be the justice that attends to the gods, rather than the part
of justice that attends to man.
And Socrates asks,
That is like saying horsemanship is tending to horses, and that being a huntsman is tending
to his hunting dogs, and that being an ox-herd is tending to the oxen.
Likewise, is holiness the art of attending to the gods?
So life is like us bargaining with God, saying, God, let's make a deal, I'll be good, you
make my life easy.
However, leading a godly life does not guarantee that life will be fair, nor does it guarantee
that we will not suffer needlessly.
If you lead a godly life, sometimes you will be happy, sometimes not.
So beware, if you fancy yourself a devout Christian, you may think you are trying to
please God.
But how do you know that you are really striving to please the person in the pew next to you?
So after more back and forth, Socrates asks Euthyphro,
Does your piety or holiness, your attending to the gods, benefit or improve the gods?
Do your holy acts make any of the gods better?
Of the manly and fair actions of the gods, which is the chief and principal one?
Euthyphro says to Socrates, I have told you already, Socrates, that to learn all these
things accurately is very tiresome.
Let me simply say that piety is learning how to please the gods, in word and deed, by prayers
and sacrifices.
Tiresome, indeed, it is to learn how to lead a godly life.
Why do we need to learn such things?
Isn't it good enough just to get a good job, mow the lawn, and pay our taxes?
Why not just let the preachers learn such tiresome things?
They can preach to us, and we can ignore what we think is too hard from what they say.
But if God gave us the gift of consciousness, gave us the ability to worship God, God also
gave us the ability to ponder questions of right and wrong, gave us the ability to love
our god and our neighbor, who are we to deny these precious gifts and choose to live like
selfish beasts?
Socrates then asks Euthyphro many unsettling questions.
Is piety the science of asking and giving?
Is piety the right way of asking of them what we want?
And crassly, is piety an art which gods and men have of doing business with one another?
Socrates has done his best.
He gives up, so he ends the dialogue.
For, if you had certainly known the nature of piety and impiety, I am confident you would
never, on behalf of a serf, have charged your aged father with murder.
You would not have run at such a risk of doing wrong in the sight of the gods, and you would
have had too much respect for the opinions of men.
So he answers the question, how do you know?
How do you know what is right and wrong?
Do you start with what you think is right and wrong and shape your morality around that?
Or is there an independent right and wrong out there that you should measure yourself
against?
Do you start with your interpretation of this right and this wrong and shape your morality
around that?
How do you know your interpretation is an honest self-judgment, or merely self-justification?
How do you know?
Which is how I ended my blog, but that was then, and now is now, and after pondering
this further, maybe Yuthifro was morally correct.
Not only that, maybe this was a trap set by Plato.
Maybe he really agrees with me.
Maybe he described an extreme situation to test whether we have passed the Kantian test,
which is that we should act in a morally decisive manner when necessary, regardless of the consequences.
And after reading several modern slave autobiographies, this kind of swayed my opinion of Yuthifro.
Socrates was influenced, and Plato also, by the cultural norms of his times, and the ancient
Greeks had a rather low view of slaves and their worth in their basic humanity.
This can be seen by the discussion by Aristotle.
This slide is from our video on Slavery in the Ancient World.
Aristotle in his politics asserts this, the slave is a piece of property which is animate,
that slaves born into slavery are by nature slaves, and natural slaves are similar in
nature to tame animals.
He does not have an opinion of slaves or women or children.
The slave has no deliberate faculty at all.
The woman has, but it is without authority, and the child has, but it is immature.
This refusal to view slaves not as real people, but as basically talking livestock, with little
moral development or intellectual capability, is also seen in the slave autobiographies
that were published around the time of the Civil War.
For instance, Booker T. Washington in his Slave Autobiography states that white masters
regard their slaves merely as talking livestock.
Booker said that when his mother was purchased by his master, she was noticed just as much
as a newly purchased horse or cow would be noticed.
And W.E.B.
Du Bois in Black Reconstruction tells us this,
In the upper states, as much attention is paid to the breeding and growth of Negroes
as that of horses and mules, and that planters command their slave girls, married and unmarried,
to have children, and many of them are sold off if they don't have children.
Likewise, Frederick Douglass, the famous civil rights leader during the Civil War times.
It is a common custom in Maryland to part children from their mothers at an early age.
These slave owners were as quick to separate slave children from their parents as people
today give away puppies from the pet dog's litter.
So going back to the Euthyphro, tying a slave or his servant hand and foot, throwing him
in a ditch, then spending a day or two to consult with the diviner on what you should
do with the troublesome slave, leaving his slave to die from cold and hunger, this is
just sheer callousness.
This is cruelty.
This is murder.
And Euthyphro's father was a murderer, pure and simple.
Euthyphro's father cared nothing for the welfare of his slave, and we might add to
that list also possibly Plato and Socrates and Aristotle.
And as is observed in many of the slave autobiographies, slavery damages the soul of the slave owner.
Why indeed are we exhorted to love all of our neighbors as ourselves, no exceptions?
Well because it is impossible for us to split humanity in two, into this portion of humanity
that we will love, and that portion of humanity whom we will either hate or disregard.
Cruelty towards one corrupts our love for all.
So when pondering this dialogue of Euthyphro, we must remember that slavery, both in the
ancient world and the antebellum deep south, was a cruel institution, although there were
a few kind masters.
Slavery as an institution was cruel and uncaring wherever it existed.
So you might ask, what happened to the son of the capital rioter?
Well, People Magazine article says this.
Jackson says he has not spoken to his father since his arrest, but I wish I could, he told
the reporter.
I would say I'm sorry, because I don't feel like I put him in this situation, but I still
feel a little guilty.
But asked by the reporter if he'd do it again, he said, yes, I would do it again.
And a Politico article in March 2021 stated that the judge in the case denied bond for
the rioting father, concerned that he would commit further violence based on his prior
statements.
His family testified that they felt totally safe with their father.
They thought he got caught up in the Fox Newsiness of the situation.
But perhaps the judge was skeptical that his family would be safe if their father were
released because, well, how often do a father's children feel compelled to testify that they
really would feel safe if their father was released?
Perhaps this was also an issue with Euthyphro?
Quite likely this was an actual event.
If his father could be so cruel to his slave, well, the next question then is, was he guilty
of abusing a son, and possibly his mother also?
But men had much greater latitude in the ancient world to punish their slaves, their wives,
and their children as they saw fit.
So like all Socratic dialogues in Plato, the only sure statement possible is, nothing certain.
Who knows?
But let's ponder the two situations a bit further.
When we're exhorted to love our neighbor, when we're exhorted to honor our parents,
many Christians think that this means we should not do anything that will make our loved ones
angry.
But loving our neighbor and respecting our parents doesn't really mean that.
What it really means is that we should act in their best interest, that we should be
positive influences in their lives.
Perhaps the questions Jackson and his mother could ask themselves when they pondered whether
to turn in their father for insurrection is this, could this experience lead their
father to become a better person?
And if they did nothing, would this prevent their father from becoming a better person
as a result of this experience?
The same two questions could be asked by Socrates and Euthyphro, though their situation may
be a bit murkier and less certain.
And we want to discuss the sources that we used in this video.
Euthyphro is one of the shorter Platonic dialogues.
This translation by Benjamin Jowett is very readable.
And there are also some YouTube videos and a LibriVox video that narrate the entire dialogue,
which only takes about half an hour.
Please click on the link below for our blog on Euthyphro in the description.
And please click on the links for interesting videos on Socrates and other topics that will
broaden your knowledge and improve your soul.
Thank you.