Cocktails with a Curator: Rembrandt's Polish Rider

Vintage Visions
7 followers
Good evening, and welcome to the second episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
I am Xavier Salomon. I am the Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator at The Frick Collection.
And this evening I would like to talk about one of the most celebrated paintings at The Frick,
but also one of my favorites, Rembrandt's Polish Raiden.
This is a painting that was described by the English art historian Kenneth Clark
as one of the great poems of the world.
And I think this poetic quality of the painting is still something that's very haunting
and that very much touches us today.
Since we're traveling to Poland, I would like to pair this painting tonight
with a typically Polish drink, which is called szarlotka.
And a szarlotka is actually an apple pie in Polish,
but it also is this very typical drink that people love to have in Poland,
which is made out of two very simple ingredients, but you have to get the right ingredients.
One is Polish vodka, and the type of Polish vodka that has bison grass in it.
The only type of European bison that survives lives in a primeval forest,
which is also the last stretch of primeval forest in Europe,
a place called Białowieża, which is on the border between Poland and Belarus.
And it is an absolutely beautiful, wonderful, wild place.
And with the bison grass that comes from that area, they make this deliciously flavored vodka.
So you have to use that, and then you have to use freshly pressed apple juice or cider.
It's important to have the two right ingredients.
Mix them, have them chilled with a little bit of cinnamon.
Of course, if you're under 21 and you can't drink vodka, or if you don't want to drink vodka,
you can equally well have a delicious glass of apple cider with a little bit of cinnamon,
chilled, and it's really, really wonderful.
The Polish Rider is a very mysterious painting.
Haunting, beautiful, poetic.
We know very little about it or what it means.
It shows a young man on horseback.
He is set in a very strange landscape.
It's difficult to make out what time of day it is.
Is it dawn? Is it dusk? Is it day? Is it night?
Behind him, there are a series of buildings, a town, but you can make out very little of it.
There is a domed building at the top of the hill.
There is a tower below, a body of water, maybe a river, a lake,
a little group of figures you can just about make out near a fire in the very far distance.
But he is resolutely riding across the painting, across the landscape, towards the right.
But as he's doing that, he is pausing, he's stopping, he's looking not quite back,
but he's looking past us, out of the frame,
in this very puzzling way that has been interpreted in a number of different ways.
The man wears a Polish outfit.
The hat, the jacket he's wearing, a zupan, are typically Polish costumes from the seventeenth century.
And he is also fully armed.
He has a series of weapons.
There is a bow and arrow of a design influenced by Eastern prototypes
that was used very much in Poland in the period in the seventeenth century.
He has two sabers, one on the left, one on the right.
These are of a type known in Polish as a karabela.
And he holds in his right hand a nadziak, which is actually a strange weapon.
It's known as a horseman's pick or a war hammer.
And effectively, that's what it is.
It's a type of hammer that was used in combat by Polish military figures.
But it's also a weapon that was known in the seventeenth century in Poland
because in November of 1620,
there was an attempted murder on the king of Poland,
on Sigismund III, Waza.
And this drawing shows you the actual nadziak
that was used to try and kill the king.
The king survived.
The attempted murderer was captured and executed.
But this is a drawing in the castle in Warsaw that records that weapon.
And so this is a weapon that is very much part of Polish military
and also non-military history at the time.
Rembrandt painted this in the mid-1650s,
probably around 1655, 1656.
We don't know for sure.
Here he is as the great painter in 1652
in a self-portrait now in Vienna.
And by the 1650s, Rembrandt was a well-known artist in Amsterdam,
a wealthy artist with a large workshop
and a very large house with a collection of objects.
We know he collected costumes and weapons and shells
and various exotic objects.
But in 1656, Rembrandt goes bankrupt.
We know he is not very good at managing his money.
And his life suddenly changes.
1656 is this moment of rupture
where suddenly Rembrandt is destitute.
His house is sold.
Everything in it goes at auction.
And his life changes.
It changes dramatically.
And we don't know if the Polish Rider was painted
before this event or soon after,
but it is around that time.
And I think some of the doubtful figure in the painting
may be reflecting somehow Rembrandt's own situation
in those same years.
We don't know who Rembrandt painted the picture for.
We don't even know what he meant for it to represent.
But the Polish connection starts about a hundred years later,
when in 1791,
the Polish aristocrat Michał Oginski,
who you see here on the left,
travels to the Netherlands
and on his way back brings the Polish Rider to Poland
and offers it for sale to the King of Poland,
Stanisław August Poniatowski,
the last King of Poland,
who you see on the right in a very beautiful portrait
by the court artist Marcello Bacciarelli.
Stanisław invited to his court a number of foreign artists,
Bacciarelli from Rome,
but also the famous Bernardo Bellotto,
who came from Venice,
and started to create a very important art collection in Warsaw,
in the Royal Castle and in his other residences.
He was also a great collector of plants and orange trees.
Oginski offers the painting, curiously,
in exchange for orange trees,
because we know Oginski was building a country house
outside of Warsaw at that time,
and in exchange for the Rembrandt,
he asked for orange trees.
So Stanisław August becomes the owner of the Polish Rider
in Poland in 1791,
and he displays it together with other paintings in his collection,
including a number of other Rembrandts.
And these are two, for example, that he owned,
two beautiful, sort of fancy pictures
that are currently at the castle in Warsaw.
And so you have to imagine that the Polish Rider
entered a group of paintings, a collection,
that included other great masterpieces such as these.
The king decided to display the Polish Rider
in his favorite residence,
the house, the palace at Łazienki,
the so-called Palace on the Isle.
This is a palace that was enlarged and decorated by him,
and it's surrounded on all sides by water.
It's in the middle of a lake,
connected to the land by bridges,
and this is outside of Warsaw.
And the king kept the Polish Rider
in the anteroom to his private apartments,
on the upper floor of the house,
very close to his study and his bedroom.
And the painting remained there for four years.
These were very turbulent times for Poland.
In 1795, Poland effectively ceased to exist.
It is partitioned between Austria, Prussia, and Russia.
The king abdicates and moves to Russia,
where he will die three years later in 1798.
So the Rembrandt remains in the house,
but it's then sold to another family,
to another private collection.
This is Valeria Tarnowska, born Strojanowski,
and it is her father who acquires the painting.
But she first describes it in 1811 in her diaries
when she sees it at the Łazienki Palace
and falls in love with the painting.
Her father acquires the painting.
When he dies, it passes on to Valeria
and to her husband, Jan Felix Tarnowski.
And the Tarnowski family kept the painting
for four generations in their ancestral home,
Dzików in Galicia, in the southeast of Poland.
This is a photograph of Dzików in the late 19th century.
This is how the house was redecorated
in a sort of neo-Gothic style in the 1830s
by the Tarnowski family.
It is Valeria's great-great-grandson,
Zisław Tarnowski,
who you see here in this very beautiful portrait
by Jacek Malczewski,
one of the great artists of the early twentieth century
in Poland, a great portraitist.
And you have to think this is a painting
that's done soon after the First World War,
in the 1920s,
where the background still reflects
the damage of the war.
And you can see there are dead soldiers
and soldiers riding
and sort of wounded people in the background.
Zisław Tarnowski sells the painting in 1910
to Henry Clay Frick.
Frick buys it directly from Poland
through the advice of the art historian and critic
Roger Fry, the English art historian,
and brings it to New York.
Tarnowski sells it because at that point
this area of Galicia was under Austrian rule
and many Polish aristocrats
were heroically trying to buy back land
from the Germans, from the Austrians,
to keep as much Polish lands in Polish hands.
Of course, this is something that will end up
in tragedy with the First and Second World War.
Many of these lands will be lost.
But it is interesting to think that the Polish rider,
so deeply connected to Poland
and to the imaginary of a new nation
that didn't exist at that time,
actually lived in Poland through a century
where Poland didn't exist on a geographical map.
The Polish rider between 1791 and 1910
is effectively in a country that doesn't exist.
It's in Austria. It's in the Austrian Empire.
Warsaw is under Russian rule.
It's not in a country that gets recreated
at the end of the First World War in 1918.
Frick brings the picture to New York.
And, of course, over the last hundred years
the picture has been one of the great treasures
of the Frick Collection.
But what does this painting represent?
Who is this man who is riding
across this mysterious landscape?
Many theories have been put forward
and none of them has ever encountered
a full agreement from art historians
or the readers of these articles and books.
Is he a specific human being?
Is he a portrait of someone, a Polish man?
In which case the format would be somewhat strange.
Is this meant to represent a specific historical character,
a specific biblical character?
The names of King David and Nimrod
have been put forward, among many others.
Is he a theatrical figure?
Is he related to a number of plays
that were being performed in Amsterdam in the 1650s
and that Rembrandt may have responded to?
It's even been argued that it's actually not a man
and it's a woman dressed up as a man
as it appeared in one of these plays.
So the mystery as to the identity of this figure remains.
And did Rembrandt even think of it as a specific figure?
Is this just a fancy picture?
Is this just showing a beautiful youth
dressed in exotic outfit
going forward towards the unknown?
We don't know.
And the mystery remains
and it's a wonderful thing to think about.
But I think it's an appropriate thing to think about today
as we're all in this strange situation.
And what I love about this picture
is the sense of mystery
and the sense of facing the unknown.
And that's what we're doing right now.
We're in a world that is changing around us.
We don't know where we're going
and what will be happening.
And I feel a little bit like the Polish Rider
sort of going forward and yet looking back
and stopping and pausing and puzzling
as to what our future holds.
I am sure it will hold great things
and the world will be hopefully a better place in the future
and we will be out of this situation soon.
But the Polish Rider for me remains a symbol
of this moment in history
where we're stuck in uncertainty and doubt.
And I would like to finish with a quote
by Julius Held,
who wrote probably the most beautiful article
on this painting in 1944,
in the middle of the Second World War.
So he's thinking about this picture,
interestingly enough,
at a time of great changes
and great tragedies in human history.
And one of the things that Held writes
about this painting is a sort of description of it,
an ideal description.
And he says that this is a shining youth
who himself seems to be in search of something distant,
unmindful of things close and familiar,
still withhold from us, like another low and green,
the secret of his name.
So we don't know his name.
We don't know who he is.
And yet here he is,
surrounded by familiar and unfamiliar things
going ahead towards his future
in the same way that we go ahead towards our future.
I hope you've enjoyed looking at this picture with me,
and I hope you're enjoying your szarlotka.
And I look forward to seeing you all next Friday
for another Cocktails with a Curator.
Thank you.
