Debunking Dental Myths: Water Flossers Vs. Regular Floss With Dr. Gill - Vol. 2
In this video we look at homemade toothpaste, water flossers, fizzy drinks and tooth decay, and what to do about bleeding gums
Many things get banned around, such as dental opinions. Often you hear that people will make their own toothpaste. Is this a sensible idea? Is there any danger to it? And what might be the benefits of making your own toothpaste as opposed to buying that pre-prepared by, scientists, and learned individuals
In this video, Dr Gill joins Dr Alison Mace, a dentist, to dispel more of the dental myths
00:00 - Introduction 00:55 - Problems with Homemade Toothpaste 05:48 - Risks Dentists Face 06:56 - Do Water Flossers Work? 08:00 - Solutions to Bleeding Gums 10:01 - Adding Mouthwash to Water Flossers 11:02 - Effects of Fizzy Drinks on Teeth 14:02 - Impactful Food Types on Dental Health 14:57 - Does Chewing Gum Clean Your Teeth? 16:04 - Mental Health and Oral Health Connection 25:28 - How Often Should You Visit the Dentist? 26:29 - Final Thoughts
[Music]
hello and welcome back to the channel
we've been joined once again by Dr
Allison mace for
another Dental demystifier shall we say
that sounds like some kind of product
that you have in the corner producing
gas but I want to say thank you to all
the questions that you guys put on the
previous video it's provided us with
some really interesting things to delve
into I say we it's not myself that's had
to do the vast majority of the work here
so you know we're again relying on your
dental expertise so what which which
things sort of particularly peaked your
interest from people's questions um yeah
there was a really really good range of
questions that came through and I'm
really grateful to everyone who
commented and gave such positive
feedback on the last video um so there's
kind of a few questions that really
stood out as to um things that people
wanted to go through so one of them was
homemade toothpastes and if there's
actually benefit to sacking off the ones
you buy in the shop and making them
yourself at home now the question is
does she know what I've done in a
previous life let's let's have a chat
about what what your view is on
toothpaste first and then maybe we'll
see my side okay so um homemade
toothpaste they they've kind of been
around well they were the original
toothpaste before they started to get
mass produced um but there's lots of
recipes out there most of them have kind
of Three core ingredients so sodium
bicarbonate
um or like a bentonite clay um a
essential oil to make it taste nice and
then like coconut oil just to help kind
of bring it all together the bicarbonate
that's essentially the scrubbing bit
though isn't it yeah essentially yeah so
that's the main abrasive element which
is the thing that helps get the plaque
off your teeth um so there's loads of
different recipes to make it there was a
really good study that I found that was
done in 2021 okay um and it kind of
looked at 84 different homemade
toothpaste recipes I I I can't imagine
that you can manage to make 84 different
varieties of that I know yeah of the of
three ingredients essentially um and
essentially they looked at that and they
found that none of those toothpastes
contain fluoride which as we know from
the last video is really beneficial to
preventing tooth decay um and then only
20% of them contain some sort of foaming
agent which is really useful for
actually getting some of that plaque off
your teeth um so essentially what you're
getting is a kind of a flat
abrasive toothpaste almost like car
polish that sounds kind of yeah um that
has some essential oil and to take make
it taste nice um so the other issue with
them is that in store board toothpaste
you know exactly what you're getting
everything's been premixed measured out
to the nth degree and so you know that
everything in it is going to have some
sort of
benefit with the homemade ones because
it's you that's mixing it yourself at
home it might not be that way so if the
recipe says Heap te teaspoon my Heap
teaspoon might be different to your HEAP
teaspoon so you might end up with loads
and loads of bicarbonate which is the
abrasive ingredient and then not enough
of everything else so then you end up
scrubbing away more of that enamel of
your teeth than you should do which can
cause you more issues than benefit so
generally I'd ER on the side of caution
and recommend not to make your own
toothpaste at home and to to buy it from
the shop if for the sake of AR somebody
did um is there a you know a fluoride
supplement can buy that you could put
into your homemade um that's a good
question I don't know probably not I
imagine because it's the kind of thing
that I imagine that there's a bit of a
safety element of getting bulk yeah I
I'd be cautious with adding your own
fluoride into things because again it it
can have kind of negative impacts if the
concentration is too high the
concentration you get in store bought
toothpaste is completely safe for use
and is unlikely to cause any kind of
harmful effects especially if your teeth
are fully formed um but adding it in on
your own it sounds a bit dangerous risky
it's a little bit like sort of making
your own glow-in-the-dark clock there's
no problem with radiation until you're
trying to buy it from the shop then the
police tend to get involved yeah so what
did you do in a past life you're aware
that I had a bit bit of a an episode on
on an island yes yeah so out there we
were using uh toothbrushes that washed
up on the beach oh gosh um and we were
mixing our own toothpaste uh which was F
Ash a little bit of sand and some sea
water um hey at least we didn't get any
problems out there yeah I mean if you're
washed up on an island and the only
thing you have is some washed up
toothpaste and some ash then go for it
but if you have tesos next around the
corner or any other Super Market that's
your better option yeah I think
so I wouldn't recommend tasting fire Ash
no just don't really really
salty um so one of the reasons people
might go on to making their own
toothpaste at home is not because
they've been washed up on a desert
island but because they're trying to be
more environmentally friendly um and to
that I kind of say there are lots of
environmentally friendly options out
there now so there's lots of refillable
toothpaste lots of kind of toothpaste
Brands created by dentists that are
sustainable um which would be a better
route to look down than making it
yourself at home and just a quick Google
of it we we'll find you a whole load of
Brands the main thing is just making
sure it's got fluoride in apart from the
plastic tube is there a big
environmental impact from toothpaste um
I don't think so massively it is just
that tube but then you consider if
you've been using poor quality
toothpaste and then you've got tooth
decay from it and you need a filling
there's also an environmental impact of
that so prevention helps kind of prevent
that environmental burden too in terms
of the environmental burden just going
SL slightly sideways there was some
research I saw years ago that when you
know in theater we're using the dimy
there's a theoretical risk to the
surgeon with regard regard to Cancers
and things like that because essentially
it's volatile compounds being breathed
in is there any risk to dentists with
regard to grinding teeth and things like
that um so with teeth gring obviously we
always wear a mask things like that um
because a lot of it is we saw of Co with
the aerosol that's generated so
especially if um we're using like the
high-speed drill which puts out water
that is a risk to to the dentist if
they're not wearing a mask because you
can breathe in that aerosol which as we
all saw during Co that's got loads of
nasties in it which you don't want to
breathe in if possible um the other
interesting thing is Dental technicians
um when they're working with acrylics if
you breathe in the monomer that can be C
that can cause cancer as well okay that
makes
sense so what what else did you uh find
you know on the questions that people
forth that you really wanted to get
stuck into because obviously you've done
quite a bit of prep for today yeah so
another really interesting one was about
water flosses um and then if they're
actually good or not um so they are good
um there is there are studies to say
that they're actually better than using
normal floss um so if you've got kind of
reduced manual dexterity or if you don't
really like normal floss water flosses
are a really good
alternative to getting rid of that
plaque between your teeth so thumbs up
for the water flosses so is there any
problems you know for example you've got
a filling or stuff like that because um
current if I'm wrong but the white ones
are chemically bonded but the metal ones
are friction bonded is there any risk
with a water flosser there um if it's a
well done filling you shouldn't be able
to force it out with the water flosser
um it would be kind of the same with
floss if it was loose anyway okay then
you could potentially flick it
out but if it's well done it's not going
to come out with a l jet of water fair
enough so I'm I'm confusing my water
pick with my car wash okay
yeah um yeah so that's kind of it with
the water flosses um another thing that
was raised is kind of what should I do
if my gums are bleeding um which is
something I hear really commonly um
because I mean I don't know about you
but if my first reaction without being a
dentist was I brush my teeth and my gums
bled I probably wouldn't brush my teeth
I don't know what you'd do but um so my
viewpoint is blood should be inside if
it's outside I probably want to talk to
somebody quickly yeah yeah so if your
gums are bleeding it's a sign that
they're inflamed like I said before
you've got that plaque that sits on the
teeth um and that's all the bacteria
that's there um in a similar way to if
you get a cut and there's something
stuck in it on your body um what can
happen is when that plaque sits on your
teeth your body thinks or your body
knows it's something that's there that
shouldn't be there but it can't get rid
of it so it's way to try and get rid of
it same so if you had a cup and there's
something stuck in it it gets
inflamed and so then it's more likely to
bleed what you need to do at home is
brush all that plaque away so really
brush brush your teeth um because the
bleeding is a sign you've got something
called gingervitis which is kind
of very early stage reversible gum
disease um so if you're brushing your
teeth properly what you'll find is that
brush the areas that are bleeding more
because that's obviously the areas that
need it more and then after about a week
if you've been brushing right the
bleeding should settle down okay that FS
yeah if it's not settled down then see
your dentist because it may be that
you've got slightly worse gum disease
called parodontitis which is kind of a
more serious condition and can lead to
tooth loss if it's not treated okay
makes sense now that actually gives me
another thought this is one of the
things with doctors we are specialists
in our particular area so for example I
don't know a huge amount about
neurosurgery because I'm just a GP and
thus if I have a a think about
neurosurgery I could be very wrong I
don't know anything about Dentistry so
connecting the two bits you just said
someone's got gavitas gingervitis
gingervitis
um why not put mouthwash in your water
pick yeah you absolutely could do you
could blast it off with that could you
yeah you absolutely could do M put
mouthwash in your water pick um what the
mouthwash that's particularly good for
that is cdil or any kind of chlorexidine
based mouth wash um and then you can put
it between your teeth which can get to
the areas that you can't brush so it's a
really good idea to put that in there um
the only issue with chlorexidine as an
ingredient is it can cause staining of
your teeth sometimes um so just being
cautious with that but now in terms of
staining of the teeth is that staining
of the teeth like coffee where you know
we can adjust it or is it staining of
the teeth like doxycycl where bad luck
Chief you're stuck with that uh it's
very much more like the coffee side of
things so um if you see a dentist which
you probably should be doing anyway if
your gums are bleeding they can easily
clean that off that's that's not an
issue yeah so something that was asked
previously actually I think is quite
important we we
consume significant quantities of fizzy
stuff in our house um to the degree that
we've gone and got you know a a a soda
stream thing is it that the carbon
dioxide making it fizzy is the bad for
my teeth or is it the orange flavored
syrup that you know we're sticking in to
sort of make faux fanter and things like
that that causes the problem yeah so
it's a little bit of both to be honest
unfortunately yeah so we'll start with
kind of the syrups and then we'll move
on to the the CO2 that's added in so
with the syrups again they're kind of
sugar based so every time you drink that
fizzy drink you're adding kind of that
sugar into your mouth um and as we kind
of said last time the frequency that
you're kind of consuming sugary things
with is what really adds to the burden
of tooth decay um because if you're
constantly sipping on things you're
constantly feeding the bacteria that
sits on your mouth in that plaque and
they're constantly producing the acids
they're constantly eating away at your
teeth it's kind of like if you keep
feeding them they're going to keep
producing the thing that eats away at
your teeth to be fair I mean it's
perhaps just a little bit too personal
for a second but I recently went on a
hot chocolate binge I was stressed all
right sue me um but I I was very aware
of the change in my teeth during the
days where I was having a lunchtime hot
chocolate as opposed to just having
lunch as well and it it's it's actually
something I've stopped doing because I
didn't like the feeling of it yeah so
having it with your lunch is actually
the best thing to do if you do want to
kind of drink a lot of fizzy drinks or
any kind of sugary drinks having them
with a meal is the best thing to do
because then you're already getting that
kind of I I don't want to say insult
from the food but the hit from the food
yeah um so if you want to have a sugary
drink have it with a meal it's when
you're sipping on it constantly between
the meals that it's the issue so hot
chocolate with lunch sounds great yeah I
think there was more hot chocolate and
less lunch I think that was the problem
fair enough um yeah then moving on to
the second bit of things with the the
CO2 so you might think okay I'll go for
the sugar sugar-free syrups and just
have the fizzy
pit again that can cause some issues in
terms of the actual acidity of the
carbon dioxide that you add in um so
again if you're sipping on it constantly
that acidity from the fizzy drink will
wear away at that enamel and then that
will end up reducing the amount of
enamel that's there and then increasing
your risk of things like sensitivity
and once the enamel is gone you can't
put it back that was going to be my
follow-up question I said with hope okay
fair enough yeah so this is essentially
sort of going back to that thing you do
at secondary school where you put a
penny in the Coke and just leave it and
it sort of slowly dissolves over time
isn't it most I thought it was more to
do with the the syrup in it but yeah it
makes sense that the CO2 side of it is
going to have that effect as well yeah
so yeah unfortunately with a meal great
but if you're sipping on it throughout
the day maybe rethink okay that so in
terms of meals and things like that is
there one particular food type that you
think oh from a either a texture
perspective is rubbing the enal or a pH
perspective or a sugar thing it's like
this is the worst thing you can think of
to
eat um there's nothing that I can think
of as particularly the worst thing but
things kind that have bad
characteristics are really sticky things
so things that will stay stuck on your
teeth kind of keep producing that sugar
so things like sticky caramels that will
just coat your teeth and they get stuck
in all of the cracks you can't really
get rid of it all yeah they're they're
not great yeah to be fair I don't I as I
say that that whole sticky sensation
doesn't go down too well anyway so at
least I'm not a risk of that one yeah
but if you want to kind of help things
out after a meal as well or if you're
looking to kind of chew on something
throughout the day that's not harmful
chewing gum is a really good alternative
so sometimes you see that they advertise
chewing gum with sort of teeth whitening
and sparkled dust and all the rest of it
is that just PR or do you think there's
any benefit to it um I can't say about
the whitening ones because I haven't
looked too much into it but the actual
theory behind the chewing gum is that it
stimulat saliva flow and because of the
motion of just chewing something will
stimulate that and that will help remove
some plaque from your teeth because
saliva helps neutralize things and it
helps with kind of the mechanical
removal of plaque um so so long as
you're eating a sugar free chewing gum
that's absolutely fine does anybody
still make a sugar chewing gum there
there are a couple like yeah I mean that
that sounds just so daff he says
thinking about the bag of harrybo has
got in his car so you know why why am I
opposed to sugar in this but not sugary
food I don't know but just seems a
strange one yeah yeah chewing gum is
pretty good okay yeah I have to go pick
up some to wash away the har afterwards
other other sweets are available
um yeah and then the the last point that
was the last question was asked was um
about the link between mental health and
oral health which I think is a really
good thing to go into but it will come
with a little bit of a trigger warning
just in case anyone is does kind of want
to skip past this bit um be covering
things like eating disorders things like
that um so a really interesting piece of
research that I found was people with
severe mental health issues um about
three times more likely to lose all
their teeth compared to someone without
mental health issues there's kind of two
factors that play into causing that um
so the first one being things that we as
doctors do being the medications in that
a lot of the medications have the side
effect of dry mouth oh and then because
you don't have that saliva you can't
then wash away a lot of that the plaque
that's on there and you can't neutralize
things as well I'd honestly never
thought about that I mean obviously when
a patient talks to me for example if
they're using amitryptiline dry mouth's
quite common and I say you know oh dear
dear and try and look at alternative
medications things that don't have it
but I'd always consider dry mouth to be
an unpleasant side effect rather than a
harmful side effect that's a real
learning point for me today yeah so dry
mouth it doesn't just happen for
medication side effects it can happen
from loads of different causes I'm sure
you know but it could be really harm not
harmful it can be really unpleasant for
people because your sver helps you with
talking and it helps you with swallowing
things and to wake up in the morning
with like a desert dry mouth is awful
and if you think about on your hot
chocolate binge when you had that kind
of horrible feeling on your teeth it's
much much worse for someone with dry
mouth because you've constantly got you
can't clear away a lot of the plaque
that's there so you get that fuzzy
feeling kind of instantly and you can't
clear it away um things you can do to
help with the dry mouth kind of frequent
sips of water again that comes back to
the fizzy drinks thing make sure it is
just water don't be sipping on squash
because then that'll increase your risk
of Decay uh chewing gum again really
helpful so long as it's sugar- free um
and you can get some saliva substitutes
but they come with mixed
reviews um and the other thing that kind
of leads to the increase kind of risk of
losing your teeth is more of the social
side of things that come with mental
health
problems um so I know a lot of people
when their mental health is getting bad
the first thing that goes is brushing
their teeth because if you're if you're
out of
whack you don't have time to do or you
don't have the motivation I think that's
that that's the point there you said
motivation and that's why sometimes when
we got severe mental health problems
even mild mental health things it's just
what if you've so I've had it described
to me as the the the teaspoon uh
approach if you've only got five
teaspoons in your you know jar to give
out today what are you going to pass and
actually you know hygiene teeth and
things are very easy ones not to let
slip but to say I don't have the energy
for that today yeah absolutely and I
think that's really important to kind of
acknowledge especially as dentists as
well that it's not as much as we like it
to be everyone's priority it's not going
to be and realistically if someone
doesn't have the motivation to brush for
2 minutes a day it's about finding kind
of Alternatives that maybe need less
spoons I was literally going to ask that
so I'm having a bad mental health flare
I can't get out of bed all
weekend what is the minimum that I can
get away with to protect my teeth yeah
so mouthwash is really good for that um
going back to the last video kind of the
claw Heine ones are the better ones so
like coril things like that they are
better for reducing kind of that burden
on your teeth they won't remove the
plaque that's there but they can stop it
getting
worse um also if you don't have the
motivation to brush your teeth for two
minutes even just a quick pass around
with a toothbrush is better than nothing
it's doing something a little bit is
better than not doing it at all um and
then again chewing gum if you really
don't have the motivation to get out of
bed keep some sugar free mint flavored
gum next to your bed and at least
that'll help freshen things up a little
bit as well okay that makes sense cuz
that's one of the reasons why I work so
hard with the mental health patients
that we have because it's not just a
case of I'm feeling low or down it has
this overarching impact on the entirety
of your life and from my perspective my
teeth aren't actually I say aren't
actually my teeth are actually very bad
but that's to do with childhood issues
um you know I know
how um What's the phrase I'm looking for
self-conscious I am about my own teeth
and how they look and things like that
and I can see very clearly how a mental
mental health insult leading to you not
looking after your teeth leading to an
intervention by a dentist um would then
result in actually worsening of the
mental health so I you know it's if I
could pay somebody to take out all the
metal stuff without it causing a
additional damage I would do in a
heartbeat but I know that doing that
would still damage the remaining healthy
teeth so I have you know keep things as
they are and that makes a lot of sense
yeah and I think with with kind of the M
heal side as well is that your teeth can
have such an impact on your quality of
life and that if you're recovering from
a severe about of a mental health issue
and then you know afterwards your teeth
aren't great it can really kind of play
into your self-esteem
MH really make you struggle with things
so it's about kind of trying your best
to prevent that happening but also I
completely understand that it's not
necessarily something you have any
control over well I presume it's also an
additional hurdle to going to Senor
dentist I imagine that somebody coming
to see me as a a doctor a lot of it can
be done at arms length or even if I'm
listening to your chest it's relatively
non-invasive but to have somebody going
and poking around in your mouth you know
is just about as invasive as you can get
without having being a
gastroenterologist you know it it's so
very in there yeah it is kind of one of
the most personal things that you can
have done because yeah like you say when
you have any other bit of your body
examined you can kind of distance
yourself a little bit but as dentists we
have to look inside your mouth to be
able to diagnose things so it's if
you're anxious anyway it can add a whole
of a layer of it and especially with
dental anxiety it's a really huge thing
and it can be a real barrier to people
accessing accessing dentists now I'm
really really lucky with my NHS dentist
um he's known me for a couple of years
now and he we have a good enough
relationship that I'm happy for him to
poke a little bit of fun at me but he he
will make a comment about that Dental
anxiety I grip the sides of the chair
the minute I lie down you know it's you
know I am rigid whilst I'm in there and
I'm don't think there's many things that
properly unsettle me I
am not the best person to be around just
before I go to the dentist yeah that's
fair enough but but you know he cares
for me fantastically and you know I
would Champion him until the cows come
home just getting over that hurdle every
time yeah I think that's the same with a
lot of people is that it's just it's not
a hugely Pleasant thing to have done is
going to see the dentist one one thing
that I find does help some people is
bringing headphones with them um because
then you can try and close your eyes and
listen to music and let them get on with
their job and then they'll tap you when
they're done interesting I might suggest
that because again we've had a couple of
patients that are very anxious and
sometimes it's bizarre how as a GP I get
involved in the dental side of things
like there's a dentist very close to us
and some patients it's like fine they'll
comeing we'll give them the da of Pam so
then they can go around to the dentist
and things and it's you know it's
shocking
how we don't actually bother about our
teeth until they're bothering us and
then they seem to have this massive
ability to weigh on our lives yeah
absolutely they they're the type of
thing that a lot of people would rather
forget about until they get an issue but
then the issues can be so awful in the
sense of toothache is so all
consuming you just want it gone but I
imagine that must make some parts of
your job very very satisfying because
you can if push comes to shove you can
take the tooth and remove that pain you
know if somebody's having difficulty
eating you can give them back that Joy
of food by you know dentures and things
like that so it must be quite fulfilling
at times yeah absolutely I did find some
of the most kind of fulfilling patients
I saw when I was in general practice
were the toothache ones you'd come in in
pain and then in the space of 20 minutes
you can fix their pain and suddenly
their quality of life is so much better
and just being able to have the skills
to do that
is a really special thing that makes
sense that makes
sense yeah I think that's kind of come
to the list the end of the list of um
the questions that people have asked
well I think that's probably a
relatively upbeat positive point to end
it on you know not only seeing the
benefits that you know our dentists
bring to us but actually the care not
the worry but the care that we can
actually get from our dentist so to that
end how what's the minimum that we
should be seeing our dentist um it kind
of depends for everyone your dentists
will be able to kind of tell you if you
should be going every three months every
six months uh or every two years um it's
kind of all dependent on what your risk
of getting Decay and gum disease is um
but every six months is kind of the
standard I mean your dentist might say
no you're doing really well two years or
need to see you a little bit more often
every three months perfect okay because
I certainly in some of the areas I work
we've got quite a Transit population so
people obviously will sometimes not have
that regular dentist so at least I'll be
able to tell them that you know aim for
the six months try to get registered in
place
yeah well thank you so much for coming
in um genuinely I find it really
interesting I I learn a lot from these
conversations so I hope you guys at home
have benefited as well please put some
more questions in the comments so that
we can run another sort of dental myths
debster and uh we can see what more
light we can bring to this sometimes
scary subject yeah absolutely yeah any
comments or any questions feel free to
to write them and I'll try my best to
answer them in the next video and yeah
fantask thank you very much for having
me again we'll see you in the next one
cheer