What Happens When PROFESSIONAL Pilots Let Their EGOs Fly!
3 Video Views·Oct 31, 2024
Okay, welcome back to Fast Trip Performance,
and my name is Tim Davies,
and today we're looking at a couple
of the United States Marine Corps F-18C single-seat aircraft
that have got themselves in a little bit of trouble
on a recovery to an airfield,
and now this is a tape about what you should not do.
Okay, let's talk about this investigation then.
This is an FAA fighter call close in Texas.
They're going into Austin, Texas.
This was 23rd of September last year.
For the actual tape, guys,
I will make myself smaller,
but for now then, what we're looking at
is the FAA is investigating a close call
between two U.S. Marine Corps F-18C jet aircraft
and two civilian aircraft in Austin, Texas.
They're like on a land away or something,
and what happened pretty much was a bit of confusion,
and then everyone started acting like children.
Now, in my job in the Royal Air Force,
when I was teaching for about a decade,
I would have brought all these people into the office,
sat them down.
There'd be no coffee,
but there would be a very significant chat,
and the flight tape actually comes
from a channel called Avocado Flight,
and so I wrote to the dude,
and I said, hey, buddy,
can I use your tape for one of these things?
I want to have a bit of a chat about it.
He went, yeah, have a go, mate.
No worries at all.
What an absolutely solid dude.
I'll put the link down in the description.
Go and give him a follow if you are into
this pictorial representation with audio
of flights that are quite interesting.
However, I'm going to break it down for you.
Let me minimize myself now.
I'm going to play it, but I'm going to stop it.
Again, you want the full tape,
go over to Avocado Flight.
So the simple rules is don't be an absolute child
in the airplane.
What we've got up here is a couple
of business jets coming in.
On the screen on the top left there,
you will see a couple of F-18Cs coming in.
Now, they're not actually like that.
What they've done is,
Avocado Flight has put them like this
because he just wants to show that there's a pair.
These are both single-crewed airplanes.
Of course, single-seat airplanes from the F-18C
on a land away to Austin, Texas.
Take two one off.
Flight Austin pros, good afternoon.
Maintain VFR 5,500.
I'll give you a couple vectors
to send you to about a four-mile initial.
These are military airplanes.
They have a UHF and a VHF radio.
It's called a VUHF radio in effect,
and you can transmit on either one.
So you're not going to hear necessarily
these USMC guys repeating back on the civilian frequency,
but you will hear the business jets on that as well.
And what he does, he simulcasts,
so he kind of transmits on both
so that everyone can hear them.
However, the civilian aircraft probably aren't hearing
the military aircraft at this time.
Foothill 73, once you get established on final,
there's going to be a flight of two F-18s.
It'll be 1,000 feet above you at 3,500 for the overhead.
Awesome, we'll be ready.
And that's, I'm not going to keep stopping this,
but that's what we tend to find as well.
People are like, yeah, rock on.
We've got some jets coming in.
How cool is that?
Yeah, jet 699, descend and maintain 2,500.
2,500, this is 699.
Foothill 703, descend and maintain 4,000.
4,000, Foothill 703.
Foothill 703, turn right heading 130.
Right heading 130, Foothill 703.
Take two and roger.
Turn right, give me a right turn heading 195
and go ahead and join the localiser at or above 5,500.
Okay, just join the final approach course then.
Yeah, so these jets are talking back to them
and going, bro, we haven't got an ILS in these aeroplanes.
In fact, I think the only jets that have ILS
of the F-18 fleet are the Blue Angels.
I think Canadian Hornets have them as well.
What they have is something called the I-CLS.
And now I teach this in my school.
In fact, it's Boat Week at the moment in Shadowlands.
If you want to come and join that,
link in the description down there.
And we do a lot of these tapes as well on a Sunday.
We really break these tapes down,
really kind of get into the nuance
of these flight safety incidents.
They can't join an ILS,
but they can take a localiser pretty much on the TACAM.
So they're saying, oh, we can line ourselves up
for the airfield.
We can do that.
We have the kit to do that.
We just can't fly an ILS here.
So they're probably gonna ask for what we'd call a join,
which would be a visual run and a break
in the Royal Air Force.
And these guys call it the overhead, I believe it is.
Very similar.
You come in and you just break to join that pattern.
We call initials at three miles,
and we're extending now.
Because he's gonna have to break in a climbing turn,
he should find it relatively easy with idle
and the airbrake to get rid of the speed,
to roll out downwind.
So we can select his services.
There's roll, pull, idle, airbrake, or travel.
He'll probably keep that aircraft
on the light buffet there.
It was a 4G brake.
Boat Hill 703, flight heading 140.
Descend and maintain 2,500.
Heading 140, down to 2,500 for 703.
You said just 699, and when you make that turn
from JEDI to R2 airport, it'll be 11 o'clock and nine miles.
That's right, it's at 699.
It's at 699.
Thank you, cleared visual approach
running 1A left, tower 121.0.
Cleared visual 1A left and tower 121.0, units at 699.
Boat Hill 703, you might see him already
up here at nine o'clock, nine to 10 o'clock there
and about five miles southbound.
Flight of two F-18s, VFR 55.
Okay, looking.
Inside foot of 703.
Snake 215, just continue straight in there.
Maintain VFR at or above 4,500.
Right, so here's another thing that's happening right now.
So we've got the business jet, the 699,
that he's setting himself up for a nice visual approach.
Sounds happy, doesn't he?
The Foothill guys are like, yeah, we're visual with him.
And you can see Snake 21, the flight, a couple of F-18Cs.
It's gonna be ahead of that business jet.
So we're all cool in the gang.
And don't forget that the military traffic
does not have to be below 250 knots, below 10,000 feet.
They don't have to comply with that civilian regulation.
They haven't, they've got dispensation.
Because jets don't fly well below 300 knots
unless they're configured for takeoff and landing.
It's a really dangerous place to be for military fast jets.
So these guys, I'd argue, really,
with the weight of the airplanes and what they're doing,
they could probably line themselves up here
for quite a nice straight in.
Not really too sure where they're going for the break.
Maybe they know some people there or something
and they wanna make a nice approach to the airfield.
But don't, your whole flight, basically,
if you've had a great flight,
then just do the easiest approach you need.
Now, sometimes the easiest approach is the break
and you just run straight over the runway
and you turn hard, left downwind.
People think it's showboating.
It's not.
It's the most expeditious way
that we can lose speed in military fast jets.
So you can see, people are lining up now.
But if I was looking at that as an air trafficker,
I'd be like, yeah, it could get busy, all right?
So let's just get some clarification
as to what people are doing here.
Also, when people aren't on the same frequency
as other people, of course, confusion can creep in.
Snake to one flight traffic at two to three o'clock
and three miles southeast bound, a citation.
He'll be at 2500, you'll be over top of him
for the left break.
You'll be following him for the airport.
Yeah, that'll be fine.
I'll let Tower know.
They probably just said there,
okay, roger that.
We're just gonna come in for the break.
That's probably what they said.
703, heading 145.
Join the 18L localizer, advise airport and site.
Airport and site, heading 145, 40703.
40703, thank you, clear visual approach
on the 18L.
Clear visual, 18L, 40703.
Snake to one flight, maintain VFR at 3500 now, 3500.
Snake to one, are you gonna need a UHF or Tower?
Just maintain 3500 and you can contact Tower now.
121.0, they'll have the break for you.
Have a good afternoon.
40703, Tower, 121.0, have a good afternoon.
So he's just handing guys over now
from the approach freak that you're hearing him on now.
This is where you just get all the longer range traffic out.
They're onto a Tower frequency.
And now these guys should all be on the same frequency
and they can hear each other again and everything.
So at the moment, the picture's pretty good.
We've got the 699 lining himself up for a nice straight in.
And we've got Foothills just sitting at the back there,
just watching everyone, just chilling out.
And we've got Snake 21 coming in.
I think the visual with the traffic ahead of them,
just gonna come straight in for the break really.
So no real dramas apart from the fact
my only concern here would be that the airfield's 500 feet.
They're currently, Snake 21 are currently at 3500 feet.
So they're 3000 feet.
And Snake 21 really wanna be down at 800 feet
for the sort of carrier break that the Hornet does.
It's 800 feet, it's ending at 600 feet downwind.
We teach it in the school, by the way.
And then they're gonna go down final.
And they're probably gonna do that break
at the end of the runway.
That's normally where I would do it,
at the end of the runway, give myself some space,
give myself some time.
FL10, Foothills 703.
Tower, 699 is Jedi inbound.
Execjet 699, Austin Tower, runway 18 left, clear to land.
18 left, clear to land, Execjet 699.
Execjet 699, cancel landing clearance,
traffic's gonna be holding position.
699, cancel landing clearance.
Career track, 353, Austin Tower,
runway 18 left, line up and wait.
Line up and wait, runway 18 left, career track 353.
So now, we've thrown another ball into the juggling mix.
Everything was kinda going well,
and now we've got this career track,
which is probably like an aviation-based training school,
just lining up to get airborne.
So the 699, his clearance has been stopped, basically,
but he hasn't been told to go around.
Now, I'm not confused by that,
because he's quite long range,
so he can still come down in the Royal Air Force.
We come down to 300 feet,
we do a high approach and go around,
but he hasn't been told to do a missed approach
or anything, or to go around.
So he's still flying his approach there.
That is fine.
I'm not too worried about this.
If I was listening to this when I was on recovery,
I'd be like, I would assume 699
probably was gonna go around at this point,
although he is quite rangy from the field.
I might not know that in my airplane.
I've just heard that his landing clearance,
it's not a call that the British use.
We don't tend to use landing clearance.
We just send people around.
We don't cancel landing clearance and then give it back.
We just send them to go around.
So I'd be a little bit confused.
Maybe this is an Americanism here.
Career track 353, traffic's citation, five mile final.
Also, I just say, if someone lines up on the runway
and there's still traffic on final,
I'm like, I don't know where this dude is.
I'm lining up going, what's going on here?
So if I was that career track dude lining up there,
I'm like, the guy's on final.
Okay, I've heard you canceled his landing clearance,
but I'm not happy.
So I want to go.
I want to get off that runway.
I want to get airborne.
Five mile final, citation for traffic 363.
Delta 2297, contact departure.
Say it.
Southwest 171, turn right at Lima, contact ground 0.9.
All right, Lima, over to ground, Southwest 171.
Austin Tower, Snake 2152, F-18, 3500,
looking for the unrestricted altitude airspeed,
break, 1-8-left.
Career track 353, Austin Tower,
fly runway heading, runway 1-8-left, clear for takeoff.
1-8-left, fly runway heading, clear for takeoff,
career track 353.
Exact jet 699, Austin Tower, runway 1-8-left,
clear to land.
You can see that, although the F-18s are asking
for an unrestricted height and speed,
the guys like, literally, break, break.
I'm just going to get this guy out of the way first.
So you clear takeoff,
and the other guy, you'll clear land now.
So you've got one on rolling,
that career track guy's rolling.
He's got a straight head departure.
And now we can clear the 699 to land as well.
We've got those tick, tick, that's the priority.
Departures and recoveries are priority.
Now we can go back to the F-18s,
and we can deal with their request
for an unrestricted speed or break,
which I must admit,
that's not something I've heard of before,
of someone asking for that, an unrestricted.
What I would ask for if I was Snake 2-1
is I'd tell their traffic exactly what I was going to do.
I'm pretty sure Austin is familiar with military traffic,
from what I understand.
So I'd just say, look, Snake 2-1,
we're looking for an 800 foot break from the dead side,
end of the runway, we'll be at 350 knots.
So that air traffic know exactly what we're after.
When you say unrestricted height or speed,
you could be like 600 knots or something,
at like 100 feet.
No one's going to give you that stuff,
because it's illegal, okay?
So it's kind of a strange call to make, really.
I don't really understand it.
I've never really heard it before.
And I would have thought that's going to put
a bit of confusion into the whole thing here.
Left final landing, 699.
Snake 2-1, Austin Tower,
as approved as requested,
report a left break over the numbers.
Snake 2-1, roll call.
Right, left break over the numbers.
That means at the approach end of the runway,
that's the bit you land on.
He's telling him to break over that.
And he's also said as requested, which I wouldn't.
So now he's kind of said, do what you want, basically.
I wouldn't do that, because you could.
Now you can do what you want.
Air traffic told me I'm the boss.
You can do what you want.
That's the problem.
Look, so these guys,
Snake 2-1 currently five and a foot above 699 now
as they come in.
All right, push up, dude.
Give me burner if you need to.
Right, that's obviously done on the tower frequency.
There's two radios in the airplane.
There's a front and a back box,
we used to call them box one, box two.
Box two, you're chatting to Freak.
So with your wingman, you chat on.
And then the front box, you'd be chatting to air traffic.
Now he's just kind of,
I think it goes up for the air traffic, Freak down.
That's what he did in the tornado anyway.
Tornado was on the stick.
Hawk was on the throttle there.
So he just answered him.
And he just said, basically, push him up here.
Probably get to a break speed of 350 knots.
Which is normal.
It's not showboating.
That's what you break at.
It's better to break fast, 350.
So then you can lose the speed in the turn.
As you roll out, you can then configure.
And you will be descending Hornet 800 to 600.
And then you can land tip final.
So he's not doing anything wrong here.
My only thing would be,
when I first saw this tape, I thought,
yeah, he's gonna set the TCAS off.
Traffic Collision Avoidance System
in the business jet there.
Because of the closure speeds
or the rate of ascent or descent,
that TCAS is gonna go off in the 699.
If you do that, you'll get what's called
either a resolution or a traffic advisory.
A traffic advisory, you could acknowledge.
It just says, hey, someone is in close proximity.
But a resolution advisory says a collision is imminent.
And you have to react.
In civilian aircraft, you have to react.
Now in Tornado, we never had TCAS.
But in Hawk T2, we did.
We did it slightly different
about whether we have to react to a resolution advisory
or whether we need to call it at all, really.
Because we're doing air combat with TCAS on.
It's a bit kind of crazy.
TCAS 2.
However, if you're a business jet on approach here
and you've got fast jets coming behind you
and you get a resolution advisory,
have those fast jets really seen you?
Do they really know where you are?
I'd be really, you know, a little bit nervous
if I was that business pilot.
You know, if I was a business guy.
TCAS RA for get to 699.
Oh, there you go.
So now he's just called it.
So yeah, when I saw this, I was like,
that's gonna happen.
And then it did happen.
So he's saying, I've got a resolution advisory for 699.
Now, he's at 2,000, they're at 2,400.
So I'm assuming he's got traffic
and the resolution advisory is probably gonna give him
a descend call there, which he can't really do.
He's on final, he's configured,
probably coming in about a hundred knots there
for a business jet.
He's not maneuverable at all.
So he's entirely vulnerable.
And as a pilot of a business jet there,
I'd feel a bit kind of like,
I don't know where these guys are.
I can't look out, you know, I can't,
there's no, you know what I mean?
I'd be, yeah, not in a happy place.
Check jet 699, roger.
Sub zero three, 2,500 visual at one eight left.
Snake one one to break at departure.
You're changing a lot of things.
People have expectations and now you're,
which is fine, break at departure end.
He's like, I've got 699 on
and I've got the foothills guy coming in as well.
If you break at the departure end,
maybe I can get both those guys in.
Don't get this wrong now.
It's not like Snake two one
haven't actually seen the business jet.
They have, and they are gonna avoid him.
But the separation you give to him,
what is it laid down as?
And when I was flying,
it wasn't really laid down as a separation.
If you do have a separation,
you've got to visually judge it anyway.
So it's not easy.
You have seen him.
I normally gave them a wide enough berth
to make them feel secure, if that makes sense.
So I'm not gonna zip past them
because that's not on.
It's not fair.
I don't want any wake turbulence on him.
Maybe I can give him half a mile or something,
but what does half a mile really look like anyway?
Snake one one traffic.
So you can see the heights were very similar
when they came past there, like 1,300 feet.
Both of them were.
So they have passed quite close by
and I'm assuming that business jet guy
is not gonna be happy.
Cessna, Cherokee.
Snake one two one to extend down.
Yeah, so he was asking him
was he gonna break late at the departure end.
They actually broke early now.
They've gone to the break at the approach,
at the approach end of the runway.
That's not gonna be great.
So now things are gonna get a bit tight
and he's just said extend downwind.
So you're gonna have to extend downwind for me now
because you broke in the wrong place.
Right, this is what we call a bitch comment.
Okay, and understandable.
The guy's unhappy.
It's the first of many bitch comments
we're gonna hear on this tape.
It's unnecessary.
It doesn't enhance anything.
It doesn't help anyone.
If anything, it just prejudices flight safety
because people are just now gonna have a conversation
about it because people get delicate.
And this is what we teach in my school
about humility of aviation.
Let's sort it out on the ground.
Aviate, navigate, communicate, remain professional.
Let's not throw these things out.
He said something there.
Would it be nice to know, guy?
And now the air traffic is gonna feel defensive
and you have to say something back to him.
Snake two one, we thought you were gonna start your descent
in the break there, it's not prior.
He said, she said, wouldn't it be good if,
no one cares, guys.
I'm not gonna swear on my own tape here.
No one cares.
All right, let's just settle down,
get jets on the ground,
then we can have a conversation about it.
Snake two one, negative.
I request the officer to excuse my discretion
for the break.
All right, what being professional here
for the United States Marine Corps guy to do
was to say, roger that.
End ex.
He's on a break.
He's configuring.
His aircraft is vulnerable.
He's getting his gear down.
He's flaps down.
He's trimming into the E bar and everything.
He's looking for the separation from the runway,
looking for the tip in point.
He's gotta extend downwind.
He's looking for the guy coming in on final there,
which would be that 699 guy.
So, let's not have a conversation with anyone here.
Let's square yourself away first, all right?
Just, roger that.
And then let people speak if you want to.
Roger that.
You're not admitting fault, culpability,
none of that stuff.
Roger that.
Get your jet on the ground.
Remain professional.
We'll sort it out later.
This is not the place to have a conversation.
Sorry, some misunderstanding I suppose.
I have the traffic in sight.
Doesn't matter.
Yeah, that's another bitch comment
from the BizJet pilot.
There's a thing here.
I'm not gonna call it out.
And in the comments, guys,
whack down stuff if you're flying BizJets
or Civi Aviation,
especially if you've got a history
of military aviation as well.
Look, sometimes when I'd landed,
if I'd pushed someone or did something, whatever,
I'd walk up to that pilot and say,
hey, sorry, buddy, I did see you on approach.
And if they had a bit of a go at me or anything,
I'd say, hey, do you want to see the jet?
And they normally would come over,
have a look around the jet.
I'll put them in the cockpit
and just show them things like this
because everyone wants to see inside a jet cockpit.
And one of the things they'd probably say to me was,
you don't have much space in here, do you?
And I'd be like, no, no.
Do you want to try the helmet on?
Yeah, yeah, try to put the mask on.
It's like, wow, you have,
for a BizJet pilot,
you may have the approach plates up in front of them
so it can show the airfield diagram and everything else.
They've got all the buttons, everything laid out.
They're having some cup of tea there and everything.
In a fast jet cockpit, it's very small.
A lot of things happening very quickly.
You're force-fed oxygen, all that kind of stuff.
They start to appreciate the limitations of operation
that you have in the fast jet world.
And they can just chill things out
and then just apologize.
Hey, I'm sorry, dude.
I'll give you more space next time.
Is that all right?
Normally they have a go.
Mate, you know, I'm a bit vulnerable in my jet here,
in my business jet.
I can't see you, right?
Yeah, I'm sorry, dude.
We don't have teacups or nothing.
So I should have given you a wider berth.
Next time I will.
In fact, next time I'll go around at 3,500 feet.
I'll reposition through initial, again,
three miles to give you that space to land.
I didn't mean nothing by it.
And what happens to me sometimes
when the guy said, well, I've got to put a,
I've got to put a flight report in anyway.
And then that flight report never gets put in.
Because you're going to have something
called a conversation.
You've got to spoken to someone like adults.
You haven't thrown bitch comments around here
like it doesn't matter.
You've just been sensible.
You've been professional aviators.
And I'm not having to go at anyone here today.
All I'm saying is, I don't think that's the case.
Snake 2-1, we'll call you at base time.
Snake 2-1, roger.
Just calling in ASAP, just so you know.
Foot hills, Sub-Zero-Three-Five-Alpha.
That foothills guy's like, this is awesome.
I'm just watching this shit play out.
It's funny.
That's funny.
If I was that foothill guys,
I'd be like sniggering in the cockpit a little bit.
Zero-Three-One-Way-One-E-Left-Clear-Land.
Y-Left-Clear-Two-Left-Foot-Hills-Sub-Zero-Three.
Zeta-Six-Nine-Nine-Turn-Right-Taxi-Way-Kilo.
Contact-Ground-Point-Nine.
Right-Kilo-Six-Nine-Nine.
So he's down.
Snake 2-1, you can turn base to your discretion
on Y-One-E-Left-Clear-Land.
Cool.
Snake 2-1, base to your discretion on Y-One-E-Left-Clear-Land.
By the way, the jets aren't together at this point.
He's just avocado flight.
Just put them together to show they're a flight or two.
There will be two different aircraft on the screen here.
They're not landing together.
They're landing behind each other, right?
Right-Kilo-Land.
Foot-Hills-Seven-Zero-Three-Turn-Right-Taxi-Way-Kilo.
Contact-Ground-Point-Nine.
Kilo-Ground-Point-Nine.
Foot-Hills-Seven-Zero-Three.
This is the weirdest thing I've seen.
So apparently it's Jen.
This is like a four-bag fit, which I'm not,
I teach F-18 in the school, F-18C, in fact.
A four-bag fit is a really, it's an asymmetric fit.
So there's four fuel tanks on there,
which means you're limited on what you can do
with the airplane here.
So if you want to do a break,
the aircraft's not the most maneuverable aircraft
in the world there.
Yeah, I'm quite surprised.
I would have thought,
well, they're on a cross-country trip, I suppose.
I would have probably, maybe they come a long distance.
You could probably get away with three bags on that,
three tanks on that.
I would have thought, I'm not an expert on the F-18.
So yeah, I'm sorry about that, I'm not.
Snake-Two-One, Turn-Right-One-Able
and not remain in the strictly.
Snake-Two-One, hold still.
This is Snake-Two-One, just want to verify.
You guys did have that jet
that you descended in front of in sight?
Snake-Two-One-A, affirmative, break.
If you've got a number,
I kind of want to talk to you guys about that.
Yeah, I was going to give you the number here
because I guess there was a miscommunication.
I misunderstood what was requested, I guess.
So give me just a second, I'll get that.
So I'm sure if you want more on this then,
then head over to the Groover and Donkey Show.
I'm sure they're going to cover this.
You know, those cats have got some F-18 experience.
I'm a tornado and hawk guy.
But all I would say about this really is
the main takeaway here is just don't be a little bitch
about it.
If something happens in the air
and you're all kind of pushing towards something
that's not healthy, then just be professional.
Everyone makes mistakes.
There'll be a report about this that come out,
but it'll be a USMC report,
so I won't be able to read it to you.
Either way, I would have thought to just say,
look, F-18s have seen the business jet,
should have given them a wider berth, that's all.
And there was a bit of non-standard communication
for the nation, wasn't there?
This, I need unrestricted height and speed.
It's like, dude, no one's going to give you that
because you might come in at 20 feet at 700 knots.
All right, so just state what you want.
Hey, I need 800 foot break at 350 knots.
That's all I want.
And it'd be cool in the game.
So just tell people sometimes.
Also, what I would used to do
if I was landing away at civilian field
is I'd phone air traffic at the field first.
Let's say I'm a flight of two or three tornadoes coming in.
This is the kind of circuit that we fly.
It's 1,000 feet downwind.
It's about half a mile, whatever.
Just tell them what we're expected to do
so it's not a surprise when we rock up there
and batwing legends acting like bosses
bust up their circuit like man-children
into a nuff-style downwind to get the jets on the ground.
Obviously, like professional aviators, we are.
But the other thing is,
just don't make this the worst part of your flight
because everyone's watching.
So do something very predictable when you come in, all right?
Just chill out.
Keep everyone safe.
These business jets are vulnerable, all right?
And they're slippy as tigers as well,
so they need a long space to slow down.
They can't slow down like jets can.
Hope that was useful, guys.
As I said, head over to Groover and Donkey's channel.
You know where they are.
I think they're called Groover and Donkey.
I'm just taking the piss.
Tell them I'm taking the piss out of them.
They love that.
They love it.
Because they're very delicate, aren't they?
These American pilots, as we all know.
Go and have a look at them, guys.
I really appreciate it.
Join the school if you want more of these conversations,
by the way.
I'll put the link down in the bio.
Tim Davies, Fast Ship Performance.

