Will Pilots Become Obsolete? SINGLE- and NO-PILOT Operation explained by CAPTAIN JOE
Nov 23, 2024
Nowadays airplane manufacturers and airlines are working closely together
to reduce the number of pilots in the cockpit more and more
to potentially a state where no pilots will be required to fly a plane.
Dear friends and followers welcome back to my channel and to a
dreaded video topic. Yes we do have to talk about it
as this topic is being addressed more and more in the aviation world.
The hype about the potential single pilot operation
and or is artificial intelligence going to replace the pilots entirely?
What can we expect and should you worry as a pilot or a future pilot?
What are we waiting for and let's get started.
A few years back some airplanes needed a four-man crew
to be able to operate the aircraft safely. You had a navigator,
Now the navigator has become completely obsolete and the engineer
you do see every now and then but 99% of all airlines are
safely operated by two pilots. Technology just got better and better
over the years. Nowadays airplane manufacturers and
airlines are working closely together to reduce the number of pilots in the
cockpit more and more to potentially a state
where no pilots will be required to fly a plane.
Wouldn't that make this guy super happy? But in order to understand this better
let's first take a step back and look at why aviation is even able to
talk about single pilot operations. Therefore we need to understand the
implementation of the autopilot. The first autopilot was
developed in 1912 for mainly two reasons.
First and foremost to assist the pilots and reduce their workload on longer
flights. Now just imagine the amount of workload
former pilots were dealing with. Navigating,
avoiding weather, finding enemy territory and besides all that
fly the damn plane which wasn't the most reliable either.
So the first autopilot had two features. Maintaining altitude and heading.
Very basic but an absolute milestone in the aviation industry.
The second reason was to reduce the accidents due to fatigue
and pilot errors in bad weather conditions. As mentioned earlier
the pilot had to manually fly every flight for the entire duration
of the flight by hand. Now this causes extreme fatigue and potentially
dangerous situations especially when the pilot encounters bad
weather or low visibility conditions plus
low oxygen levels. Now two of my colleagues experienced an
unreliable airspeed event a few months back
and then they had to fly the aircraft manually
from New York to Chicago in lousy weather.
They had to change over controls every hour because
symptoms of fatigue were kicking in. Side note
Mythbusters showed that fatigue drivers made more mistakes on the road than
drunk drivers. I advise you to neither drive your car in either state.
So now you can imagine the dangers of a fatigued pilot
entering bad weather in the last 30 minutes of the flight
and is required to fly an instrument approach
right to the minimums. So we can say with no doubt that the autopilot was and is
an incredibly helpful tool for any pilot. Now take note
tool a very important word to remember. A single pilot in the cockpit of a plane
is not a very uncommon sight in smaller general aviation aircraft.
Legally you are allowed to fly an aircraft with
one pilot given that two requirements are met.
One the aircraft is certified by the manufacturer to be
operated with one pilot such as the Cessna 172
that we are all very familiar with and most of the
Cessna Citation jets. Secondly the aircraft is
legally allowed to be operated by one pilot
given that it is complies with certain legal requirements
like being under 12,500 pounds maximum takeoff weight
and less than nine passengers on board. I will not bother you guys with all the
legal parameters to fly a plane single crew but what I will make clear
is that most airline jets are required by
their manufacturers operating handbook as well as the
company's operating manuals to be operated by a minimum
of two pilots and because airline CEOs are greedy and want to save as much
money as possible they are trying to change this to one
pilot or even in the future no pilot at all
operations. I have personally met one of those pro
single pilot or no pilot cockpit CEOs. After a brief chat about this topic
with him I made sure that he would never hire me.
According to an article published on Euractiv
in September 2021 Airbus is developing improvements in their technology to one
day eliminate the need for a co-pilot in the
cockpit. The article states that Airbus is in
negotiations with the EU regulatory authorities on whether the
technology can be used to certify aircraft for single pilot operations
either for the entire flight or certain flight
portions for example during cruise. They claim that their technology is capable
of handling most of the duties required and that
the pilot on board will only be on board for strategic
decision making and monitoring of limited systems a job
apparently only one pilot is needed for. Really? Are you sure about that?
The EASA is currently discussing two scenarios
one where long-haul flights can be reduced to only
two pilots rather than four like on my last rotation for example
stating both pilots will be in the cockpit for critical phases of flight
such as takeoff and landing and then only one
pilot will be in the cockpit during non-critical
stages such as cruise. They will rotate with each other during
the flight always having one crew member resting.
The second scenario is a fully single pilot operation where only
one pilot will be on board. This will be on
shorter flights initially and the program is known within Airbus as
Project Connect. Funny enough many of you have already flown on this plane or
are even type rated on it. Now pause the video and make a guess which plane that
might be. Three, two, one, yes!
The fourth best looking aircraft after the 747, Concorde and the
Supermarina Spitfire. It is the Airbus A350.
That is the future. As much as I love Airbus and their constant strive to
improve the aviation industry in regards to safety and fuel efficiency
they are the ones pioneering the SPO, the single pilot operation. It's always a
bad sign when they already have an abbreviation for it
and will be starting with this project in 2025
and the leading airline in connection with Airbus
at this time is, make an educated guess, primarily flies Long Haul out of Hong
Kong. Yes, good old Cathay Pacific. With the
technology already implemented in the military by flying drones
autonomously and flying others from the ground the co-pilot's
position will in the future be replaced by an
aircraft dispatcher trained in basic flying abilities.
Dispatches today handle anywhere from 5 to 15
aircraft at the time, supporting them with route and weather information in
real time etc. It is proposed that during single pilot
operations the dispatcher will act as a backup pilot
assisting from the ground if the single pilot on board requires any
assistance. So as we can see reducing the number of
crew on your flight is sadly a very real
discussion going on by airlines and manufacturers
today. Claiming that it will be safer and more
fuel efficient the more autonomy is brought into the
cockpit and the humans are taken out of the
equation and of course it saves companies
millions in salary costs per year. Just a brief reminder, salary costs are
absolute peanuts for airlines compared to
airplane leasing and fuel costs. Salary costs
are less than four percent so taking out the first officer will make
all the difference. Yeah right, don't get me wrong seriously.
But will this be possible? Will the technology be able to completely
replace the judgment, assistance and safety a co-pilot
provides? Let's look at a few, let's call them
hurdles the manufacturers and airlines and authorities will have to
overcome before taking away the co-pilot.
First of all the pilot is part of a safety critical system.
A system that was designed over the years to connect and introduce
harmony between the pilot's judgment and the computer's ability
and accuracy. Now while we have backup systems on board an aircraft we also
have a backup when it comes to human ability.
Removing a human from the safety equation
will without a doubt reduce the monitoring capability
and problem solving capacity of the cockpit environment
and until now any addition and improvement
in technology has been implemented to improve
safety. This one will directly reduce it again.
We hear a lot about pilot error. Every other aviation
youtuber talks smack about pilots planting their plane into the ground
about the mistakes they've made. But we are rarely told about pilots
saving the day when technology fails. This happens
more often than you think. If you want to see
how it looks when technology fails on a flight deck have a look at the flight of
Qantas 3-2 and imagine a single pilot in that
cockpit when that happened. I have three words no thank you.
What they did was a miracle how they saved that plane trust me.
Number two what about pilot incapacitation?
When the single pilot in the cockpit becomes ill
or passes out you are left with no human intuition and ability in the cockpit.
That will put some real confidence into the rest of the crew
and fearful passengers. Authorities will have to be
able to demonstrate the ability of the technology
to monitor a single pilot and notify the cabin crew
when the pilot is non-responsive. This is the day when the Microsoft flight
simulator pilot gets his chance. This introduces another problem when it
comes to sleep. Depending on which sleep cycle the
resting pilot is under it will take him a long time to be fully
cognitive and able to first see the situation
and react. Number three redundancy. People make mistakes. Do them all the
time. When taking out the second pilot of the
cockpit you will have to implement a system
that is able to recognize that what the pilot did
is a mistake. It is one thing to have a computer to tell you that two plus two
is four but to have a computer understand the
situation you are in and the decision you made from that
situation is a completely different thing. In the
interest of safety the pilot can decide to deviate from normal procedures
but will the technology allow him to do this?
Will it understand? Unusual instructions are
a daily obstacle pilots need to follow for example from ATC on ground or in the
air. That is the huge difference that makes
aviation so interesting because it's so diverse and
every day is different. Number four safety. We all remember the
tragic Germanwings accident. The other safety issue is with
technology. The more automation and AI the more threat of cyber attacks.
Remember if we get to no pilot operations an
operator will operate their fleet of aircraft
from a command center. This gives us the terrifying thought
of a hacked airline fleet. Authorities and manufacturers will have to prove
their technology is unhackable and I'm not so sure how
plausible that is. Playing remote control planes with actual
planes and passengers. That's a headline that writes itself.
Number five mental problems. Leaving a pilot in a
cockpit alone on long-haul flights for several hours will have a massive
psychological impact on the pilot. Additional
and special training will have to be implemented for such environments
so having a crew member with you at all times
is a big morale boost. Taking that away
in my opinion is pretty problematic. Number six
we have not even looked at the problem relating to upgrading co-pilots to
captain etc. Today a co-pilot needs to fly a lot
of hours with captains in order to gain the experience
of commanding an airliner. If airplanes are only required to be flown by
one pilot how and when will new pilots gain their experience?
Also what about the public acceptance? Pilot workload during turnaround,
pre-flight setups, paperwork etc. This all contributes to mental fatigue
done by only one pilot. I just don't see it. It's too much
if you ask me. There are so many things that need to be
overcome that we cannot fit them all into this one video
so I will leave you guys with my personal opinion.
In recent years success is measured on how
cheap we can do something not on how safe.
I hate to break it to you but there is a blue and white
airline which is one of the biggest contributors to this trend
especially here in Europe. I believe that in the past when safety was replaced by
profit bad things happened later on and
unfortunately profit is the big motivator in this
case. So many aviation incidents and accidents
are a sad indication of this trend. The COVID pandemic has undoubtedly
caused financial pressure on airlines and this might just be a financial
solution for them. Safety on board an aircraft is
directly dependent on the human factor. Yes,
automation is an amazing tool as discussed earlier
but that is where it is good at. It is a tool
not a creative problem solver in emergency situations. So why not
develop a safer cockpit by designing these
incredible technological improvements in the cockpit environment in order to
increase safety even more. The first word in aviation
is in capital letters SAFETY. Let's improve it and not compromise on
it. In the past innovation was the cost of
many innocent lives. Surely today we can
innovate and not compromise flight safety at the
same time. That's it for today let me know in the
comments below what you guys think of the idea of a single pilot airline or
a no pilot airline. Maybe we can start a pool
in the comments to see where the aviation world or
fans stand on this topic. Thank you very much for your time
here's your checklist for today subscribe to my channel check activate
notification bell check follow my instagram account check
perform a touch and go at my website check where you can get this
amazing book and don't forget a good pilot is always learning. Wishing
you all the best. Your Captain Joe

