6 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
Improved versions of a classic demonstration, the simple water glass turned upside down has a new twist when a balloon is used instead of a flat card.. The seal is improved enough that the jar of water can shaken and spun around without the water being spilled out. The weight of water inside the jar causes a slight pressure drop inside the container and the cohesive attraction between the water molecules hold them together when turned upside down, with a lower pressure inside the jar, atmospheric pressure pushes against the covering, which in turn seals the opening of the jar so the water stays inside. This behavior would be similar to the action of a suction cup.
Special thanks to Homemade Science Junior (my granddaughter, Ella Yeany and friend.. watch at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QnKqM2uta_g
MISTAKE: maximum water column should be 33.9 feet which converts to 10.3 meters.
Absolute zero is usually referred to as a measurement of temperature, in this case the absolute pressure is zero meaning it is a vacuum.
I briefly removed this video due to some questions about the explanation of the cohesiveness of the water being required for this to work and replaced it with a 2nd version that had that part of the explanation removed. After running some additional tests, I believe that it is correct as stated. However, it is my theory and I value any additional explanations proving me right or wrong.
I have had quite a few additional questions regarding other variable in this experiment I will test additional ideas and present them in a future video.
[Music]
BR Shan and today in homemade science
we're going to look at a classic
demonstration and see if we can make
some improvements on it we'll try this
with some different size containers some
of them having more than one opening now
I also want to investigate the
coverings now this could make a great
stem investigation for any
age now we KCK this
over
wow okay so get close
all right to do this experiment of
course we're going to need a container
but to do it well it's really going to
come down to what we use for a
covering rigid pieces like plastic work
but it'll come apart very
easily foam plates are less rigid and
they'll work a little bit
better cardboards a good choice until it
gets soggy
I like these flexible Lids they work
really
well this cover actually gives me a good
enough seal that I can do some tricks
with it can shake it up and down I can
wave it back and forth or
around I can even flip it up in the
air there we
go I think my all-time favorite have to
be these balloons they give a really
good
seal another fun material to try is a
piece of screen it does need to be
covered until you have it turned upside
down it can leak and fall apart with the
slightest
touch now going on to the containers you
can start out on an extremely small
scale of course we can always go larger
and use a variety of different
containers like this
funnel put a plate on top of
it that works pretty
[Music]
good the largest container I can tie it
in is a 5 gallon bucket now I have
adapted one by adding two sticks to the
bottom this is going to make it easier
to
show the rim of the lid was cut so that
it's loose fitting
P it up to
here and I have a stopper in the bottom
of it so that I can let it
out now instead of that lid we can also
just top it with this
[Music]
ball water levels right to
here
and I release the pressure
inside so the question is why doesn't
the water come out of the container when
it's turned upside down what's holding
it in there the usual answer is that
it's air pressure pushing up against the
bottom a more complete answer would take
a look at the water itself the water has
a property called cohesion it means that
the particles themselves want to stick
to each
other let's see what happens with a
material like sand where the particles
don't stick
together they simply fall
out now a pressure gauge could help
explain this experiment a little bit
better however this one's just not
sensitive enough so I'm going to switch
to this homemade
one this represents normal atmospheric
pressure and if I inhale in the tube
the pressure drops below that and if I
exhale the pressure increases I'll
attach it to the top of this tube so we
can see what's going
on now as I start lifting the tube out
of the water we can see the pressure is
being
reduced and we'll get it all the way out
here reduction in pressure and if I
release the cap let's see what
happens it goes back to normal
this is showing us that the pressure at
the top of that container is less than
that of the
atmosphere this is due to gravity trying
to pull that sticky water
downward now what about if the tube's
longer fill it up with water in this
grain Barrel attach my gauge
here and as I slowly bring it up
notice it's showing a greater reduction
in pressure
the
bottom as the water drains out the
pressure returns back to normal now
let's try it with an even longer
tooth this one's 55 in Long and I'll cap
it with a foam
plate and there we go that works turn it
back up
again as the water gets higher the
pressure at the top of the tube will
continue to reduce as the increasing
amount of water gets
heavier I haven't tried it yet but this
one's 7 and 1/2 ft long let's see if we
can get this one to work
all right well that didn't
work let's try once more this time I'll
use a balloon
instead there we go that's
better it
works in theory we could go up to about
33 ft at that point the pressure would
drop down to absolute zero
going higher would actually form a
vacuum there is one other way that
pressure can be reduced inside the
container and that's when you turn it
over a small amount of liquid will leak
out without additional air getting
inside if I shake it really hard you can
see additional water come out reducing
that pressure just a little bit
more we should note that air pressure
just doesn't push against the bottom
there's about 14.7 lb of force applied
against every Square in on the
containers with atmosphere pushing
against the container in all directions
we can actually cap it at the bottom and
also at the
top this funnels open at both ends and
it
works we can even do it with this
container that's got holes on the top
bottom and all four
sides there it
is I think of all these demonstrations
this one's my favorite this bottle has a
string and a handle attached to it so
let's add some water and P it
up that looks about
right and I'll stick a balloon on top
turn it
over that's pretty
good and the drink's going to allow me
to swing it around a couple
times see if I
[Music]
can and there we go well I hope you
enjoyed this video and as always I want
to thank you for watching
here for
[Music]
meure wait so
[Music]