bookslikewhoa picks what i read (her fave mysteries!) ✨ booktube twin test ep5

megwithbooks
324 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
[Music]
hello friends welcome back to my channel
it is time for another episode of
booktube twin test so this is a series
where i put different booktubers to the
test they each give me three books that
they love that they think i'm gonna love
and i read them and we find out who my
booktuber twin is
this is leaderboard from the first
couple episodes so today the booktuber
we're gonna be paying for the test today
needs to get like 13.5 i think to beat
kayla now the booktuber i'm sure you've
seen by the time i saw that we're going
to be putting to the test is mara from
books like whoa
quite a few of you have said mara i'll
put you up on the screen now and i agree
i can get
mara and kayla are probably the two
booktubers i watch the most and mara
i've been watching more and more in the
past few years year and a half as i've
been getting more and more into mystery
she's someone who i've really been
looking to for recommendations and
getting a lot of great recommendations
from so this is probably the episode of
booktube twin test that like i've been
most excited for since we did that first
one with kayla and i feel i feel almost
positive vibes towards you know i feel
like it's gonna happen
just gotta keep positive and keep busy
i just can't wait i don't know what
we're gonna get i feel like she could go
a lot of different ways but i'm just
excited to see so let's go ahead and
watch the video that mara has sent over
so if you haven't seen this before they
each give three recommendations and how
many stars
i give
each book correlates to amount of points
they get okay let's do this well hello
miss meg hey
i have been on quite a journey to find
your tbr because oh my god i so when you
message me
i may or may not have been looking at
instagram during a work meeting and so i
may or may not have fully seen the twin
test part so i initially was like oh she
just wants me to pick some books for her
to read i have some ideas so i grabbed
some things that i thought that you
would like but not all of them were ones
i like i mean i think you're like me
you're a good time gal you like it just
a fun thriller this one i was so so on
but it's all vibes with little plot and
i know that you love
like that uh the wilder girls and you
know oh my god
not mara exposing me anything
and then you know if you like the love
hypothesis that means you like a grumpy
hero with a big eggplant so i thought
this had some nice fanfiction quality
but again when i went back and actually
like fully read your message and
realized it was twin test i was like oh
okay that won't work because not these
are not favorite so then i was like okay
let me think through some of my all-time
favorites things that i absolutely love
and that i think have some connection
for you and i was thinking about it i
was like yeah okay but some of these are
risky and i thought to myself so do i
want to win do i want to unseat lala am
i coming for kayla's crown and i
realized that yes i am i'm a very listen
our whole family is super competitive
there have been fist fights over
scrabble which is especially ironic
considering all of us are terrible
spellers okay hold up hold up so i saw
library match howard had been a good
pick i didn't want to read that i saw no
roberts i've never read nor roberts i
know mara loves noah roberts has read
like almost all of her books my mum
loves nora but she reads a lot of nora
roberts romance books and she reads a
lot of jd robb which is normal it's like
speculative thriller i think kind of
thing or just thriller maybe throw in a
romance i'm not i can't remember but
like that's an alias she writes under my
mom has a lot of them and mara mentioned
recently a jd rob that you can start
with because the series been going on
for like 30 years or something [ __ ]
um she mentioned one that you could
start with a recent one and i have been
planning to start with that but i never
would have thought of nor roberts for me
personally so i'm competitive i want to
win and i don't think that these are
winners they could be i'll kick myself
if you end up reading these later and
loving them but i'm going for what i
hope is a winning stack okay so final
recommendations
this is precious three mysteries
all of these are favorites
all time favorites like top hunters oh
my god
all of these are a variant a different
flavor of a mystery because you like a
mystery and i feel like this is what is
a better winning stretch i do okay so
this is so exciting i was hoping maura
picked mysteries because i don't get to
read mysteries a lot in these kind of
videos where my tbr's picked for me by
someone else or like i don't know buy
like an app or whatever because
mysteries aren't as red and i love
like mysteries not thriller mysteries
mysteries and mara get that and i'm so
nervous i'm actually about to cry so
first up like maybe let's just start
with the one that is very on brand for
you and i saw that you had this shelves
so i think that you have some interest
in this death on the nile by agatha
christie okay i am the christie gal and
this is a classic who done it this is
one of her very best books in terms of
the writing is great the
characterization is super interesting i
think it has some interesting themes i
also saw that you loved murder on the
orient express and i think that this is
the book closest to that in her ubra we
got a lot of like foreign travel vibes
it's just like a lovely escapist good
time also the movie just came out so you
can read this and then see the movie but
i'm gonna go i'm gonna go back on the
nile as a as a tbr pick okay let's
quickly chat about that so when i sent
mara this message i almost said
don't pick an agatha christie
i'm gagging
i almost said that because many of you
know
essentially my agatha christie journey i
read murder on the urine express i loved
it i gave it five stars it is still my
favorite agatha christie i have ever
read i love the format of it with like
all the interviews that happen and then
what i've done is i've gone back and i'm
reading the priority series in order so
the next one i have to read is perilla
end house and i was pretty sure that
wasn't one of mara's favorites i was
like i don't want to read it out of
order there's no reason you need to read
it like in order really the priorities
you can read them out of order but i was
like i'm reading them an order so i
almost said don't pick one but then i
thought you know i love agatha christie
mara is like the epitome of loving
angela christie and she's a big reason
as to why i want to read more agatha
christie so i feel like it would have
been a disservice for me to say that so
i'm actually really glad um i've been so
excited to read death on the nile i have
a shelf because i own it because i
bought a special edition of it it's can
you see it it's like there i think i
bought the um harpercollins special
editions that they do that i absolutely
love there's my murder on your express
one i absolutely love them so that's why
i had a shelf but i was not expecting to
read that for like a couple years until
i got to that point in the series but
it's all good i'm excited okay then
we're gonna go to a mystery that has a
that is speculative so i picked the rook
by daniel o'malley and this one never
has
our protagonist wakes up in someone
else's body and that someone else is in
a super secret magic
sciencey speculative ministry and they
have to figure out who killed the person
whose body they're in and why and they
also have to figure out how to do the
job that that person would say and it
also actually it also got adapted into a
tv show this one is just so fun it has
purposeful disorientation which is
really fun i don't know it's just like
grumpy good times again very
entertaining high concept mystery so i
think that this could also be a winner
for you i'm excited for that i have
never heard of it i have no oh that's
scary to me though i i don't think i've
ever had a a book in a twin test yet
that i haven't even heard of i've even
heard of the rook so i don't know
i don't want to expect but she said
something about like a person waking up
in someone else's body although i didn't
like the seven deaths of evelyn
hardcastle i liked that feature of it
like waking up in all these different
characters bodies it sounds like it's
just one in this one but um
yeah oh my god oh my god i'm terrified
and then my last one is more of like
kind of horror mystery stuff because
simone st james always has
sort of like a paranormal element in her
mystery this one is set at a creepy
boarding school in one of the timelines
so i feel like that works for some of
your dark academia or dark like creepy
school things that you've liked and the
writing is great this is one of the only
multiple timelines that i really love in
a mystery thriller and i think this
could also be a winner i
am sorry
so excited
i'm very excited to read someone say yes
oh my god i own
uh the book of cold cases which her
newest release but i've been wanting to
pick up a similar student james for ages
partly because of mara this looks like
what we're starting with i'm also
intrigued actually because she said dual
timeline and she liked that i know we
both we both have this issue of when
there's dual timelines
not liking that because you prefer one
over the other so i'm excited to put
that to the test and see how i feel
about that uh this time so i'm gonna be
really sad if i'm totally striking out
but i'm i'm coming for kayla's throat i
want to win this i want to move up the
leaderboard so these are my picks for
you and thank you so much for thinking
about me this was so fun i'm gonna try
not to be too disappointed if i
don't take the crown but anyway i hope
you at least medium enjoy these books
and thank you for asking me okay okay
okay okay so they are the three books
that we're going to be reading
i feel good about this you know i feel i
feel like we're gonna rate these hype
i'm feeling very very positive super
excited i own definitely not i need to
go purchase the other two
so i will check in with you in a bit
when i've decided what to start with i
don't know what i'm gonna start with out
of these
right
i am
a hundred pages into the wreck
and i'm loving it
well today is going to be
the best day ever okay i will i want to
promise before we get into the like
topic um discussing what the book is
about i really want to say this book is
long it's almost 500 pages the font is
small
it takes a long time to read the topic
you really have to like read everything
very carefully it's not like a quick
read so like reading these first hundred
pages has taken me like hours
which it wouldn't usually but i'm still
loving it so essentially our main
character wakes up in london surrounded
by corpses with latex gloves on them and
she's like
what she quickly finds out she is not
the person whose body this used to be
her mind has somehow come into this body
and this woman was someone else
previously and she knew this was gonna
happen to her so she has left notes
to
our protagonist
explaining the situation and kind of
helping her live her life so her life is
i don't want to spoil too much because i
didn't know too much going into it but
basically she's like high up in this
secret society for magical people that's
what i'm gonna say it's like very like
bureaucratic kind of like behind the
scenes of english government like you
know powerful people do you know what i
mean that kind of situation so we kind
of have two protagonists in a way we
have our our point of view character now
and we have the old main character who
we have letters from and then
occasionally we have chapters where
we've already had like flashbacks
explaining well not flashbacks i think
it's part of the wider she looks like
dossiers of stuff basically explaining
her life to our point of view character
so i think it's excerpts from that that
we get sometimes the whole chapter and
you guys this is so interesting
it's such a like detailed complex
fantasy with a mystery element
i'm loving the detail and the complexity
of it so i don't mind that it's taking
me forever to read yes we'll be anxious
because i do want to get this video out
this weekend and it is wednesday so like
you know
i better get [ __ ] reading i want to
try and finish this today that's not
happening all right
i get the sense it's just gonna be so
detailed and so much go on it reminds me
of like jade city jade warjade legacy in
like the level of like detail and world
building and like characters were
meeting and like it's so interesting
being this character who's literally
just like landed in this earth he's like
what the [ __ ] right uh
it's so interesting because she knows
nothing like we know nothing about this
secret society well i'm saying secret
society that's quite the right time but
you get what i mean she doesn't know the
rules of it she doesn't know who the
people are she doesn't know all the
linguistics they use like she's like
balls to the wall trying to fake it do
you know what
i can't believe how much i'm loving it i
actually started this last week and it
was like too detailed it was like oh i
need like to take a break so i went away
read something easier and i've come back
and it's so good it does take ages to
read like i'm not even like consciously
thinking oh this is taking me so long
but when i look at how many pages i'm
reading per half an hour for example
it's like 20 which is very low for me
how old are you i'm 20. um anyway
yeah i'm just loving the detail loving
the characters loving the two kind of
main protagonists that we have i think
it's so interesting and so different to
anything i've ever read i'm absolutely
loving it
also look at lux this is just where he
permanently is
look at him hang on
tell me that ain't the cutest cat look
at him he loves to sit in between these
yellow pillows
oh i love him so much
i love him he's so cute even if he gets
mud all over my bed all over it
he's the gross cat in case you're
wondering
right we need to chat
we need to chat i have no clue
when i last checked in with you i i have
no clue like in terms of i know i
checked into your hundred pages in
roughly but i have no idea what it was
it was probably like a week and a half
two weeks ago genuinely it was probably
that long ago my math isn't great but it
was maybe a week maybe i'm being
dramatic i don't know but um yeah your
girl has not been reading but
i just haven't been reading so i did a
video a couple weeks ago where i read
seven books in seven days following
seven readathons and i spoke a bit about
in that video but i basically was ill
for like the entire last half of that
video and i just didn't want to be there
doing it then it'll be filming when i'm
ill i don't be filming myself i don't
really want to be reading but i forced
myself through it the train was already
running we were already going
stopping the video so i carried and i
did it and you know reading seven books
in seven days that's not the easiest
thing is something i can definitely do i
often for vlogs might read a book and a
day and stuff
but i think forcing myself to do that to
the video when i wasn't in the mood to
read has put me i wouldn't call it a
slump but just after that i haven't
wanted to read and i've kind of honored
that and not made myself read until now
when i've got three days to finish this
video i need to finish the books in
three days but it's crazy it's crazy i
think this is christ but i'm actually
now that i've had that break i'm
actually excited i'm excited to like
read these books quickly because i'm so
excited for them they're all like five
star predictions and
this book
i love it i
love it it's a lot right like it does
take a long it's not a quick read don't
come into this thinking it's a quick
read it's not it takes a long time to
read but
um
yeah i might be loving it yeah i might
be loving it it might be lovely some
books you read right and you're like
this was like the second draft you
needed to like you know it's a sim a
story is too simple you know and you're
like this needed to go
you know through the ringer a bit more
this feels like it's like the 20th draft
of a book it feels similar to me in
terms of like jade war and jade legacy
in
its complexity and its level of detail
where the author knows the world so so
so so well that you're like how did a
human being come up with this like it's
like how is that even possible it's so
good like the level of depth when you're
reading certain scenes i love
this may be ridiculous but i love when i
have when i read a book that i'm like
this isn't
objectively like furthering the plot
like it's just there to give us
depth
i love my work i love my life
i love the indispersions of where past
hair has written this kind of purple
folder whatever it's called purple
binder of all this information of all
the different places and people in this
like secret
world again it's called the the
jackie um don't ask me dan asked me to
pronounce things
yeah she's written all this stuff and
she the character the present day
characters kind of read all that stuff
but you're being fed it as and when it's
important to the present-day plot it's
just
it's just so well done it's really
really well done and there's certain
things that our present-day character
doesn't know but other characters around
her her know about her that then then
feeding to her when they kind of
figure out stuff and it's just it's so
interesting it's so interesting there's
a lot of funny jokes and there's about
like administration because it sounds
when you when you like
administration like when you pitch in
like the secret kind of governmental
society so it's all so intriguing but
like there are main characters
essentially it's just a lot of paperwork
like she does a lot of like the kind of
admin behind the scenes and so whilst it
is this fun exciting secret society at
the end of the day it's like it's still
a bit like an administration like it's
like you know it's still got all the
paperwork and it's still
people's place of work that they can get
fed up with and i just think that's
really funny and something you don't
it's got this kind of self-awareness
that you don't often see in books and i
would say already i'm about i didn't
tell you how foreign i am on page 300.
sorry so i've got that left to read i
got about 180 pages left to read i would
say it's my favorite
present-day urban fantasy so far that i
think i've ever read i can't really
think of something
perhaps i'm like ninth house yeah okay
perhaps something like ninth house is up
there as well
but in terms of like
i've never read anything like this that
i've loved as much as i as much as i
have i think the writing is absolutely
crazy and crazy
i wanted to say incredible and crazy
it's crazy incredible
the two protagonists kind of
well two protagonists it's the same
person but like they're bleeding into
one another and you're you're
liking and like feeling for both of them
whilst also like they're the same person
but they're not it's just so interesting
i'm
i'm confused because
and there was a twist about 30 pages ago
that whoa
it was so good i love books i spoke
about this with something like they'll
never learn i love and p some people
will say it's a spoiler it's not a squad
there's a twist coming i would love that
if you tell me to twist it halfway i'll
go give it to me now but there's a twist
like i love books where there's a twist
at half way i love it that completely
switches up what's happening in the
story you've been lured into a sense of
full security and you
switched up on and i love it i love when
that happens so so much i'm just loving
this book it's a slow read so i'm not
reading it first but i'm really enjoying
it i'm really really enjoying it it is a
series but i'm listening i'm happy to be
taken along with this series i don't
think it's finished yet the second one
has come out i think the third one's
coming out end of this year perhaps
start of next year
but um yeah and now we're just going to
be reading [ __ ] for the next couple
days and just read loads that's
so anyway i am going to go out in the
garden and finish this and then
hopefully we'll start them sometime this
evening to read a good chunk of our next
book as well
[Music]
when winter comes
i'll see you again
[Music]
i wish that i
didn't have to wait
[Music]
okay
i finished it
it only took me like 10 days to read i
mean
now
we're giving it five stars mara starts
off with five points and i felt like at
the start of this this was the most
risky book i feel like death in the nile
with it being the most similar to murder
on the orient express which i gave five
stars we have a good possibility of five
stars there and someone said james i've
wanted to read for so long like i want
to get too ahead of ourselves but if
mara gets 15 points do we just stop the
series like has it reached its point
like
is that it wishful thinking yeah you're
a dreamer you dream a lot and you're no
no i i really enjoyed this perhaps i
feel like the ending i didn't enjoy
quite as much as like the middle i
absolutely loved but i think i was just
like a little bit stressed when i was
reading it like i wasn't like in my
optimum reading capacity do you know
what i mean but um yeah i really really
loved it now i feel like i haven't
mentioned what the whole special powers
thing so basically this whole secret i
feel like i didn't mention this at the
start which is you know this from the
start so whatever this whole secret
society is made up of people often
children
well they were discovered when they were
children now they're adults in the
secret
situation with special powers right and
our protagonist special power it doesn't
feel like a spoiler you find out very
early on and she can kind of like
manipulate
people's bodies to like do what they she
wants them to do kind of anyway and they
all have special powers i just feel like
i had to mention that because it's kind
of like a key point in the plot and i
left it out one thing i will say is
there is a lot of different characters
in this i would have appreciated a
character list like at the beginning or
something i just feel like there's a lot
of different characters there were
points where i was forgetting who was
who just for a moment and then when you
read into the scene and like read the
context around them you're like oh yeah
i know who you are but like at when you
first see them again you're like who are
you
he could be walking down the street i
wouldn't
i wouldn't know a thing
sorry to this man there's a lot of men
basically high up in this institution
and i was like hang on i'm getting a bit
confused here there's a lot there's a
lot going on
um so i think a character list at the
start would have really helped it's
funny it's very i feel like you don't
get that right this up but it's very
like full of humor in a really good way
like our main character will come out
with very sarcastic one-liners i found
the whole idea of her being like someone
who has no idea who she is and yet
forming an identity very very
interesting i will say i was saying this
on uh reading sprints earlier today with
my patrons if i'm joining the patreon
links and links in the bio
but it's one step away from being clever
man syndrome no one ever got me here
saying this but sometimes you read books
by men
and it's like oh i'm so clever oh look
at how little bask in the glory of how
clever i am it's one step away from
being that it teeters on the edge of me
being annoyed like if it was one or two
steps more i'd like i hate it do you
know what i mean i do like books that
know they're clever usually they're by
women usually like women being
but this is by man yeah it's like one
step away from being overly in the know
of how clever it is does that make sense
but it's not there which means i can
love it and bask in the glory of it and
think it's amazing um and i will say it
is info dumpy with the past main
character writing all these letters
about the institution and about like
that's where all this detail comes from
that is info dumpy but in like a good
way not in a way that i'm like
you know it wasn't a good way so we
start off
with five points i can't believe it this
was absolutely amazing an absolute
favorite
knocked out the park it was so good i'm
gonna start death on the nile and i'm
hoping to get at least halfway through
this active christie's always a pretty
quick read so i'm hoping to get halfway
through it i believe the audiobook on
scribd is uh narrated by the guy who
plays paro in a lot of the the famous tv
show in britain um so yeah i love this
edition i'm so excited to read it and
i'm hoping
that we will get halfway through it
tonight bare minimum i want more but
bare minimum halfway
[Music]
gonna stay in this moment
gonna lay here on the grass
i don't need to feel lonely
i am finally
[Music]
no
[Music]
cause the best thing about it
right
it's late evidently
so you better pay you can pay for me to
have a new set of extensions
the [ __ ] hair is frazzled
but i'm halfway through death on denial
can you are you proud of me it took me
let me take my hair out it took me 10
days to read the rook and it's taken me
two hours to read half of this book
vastly different i was actually saying
to my mom it's very interesting how the
rook is so like detailed and oh my god
the windows open because it's hot but
like
the wind just blew it all the bugs back
it was scare me
it was really scary
look at the big deadly long legs flying
it's scaring me no stop coming towards
me please please please
stop it oh my god
what's on my books
it's there
go out the door oh my god oh my god
i'm hoping i spun him i don't know where
it went
oh i see it
okay we're gonna try and talk um
the rook
is so
detail oriented and like miss agatha
said details
like nothing gets described in this book
like settings you just kind of know
like when she says a steamer boat or you
know going down the nile you kind of
know what to envision she doesn't he
doesn't do a lot of description it's
basically just people having
conversations you know and
yeah i'm loving it i'm loving it it's up
there as one of my favorite agatha
christie so far i love
these closed isolated settings these
stories we've got a really interesting
mix of characters essentially the
opening of this of this book is about
this one woman who we focus a lot on
getting married
and when they find out that she gets
married it kind of spurs a lot of the
other characters into action
um and it's just really it was a really
interesting premise that sets up the
murder and the murders literally just
happened the last line
of the chapter i just finished halfway
was then who then had shot
blank and it's very dramatic and i'm
just really loving it like i because
chrissy just like gets what i want it's
fun
quick light-hearted in a way reads and
i'm just loving it the mystery is being
planted very well i [ __ ] love when we
have a map let me show you map of the
boat yes please uh yes please yeah i'll
take a map on the boat yeah i'll take
that um
and we just got a lot of interesting
like betrayal and revenge on these
themes on par in the middle of like oh
i was trying to take a [ __ ] holiday
[ __ ] like and i'm out here having to
serve another cake i was saying to my
mum actually she was saying how she read
a lot of agatha christie like she went
on with christy like binge when she was
12. and i was like [ __ ] why don't you
put me on them like i'd never read
agatha christie until a year or two two
years ago maybe
um and i just love mysteries i just love
mysteries okay i love mysteries
and there's something about this is my
first agatha christie novel i've read in
about a year i read short stories at
christmas this is my first novel in
about a year and i'm just loving it i'm
loving the experience reading it so i'm
gonna go to bed and then i'll probably
finish off the other half in the morning
it's super quick super fun super easy
and i think it was the perfect order to
read in like to read the rook first and
read this after it because i'm enjoying
them both so much
but for very different reasons
it's the next day
i finished death in a nile
and i'm gonna get five stars yep i'm
gonna find that
i'm doing it i'm doing it mara has got
10 points from two becks mara has a 100
success rate
right in here i can't believe that i
actually can't believe that difficult
book to talk about because the thing
with agatha christie is she's just like
for me anyway pure escapism right sorry
like you're on the bed i'm shaking you a
bit i'm shaking she's just fun to read
quick enjoyable paro is one of the most
fun characters to just like dive into an
experience but like unlike the rook
where i had so much to say because
there's so much detail i don't have as
much to say with this but i think this
is actually up there are some of the
best agatha christie writing i've read i
think because i've read a lot of her
earlier stuff where she's still like
honing her craft then going and reading
a book that's much later in the kind of
series it's a very different reading
experience it's really really fun and i
feel like her writing was just
magnificent i also felt like in this
book the characters the red herrings the
way that the characters backgrounds are
slowly revealed and like developed upon
i just thought was wonderful it was just
fun i just had so much fun reading it
you know there's not much more to say
than that i just had the best time
agatha christie just gets
what i love to dive into and for me
mysteries are
my favorite thing to read like i can 100
now i remember i was on a live on
kayla's channel like
it must have been like a year and a half
ago now and we got the question what's
your favorite genre and i couldn't
answer and everyone else was like
mystery megan it's a mystery i was like
oh i don't know but like i'm 100
certified mystery fan now i just there's
something about it that i find
especially books like this like i
haven't read an agatha christie for like
a year of a novel and um i really miss
it so i'm looking at my next two in the
series to read parallel end house and
lord edgware dies and i'm just like i'm
so excited i something about them just
makes me feel very comforted and happy
and there's a nostalgia in it even
though
i didn't read these when i was younger i
didn't read a lot i didn't really read
any mysteries i read a lot of like
paranormal
fantasy romance ella twilight when i was
a kid we all make choices
but that was a choice
so i never got into mysteries but
something about it feels very nostalgic
and comforting my one drawback i guess i
would say
is that like
especially when you go on into a book
where agatha christie is writing in a
foreign country
like
there's some problematic elements but i
will say i was listening to the
audiobook and reading along physically
and in the physical version which is
obviously a new release they have
altered all of that they've pretty much
gotten rid of all of the like
bad phrasing that's used in the book and
replaced it and you can do that two ways
right it can be like it's like a is that
erasing the problematicness of agatha
christie
i would argue it's good because it's
like adapting these novels for a modern
audience and i mean i'm not i'm not like
saying we all say stuff that's bad but
i'm sure in like 80 years time or
whatever because it's like this is
written like 80 years ago there will be
certain things not that i really think
that we do but i think there will be
things are outdated perhaps not
problematic but they're outdated and i'm
glad they have
endeavoured to adjust that now people
have different opinions on that and i
think it is a nuanced conversation i
always think it's a nuanced conversation
that i try not to shy away from when i
do read ecuador christy i think some
people like don't mention it
but i'd always try to mention yeah
there's some parts of this if you listen
to audiobooks you're like hey girl that
would don't say that that is not good
there's a difference of course between
shitty because there's a few times
shitty characters in this say shitty
things i'm like well you're a shitty
person so like it's not
you know out of the realms but there's
other points where it's like in
the descriptions of stuff and that's
when i really have a problem so i would
just like warn against that if you're
listening to your audiobook that's
something that's gonna upset you be
warned of that but it had gotten rid of
pretty much one of it in the physical
version so yeah listen
we're gonna start now it is what time is
it it's five o'clock i need to edit a
bit more of this vlog and then i'm gonna
start the broken girls by simone james
our final book i'm so excited i want
mara to get a home run i want this to be
a five star i'm not accepting anything
less i don't know i just don't think
this is like great for me i don't want
to do it
i want to go home like i can't take the
pressure of it don't you think any job
interview
but if this gets a 3.5 or more mara's
top of the leaderboard i'm so happy mara
just gets what i want this is what i'm
saying this is why i watch every single
one of mara's videos without fail as
soon as it comes out because i just
think we have very similar reading
tastes so i'm very excited with my first
simone st james i don't really know much
about this so i'll check in with you
probably at halfway with my thoughts and
kind of a snapsees but um
yeah let's go get a final five star i'm
feeling i'm feeling like our luck is you
know luck is on our side
[Music]
oh my god okay so
i am currently actually hosting
you can't see my reading sprints for
becca's um becolathon which she's
running this weekend i'm hosting my
sprint spirit with nicole which are
going great there's so many of you here
i can't believe it and i've been reading
the broken girls and i've now reached
halfway
and
i'm loving it
oh my god okay it's happening everybody
stay calm what's the procedure everyone
what's the procedure
mara what are you doing to me honestly
this is like this is actually i can't
believe it i'm loving it so much so
basically in this we have two timelines
we have in the 1950s these four
roommates and we're getting each of
their perspectives like dotted around
these roommates at this boarding school
for troubled girls essentially and then
in the present day we're following this
journalist she's the only perspective we
have in the present day whose sister was
murdered on the grounds of this
abandoned boarding school 20 years ago
and she's trying to like um the the
school is being renovated so she's
looking into that and then her body is
found
at the boarding school during the
renovations and it's like
somebody say james
yeah
yeah
her descriptions
are incredible the way she describes
things are so vivid and atmospheric like
i'm i
i actually feel a bit overcome with how
much i am loving this and have loved all
the books in this video like what are we
gonna do what are we gonna do how how do
we move on from here i just need mara to
pick what i read every day apparently
the two timelines
equally interesting i'm equally drawn
into both of them and that like so very
rarely happens to me but because they're
kind of these two
independent stories i think i don't
often like flashbacks but these two
independent stories that intersect in
ways and relate in ways but they're not
dependent on one another to be
interesting i think that really helps
i'm just i just can't believe i'm liking
both timelines like equally and i'm so
excited to get back to either one this
is what when they do dual timeline
people are trying to do they want you to
be so excited to get back to the other
timeline or get back to the perspective
that you'll like want to read both quick
and they never do it they never do it in
the way i want but this book
is i've spoken about it before let me
know i love playing nancy drew back in
the day right i was a nancy duke early
when i was a kid me and my granddad used
to play it all the time together and
this has strong nancy drew vibes but in
like kind of disparate parts so in the
present day the journalist is doing all
this investigating and she just reminds
me nancy g like the way she's like
scouring through old records and like
calling people up on the phone oh my god
it's so cool in the audiobook when she
speaks to someone on the phone they
sound like they're on the phone like
it's kind of like grainy kind of sound
and in the past it's set in the 1950s
and so some of the language and like the
way they think and just particularly
like kind of phrases they use is very
like nancy drew and it's just giving me
it's giving me everything i've ever
wanted it's giving me antsy dream vibes
all right no i'm not gonna cry
okay what happened
maybe i'll cry i chase nancy drew vibes
i don't think you guys understand what a
big part i think it's probably why i
love mystery so much is my childhood i
didn't read mysteries but i played them
and it was just such a highlight of my
life i was playing these ncg games with
my granddad and i loved them so much and
they were so special to me
um the fact that it's giving me those
kind of vibes in separate parts
is great i also think the audiobook
narrator kind of somewhat reminds me of
the narrator of the nancy g audiobook
she just kind of has this old timey
sound to her i am just loving it the the
tension in between the kind of two
different timelines the different
mysteries that are in both of them are
so so interesting there's so many
different mysteries there's not like one
main mystery there's a lot of different
mysteries that you're constantly
thinking about and trying to make the
links between and there's a paranormal
element to this as well which i've heard
a lot about uh simone st james she
always has like a kind of speculative
element there's this element of this
ghost that that haunts the boarding
school when you don't know whether it's
is there a ghost or is there not a ghost
i don't know it's very very interesting
so i'm gonna go get back to the sprints
i've got an hour left of the sprints i
think i've got about two hours of the
book left so i should read the last i
should read another hour of the book on
the sprint and then i'll finish that off
after
and then i'll come chat to you and give
you my final thoughts and mara's final
rating but i think we can all agree it's
gonna be pretty high it's gonna be
pretty high
guys um i'm gonna cry
i'm gonna cry i'm not because
not well this book did make me cry
almost a couple times right but i'm not
gonna cry now because i'm sad
i'm
overwhelmed
i don't even know i know how to speak
the end of this vlog cut it cut it cut
the cameras i can't
cut the cameras
get it
i love this book so much
i
i love this book so much let's just get
out in the open we all know what that
means
i gave it five stars which means maura
has got
15 points maximum points i just actually
i can't believe it i can't look
i got
mara making me have the best reading
week of my life
that's it
i feel like we all need to take a moment
to bask before we even speak about this
let's bask in this moment
[Laughter]
[Applause]
[Music]
i've reached the point of the series
i've found my booktube twin
uh
like where do we go from here where does
this i mean if you know the buffy song
anyway does booktube test carry on have
we reached i never thought it would
happen i thought it was impossible i
don't think i've ever gotten three five
stars and a vlog in my life if you know
me better than me feel free to put the
archives but i don't think you can i
think there's a vlog where i've given
out three five stars
and that's what we did that's what we
did in this vlog mara is my booktube
twin mara gave me three five stars i
can't believe it i've never read three
five stars
in this quick succession i feel like my
whole reading year has been turned
around i feel like my life is about to
change like what has happened guys
what
mara got 15 points let's just look at
the board for a sec i mean come on i
mean come on
i can't breathe anyway uh let's talk
about the book i loved it
what a beautiful
haunting
book i just i can't believe it like i
said everything i said in the last clip
counts like the writing is beautiful but
i mean
the three five stars have given out this
vlog are so different the rook is like a
master class of detail
the death of the niles are master class
of quick fun entertainment while still
being so clever
this is a masterclass of really making
me feel so much and i i don't get
attached to characters very often but i
was so attached to particularly the
girls in the past in the 1950s and just
feeling so much for them even though it
was perhaps the lesser timeline i i
really cared for them so much and i just
thought this book was incredible
incredibly paced i couldn't stop reading
it the way everything came together i i
called a big kind of reveal that happens
at the end i think it is fairly obvious
about the whole book what's going on but
i didn't mind because i just thought it
was still kind of you know beautiful and
i that's how i would have wanted the
story to go even though i knew from
literally page 50 that that was what was
going to happen god what i can what can
i say what can i say about spawning is
here i try to gush about the book i'm
finding it very hard not to like spoil
things but i just loved every element of
it i mean what draw me to say i love it
i mean it's just called the broken girls
and i think [ __ ] i i i really love books
about women and girls and you know
whether that be non-fiction or fiction
um
i think it's really important to discuss
the
the [ __ ] hand that for many years women
and girls have been dealt in society and
i love fiction that does that
and um i just loved it i loved it it was
spooky it was haunting it has
that paranormal element which i've so
many times
i have read books that maybe you know
say they have a ghost in it or like i
think of white smoke oh it's got a
haunted house whatever but they never
follow through with the dramaticism that
i want and like it just it just gets
what i want it gets how i want
paranormal elements to be handled i mean
listen let's just say i can't even get
it i need to read this right now and i
need to pick up all of someone saying
james's other books like i'm in love
part of the reason i'm so overwhelmed is
because i'm like i have found i felt
even more like this than i did perhaps
with danny o'malley even though i love
the rook i feel like i found an author
that i just need to read all of her
books you know like an author that i
pick up every new release they come out
with like a ruth ware or a leigh bardugo
or a courtney summers or like these
people and i feel like you can see a lot
of themes running through the work that
i like that i just need to pick up and
read everything that they write so
i'm in shock i'm in shock i never
thought this would happen three or five
stars everyone let's just hold them all
up together these
three books
were incredible i loved them so much i
adored them you need to go away and read
all of them they're all great for so
many different reasons i mean i knew
mara wouldn't let me down but i didn't
know to this extent i really did not
know i can't believe it so i just need
mara to pick everything i read forever
evidently like
i need to call up mara and be like um
what should i read today tell me thank
you for watching this video if you got
into the end let me know what do you
think we should do with the series now i
mean i want to carry it on because i
love doing this series so much but i'm
like what's the point we've i mean do we
just find another twin do we do we
rename it booktube triplet test i mean
what am i supposed to do if you've
gotten to the end of this video
comment the broken heart emoji because
that's how i'm feeling
right now and it's full of broken girls
so comment the broken heart emoji if
you've got on the end thank you guys so
much for watching uh i hope you enjoyed
this vlog and i'll see you very soon in
another one bye
[Music]
you
