hm it seems we have a mystery on our
heads Hello friends today we can to be
doing a video I do every single year
where I basically chat through all the
murder mysteries I've read in the past
year that I would recommend to each and
every person out there I do this video
around this time every single year and
it's basically looking back on every
single m m in the past year and any that
I gave a four star or above I want to
recommend to you I read 29 murder
mysteries in the past year and here
we've got 12 that I'd really recommend
which is kind of sad cuz that's like a
50% success rate but well not really
because there's books I gave a 3.5 or
even a three which is passable but this
is anything that I would really
recommend that's a four star above that
I think is really good quality D has
come to stand next to me filming this
hello you want to say hello you can just
stand here if you
want come on you love the camera don't
you you love it
oh my God look at her face I can't take
it but yes as someone who I think I I
don't want to call myself a murder
mystery expert but I'm quite the coniss
set of murder mysteries this is any that
I would really recommend that you pick
up also there's some here that like you
know Murder Mystery is a bit of a
nebulous thing nowadays some books kind
of skirt the line have combinations of
other things with a murder mystery this
is anything that I think you know is
close enough to a murder mystery to make
the list but before we get into it I
just want to give a brief shout out to a
partner I've been working with a lot
magic mind which I absolutely adore they
do these mental performance shots that
I've honestly had such a brilliant
brilliant reaction to they reduce my
stress I find I'm so much more
productive when I use them and I've got
a code that you guys can take advantage
of which is books 20 and that will get
you up to 48% off the first subscription
for the next 10 days or 20% off for a
onetime purchase okay let's get into the
books the first one is right here behind
me but I can't get it out of the book
without like 20 it's there okay and all
of these would need to come out and all
of these would need to come out in order
to get this one out and I'm not doing it
part of me thinks I can't really be
bothered just rather eat my meal and go
home the bookshelves are in aate but I'm
going to be gone soon um teaser you'll
find out in my next next video next next
video more about that let's not talk
about that yet it's right here I
couldn't I couldn't get it out but it is
when the stars go dark by Paula mlan now
I am going in order of like when I read
them so I read this I think in February
last year it's been a while and this one
is a little bit of a police procedural
murder mystery you've got I believe kind
of girls that are going missing and
there was a detective brought into the
town to kind of uncover what's going on
and it's you know it's a fairly typical
plot right there's nothing I don't think
special about the plot but what I did
think was special about this book is it
had an intelligence to it it had an
Integrity to it it had like a maturity
to it it's not like a silly fun time
like a lot of Mur Mysteries and which I
enjoy also but it just I think it was
written very well I think it was paced
very well like this is like I gave this
four stars right and I read it so long
ago and I do think it's a bit
forgettable because of the nature of the
plot being so like done but I almost
think that was purposeful that it was
like a very generic plot but I think
it's almost like done very well you know
like it's done to a great standard is it
going to blow your socks off absolutely
no but if you're looking for something
along those lines detective with a past
you know in the town and girls going
missing and like a true crime element
and like all these elements I think it
does them all almost perfectly you know
so I don't have a ton to say about that
one cuz I did read it a long time ago
but I did really enjoy it then we have
Night film by Marisha pestle now this
one I would yeah it's a murder mystery
we have got Ashley Cordova who is the
daughter of a very very well-known
underground horror film director is
found murdered and we are following
through the eyes of an investigative
journalist who spent a lot of time kind
of examining this family's history and
this family's secrets and you know it's
a chonka this book is how long like 560
Pages almost 600 pages but I do think
this is this is like you know a bit of a
magnumopus of a book I say this often I
love a book where you can tell so much
has been poured into it I think of Babel
by a of Quang I think of the secret
history I think of like what else what
big books that just like they don't have
to be long but they feel like they
Katherine ardan's books they often feel
like this they felt they feel big they
feel like a lot's been poured into them
right and I feel like a lot has been
poured into this one it is semi mix
media I don't want to show you too much
but there's like web files for some of
it although the majority of it is kind
of a narrative but like there's more
like Wikipedia pages and stuff it is
long it probably could be trimmed a
little bit and the ending is a little
bit crazy but it's a book that you read
and just go like wow like you could have
taken 10 years to write this and I feel
like it would have been worth it you
know what I mean so yeah if you're
looking for something a little bit mixed
media a little something that's a little
bit unusual you know I think there's a
lot of things that it plays with that
isn't typical in a book I think this is
a very unique book so they're kind of
like polarizing opposite when the skars
go dark it's very generic book done well
I think this is a very unique
interesting you know clever and like you
know unique way right pushing the
boundaries of stuff book but I I kind of
would almost recommend them to the same
people I think I read them around a
similar time to one another and I feel
very similarly about them but they are
so different but they're just both doing
what they set out to do very very well
next I have got the two lady hard
castles I read this year I wasn't
expecting that at all we've got number I
don't know what numbers they are N9 and
10 maybe in the lady Hard Castle series
I think I gave both of these
4.5s I love these if you are watching
this video looking for a cozy murder
mystery and you have not even tried out
the lady Hard Castle series yet please
what are you doing switch off the video
right now I don't care about any other
book if you're looking for a cozy
historical murder mystery look no
further you need to read anything else
being deadly serious I love it I mean
I'm I'm so passionate about it I love
this series so much I always say listen
to the audio books the audio books are
like the peak of how to read these books
the audio book is the Audi book narrator
is incredible but we're following lady
Hard Castle and flow her made flow as
they solve murder mysteries together and
one of these was a apple orchard right
I'm pretty sure they are CER related
murgers taking place and an acto F play
is like a theater death and then just so
fun I love them they're like my comfort
books they're pet cleansers I I just
adore them guys I love these books so so
much I have so much fun with them
they're just always a wonderful time I
can guys if you have followed me for
like longer than like 6 months and you
haven't tried out a lady hard cost yet I
fly don't know what you're doing like I
don't know what your game plan is in
life we need this this is essential this
is a crisis just pick up the audio book
of a quiet life in the country my
favorite one is maybe even still the
second one I love the second one in the
series and just the deeper you get the
more Comfort these characters give you I
just love them love them love them love
them love them next we have a few
actually a lot of the rest of these are
like 2024 releases apparently 2024 was a
good year for for M Mysteries we have
got first Miss Austin investigates I
think this was maybe the first 2024
release I bought last year I remember
vividly going in and buying this it's
Jane Austin solving a murder mystery
yeah it's just a fun silly fun time this
is the four star for me a lot of these
actually they're coming up with like
solid solid four stars so me how many
five stars do we have on the list one
one we have one five star a couple 4.5
so a couple four point fers but we have
one four five star but I'm picky what
can I say I'm picky when it comes to
murder mysteries I'm very very picky I'd
love to read more F that's kind of sad
though one five star M my I mean I
didn't have many Five Stars last year I
had like what 15
maybe 16 so like the odds aren't in the
favor anyways yeah this is Jane Austin
solving a murder mystery and her brother
actually her brother in real life it's
all like her real family and real life
of the characters and this and one of
her brothers had learning difficulties
and he is framed for the murder in this
one or like you know the police want to
accuse him of being the murderer and so
she gets involved with solving it
because she doesn't want she knows her
brother is innocent basically and I
loved it it's just so fun it's so fun
reading Jane Austin so it's like my two
worlds colliding I mean how there been a
book that's more Made For Me Jane Austin
solving murder mysteries I don't think
so I think this is it but yeah I just
loved it I had so much fun I do think
the writing this is a bit debuty so I
would prepare yourself for that like
this is a debut and at times I think you
could tell that but if you love Jane
Austin and you love Mur Mysteries you
have to read this it's a fun silly goofy
fun time right it's not going to win the
book of prize you know
it's no no no sh
um no no no sh it is what it is right
you know what this is when you look at
it but I really enjoyed also just how
much her real family brought into this
her cousin who played a big part of her
life like I think if you're looking to
read more stuff it's not just Jane
Austin thrown in as a character right
like it's set at the school that her
parents ran and you know all of her
family and the stuff that her family
went on to do it's set a very specific
time in history and there's stuff that
went on happened to her family that is
kind of hinted at so I think if you're
looking I mean obviously it's not
non-fiction but if you've read some
nonfiction about Jane Austin I think you
would really benefit from this because
you'll kind of see what she's doing with
all the characters and siblings you know
Jane had like so many siblings so I
really really enjoyed it I had a lot of
fun reading it then we have how to solve
your own Murder By Christian parin this
was another release that came out last
year made it into the good read Choice
Awards I didn't read it then I read it
near the start of the year in the 1950s
a woman is told you're going to be
murdered babe you're going to be
murdered she spends her whole life
trying to figure out who's going to
murder her keeping like inform on
everyone in her life keeping documents a
crime board and then she's murdered
shock horror she's murdered when she's
like 80 or something and her great niece
arrives from London and ends up trying
to solve it again this is a debut I feel
like you can see that in some of the
writing and I do feel like it's a little
bit forgetable I've read a lot in the
past year of like cozy quaint English
town murder mysteries and I just feel
like I imagine the town the same in my
brain I have like I can picture it now I
have a cozy quaint English town murder
mystery setting like The Magpie murder
is another one and I I I can then
confuse them in my brain because I've
imagined them the same does that make
sense for
what I'm
you there were times in this one I
remember the main character annoyed me
with like the decisions that she made or
like it would why am I telling you
negatives but anyways decision she made
or that she'd come to conclusions way
too easily I'd be like how you put two
two together and made eight that that's
what she would she was coming to
realizations that were correct but
without like earning it does that make
sense but for the most part I would say
this is a really fun cute quaint murder
mystery it's going to be a series just
like Miss Austin investigates are both
going to be series and I am going to
continue both this had a split timeline
but I enjoyed that element of it I
thought all the characters in the town
were very very interesting so yeah both
of these are just like cutesy again not
going to blow your socks off not going
to win the book of prize but fun then we
have a very unique one this is by far I
would say the most unique one on this
list we have the tainted Cup by Robert
Jackson Bennett now this is technically
class's fantasy I was in the fantasy
category for good re Choice Awards but
it's a murder mystery it's a Part
Sherlock Holmes murder mystery part
Fantastical and I really really enjoyed
this it's very very unique you're
basically following this guy who is the
Watson character in a Sherlock and
Watson Duo the um Sherlock kind of like
doesn't want to go places so she'll send
him and then he has to report back on
stuff that's happening an imperial
officer is found dead with a tree
spontane ously erupting from his body
and it takes them basically into like
this big city this investigation and
like all these people who have power
dynamics and the kind of politics of the
city and like all these different kind
of Fantastical elements there's a lot
thrown at you in this but from what I
understand the series is going to be
like episodic like different storyline
in each one and I just think this is
something very unique I love fantasy
Mysteries I love fantasy Mysteries not
even MD mystery some of my favorite
books are like fantasy with a mystery
EDG to it you know and I'm just so glad
that something like this is being
written it makes me happy that people
are like pushing the boundaries of what
the murder mystery genre could do and I
think if you're looking for a
Fantastical murder mystery this would be
one of my top recommendations it's again
it's a big book it's a heavy book
there's a lot going into it there's a
lot of characters I think I struggled
with the character names in this they're
very like Fantasy names you know and
sometimes my brain doesn't want to take
those in but again I thought the
character dyamics were very interesting
this I thought it was very well written
and I thought that the murder mystery
was you know interesting and interesting
resolution and I'm excited to see how
this series grows okay then we're going
to get into three books that I read for
the Good Choice Awards and loved we have
first the midnight Feast by Lucy Foley
Love It I Love Lucy Foley I'm a Lucy
Foley apologist she's incredible she's a
beautiful person her talent and
Brilliance is beyond I mean this this is
a four for me I given both the guest
list and the Paris apartment five but I
still had some I mean it's maybe this is
maybe a 4.5 actually if Hest with you I
just had a lot of fun I had a lot of fun
reading this this one God the thing
about Lucy f is she's going to do
unlikable rich people and she's going to
do a setting I love you know some of
Agatha's best books are like this a
setting for the murder mystery right
there's no Agatha on this I haven't read
a new Agatha in 2024 I didn't read like
a new Agatha novel I read I read a short
story collection and then I just read
Mur on the UR Express again in January
but I haven't read a new one I need to I
need to up my PR reading a little bit
but anyway sorry Lucy Foley does a
setting like Agatha merge on their
Express death on the Nile like so many
of her books have a great setting and
Lucy Foley oh it's set at this like new
rich person Hotel think about thisy oh
she has a finger on the pulse of what is
a signifier of wealth right and at the
moment it's like health and skin care
and like healthy food and like you know
access to food you know you know oh it's
so interesting I just think she's a
genius and we find out we have like
flash forwards to the next morning the
Sunday morning there's been a fire at
the hotel and a body has been discovered
on the beach and then we go back in time
and we're following all these different
perspectives of following the founder
the husband the mystery guests and the
kitchen help and she just I just love
the formula that Lucy Foley has to her
books this is just so Camp it's so silly
it's so fun it's so ridiculous I think
again the murder mystery is very very
well plotted I just love what she does I
love what Lucy frdy does I'm a Lucy frdy
apologist if I die I well I don't like
the hunting party I that's that's the
only one but I read it right after read
in the guest list and that's just not
not a fair comparison but I just think
if you I think if you enjoyed the guest
list you'll enjoy this I know the Paris
apartment people didn't love but I do
think this has just again just the
setting is so potent I can always smell
it I can always taste
it I can like a
smell Lucy finally does setting so well
I'm just thinking about that setting I'm
just there I feel transported I feel
there you know so if you're looking for
something with a strong setting this
would be my recommendation something
that does multiple perspectives with
short Snappy chapters just so
compulsively readable oh I just love
Lucy Foley love her love her then we
have my only five star in this video can
you guess what it is we all know what it
is Rich dosman we solve murders
absolutely absolutely I'm shocked this
is shocking new this is a start of a new
series from Rich Osman where we're
following father-in-law and
daughter-in-law Joo as they solve Murder
Mysteries and it's a bit more of a jet
setting you know they're traveling all
over the world
Espionage Crime Guys guys guys guys guys
I love Rich Osman we know this that's my
man that is my man he wants to marry
me I don't think I don't think it's
actually like a quantifier that can like
truly describe how much I love Richard
osman's books love love love love love
love love them like it's so deadly
serious to me I had so much fun in this
one you know I was worried you know what
was it going to be like going away from
the Thursday Murder Club and these
characters that we love but I really
feel like we got to know so many more
wonderful characters in this Steve and
Amy's relationship and kind of like how
emotionally suppressed they both are and
just the pace at which he moves he does
such short chapters I think I do love a
good short chapter like two page
chapters it just keeps the pace going
and like I would say I think one of the
most masterful things Richman does about
pacing is like there'll be three story
lines that we're following at any given
time we're like alternating between them
each chapter like 1 2 3 1 2 3 and maybe
this one Subs out like that one's done
and dealt with so another one comes in
and we're like constantly like
flittering and then this one comes out
and something else comes in like there's
so much movement and like jostling of
storylines and like topics and locations
and he does that so so well I love it I
love it if you haven't read Richman yet
I mean I don't know what we're doing
here but um do I love it quite as much
as the Thursday meta Club no that last
the last LEL to Die the most recent
Thursday meta Club one of the books I've
ever read like so so so good but this is
fun and I had a great time next we have
the final one from the good Rees video
we have listen for the Lie by Amy Tina
this is just a bit of a fun mixed medium
m mystery there's a podcast element to
this basically our protagonist was
accused of murdering her best friend but
she has no memory of the evening so she
kind of moved away from this town but
then stuff happens to bring her back and
at the same time there's a podcaster and
the audio book is mixed media covering
the case and trying to find out the
truth of what happened do I think this
is the perfect book No in fact I often
felt like it's a great book and it was
actively trying to like undo all the
good work it did I had a few issues with
like relationships in their or the
ending or just how certain things were
like enacted but again I would say if
you're looking for a page Turner murder
mystery with a podcast element if these
are buzzword to you if you're wanting
something quick if you're want something
with a bit of like an unreliable
narrator like she's kind of like Dead
Pan about like oh maybe I did kill my
best friend I don't know I can't
remember it you know what I mean like
Dead Pan about it it's a very
interesting book I'm intrigued about to
read for more from Amy tar in the future
cuz like I said there was so much I
loved about this but there was just also
like it just kept trying to [ __ ] it up
it just kept trying to like mess it up
but again I'm a sucker for a forecast
audio podcast element to a book I just I
mean that's already I'm probably going
to enjoy that book like I'm a sucker for
it it gets me gets me every single time
I'm what can I say I'm weak I'm weak and
easily manipulated I love it I love it
and it gives me that buzz it's it feeds
exactly what I want to do I think this
is a very again like some of these other
books very solid solid solid release
that I think most people will have fun
with then we have a very interesting one
this one was recommended to me by
Librarians where did librarian pix by
read video and I'd never heard of it and
this author is usually a male male
historical romance author and there's
hints of that in this but this is their
first murder mystery and I am like
praying that this author writes more
murder mysteries cuz I think this was
really wonderful I think this was a 4.5
for me it was so close to a five this is
death in the spires by KJ Charles where
it's trying to reheat some of the secret
history's natos it's trying to rehe it's
trying to steal the natos it's set in
kind of the late 1800s early 1900s and
in the previous timeline there was a
group of friends and one of them was
murdered at Oxford they were studying at
Oxford in like Victorian era one of them
was murdered and it drove the the
Friendship group apart I know we've
heard this plot many times and now one
of them is trying to uncover the truth
of what happened and again I just
thought this was like yes it was
reheating those naos but it was
reheating them perfectly perfectly
they're still crunchy there like it it's
it's yes it's something we before but it
was so fun to read this done well
there's also a little romance element in
this that I thought was really done well
and like constrained to the right amount
of the book it didn't overtake the book
the book was still about the murder
mystery but just this setting at Oxford
in the 1900s 18 late 1800s early 1900s
is so vivid again so like potent and I
thought the Friendship group was done
very well I thought the main character
had a very interesting voice and a very
interesting perspective and like
interesting
motivations yeah listen we've seen this
s before 10,000 times but I loved I had
so much fun reading it I couldn't put it
down I loved the writing style I really
enjoyed the writing style like I thought
this was so well written from this
author and that's why I'm begging
begging for more murder
mysteries what do we have here here
because I don't really like historical
romance I'm not a big historical romance
reader and so there's not many of this
author's other books that interest me
but oh my God like this is just so well
written such a such a well such a good
writer you know what I mean he's read
booking like you can [ __ ] write babes
you can [ __ ] write so loved it loved
it so much and then finally we got a bit
of a wild card at the end of the year I
read seven Christmas Murder Mysteries
and this is the only one that I gave a
four star or above which is not great
not great not great hopefully I love
Christmas M Mysteries well one of them
was a reread so there was two of them
you know but anyways we've got the
Christmas appeal By Janice halet I
really really enjoyed this this is a
christmy murder mystery there's a dead
center they're performing a panto I
thought it was very very christmy and
very very fun it's super short I think
if you're looking for a Christmas murder
mystery to read this year I think this
would be a great pick I do think you
should have read the appeal though to um
to fully appreciate it however I barely
remembered the appeal and it refreshed
me very well
and so I do think probably if you
haven't read it you could read this
although it would spoil some elements
from that kind of a little bit yeah just
the the act of them like putting on this
Pano and it's a dead center and it's
again it's all these emails if you don't
know Janice halet is all mixed media and
the appeal Series in particular is kind
of all emails and text messages and I
thought that worked better for me in a
shorter format the appeal is quite long
it's just a lot of emails I prefer if
it's mixed media to be like a variety of
mixed media whereas I didn't mind it all
just being emails in this because
because it's so short you know so the
pace of it was really really well done
so I had so much fun with this if you're
looking for a Christmas mder mystery
pick this one up so there we have it
friends that is all the best murder
mysteries I have wrote in the past year
hopefully when I do this next year we're
going to have more five stars hopefully
just in 2025 in general we will have
more five stars but U let me know if
you've read any of these and your
thoughts on them I would love to know
all of your opinions and thank you so
much for watching and I'll see you in
another video very soon bye
[Music]