Medigap Plan G vs Plan N Two Years Later
1 Video View·Oct 27, 2024
Hi, my name is Jim and I was retired. Have you ever wanted to go back in time to see if you
made the right decision? Well, in this week's video, I'm going to go back and look at the
decision I made two years ago to select Plan M for my Medigap plan. I did a spreadsheet at that
time to compare the options and in this video let's look at that choice between Medigap Plan G
versus Plan N two years later. Stay tuned. Now, this week's video is really a counterfactual.
You really don't need to shop for your Medicare supplement plans or Medigap during this annual
enrollment period, but December is also my anniversary month, so I have a rate increase
for my Plan N from Mutual of Omaha. It's going up four percent from $124 to $129 a month next year,
so what would I be paying if I had elected to stay with the more inclusive and more expensive
Plan G when I turned 65? When you sign up for Medicare, you are faced with your first choice.
Do you stick with original Medicare with a Part A for hospital care, a Part B for doctors and labs,
then you add a Part D prescription drug plan and your supplemental coverage or Medigap policy
to cover the 20 percent that Medicare doesn't cover, or on the right, do you go with Medicare
Advantage, a Part C that turns your Part A and Part B over to a private insurer,
which may also add a Part D drug coverage and other extra benefits, but if you go with the
Medicare Advantage route, you will not shop for a Medigap policy. Your Part C includes everything in
one managed care model. Now, if you do go with original Medicare, though, you will want to add
that Medigap policy unless you have retiree health care or a union plan that will pay the 20
percent balance. Now, Medigap options are all standardized by law and each known by a letter.
All insurers that offer a Plan A, for instance, must offer the same benefits, but insurers set
their own premiums, which vary by market. Now, two of those plans, Plan C and Plan F,
are no longer available to those who joined Medicare after January 1st of 2020, so I've
shaded out those from this graphic from medicare.gov, and that leaves you with the rest of
Of those, Plan G and Plan N are the most popular. Medigap Plan G, which offers the broadest set of
benefits, covers everything but the Part B deductible. In fact, part of the decision to
take Plan C and F off the list is that Congress didn't want Medigap plans to cover the Part B
deductible, which should be your co-pay for the medical care that you're getting. So, Plan G is
now the most popular and most expensive in most markets. Here in New Jersey, premiums start at
$153 a month for somebody my age. Plan N covers everything that Plan G covers except Part B
excess charges, and it uses modest co-pays of $20 for an office visit or $50 for ER.
In exchange for those co-pays, monthly premiums start at about $112 or about 25% less than Plan G.
Now, some are scared off by this not paying for excess charges, the fees in excess of Medicare
assignment, but Medicare.gov offers a very easy way to ensure that your doctors accept
Medicare assignment and agree not to bill you those excess charges. Also, Kaiser Family
Foundation reports that only about 1% of doctors have opted out of Medicare and don't accept
Medicare assignment. When I did my original research in Medigap plans, I also looked
at the Plan G high deductible, which offers much lower monthly premiums in exchange for a
high deductible. Now, that's linked to inflation and it goes up each year,
and you have to pay all of that before the insurance kicks in. Now, if you'd like to see
why I did not elect this route, please go to my earlier video here. Now, I found this study in
the Congressional Research Services Report on Medigap that reports the enrollment trends in
recent years, and the most popular plans are Plans F for those who still have it. Again, if you were
on it before 2020, you're allowed to keep it. Plan G for those joining Medicare after 2020,
and Plan M. Now, I plugged these numbers into a chart to show you the slow decline of Plan F in
red from about half in 2018 to 41% in 2021. You can also see the growth in Plan G in light blue
from about 17% to 32%, and a steady 10% of enrollees who use Plan M with its modest co-pays
in the dark blue. Here's a spreadsheet that I used two years ago when I did my original Medigap
shopping and looked at the choices between G, G high deductible, and N, and I've narrowed the
choice down to just comparing G and N to see what would have happened. If you could see,
the monthly premium average that I was being quoted for G was $158.83, and the average premium
that I was being quoted for N was $116.08. That's a $42.75 difference between the two,
recognizing that under Plan N, you'd have these co-pays, modest cost sharing of $20 for an office
visit and $50 for an emergency room visit. Well, if you look at the annual premiums just of the
Medigap policy, you could see G would be running you $1906, let's call it, and N would be running
you $1393, and that's like a difference of $513 a year in the two Medigap policies. And if you
just looked at that and then divided $20 into that, you would have to have 25.65 office visits a year
to come up to where you'd be spending as much as Plan G. So that's one part of the equation.
Now, in a lot of my spreadsheets, I use one tab for input to put in some key variables in what
I'm trying to study. And here is a version of what I did two years ago, again, narrowed down
to just the choice between G and N. And these are those monthly premiums. And then I assumed
originally that I'd be seeing the doctor about twice a year, maybe two specialists a year.
And I'll allow one ER. I would tell you in the last two years, I haven't been to an ER,
so that was like padding the estimate a little bit. I'll also say that these two visits,
total of four visits, that would be times 20 under Plan N is also overstating it,
and I'll get to that in a minute. I had some CPIU and average CPIU for long-term projections of
costs. That's next year's Part B deductible, which you're going to pay under either plan,
and that's next year's premium. Again, you're going to pay that premium in addition to the
Medigap policy each month. When I did this two years ago, I used the same guess for a increase
in premiums, 4.5% a year for both plans. And I've been doing some work to understand if that's the
case or whether I should change it. And one of the things I came up with was this CGS actuarial,
which has tracked rate increases for a number of carriers and then averaged them out. And this is
part of a workbench that brokers actually use when they tell you what the average rate increases are
in a particular zip code. But for a national average, this is the report, and it showed that
G here had increases with a five-year average of 4.96, and Plan N had increases with a five-year
average of 3.64%. And the trend, if you see, is that N has been declining and G has been
increasing in their national average picture. And so rather than using the same price increase for
Medigap, my study is going to use two separate. And those are the inputs here. I'm going to use
an average increase of 4.96% for G and 3.64% for N. And then I'm going to run the comparing
spreadsheet again with those two models. This was going back to age 65. And we'll say these are the
actual Part B premiums for the last few years, the one for next year. And then these are the
trustee report estimates for the next few years until it gets down to here. And then it's going
to use an estimate above that where it's going to use the projected increase of using an average.
And then I'm using for G, I'm using specific percentage increases for G
and a specific increase for N. Now, those are the monthlies. These are the annual figures for the
Part B premium that you're going to pay under either Medigap plan, the annual for G, the annual
for N. You'll also have to pay the deductible. And so the next columns over here include the total
health care costs for Plan G with the Part B added. And then the total health care costs for
Part N with co-pays added. And going back to that formula, I'm going to edit the formula here to show
you it. So this formula adds up the deductible, the annual Plan N premium, and the annual Part B
premium. And then it adds $20 times the sum of these inputs. And again, those are the office
visits back on the input screen, as well as $50 times the input of ER visits. And again, I think
I'm padding it a little bit, and I'll explain in a moment. I haven't had an ER visit in the last
two years. So right there, it's $50 off for the last two years. And so this adds the figure for
Plan N. And then it has two running totals here. And it comes down to these charts here. This is
the annual numbers. Experience has been here. And then I'm going to let inflation pick up.
You'll see the green line never catches up to the blue line, and is always going to be less
expensive than G in the projected future. And on the cumulative totals, you can see you're going
to save significantly under Plan M. Now, this is the cumulative premiums only through age 80 for
Plan G and Plan N. Now, in both cases, I'm looking at the cumulative premiums only
through age 80 for both the Medigap policy, either Plan G or Plan N, and the Part B
premiums that you'll be paying. And here is the adding in the out-of-pockets, particularly for
Plan N. Even adding those modest co-pays that I put in there, you're saving about $12,000 by age
80 by going with Plan N. Unless you are visiting doctors more than twice a month, the premiums
plus the co-pays under Plan N will not surpass the higher premiums of Plan G.
But if you are seeing doctors that often, maybe Plan G is right for you. But if you're only seeing
doctors several times a year, the savings will be well worth the modest co-pays. Now, I mentioned
when I did this study two years ago that the other key ingredient for Plan N versus the Plan G
high deductible was that the high deductible figure will be inflated every year with CPIU,
the Consumer Price Index for Urban Workers. But the modest co-pays of $20 for an office visit
and $50 for an ER are hard-coded into legislation. They do not adjust each year. And therefore,
you're going to have some inflation protection in those modest co-pays going forward.
There is one theory that Plan G, because it is a guaranteed issue plan, and that means anybody
who falls into the guaranteed issue categories, and that's the first six months of enrollment
in Medicare. Plus, if you lose coverage in certain circumstances, an insurer offering a Plan
G must accept you with no medical underwriting. Plan N is not a guaranteed issue plan.
So except for those six months around Medicare enrollment, every time you select Plan N,
you would need medical underwriting to get into the plan. And those risk pools may mean that Plan
G will see higher increases in the future. I really don't know whether Plan N will see
more modest price increases compared to Plan G. Time will tell. But for now, I'm still very
pleased with my experience with Plan N. I will also tell you that in doing this research for
this video, I asked people who were out there on Plan G what kind of experience that they've had
in the last few years. The more important ingredient was the insurer they selected.
And that's why a broker, a national broker that represents multiple companies with good data sets
can give you the guidance to select a company that is known for only one rate increase a year,
modest increases, and has been in the business for a long time, not somebody who's getting in
with a low price and may not be here tomorrow. So using a broker to select your Medigap policy
is probably the best thing you could do. Select the right insurer. But if you've got a choice
between a Plan G and a Plan N with a quality insurer, go with the Plan N. Hey, please like
and subscribe to this channel if you like entertaining ideas from a DIY retiree. I'm
not selling a course. I'm not a Medicare broker. I'm just a consumer sharing my perspective to
help you plan for your own DIY retirement. I will conclude with my standard warning. I have
no initials after my name. So take these as entertaining ideas from one educated consumer
to another. Always do your own due diligence and seek out a professional if you need one. See ya.

