Is A High Deductible Medicare Supplement Plan Right For You?
3 Video Views·Oct 8, 2024
Here is what you need to know about that high deductible supplement plan that you may have
been hearing about. High deductible plan G is getting more and more buzz in the Medicare world
and for good reason. Now there is a high deductible plan F as well but this video is specifically
around the plan G. It is a Medicare supplement plan that works similarly to regular plan G with
a major exception. High deductible plan G has well a high deductible meaning before your plan
will start helping you pay for things you are going to need to spend a little bit out of pocket.
Now before you stop this video and run to talk to your agent about this plan I'm going to go
through the strengths and weaknesses of this specific plan and should we start with the good
news or the bad news first. Let's start with the good news first. The good news with the high
deductible plan G is that the monthly premiums are significantly lower than the regular plan G
or plan N options. The average regular plan G nationwide for a 65 year old is around $130
per person per month. Plan N is around $100 per month. I say this in all of our videos but if
this is your first video with us these numbers vary dramatically depending on where you live.
In some places plan G and plan N start at around $300 per month. The high deductible plan G
that's coming in with an average around $60 per month. Using the averages you're saving around
$800 per year in premiums versus regular G and around $500 per year versus a plan N. Compound
that over 20 years and it can be a significant number. Another strength of the high deductible
plan G is the fact that you still have original medicare where you can still visit any provider
or facility as long as they have not completely opted out of medicare. This is about 99% of all
non-pediatric providers nationwide. In the event that you do visit a provider that does not
participate with medicare but has not fully opted out of medicare you could see excess charges that
plan N does not cover but this high deductible plan G would cover after you've met that deductible.
If you have a health savings account or HSA you can use those HSA dollars to pay for that
deductible. You cannot use them to pay the high deductible plan G premiums but you can use the
HSA dollars for the deductible. Okay now let's move to some of the weaknesses. The glaring weakness
is that deductible and look if nothing goes wrong you don't have any medical issues this is great
but if you do need to use the healthcare system in 2024 you are paying $2,800 before your supplement
plan starts to help. Now there is some confusion as to how this all works so let's go through it
with an example. Let's say that you have $50,000 in total medicare approved medical bills. This
means part b for those who want to get specific. This may not be all in one bill it may be spaced
out over the year but for kicks and giggles in this video we're going to pretend like it's all
one bill because that will be more simple. Original medicare does not start to cover part b expenses
until you meet your part b deductible. In 2024 the part b deductible is $240. So you pay $240 first
you now have $49,760 remaining on this bill. Well original medicare takes 80%. You and your
high deductible plan g will handle the other 20%. 80% of $49,760 is $39,808
leaving you and your plan responsible for the remaining $9,952. And how does that get split
between you and your plan? Well you have that $2,800 high deductible. Fortunately the $240
that you paid as the part b deductible earlier counts to that number so you have $2,560 left
on your deductible. Of the $9,952 you need to first write a check. Wait are we still writing
checks today? You need to pay the $2,560 however you choose to pay that first before your plan
will step in. Once you pay that the high deductible plan g takes care of the remaining $7,392 plus if
you have any more approved part b expenses that year from providers who have not opted out of
medicare your original medicare and your high deductible plan g are taking care of those 100%
until the next year on January 1st when your high deductible starts over. That's one example. A
weird wrinkle here is that in that $240 part b deductible counting towards your $2,800
high deductible I was specific in saying part b expenses earlier for a reason. If you are admitted
into a hospital those are now part a expenses. Part a is your hospital coverage. Part b is your
medical coverage. And if you meet your high deductible that $2,800 with part a expenses
the $240 part b deductible does not go towards that $2,800. So again you meet the $2,800 with
part a expenses then later you have part b expenses you need to pay the $240 out of pocket
bringing the total out of pocket costs from your deductibles for you to $3,040 instead of just the
$2,800. Okay I have two more weaknesses for high deductible plan g and then I'll share our
experience with those who have chosen high deductible plan g. So another weakness is that
they are not available everywhere. Insurance companies that offer medicare supplement plans
must offer the 10 standardized plans. They do not have to offer the high deductible version. So in
our state as an example most of the insurance companies do not even offer a high deductible
plan g. Only one of the major carriers does and it doesn't really have much traction here. So this
may not be available where you live. The last weakness isn't specific to this plan but to all
supplement plans high deductible plan g does not cover prescription medications, dental, vision,
or hearing aids. So if you want coverage for those you would need to purchase separate plans
that each have their own premiums, deductibles, co-pays, and co-insurance out of your pocket
dollars. Okay let's look at a couple real world numbers that will help illustrate whether or not
this plan will make sense for you. Remember using the averages regular plan g would cost about $800
more per year in premiums and plan n was about $500 more per year in premiums. But if you have
a year where you hit your high deductible you're losing almost $1,800 compared to regular plan g
because of that high deductible and then you would be losing about $2,000 versus plan n. You
just wiped out over two years worth of premium savings versus a regular plan g and four years
of your premium savings versus a plan n in one bad year with the high deductible plan g. And
that's assuming a year where you hit your full deductible. We used a $50,000 expense. It only
takes a bill of $13,040 to hit your full high deductible plan g deductible. $13,000 even with
heavily discounted medicare approved rates really isn't a lot to push you into fully hitting that
deductible. The break even point is $4,000 in total bills meaning if you have $4,000 in approved
medicare part b costs using our averages you will break even with a regular plan g versus a high
deductible plan g. Any bills over $4,000 and regular plan g is saving you money. For plan n
that number is just $2,500 in total bills to break even every year. Anything over $2,500
and you are saving money with plan n in that year. If you have multiple bad years in a row or even two
to four years costs can get tough. Now our experience with the clients who choose high
deductible plan g has been that this plan either works great for people because they don't have
health issues not just when they start medicare but moving into their older years and they have
a sizable hsa balance. High deductible plan g is a strong setup for those who fit this description.
On the other hand and this happens more than we wish it did people go into this plan bright
and bushy tailed but as soon as things start to go wrong and it doesn't take too much as I showed
with those numbers that high deductible becomes really frustrating and can quickly exceed the
savings that you are enjoying compared to regular plan g or plan n. Especially those who either do
not have an hsa or they do but it doesn't have much money in it. So look I'm not trying to
discourage you from a high deductible plan g this is just our experience that many jump into this
bills happen and then they want to switch to the regular g or the plan n but doing so can
be tricky depending on where you live. Very similar hoops to jump through as switching
from an advantage plan to a supplement plan. If you're hearing about this high deductible
supplement plan out there now you know more than you probably wanted to know and I think you're
going to want to check out this video right here if you haven't already because we looked at the
costs of a regular plan g a high deductible plan g and an advantage plan over 20 years
to try to get an idea around how much medicare will cost you throughout retirement
rather than just one year I will see you over there

