Plan G vs Plan N....which is better?
Oct 24, 2024
Plan G versus Plan N, which is better?
Hi, this is Kathy Bukowski.
I'm the owner of CB Health Insurance
and CB Health Insurance YouTube channel.
In today's video, we're gonna answer that question.
But first, don't forget to subscribe to our channel.
Hit the little bell so you get future notifications
when we release new videos, which is about twice a month.
Don't forget to tell your family and friends
and give us a thumbs up if you like this video.
Now onto today's video.
Plan G or Plan N, which one is better?
First of all, what are we talking about?
We're talking about Medicare supplements.
Medicare supplements, they have standardized policies.
Plan G is one of them, Plan N is another.
People that are enrolled in original Medicare
through the government, Plan A and Plan B,
can buy a supplement.
And when can they do that?
Well, when they first become eligible or at any time.
But we're gonna talk about which one is better.
And not only that,
but why would you consider one over the other
and who might consider one over the other?
So, first, I think most people
will agree with this statement.
Plan G is considered to be the best plan
that you can buy currently.
When I say currently,
it covers the most benefits that you can buy.
And that's for anybody that turns 65 after
and became eligible for Medicare after 2020.
Prior to 2020, there was a plan
that was a little bit better than G called Plan F.
And while it has not gone away,
people that were eligible for Medicare before 2020
can still purchase it, they can still enroll in it,
they can still keep that plan.
Those individuals turning 65 after 2020
cannot buy Plan F, right?
So Plan G is currently the best plan out there.
Plan N is really a cost savings option.
When we say cost savings, what does that mean?
It means the premium is lower, right?
So you're gonna save money on the monthly premium.
But, oh, by the way, it has less benefits.
So let's take a look at, is the premium worth the savings?
And I think in order to analyze that,
we really need to take a look at what is the difference
before we even look at the cost.
So take a look at this.
So here we have all of the Medicare supplements,
A, B, C, D, that you can buy.
And you'll notice the far right-hand column,
you see that in order to buy Plan C or F,
you had to be eligible for Medicare prior to 2020.
So I've highlighted Plan G and I've highlighted Plan N.
Plan G is, quote, the best plan
because it literally covers everything
except, oh, by the way, it doesn't cover one thing,
the Medicare Part B deductible.
What is the Medicare Part B deductible?
Well, it's the annual deductible
that you must meet for any outpatient services
before Medicare starts kicking in.
The government sets this each year.
For 2024, it's $240, but it does go up each year.
Now, $240, if you have Plan G, is the only deductible
that you have for any outpatient services.
And quite frankly, this is a lot lower
than many individual policies or group health insurance plans.
I think on the individual market,
the lowest deductible you can buy is $750.
So $240 is what it currently is at.
It does go up every year.
Now, Plan N, we talked about, has a cost savings options
and because of that, it has less benefits.
So what are the less benefits?
First and foremost, it introduces some copayments.
Oh, by the way, it also does not cover
the Part B deductible.
So that's the same, right?
Plan G and Plan N, they both have,
you meet that Part B deductible.
But N introduces copayments and what are they?
So let's take a look at the details here.
What you would have to pay is if you see a physician
for an office visit, and it can be a primary doctor,
it can be a specialist,
you're gonna pay a $20 copay each and every time.
If you end up in ER, an emergency room,
now this is outpatient, you're gonna pay a $50 copay
at any emergency room visit.
That copay will be waived if you are admitted
to the hospital, right?
And then Part B doesn't apply,
this is your outpatient, Part A would apply.
So it would be waived if you were admitted.
But what we're talking about is outpatient ER.
There's a $50 copay.
The second thing that is different is that,
well, there's two different copays, right?
So that's one and two.
The third thing that is different is this excess fees.
What are we talking about?
What are excess fees?
Excess fees are what physicians and providers,
doctors and other physicians are allowed to charge
over and above the reimbursement that they get
for any given procedure from the government, from Medicare.
When you're on Medicare, you can go to any doctor
that agrees to accept Medicare,
and they're gonna get reimbursed per procedure
X number of dollars.
The government sets it, right?
They can't really negotiate.
And the government does index it,
so it does keep pace with inflation.
But a lot of physicians get paid a lot more
when you're on private insurance versus on Medicare.
And so within the law, they are allowed to charge 15%
over and above the reimbursement
that they get from the government.
It's called the excess fees.
When you're on Plan G, that's paid at 100%.
You don't have to worry about it.
However, when you're on Plan N, that is not covered.
So what you should do if you're considering Plan N
is ask your physician, do you take Medicare assignment?
What is Medicare assignment?
That basically says, do you agree to accept
the reimbursement that you're getting from the government
and not balance bill me the excess fees, which is 15%.
And that could really add up.
If you are considering that,
you should really talk to your physician about that.
Now, let's look at premiums.
How much savings are we talking about?
Premiums are based on a couple of things.
One, your age, right?
How old you are is gonna vary the premium.
Two, male or female, right?
Typically males are more money, unfortunately.
Smoker, nonsmoker, and yes, the insurance companies
are allowed to charge smokers more money, and they do often.
And then your zip code, where are you located?
Where do you live?
So these numbers are based on Illinois.
That's where I'm located.
They can vary by state and they can vary by county.
This is DuPage County.
I happen to do a female nonsmoker,
and I wanted to take a look at what is the differential
between G and N at age 65, age 75,
and if somebody was under 65,
because those premiums are a lot higher.
So what is the savings gonna be?
So at age 65, Plan G is around,
and I checked the top carriers
and I just went with the lowest cost one,
and I stuck with the same carrier.
So Plan G is about 120, just under $123 a month.
Plan N at age 65 is a little over $87 a month.
The savings per month is $35,
which equates to $422 a year.
Moving from G to N, that's the difference at age 65.
At age 75, premiums about 159.
Plan N, for Plan G, excuse me,
Plan N is about 114, savings about $45 a month,
which is about $541 a year.
Plan G to Plan N.
Savings.
Under 65, Plan G is $325 a month.
Plan N is 241.
Savings is $84 a month.
It's over $1,000 a year savings.
Wow, that's pretty big.
So who would do this?
Why would you do this?
One, you're looking to save money, right?
And two, you still want that freedom
to choose any provider in the country that you,
because when you're on original Medicare,
you can go to anywhere in the country.
There's not a network.
Anybody that takes Medicare, anywhere in the US.
And three, you're trying to save enough money.
You're analyzing, is it worth it for me to have the savings?
Because, oh, by the way, I'm giving something up.
So if you look at, for an example,
an example would be, let's say you go to the doctor
on average 10 times a year.
You see your primary doctor for an annual physical.
You do a checkup.
You go to the dermatologist.
You might have an allergist.
Maybe you have a specialist like a cardiologist
that you see four times a year.
You have certain tests that you do every year.
And of course that requires a doctor's visit
to review the test.
So let's just say on average 10 times a year.
Remember, if you move to plan N,
you have that $20 doctor office co-pay.
So $20 times 10 is 200.
If you're saving $400 a year, but you have to pay 200,
is it worth it?
So, you know, some people say yes, some people say no.
Remember, you also have that $50 co-pay for emergency,
outpatient emergency.
So that's another factor.
Most people don't plan on going to ER,
but that could be an additional cost.
And last but not least,
does your doctor take Medicare assignment?
So those are the things you need to look at.
When would you consider the difference?
And when should you shop?
Well, clearly when you're in your initial enrollment period,
your IEP, that's when you turn 65
and sign up for Medicare
and enroll in a supplement for the first time,
or you could be retiring over 65
and enrolling in Medicare Part B for the first time.
And oh, by the way, in either of those examples,
when you enroll in Medicare Part B at 65 or older,
it's a federal law,
you have a six month open enrollment period
when you can buy a Medicare supplement, no questions asked.
It's what we call guaranteed issue.
They cannot decline you.
They cannot ask you medical questions.
They can ask you smoke or non-smoker,
but they cannot decline you.
Outside of that initial period,
it is not guaranteed issue.
So the other time you would shop
would be outside of your initial period.
And by the way, Medicare is not,
Medicare supplements are not a Medicare program.
Medicare is ABCD through the government.
A Medicare supplement is supplemental insurance
that picks up where Medicare leaves off.
So it is not a guaranteed issue product
that you can shop during the annual Medicare open enrollment
that happens every fall.
You can shop a Medicare supplement all year round.
And when most people do that is when they get rate increases
because these premiums go up every year.
So you don't wanna shop every year,
but if you get a significant increase,
and some people have been on a supplement for 10 years,
and guess what?
The price of everything is going up.
So now they're looking to shop.
You'll wanna talk to a broker
because it's not guaranteed issue.
And so you need to find out, can I go through underwriting?
Can I switch to another company?
Now, there are some states
that have guaranteed issue products.
We have one in Illinois that you can buy anytime.
The question is, is there premium savings to move to that?
The second thing is that some states
have passed birthday rules and they vary by state.
So in the state of Illinois, we passed a birthday rule
that lets you within the same company, XYZ company,
move from one plan to a lesser plan
near your birthday guaranteed issue.
So you can literally go from G to N, no questions asked
if your health is an issue
and you're not gonna go through underwriting.
So you'll wanna talk to a broker
and see if you can do that.
Now, if you're under 65,
your initial enrollment period
is when you're eligible for Medicare the first time.
And the same thing applies.
You have a six month window to buy a policy guaranteed issue
but somebody under 65 has a second IEP when they turn 65.
So you have the opportunity to shop guaranteed issue,
no questions asked, a second time in your life.
Now, why would you do this?
Maybe at age 40 or 45, whenever you qualify for Medicare,
you buy a cheaper plan, plan N.
This is not as rich because you're trying to save money.
But when you turn 65, those premiums go down,
it behooves you to shop
and you might wanna buy the better policy, plan G
and see which carrier is the best at that time
because who knows, we don't have a crystal ball
and they change their rates every year.
So that's another time to shop.
Now, plan G versus plan N, which is best?
Well, we know for a fact that plan G
is considered the quote, best plan.
It has the richest benefits.
Currently, plan N is a money saving option
but when you save money, you're giving up some benefits.
So the question is,
are the lower benefits worth the premium savings?
And that's really up to you.
If you want to shop, call a broker in your state
or you can go to our website, cbhealthins.com
under the Medicare tab.
There is a little shop for,
I had it up here, maybe not.
Here we go.
Shop for Medicare plans.
We do have a little button there that you can click
and we will help you shop if you're interested.
Until next time, thanks for watching.
This is Kathy Bukowski, the owner of CB Health Insurance.

