CFPB Director on new consumer banking data rules

Invest Insight
9 followers
1 Video View·Oct 23, 2024
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Director Rohit Chopra joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss a new rule requiring financial institutions to share customer data with other providers at customer request for free, how the new rule would improve competition in the banking space, privacy protection concerns, and more.
Today the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau finalized a rule requiring financial institutions
to share customer data with other providers at the customer's request for free. The agency says
transparency will improve competition in the space and joining us right now with more on the
new rule and much more is the CFPB Director Rohit Chopra. Rohit, let's talk about this. What's the
problem that this is intended to correct? Well, Becky, it can be a real pain to switch your bank
account or your credit card or other financial service and what these new rules will do will
inject even more control for consumers and competition in the market by making it easier
to move your money to switch and to fires that bank or financial company that is not serving you
well. The way it works is that consumers will be able to permission their data securely to the
provider of their choice, and we think this will mean higher rates on their deposits, lower rates
on their loans, and for young people who don't necessarily have a credit score, a long credit
history, they can use their payments and transaction information to show their creditworthiness.
We think this is a big benefit. Okay, this was my question. I mean, most of the time this would be
done just by a credit score. I guess I don't understand the problem with being able to say,
forget it, I want to go over here and take my money here if I'm opening a new CD, if I'm opening
a new credit card, if I'm opening a new bank account. Traditionally, I don't remember it being
ever difficult to do those things. How big of a problem is this? Oh, well, if you talk to many
consumers, they have lots of auto debits pre-programmed or they have direct deposits.
They have other places where their payment information is stored. This is going to allow
them to be able to take a lot of that information and move it to that new account. Often when you
switch your bank account, you put yourself at risk of missing payments to other loans,
incurring fees, or dealing with other bureaucratic messes. And more importantly, Becky,
when you're applying for a loan, often you want to be able to show that you've been paying your
bills, that you are earning a certain income. Yeah, credit score is one way of doing it,
but for many people, especially younger consumers who don't have that longer credit history,
this will be a way to digitally demonstrate all of the ways in which they are meeting their
obligations. And on top of it, we have put into place some important privacy protections
to make sure that there are not bait and switches where your data is being misused.
What are those privacy protections? Because if you talk to the big banks,
they will tell you that they are very concerned about scammers being able to
work their way around this. The banks spend lots and lots of money on security.
What happens if a scammer gets a hold of this information? Who's held responsible?
Well, the way it works is this. Under our longstanding financial privacy laws,
you get one of those notices every year that essentially tells you we're going to do what we
want with your data. But under these rules, when you permission your financial transaction data,
it can only be used for the purposes that the new company is offering. They can't go around
and sell that data for some other purpose. And the reason why this is also important,
it's not just stopping scams and fraud. We don't want your transaction history, Becky, to be used
to change or alter the prices that you see on airline tickets and so many other goods.
We know with artificial intelligence that data can be valuable,
but we want to make sure it is not abused or misused either.
Yeah, but how do you guarantee the safety and security of that data when it's being
brought up by a third party app? I mean, the banks already do have secure APIs that have been
developed so that they can transfer this information. This will require them to not go
through those secure APIs. No, that's not true. They would often use those secure APIs. And for
the companies receiving them, whether it's another competing bank or whether it's a fintech, they too
are responsible for making sure that data is secure and that the data is not misused.
Now, how do you oversee that? And how do you make sure that that and by the way,
if that information does get stolen at some point, who's responsible for that,
the bank that originally sent it or the fintech that picked it up?
Well, banks are responsible for securing data and so are fintechs. You're right. We need to make sure
that everyone is being watched to make sure that they are adhering to those standards of the law.
But banks and non-banks alike are required to have data security standards to not allow those
leakages. Now, we are urging, of course, all of the industry players, they need to modernize to
their payment rules and other network rules that they control to make sure that we can take,
you know, take on where there may be frauds and scams. But certainly the CFPB and law enforcement
will be living up to our role on that, too. I mean, it just it just seems to me that there
could be potential for additional fraud that's picked up along the way. I mean,
well, there that will happen. That will happen in any circumstance in a digital economy.
We have to make sure that there's some degree of rules. And at the end of the day,
we should be embracing competition. We should use digital technologies to allow people to switch
more seamlessly. When the FCC decades ago, they did one thing to allow you to port your phone
number from one cell phone provider to another rather than having to change it. And it really
made sure that consumers would be able to switch more seamlessly. I understand. And that was a
to be able to port. That was a good move. I'm a little more concerned about this simply because
it's my financial information that's much more. There's much more riding on this than my phone
number. And there's fewer reasons to steal my phone number than there is to steal my financial
information and get a hold of this. I guess my ultimate question is, if you're forcing the banks
to share this information and that third party that is then sharing it gets hacked, who is
responsible for it? Will that be responsible for it? Is it the original institution that you made
share the information? Is it the consumer? Well, Becky, right now, the way a lot of this
information is being shared is something called screen scraping, where you actually hand over
your username and password to a new provider to be able to essentially backdoor log in to
your online banking to grab. Well, that's what this is a terrible idea. That's what this is
shifting that away from by moving things to more secure. Well, by moving things to more secure
sharing, we're going to be able to sunset this practice of screen scraping. And one of the ways
we are looking to make sure that all this works is with higher security in ways that really make
sure that the market is more competitive. Right. When there's a big bank says that this is a vendor,
we don't trust and we have some questions about they are no longer allowed to say, no, we're not
going to hand this data over. My question is, who is responsible for that? If you're forcing them to
hand it over, who is responsible for any fraud that comes from it? Well, multiple parties could
ultimately be responsible. It depends on really what's going on right now when you hand over your
payment information and it is hacked. You do have rights under the law to dispute those charges.
And then banks and merchants and others, they set up their own rules about how they
reimburse each other. We ultimately want to increase data security in the system,
increase competition. And, Becky, this is a way better system than we had in the past.
