Dewey's Art as Experience - Ch 8_ The Organization of Energies

Honor Art
11 followers
Oct 21, 2024
Dewey defines the work of art, distinguishes it from the art product, and explains the rhythms of artistic perception.
Okay, hi, and welcome back to Great Texts and Philosophy.
We're talking about John Dewey's
Art as Experience, Chapter Eight,
The Organization of Energy.
At the end of the previous chapter,
Dewey introduced this theme of the organization of energies
as a way of understanding the dynamic character
of what he calls the unity in variety,
the unity in variety that characterizes the work of art.
Okay, so that's what he told us
this chapter's gonna be about at the end of the last chapter.
And certainly, in the last several chapters,
we've focused a lot on what Dewey calls here
the art product or the art object
or the expressive object, right?
And the conditions of its production and appreciation,
but very much centered on the object, the product.
At the beginning of this chapter,
Dewey reminds us of the distinction he's drawn
between the art product and, you know,
the statue, the painting, whatever,
and the actual work of art,
which is what the product does in experience.
Thus, a significant part of the focus of this chapter
concerns artistic perception
and sort of the psychological aspect of all of this.
Now, according to Tom Letty,
Dewey gives us here at the very beginning of the chapter
his own definition of art per se.
So, quoting Dewey from the very first paragraph,
end of the first paragraph,
when the structure of the object is such
that its force interacts happily, but not easily,
with the energies that issue from the experience itself,
when their mutual affinities and antagonisms work together
to bring about a substance that develops cumulatively
and surely, but not too steadily,
toward a fulfilling of impulsions and intentions,
then indeed, there is a work of art.
Letty says this definition,
like a definition of a later philosopher of art,
Nelson Goodman, answers not what is art
so much as when is art.
When is an experience an example of a work of art?
And the importance of rhythm,
which we've talked about before and in the last chapter,
it's implicit here, right?
In the discussion of mutual affinities and antagonisms,
in the discussion of this cumulative movement
towards fulfillment,
those notions of rhythm from previously
are still at work.
Now, it's easy to think about a musical piece
as an example of a work of art that has rhythm, right?
In terms of the repetitions in time
behind the variations in the music and the melody
and what have you.
It's so easy to think about this kind of example
that it leads to a mistake
that Dewey is at pains here to disabuse us of,
namely the mistaken idea
that rhythm is only a product of temporal arts,
like music and arts that play out in time,
whereas there is no rhythm in spatial arts
like painting and sculpture.
I mean, take this painting by Van Gogh.
Is there rhythm in this painting?
I mean, certainly I can perceive complex symmetries
and asymmetries, order and disorder of spatial arrangement
in this painting of a sunflower or a pair of sunflowers,
but where's the rhythm?
Okay, now, but remember,
according to Dewey, it's not the painting itself
or this reproduction of the painting in this video
that is the work of art.
This is only the art product, right?
The work of art is what happens to the product in perception
or how it works in perception.
So to crudely oversimplify the act of artistic perception,
one views the work, right, with one perceptual apparatus,
and this also produces and goes along with motor responses.
And so there's that back and forth characteristic
between the creature and the object.
I also have my immediate reaction to the work.
You know, one has that surrender that Dewey talks about
in the terms of the last chapter,
as well as reflection and discrimination about the work,
there's more intellectual appreciation,
which also forms a rhythm, back and forth rhythm
with the element of immediacy in perception.
And it's just in this whole complex process of perception,
that rhythm in Dewey's sense is a part of the work.
So in these mistaken ideas of rhythm
that focusing too much on the art product
and on this distinction between the temporal
and the spatial arts creates,
one Dewey calls the tick-tock theory.
This is based on the idea that rhythm is literal recurrence
in a mechanical sense,
like the tick-tock of a clock over and over again,
a metronome in this case would be a keen example of rhythm,
but that's not what Dewey means by rhythm.
Dewey also considers the idea that rhythm is concerned
with the repetition of beats.
He calls this the tom-tom theory
and points it to tribal music as an example.
But Dewey here, you know, reminds us that tribal music
or no kind of music just has a kind of drumbeat by itself,
absent other kinds of instruments, dancing,
variations of the drumming
and all sorts of things like that, right?
So both of these are mistaken ideas
about how exactly rhythm works.
So Dewey tells us the identification of rhythm
with literal recurrence,
regular return of identical elements,
conceives of recurrence statically or anatomically
instead of functionally.
And there's that word function or functional.
Functionally, this is a common Deweyian theme.
For the latter, that is the functional notion of rhythm,
interprets recurrence on the basis of furtherance
through the energy of the elements
of a complete and consumatory experience.
So this here sums up Dewey's notion of rhythm in perception
as against the literal or mechanical recurrence theories
as about the relation of elements in experience
furthering the development of the experience through time.
Of course, rhythm in that sense
is part of the perception of any work of art, right?
Any interaction with an art product,
statuaries, architecture, painting or music or drama
or anything of that sort.
Now, Dewey uses the term objectivity again in this chapter
in a notable way, I think it's worth remarking on.
So quoting Dewey,
but the objective measure of greatness
is precisely the variety and scope of factors
which in being rhythmic each to each
still cumulatively conserve and promote one another
in building up the actual experience.
And so I think we need to ask ourselves here,
what does Dewey mean by objective in this paragraph?
By greatness, it might seem like he's attempting
to provide a kind of universal criterion
for good versus bad art, right?
In terms of the subjective measure of greatness.
But I'll remind you that Dewey's conception
of objectivity is unusual.
We talked a lot about that last time.
And notably, when Dewey talks about objectivity,
it includes elements concerning experience
and concerning individual reactions to a work of art
or any kind of situation
which we would normally class as subjective, right?
But for Dewey, number one,
experience takes place not sort of in the skull
of the individual, but in the world,
in the interaction between the live creature
and the environment, right?
Not just in the live creature by itself.
And number two, objectivity here means
not so much universal or materialistic,
but just existing, right?
Observable perhaps,
but not necessarily something that is totally
sort of absolute.
And indeed, when Dewey talks about the greatness
of the work of art,
it's not the art product he's discussing, right?
So it must include the perceiver as a term, right?
Because the work of art is precisely
what is happening in experience and perception.
Also in the following paragraph after this quote,
Dewey contrasts the term greatness with fineness, right?
This to me indicates that greatness
is a particular type of quality,
not a sort of sole sort of measure of artistic value,
but one of several good qualities of art.
It can be great, it can be fine,
not in the sense of it's fine,
but in the sense of fine art,
as opposed to popular art or industrial arts
or something like that.
We might also contrast great with classic
from prior discussions.
A classic work is one that sort of is fruitful
in many people's experience
across many different times and cultures.
So what Dewey says here in this quote
is that when the art product has a variety
of different kinds of factors
that interact in different ways with the perceiver,
such that despite that variety,
there is rhythm, stimulation,
a culmination in an experience, right?
In an experience, I mean,
that's the objective measure of greatness, right?
If it fulfills those conditions,
then the work of art is great, at least for that perceiver.
So that's all I've got for today.
There of course are a lot of examples
from poetry, literature, painting,
and sculpture in the text this week.
And we'll discuss some of those examples,
some of Dewey's examples,
and whether or not and how they fit
these ideas during class.
So we're gonna leave the example for class.
I look forward to hearing what you think about this.
And if there are threads in the chapter I didn't follow,
as there were many and always are,
I'm eager to hear about them
and hear what you think about those things as well.
I'll be reading the discussion boards,
looking forward to talking to you in class,
and also, welcome to leave a comment on the video
if you wanna discuss some of those other aspects,
or tell me what you think about
how I've explained these other elements,
these elements that I was interested in.
So otherwise, have a great week,
and I'll see you later.
