Why Great Artists Still Choose Abstraction (And What It Means Today)

Modern Art
56 followers
Sep 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
For most of its history, painting was a window onto the world. To understand the world,
to make it divine, to record what happened, to seduce and celebrate beauty, to carry a story
and the moral or the lesson folded inside it, or simply to show life as it was and find beauty
or solace in it. By the second half of the 19th century, that window had been as polished as far
as it would go. So painters started to look elsewhere. In 1863, the paintings the Salon
had rejected were shown anyway, marking the unofficial start of modernism. What hung there
wasn't a window that you look through, but an object that you look at for what it is.
From there, the journey towards abstraction begins, and it moves very fast. Turner had
already been letting weather dissolve the picture. The Impressionists broke the surface
into strokes of color. Mondrian reduced paintings to verticals, horizontals, and primary colors.
The impelling force of this Copernican revolution in 20th-century art was an almost dogmatic belief
in progress, in search of modern art for a new and modern world. Cubism, Futurism,
Suprematism, Constructivism, De Stijl, Surrealism. It ran on optimism, on the assumption that art
and life were going somewhere, and the goal was to get there first, possibly reaching its peak
in New York with Abstract Expressionism in the mid-20th century. If painting had truly been
going somewhere, where had it arrived? Or worse, where had it ended? Ott Reinhardt seemed to give
the final answer with the last paintings, he said, that anyone could make. Harold Rosenberg
is supposed to have summed up this whole journey towards abstraction as Newman shutting the door,
Rodko drawing the shade, and Reinhardt turning out the lights.
The key art movements that came next, minimal art, conceptual art, arte povera,
fluxus, and more, didn't extend painting, it actually argued against it. Against the window,
of course, but also against beauty, the hand of the artist. Art was now about ideas. Progress
itself was now under suspicion, and the word for that suspicion was postmodernism.
The great journey of the 20th century, from a window marked by depth, to the conclusive
flatness in abstraction, implied that stylistic innovation had reached a dead end. Painting was
once more declared dead. Yet the painters kept on painting, in every generation since,
with abstraction thriving beyond the canvas. So the question isn't whether abstraction survived
this art historical suicide, but on what ground does it stand today? For 25 years,
Art21 has been asking artists to talk about their work in their own words.
So rather than answer this myself, I went through the archive and asked the artists.
Let's start with two painters who were there. Robert Mangold arrived in New York at the start
of the 60s. Richard Tuttle arrived a few years later. Same city, same argument in the air.
As a young artist, I was very connected to what was going on at the moment in New York.
The latter part of abstract expressionism, pop art, which had just arrived. It was a time to
start over, go back to the elements of painting. It was all part of what later became minimalism.
It was all a seemingly simple, single idea exposed in a raw way for people to experience.
It was refreshing and got rid of a lot of stuff that needed getting rid of so that you could
start things over. Maybe all generations feel like they're starting things over for themselves.
But this was really, I think, a period when it was certainly true.
At the time, the general idea of achieving art was to find your image done over and over again,
used and used and used until it was exhausted. It was so much about coming to the end of things.
I was 22. I was interested in things beginning. For Mangold, the reduction was the beginning.
Strip painting back to its elements and you can start again. For Tuttle, the reduction was the
ending. The image found and used until it was exhausted. And therefore, the beginning had to
be somewhere else. But where? It was in the mid to the late 70s. Painting was very much under
assault or critique. And the only argument for painting was, I like to do it. And that didn't
seem like a very compelling argument. I had friends who were doing experimental music and
experimental poetry and experimental film. And I noticed that the idea of an improvisational music
sound video type of thing could be applied to painting. The work I was interested in was playing
with art history and playing with form or shape or color or process. It might have had the same
spirit that the gestural painters in the 50s had. But somehow, by the time those kinds of
paintings became commodities, the sort of spirit of it was gone. And what was left was the sort of
heroics. And so it was kind of an anti-heroic position that, you know, had to be like remade
in painting. So I guess I'm rebuilding something from a much more scrappy and casual and weird
position. The only argument for painting was, I like to do it. Perhaps it is the best argument
to survive an unrelentless wave of innovation in the wake of modernist art history and the
often destructive deconstruction of postmodern thinking. That's what Painting is Dead felt like
from a studio in 1979. So perhaps before we ask what abstraction can carry now,
it's worth being precise about what it wasn't allowed to carry then. I love these pieces.
Besides the fact that they're history to me, I just think they're beautiful. And for a long time,
I thought they were too beautiful. Beauty is a problem sometimes in art making. In the 70s,
the rest of the world thought that beauty was a weakness, but the reality is it's a strength.
And I think just as other things have changed in the world, things come around, you know.
It's very rare that you read something profound and fundamental on color.
Modern critics write about the concept on what you can see, on what is being
dealt with politically or socially, but painting being discussed in the realm of color is
never happening. Interestingly enough, color is an element in painting that has always been
discussed from the 17th century on in the big academy in Paris or wherever as the female,
less stable, less clear and not so intelligent element of painting, whereas the concept,
the line, the drawing is more the male, the clear, the progressive and intelligent part of the artwork.
I wanted this to be both inside the pavilion and outside the pavilion,
a kind of humanist sense of color and light that would be beautiful, you know, would be beautiful.
Line is intelligent, color is not, concept is serious, beauty is not. And here's the thing,
even the artist who belongs most to this reductive tradition can't quite keep to the rule. You can
hear it in the past, just before he says the words, as if he knows what he's admitting to.
Beauty had become taboo and yet something older in us keeps asking for it, against all reason,
because it's one of the few things that gives a life meaning and significance. From that
perspective, the death of beauty was never really on the table and therefore the death of painting,
especially abstraction, neither. So what does abstraction carry once you stop apologizing for
it? I see abstraction as an intuitive expression of someone's experience, both good and both bad.
At least you got the general idea. Let's see. When you work with abstraction,
you're working with your own intuitive feelings about space, color, line, shape.
Its purpose is almost a way of opening up our thought process, because you're reading someone
else's language and you're interpreting it through your own language. Intense and I wanted to figure
out how to make paintings about it. I started making basically portraits of my vagina and
ovaries, trying to depict the experience of having the abortion. I realized the abstraction
can hold within it that sensation or that emotion by its color, its composition, its texture.
Seems like in your work, you can express some part of your personality that you're maybe not
consciously aware of all the time. Like maybe your better self. I have heard similar things,
like they feel free and joyful and positive and optimistic. And I'm like, oh, really? Because
I'm so anxious and like, I mean, like living, I'm like, whoa, like that's good that comes out
like that. If abstraction reliably carried the self, a sensation or an experience,
you'd expect a maker to recognize the message it carries. But that's not the point. Because
here's one thing almost every artist in this archive agrees on. Abstraction begins where
language gives out. Not knowing is a state that I think abstraction is really, really important for
addressing, because it's not an illustration. It's not a representation. It's an experience
of understanding certain kinds of physical and formal relations, space, color, time, weight,
heaviness, lightness, ugliness, beauty. To mark, to stroke, to struggle, to contradict, to offset,
to whittle, to abstract, and then you can't name it. I've done a lot of writing, but this is a
non-linguistic activity that, you know, on some level is foiled by language. So to answer these
questions is an impossibility. I really try to think about painting in terms of the construction
or making of an image, dealing with things that we don't have proper language for.
I kind of start to think of them as these visual neologisms. The neologism is there to address
when language isn't enough. Through repetition of the mark, there's this desire of trying to
invent something. When you're looking at these paintings, they're not graspable.
They're moments where they reference Renaissance, Ascension painting, and then other moments that
feel digitized. At least for me, they're not something I feel like I could give any kind of
articulation of what's happening fully. When I started painting, I stopped reading. In school,
I loved to learn languages and read things, and I really stopped that at the moment that I started
painting, and I didn't know why. It took me a little while to understand why I did it.
It's a poem by an Austrian poet, and his name is Ernst Jandel, and he's made a lot of really
fantastic poems that are just sound, and they're super fascinating.
The linguistic structure urges you towards a certain order system where things follow one
another, which is very linear, and I realized that painting does not have a linear structure.
Silman is a celebrated writer, and she's telling you that writing doesn't reach the painting.
But it's not all about thought, feeling, or things that are even elusive to language.
Sarah C is the artist in this film who possibly thinks hardest about why any of this matters now,
not in 1965. But now, her answer has to do with images.
I'm really interested in this kind of pendulum swing,
this kind of desire to be able to feel and touch and smell materials, and then the other end of
the pendulum being the reality that we have a kind of distance from materials because we have
so much time with images. That time with images, I think, is very different than any other time
with images that I've known in my lifetime, and I think it's changing radically with each
generation. You know, you don't know the authorship of an image when it gets to you.
You can manipulate it, and you can send it. It's a kind of images as debris.
We've learned to read images very quickly.
Each one of these carries information. It's compressed into each one.
It relates so much to what's happening with modern technology, you know,
bites of information, bits. That kind of a thing.
I can build anything I want to build. I'm not a narrative painter.
I don't do the idea of the painting being the illustration of an idea. I don't do that.
It's all about the materiality of the paint.
I love materials on the one hand, and I'm not interested in materials in the other.
How can somebody love materials to the degree I do and be absolutely not interested in materials?
And people talk about, oh, Richard, you know, uses stuff that could be thrown away and all that,
but really, that's my solution for sustaining them,
because yeah, I love a piece of tissue paper, and I know the world doesn't.
How do we just talk about the luxuriousness of the material,
not material representing something else?
How does paint behave in space? How does it feel? How does it dry? How does it adhere?
When you see paper as a pile, you sort of question what's happened to the image.
That's a place where the materiality in the sculpture and the image, I think, actually,
they meet. That kind of behavior, that kind of tactility, the volume on its value, I think,
has turned up, because we have so much illusion, but we don't have touch, and we don't have taste,
we don't have smell, we don't have that intimacy with images.
Witten wants nothing but the paint. Pindell needs it to hold a memory.
Hallowell, a body. Sillman, a not knowing. Merito, a word that doesn't exist yet.
See, a weight in a world that has none left. None of them hold the reason abstraction was
supposed to have. The one the whole century was building toward. And I think that's the point.
Reinhard did turn out the lights, but only of one room. What the artists from this archive have done,
one by one, is open a new door for something else. Use abstraction for something different.
To hold a memory. To carry a body. To make a thing with weight in a world of weightless pictures.
To not know something out loud. To be beautiful, on purpose, without apologizing.
Abstraction is no longer a mere direction of travel. It's something we love to witness,
we love to practice. It's a tool to reconnect with something we forgot we'd longed for,
not by going back to the window, but by going through these unopened doors into the unknown.
Reconnecting with color, light, space, experience, matter, sensation. Because neither language nor
teleological art history can grasp what we crave, what we need, as a society,
as people. And that is exactly the ground on which abstraction stands today.
