Field Technique (Research in Geography)

Discovered in China
13 followers
1 Video View·Oct 21, 2024
Geography
Today's topic is field techniques in geography. Before going in detail, get a clear idea that
any field techniques depend on the researcher hypothesis. Researchers have every liberty to
choose any field techniques. Here we are only discussing the conventional field techniques
normally used in the geographical research. Now question is what is field techniques?
Field techniques is a method to collect quantitative and the qualitative information
from the research field for the geographical study. Basically field techniques helps to create
the primary data source. Field techniques is an obligatory part of all sort of geographical
research. It may be the part of human geography. It is also the integral part of physical and
social geography and it is equally important for social, physical, cultural, all sort of geographical
research. Now come to the principal types of field techniques for the geographical research.
First one is the observation, second is the questionnaire survey and third one is the
interview method. Observation method is segmented into the two parts participatory observation
and non-participatory observation. Participatory observation includes the active participation of
researcher and in non-participatory observation researcher is not directly related to the
participation, not directly participated in the field activities that is known as passive
participation. Participatory field work researcher regularly visit the site, visit the particular
research area, visit the particular geographical area of her or his research concern. He or she
collected the little information from the field. It creates a successful participation and
observation and researcher always records audio-visual cameras are also used to capture raw
data set in the forms of direct interaction or the help of audio-visual devices. Those are the
participatory observation. Basically, the main or prime goal of participatory observation in field
work is that to create, to build the empirical data set. Basically, it's a very direct method of the
research work and there are few advantages of active participation. Those are the observation
of natural behavior, closeness with the group, studying the real character. It helps to create
better understanding and participatory observation provides the opportunity to the researcher to learn
more about the event. Those are the advantages of participatory observation. In the participatory
method, researcher visits the field in several times and he or she takes part in active field
work. It's a direct method or the active method of field work. In this method, researcher visits
the geographical area for the specific purpose and spend time in field work. There are several
advantages of the participatory method. It helps to get the natural behavior and the natural and
unbiased information from the field. When a group knows that they are going to be observed by an
outsider, by a researcher, then they feel conscious and uncomfortable. Therefore, the neutrality of
their behavior is lost. But in the cases of participant observation, respondents do not know
that they are being observed. Hence, the behavior is not constrained by their consciousness and by
the consciousness of their belief. So, we can get from the participatory observation, researcher can
get the pure and unbiased information from the field. We can take several examples of that.
Suppose direct household survey during the village survey, land use survey by the researcher,
seasonal variation of cropping pattern, all this type of information researcher can get from the
field study. Second one is the closeness with the group, that is the group activities.
In participatory observation and participatory field work, especially for the physical geography
and as well as for social and human geography, helps to build the cooperation and the fellow
among a group of researchers. We can take an example. Suppose long profile study of a river,
suppose it's a Kanchi river of Jharkhand, it's a 30 kilometer long river, this work needs
cooperation. Without cooperation, without group study, this 30 kilometers long Kanchi river survey,
long profile survey not become possible. And take another example, Manasa Pooja festival
in Purulia and Bakura district is a very famous and ancient one. If one, if a researcher
wish to have firsthand information about that festival, so he or she needs to have group
coverage of group study of the whole thing. So it will create a bond with the co-fellow
and it create a bonding with the group activities too. Next one is that the participant observation
helps to build the better perception of the researcher. Direct or active observation methods
helps to build a practical knowledge base of the researcher. We can take an example from
the physical geography. Suppose opencast coal mining of Mejia coal field and the soil profile
creation by the borehole data in the mining areas. And we can take an example from the
social geography to dialect of the Jharkhand and West Bengal and its similarities and
dissimilarities in the border zone of West Bengal and the Jharkhand. That kind of information,
that kind of database we can only get from the field observation. Next one is that the
participant observation helps to build better understanding. In participant observation,
the researcher can better understand the perception attitude of the respondent than the outsider.
We know research, basically geographical research is an empirical research. That means doing by the
learning and doing goes hand in hand. So empiricism and the research work, that statement becomes
justified only by the direct methods of observation and the field observation. We can take another
example. Suppose nick points recession and parallel retreat study. This is a nick point
formation of Subarna Rekha and its parallel retreat and recession. This phenomena become
clear to the researcher by the direct observation of the nick point zone of Subarna Rekha. Suppose
we can take an example identification of rocks and minerals type. Only researcher can only identify
the rocks and minerals if he or she visited the field several times. Those knowledge base helps
to create better understanding of the researcher. The participant observation provides opportunity
to learn more about an event. It explores the more dimension of fieldwork. We can take an example.
The researcher's objectivity is to learn the food pattern of Shantan community of
Birhom district, West Bengal. After regular field visit and after careful observation,
it opens the new avenue to learn about the festival food pattern, festival clothing pattern,
festival ritual ceremonies of that tribes. That kind of information provides by the
that kind of information provides the participant observation.
In spite of above advantages in participant observation, this method also has disadvantages
too. These are the disadvantages of participant observation. In spite of lots of advantage of
participant observation, but it has also disadvantages like lack of objectivity.
We can take an example. Suppose a researcher goes for a sand mining techniques to study a
sand mining techniques in Damodar river region. But after the intensive and careful field study,
his or her interest towards the daily wage labor of sand mining areas. That leads to another
dimension of the researcher, but it has a chance to lack of integrity of the previous work.
Next one is that often close of association brings biased interpretation, biased view.
Intensive field study, especially in the cases of socio-cultural and economic study
in the geographical research, as an individual researcher may act and may react
with all these attributes within the biased views. We can take an example. Young generation
of a particular ethnic community loses their interest in their ethnic culture. The old members
views of that particular community, that is that this is due to the result of, this is due to the
effect of inclusion of media. Sometimes new researcher become biased by the view,
by the views of the elderly people. And next one is that misses in bonds due to more familiarity,
due to more interaction. We can take an example of that. Sometimes very frequent field visit
makes the researcher feel casual attitude. And that kind of casual attitude sometimes, sometimes
giving the misleading information, sometimes misses the important issues of the particular
area of the particular people and the field study.
And next, next one is the limited range of experience. In the participatory observation,
the observer or the researcher is confined himself within the particular community,
within the particular geographical area. Sometimes that kind of limitation, that's,
kind of experience become very deep, but as well as it also provides a negative
impact on research work. Sometimes that, that kind of experience become very limited,
very narrow, that kind of limitation always associated with the participatory observation.
Next one is the involvement of groupism. It creates the dichotomy and conflict with the
group, with the interaction of groups. Sometimes it will create, not necessarily always.
So, there are a few limitations and also few disadvantages of the participatory observation,
but it's a very direct method and it is a very obligatory part of the geographical research.
Second one is the non-participatory field work. In that field work, researcher is not
taking active part in field work. Researcher here is a passive viewer and in non-participatory
field work, researcher participate in field from a distance. So, it is often called as a quasi
participant observation. Advantages of non-participant observation. First one is the
objective and neutral, objectivity and neutral. It's free from the community bias.
Second one is that the common in respect and cooperation. It always build a cooperation
and common respect. Okay. The questionnaire survey, suppose in the cases of questionnaire
survey done by the particular individual and that will be used by the researcher
using the video, still photography taken by the other people to interpret the rock lithology soil
type, that kind of cooperation and interaction among the group, it will create a good bonding
and good cooperation in research work. Basically, research activities in today's world isn't group
activities. It will create the bonding. Second thing is that the careful analysis.
Unbiased and careful analysis is the first and foremost step of any research work. From that
point of view, the non-participatory observation helps to careful and unbiased analysis of the
research work. And there are also few disadvantages of non-participatory field work. Those are the
first one is the subjectivity. In any research and in the cases of geographical research,
subjectivity is prime and foremost important because research work is an empirical study.
So lack of subjectivity is the absence of empiricism and that will provide most of the
cases. It provides the misleading information about the field area, about the geographical area.
Second one is the inadequate observation. Researcher perspective is not always reflected
in the database because in non-participatory observation, researchers stay away from the field.
So there is not any physical connection in between the geographical field or geographical
area and researcher. And that is the basic reason behind that the researcher perception
is not always reflected in his or her dataset. And third one is the unnatural and formal
information. Sometimes it's basically the third party information. Here the researcher uses the
information that is the third party information. Sometimes it becomes very formal information.
So the research work loses the integrity and the importance and loses the analytical aspect.
So fourth one is the inconvenience to the respondents. Sometimes respondents are not
very familiar to reply to respond in the questionnaire survey to the third party's
information creation or building. So those are the disadvantages of non-participatory field work.
Basically whether it is participatory or non-participatory, but geographical research
always accompanied by the combination of both. Partly participatory field work, it's prime and
foremost step of the any geographical research, maybe physical geography and human geography
because geographical research is an empirical research. Second one is that it may be partly
non-participatory and basically in modern geographical study is a combination of both.
So it is called as a quasi-participatory field work. The second most important field
technique is the questionnaire survey. Question may be various types. It may be open-ended,
closed-ended, mixed and quasi-questionnaire, structured questionnaire, unstructured questionnaire,
scaled question, dichotomous question and multiple choice question. So questionnaire may be
may be various types and various forms that depend on the hypothesis and the choices of the researcher.
Now what is questionnaire survey? Questionnaire survey is a device, is a research device
or the instrument that is made of the series of questions. It may be closed-ended, may be open-ended.
The ultimate goal of the questionnaire survey is to collect the relevant information from the field.
It will create the primary data source. Questionnaire survey can provide the quantitative
data set and as well as the qualitative data sets too. Therefore, the goal of the questionnaire
survey is to collect relevant information related to the geographical research directly from the
field. It will create qualitative as well as quantitative database. Rather it provides or it
creates the primary database. But that method is not invented by the geographers, not first used
by the geographer. That technique was first time used by the Statistical Society of London in 1838
and we used these techniques, geographical research and geographers and the researcher
from the field of geographers, geography has been used these techniques and that techniques directly
borrowed from the statistician. We are using that techniques and we borrowed the techniques
from the field of statistics. This is not invented techniques by the geographers.
So, but there are few general rules to prepare the questionnaire survey. So, question must be
clear and language of the questionnaire survey should be simple and concept will be clear that
question should be unbiased and adequate answer option is the integral part of the questionnaire
survey. Question should be shorter and single question at a time. Otherwise, it will create
the disturbance to the respondent and affirmative sentence is the most important in questionnaire
survey. Mathematics is not imposed. It's a basic rule for the questionnaire survey.
Clear short reference period and avoid the question in referencing. Those are the basic
principle how to prepare a questionnaire, how to crafting the question. Both all these principles
are followed in the questionnaire survey. Format of questionnaire survey. So, questionnaire must
be brief and concise. First thing is that researcher must keep in his or her mind
about the size of questionnaire. It must be brief, smaller and concise.
The questionnaire paper should be constructed on a good quality of paper with good quality
of printing. The question paper should be attractive layout. Next one is the clarity.
The question should be clear, short in the term of tenured and the expression.
And next one is the sequence. Sequence should be arranged. Question should be
arranged sequentially and according to the importance and the preference. And
next one is the communicability. The question should be questioned. Questionnaire,
should be able to keep interest of the respondent. Without the communicability with the respondent,
the objective of the questionnaire survey will be ultimately will be failed. So,
communicability of the question to the respondent will be very important and a vital step.
And next one is the time span. The length of the question in the questionnaire survey should be
short and question should be should not be very long. This is another principle of questionnaire
survey that question types to be avoided in a questionnaire. Those are the question without
specific purpose and objective and the hypothetical question should be avoided.
Ambiguous concept with the complex language must be avoided. Question with math and statistics
must be avoided. And repeat question and double negative question must be avoided.
Embarrassing personal question must be avoided. And the burning issue is a very sensitive issue.
Researchers have to deal with the burning issues very carefully, very politely and very logical
and analytical languages. Those are the principle what to do and what not to do
in questionnaire survey. This is very important and vital point on the basis of the framing of
question. The failure and success of the questionnaire survey depends on that.
Next one is the questionnaire question types. Basically, questionnaire question types are
few types open-ended, closed-ended, multiple question, structured question, unstructured
question, so on. First one is the open-ended question. Open-ended questions open for the
respondent to answer with more freedom. Here, instead of presenting the series of answer choice,
here respondents write or express their opinion which they want to express. So, from the open-ended
question, we get elaborate opinion of the respondent and it will provide the quantitative
as well as the qualitative data source. And in environmental study, perception study,
socioeconomic study, open-ended question provides more information and more relevant information
in research work. We can take an example of open-ended question. Suppose in a village study,
if researcher can ask the next connectivity and the future of rural life
and their opinion from the respondent. So, respondents have a liberty, have a choice to
express their views with few sentences. And next one is the closed-ended question.
Here, the closed-ended question normally helps to get the quantitative data source.
It always included with the one or two or three options. Options should be given. Sometimes
option should be two, three or maybe series of options. Next one is that we can take an example
that. Suppose a researcher asks to a respondent to survey the taxpayer patent. So, do you regular
taxpayer? Option will be never, regular and often. This is the option, never, regular or often.
Those are the closed-ended question. Okay. Next one is the multiple choice question.
Multiple choice question in respondent with the list of the answer option. They can select one or
more from the answer option. A list of answer option given by the researcher and here the
respondents have to select the answer from the list. So, from that type of data source,
we can get the qualitative as well as the quantitative data source. We can take an
example. Suppose income level, monthly income of a family. So, you can put the range of the
monthly income in money, 10,000 to 15,000, 15,000 to 20,000 and more over 20,000 and above. So,
respondent can choose and option should be more than two. That is called as a multiple choice
question. And fourth one is the dichotomous question. It include only possible to answer,
only possible to answer and those are the just like that yes or no. Question should be like
agree and disagree, true and false, lie and dislike. Those are the contradictory answer.
Answer is confined within the two options, yes or no, agree or disagree, false or true,
or the like or dislike. That kind of option is known as dichotomous question option. So,
that kind of question is known as dichotomous question. Suppose we can take an example.
Suppose village lifestyle study, do you like to stay village? Option is yes or no. This is
dichotomous question. Okay. Another, you can take another question during the COVID-19,
government is not taking proper step, this statement, comment on this statement,
option is agree or disagree. This is the dichotomous question. And fourth one is the
scaled question. Scaled question, this is very relevant in socioeconomic study and here to
justify the degree of opinion, a scale or version of scale has been created by the researcher.
Suppose, you can take an example of Likert scale, one for good, two for very good, sorry,
one for very good, two for good, three for moderate, four for bad and five for worse.
So, question is, are you satisfied with the health services of the government hospital?
One, two, three, four, five option are there. Those are scale. Scale are in ascending order.
One is very good and five is worse. So, you have to select one. This is the scaled question. Okay.
We can take another example of scaled question. Basically, here the degree of opinion or the
feeling of the respondent framing within the scale, framing within the intensity of the scale,
that is known as scale question. We can take another example. Do you satisfied with the
class teaching of MS madam? One, two, three, four, five, one is good, very good, five is bad.
So, you have to choose an option that is in scale. So, it is known as a scaled question.
We can take an example of Likert scale. It also used in socioeconomic study.
Next one is the pictorial question. We are all familiar with the pictorial. It's related to
the image or picture. It has been a higher respondent rate than the normal question type.
It helps to visualize the respondent to the situation. That's why it has a higher
respondent rate than the other question type. Here the questioner substitute a text or image.
So, people can easily choose the text or image. So, like we can take an example of that
rainy season and impact on the livestock farming. So, we can create an image. So,
livestock farming and the rainy season. So, people can select one image and that will provide the
information. It usually has a higher response than the other question type because it helps
to visualize the situation to the respondent. Next one is the structure question. Structure
question is very important. It is pre-planned well-defined pattern of question with the
particular and proper sequence. Pre-planned well-defined pattern of question with proper
sequence. It's very important for the geopolitical study, socioeconomic study and
environmental perception study. We can take an example of that. Suppose we are giving the example
of series of question. First one is the household survey questionnaire. Suppose
first one is the number of room per family. Second question is the total number of family
member. Third one is the age and gender of the family member. Fourth one is that the
head of the family is male or female, is the earning member and his or her monthly salaries.
Those are the sequential series of question. So, that creates a quantitative database and very
easy to visualize the socioeconomic situation. Structure question is very relevant for the
historical geographical study, for geohistorical study, geopolitical study and it helps to
contemporary international and geopolitical study in geography.
And next one is the unstructured question. The open-ended question not well-defined and not
planned. Basically, those are the open-ended question not well-defined just like a like
discussion mode and not planned. It focus on the group discussion, maybe indirect or direct
discussion and here maybe one is to one interaction, maybe one is to many interaction.
We can take example of that COVID-19 and public awareness. You can get an opinion from without
any structure question. The crop failure and the farmer's crop security scheme by the government
of India. Through the discussion method, very casual manner, researcher get an opinion and
can get qualitative and the quantitative data. So, questionnaire survey, the basic method we
learned from the statistician and first time statisticians use the techniques. We borrowed
the techniques from the statistician but in socioeconomic study, environmental perception
study and geopolitical study, we used those type of techniques with types of question,
types of methods to survey the indirect observation to create the primary database
through this questionnaire survey and here few principles are very important. Here,
few question types should be avoided. Those are the hypothetical question,
second is the offensive question and third one is the extreme positive and extreme negative question.
Those should be avoided or otherwise deal with very sensitive and very minutely and very carefully.
The third important field technique is the interview method. Interview method includes
group interview, individual interview, children's opinion, elderly people's opinion,
interview through the electronic devices or the virtual interview. So, interview method
is the very important tools and most useful techniques to collect qualitative information
from the field. This method is usually used for the professional or trained researcher
for the particular purpose from a particular field area. Interviews are designed to collect
qualitative and sometimes quantitative information from the small segment of the respondent.
The interviews are designed to collect qualitative information from the small segment of the people,
number of the sample sites normally associated with the interview method is normally small one.
It includes the attributes, behavior, preference, feelings, attitude, opinion,
knowledge of the area concerned of that particular human group, particular respondent groups.
There are several types of interviews but interview method mainly include the three types
that is over the phone, over the distance, that is the second one is the face-to-face interview
and third one is the two through the audio-visual and the electronic media that is the online
interview. Now, come to the components of the interview. First component about the interview
method is the formal and the conversational interview. It's the most casual methods of the
interview. Here, the question survey is not included in this method. No predetermined questions
are asked in that process. Open-ended question and casual discussion method normally followed
in that method. We can take an example of that kind of component. Just like the if
suppose a person or researcher want to know the opinion about the person, about a particular person,
about the higher education. So, in that cases, the researcher goes for the casual conversation
with that particular person to get the views about the higher education and second component is that
the guide approach and this guide approach are the here at predetermined focus conversation
and freedom of respondent to provided to answer. So, here the questions, here the question series
and the type of conversation are predetermined by the researcher and focused on the conversation.
We can take an example of that, that is the political discussion and views of the politician
and discussion of geopolitical phenomena and those are the types of guide approach interview.
Next one is the standardized open-ended interview. This interview, the question are pre-planned and
open-ended and it's a method to get information. Through this method, researcher can,
researcher gets information very first with few selected questions. We take an example. Suppose
the question is process of mitigation of the crisis during the COVID-19. You can take the
opinion of a group of doctors and we can take an another example, that is attitude of the
farmers towards the land use survey. Suppose question is that why the farmers are preferring
the sunflower instead of paddy cultivation. If yes or no, please explain the preference.
That kind of question is the standardized open-ended question. Within the few questions,
few selected pre-planned question, researcher can get an idea about the attributes, about the
qualitative research. And next one is the closed fixed response interview. All the interviewers
are asked the same question and asked to choose the answer from the selected answer group and
among the sets of alternative. This is the structure, structure interview. Question are
pre-planned and option are also given by the researcher and through this method, researcher
get the series of options. Researcher can get a qualitative information too. We can take an
example is that suppose respondent x, y and z are there and single question asked with the same,
same single question is asked with all the person x, y and z with the multiple choice option.
That kind of questionnaires, that kind of interview method is known as the closed fixed response
interview. Now three important step of the interview, rather three important step in
fourth interview method. First is design, second is the development of the interview guide,
third is plan and management within the logistic way. First is design of the interview. Here,
think about who will interview, think about what kind of information researcher want to
obtain from the interview and third one is think about why researchers want to pursue in-depth
information around the specific topic. Within the views of three objective questions and the
conversation mode are designed, that is the design interview questions. Second one is the
developed an interview guide. So, it's very important and vital part and it's self-introduction
and confidence part of from the researcher point of view. Here, researcher have to maintain the
sequence of the question, sequence of the topic, be clear and easy understanding of the question
and also it creates the bridge between the researcher and the interviewers.
And third, third one is the plan and manage logistic and it is the management part and
during the interview process. So, researchers should be careful and also try to bring note
and also note down very selective and sensitive points. Those things to manage, all these things
to manage the whole process with confidence, this is the plan and management part. These three
attributes is very important and vital step to successful interview methods in the field research
or the field work in the geographical research. Among the all techniques in geographical research,
the participatory observation is most effective. It helps to build empirical research, a basic
foundation of empirical research lies on the observation and participatory observation.
In spite of all and all discussion, here I would like to conclude that researcher can choose
any option according to his hypothesis or her hypothesis according to his or her objective
and her own choices. So, though I have discussed a lot of techniques normally used in geographical
research, in spite of that, the techniques used by the researcher solely depend on the
research hypothesis, only depend on the research objective and researcher choices.
