The Rules of Geography & Civilization.mp4

Americas: Geography, History and Culture
27 followers
Oct 27, 2025
This video is about how geography interacts with the growth of human civilization. Think,
for example, about how Egypt having fertile farmland all along one river with deserts
surrounding it may have contributed to its formation as a consolidated and conservative
monarchy. There's one river the state needs to control for travel. It floods calmly and
regularly. Its deserts shield it from outside invaders. But if it has such a perfect setup,
why was Egypt subjugated by neighboring powers for so much of its history?
This video is my own perspective on this. Despite having read some books and articles
to fact check many of my examples, actual historians have important criticisms with
overemphasizing geography, which I will also cover at the very end. After all,
this video is for worldbuilding and explaining the arguments of geographical determinism.
So please, comment your ideas and counterarguments below, and I hope you enjoy.
Urbanization independently starts as a slow process alongside the development of bigger
and better agricultural technologies, which can produce higher yields and free more of the
population from food production. These often start in large river valleys, which is why we start our
history classes in Egypt or Mesopotamia, the Indus River, Northern China, or Sahelian Africa.
Uruk was the first major city of Mesopotamia, as it grew disproportionately large compared to the
other small cities growing in the region. This phenomenon is called a primate city, which I know,
I also wish it were all chimpanzees. But it's when a single outlier is created as the largest city
both attracts and promises more resources and opportunities. Think of why leaders may engage
in huge monumental architecture. For example, the city with the biggest temples will attract the
most attention and religious tourism, which benefits its economy, which brings more people in,
which helps it balloon in size compared to its neighbors. Naturally, Uruk created the first
empire to control lower Mesopotamia and established many colonies around the Middle East,
really influencing this region's culture and setting the tone for its subsequent politics.
Now large scale irrigation off of these big rivers is key for producing enough food for
these cities, which necessitates local farmers to organize and cooperate in how to configure
the canals and best share water resources. The case study of large rivers cradling civilization
is a good example of how geography presents both challenges and opportunities for human survival,
which are usually overcome by organizing labor and technology. Need more food? Time for everyone
to help dig irrigation canals. The river's flooding? Control the flood with waterworks.
Droughts? Build reservoirs and more waterworks. These rivers also help to demonstrate that what
we call civilization is mainly based around an area's connections and interactions together,
and these connections are, again, bolstered and expanded by large scale organized labor
and technology. So this video is really centered around the question,
what environmental problems and opportunities does geography create, regarding their lifestyles and
interconnectivity? How do people work together to solve these problems and make their own lives
more prosperous and stable, and who do they mainly interact with so they share enough
commonalities to the point where you can label them under the same umbrella? Problems, opportunities,
and interconnectivity are the roots of how we should think about geography and civilization's
relationship. Now, large urban societies don't need to be on giant river valleys. We currently
think that the first people to develop large scale agriculture were the Natufians in the Levant,
which would have relied on rain to grow a surplus of grain. Perhaps this explains why the primary
Canaanite god, Baal, is strongly associated with storms and rain, and why Mesopotamian and
Egyptian primary gods are more associated with their life-giving rivers as opposed to the harsh
deserts or saltwater sea. Or, the progenitor Olmec civilization in Mesoamerica and the
Karalsupe civilization on the coast of Peru started on small lowland river valleys. Both
the Olmec and Karalsupe civilizations would later give rise to urban societies primarily in the
highlands nearby, such as Teotihuacan and Tenochtitlan in Mesoamerica and the Wari and
Incan empires in the Andes mountains. And when you look at the agricultural technologies it took to
supply these, from the reed maps that floated crop beds on top of Lake Texcoco for Tenochtitlan,
to the extensive terraces and aqueducts used to grow crops in the rugged Andean highlands,
to the heat trapping raised platform agriculture used in the cold Altiplano city of Tiwanaku,
we see more example of technology and organized labor being used to overcome their particular
difficulties and increase their crop yields. Many environmental factors can be a problem for farming,
and the ways people overcome this directly feeds into people's politics and religion.
I'd like to indulge for a second in the ancient and legendary origins of the Chinese dynasties.
According to tradition, the progenitor Xia dynasty was founded by a figure named Yu the Engineer,
who was able to construct a system of irrigation, dikes, and canals to settle a catastrophic flood
on the Yellow River. Once complete he was given the emperorship, this irrigation helped the people
flourish, he collected bronze from all the nine provinces under his control to forge these
symbolically unifying cauldrons, and he defeated a rebellion and reintegrated its people by being
a much better ruler than that of the rebels. Now I'm not asking you to accept this tradition
written during the ancient Zhou dynasty as literal history, but it does say a lot about
how the Chinese who wrote this down viewed the authority and responsibilities of their leaders,
notably how legitimacy comes from successfully dealing with environmental problems.
Now I've noticed that large scale agriculture and urban societies tend to spread out over time.
Large agriculture itself requires a more tangible sense of ownership over the land than something
like nomadic pastoralism or hunting and gathering, so places with population surpluses would be
encouraged to send people out to clear wilderness, establish new farms, and settle colonies. We see
this all over, from the Middle East, India, China, Meso and Andean America, urban living
creeps outward, and as roads and trade routes expand, they create a more stable system of
resource exchanging cities in the region. Just a fun fact, this is part of why the Eastern Roman
Empire was much richer than the West, because the cities and their trade routes were far older,
more developed, and interconnected. The Han Chinese saw many waves of colonization between
300 and 1300 out of the North China Plain and into hilly South China and the Sichuan Basin,
due to environmental issues, fleeing the nomadic invaders, and simply in search of new farmlands,
especially when bolstered by the unified state. Here they assimilated the indigenous peoples and
developed new intensive forms of agriculture, slowly expanding the reach of Han Chinese
civilization. There are many other interesting case studies here, so just wait until we get to
Cahokia and Urban Living on the Plains to see where urbanization actually fails to take hold.
But first, deserts and shrublands carry relatively little biomass because they're dry and lack enough
resources for many species to thrive. Settled societies here need to have a good water source
that will keep them fed, or they need to have enough to drink while food is carried in here.
Importing food is an interesting case, because that usually means there's a settlement in the
The medieval traveler Ibn Battuta talks about this in his writings on traveling through the
Sahara Desert, as he encountered the town of Taghaza in the middle here, where enslaved workers
mined salt to trade for the southern city's gold, and they lived on brackish well water and dates
imported all the way from Morocco. He also can't stop insulting how terrible this town is in his
writings, which makes him a diva and is very funny. So, oases, lakes, rivers, places with
accessible well water, and the occasional pool of water left by recent rain are vital in deserts.
That means it's dangerous, and any merchants or travelers need to know what they're doing here,
or die. Areas with secure water and food would become refuges for these people, like Lake Chad
on the southern gradient of the Sahara, which gets most of its water and seasonal rivers from the
south. The Canem-Borno Empire rose here and became extremely wealthy and powerful based on controlling
the trade routes through the Sahara, coming into conflict with its neighbors along the
Savannah-Sahel region over control of that trade. From this perspective, the Sahara is less of a
wasteland and more of an opportunity, because people can control the specific areas that
dictate travel there. Its vast size also separated the radically different Islamic and Sub-Saharan
cultures, so Islam's exportation over these trade routes brought a whole new form of literature,
judicial systems, and politics into play, which became central to their societies later on.
Knowing this, let's take a look back at Egypt's position among other civilizations around them.
Yes, they're on one river and the kingdom can easily control that waterway. Yes, it floods
regularly and consistently because of the monsoon rains in the Ethiopian summer, so the Nile River
does not cause the same level of problems that the Mesopotamian Indus or Yellow Rivers cause in their
areas, namely droughts and flooding. But the Nile does have shallow regions full of cataracts,
which stifled Egypt's trade and expansion southward. I think Ancient Egypt developed
as a conservative, consolidated, divine monarchy because it didn't have as many
homeland environmental issues, which in other areas often caused social unrest and political
change. Now that's not to say that Egypt didn't suffer from stuff like drought and famine. There's
an inscription from the Ptolemaic period that describes how the Nile hasn't flooded in seven
years, which would disrupt the normal cycles of replenishing the soil nutrients and is causing
the desperate people to turn to banditry. And this isn't to say that Egypt didn't see any
socio-political change, as wars and people's ambition led to the turnover of dozens of
dynasties, and the priestly temple organizations eventually grew in power to rival the pharaoh.
But at the scope of quote-unquote Egyptian civilization as a whole, I'd pin their main
concern on its neighbors. These deserts that envelop Egypt are not great shields. Especially
on its eastern flank, people can cross through them, so nearby societies that developed to be
very aggressive and expansionistic could cross them to take and hold Egypt, making it prime
territory for people with imperial ambitions. And that's not even mentioning the people who
lived in those deserts. Now I think if you're world building areas full of tribal peoples,
like deserts and troublends, you should think a lot about how familial tribal structures
interact with city and state structures. It's not like in the fantasy books where the protagonist
is a city boy and then gets lost and adopts the alien ways of desert tribe people to go and raid
the city or something. It's going to be more like, that city boy is part of a tribe, and the city is
full of different tribes, and they all have different relationships, and the city rulers
have relationships with the tribes in the desert because they're constantly coming into trade and
worship and have weddings and stuff. The prophet Muhammad was from Mecca and was from the Quraysh
tribe, and his preaching of Islam was a unifying connective force that superseded the old tribal
and religious affiliations, which helped bring Arabia under one very powerful banner. Even people
in Athens belonged to a type of familial tribe, until they were radically changed by Cleisthenes'
democratic reforms to the benefit of the state. Just think about settled and nomadic societies
as interacting systems that are always negotiating and conflicting and evolving, not just two
completely walled off areas. It makes your world much more alive and dynamic. I've been world
building with deserts for a while in my own projects, which is where I'd like to thank
today's sponsor, World Anvil. World Anvil is the world builder's one-stop shop for organizing the
messes that are our projects. I'm a sandbox world builder, I like maps, languages, big history,
religions, battles. Their wiki-style setup is perfect for organizing all the characters,
places, events, and everything I populate my projects with. Make interactive maps,
character relationship diagrams, family trees, chronicles of all your entered historical events,
and an encyclopedic presentation of your whole project, all super easily with their dedicated
tools. And with everything for over a hundred TTRPGs and your own custom systems, character
sheets, rollable loot tables, you're playing D&D on one screen and sprinting through your notes at
light speed before your players can do something stupid to throw you off. No need to insta-name
your highborn elves Jeff anymore, you'll have your name lists right there. So go to worldanvil.com
to get started, and use the coupon code stoneworks for 51% off any yearly membership. That's stoneworks
for a year at 51% off the tools you need to be one of the greats. Link in the description and pinned
comment below. Moving on to grasslands and plains. Contrary to what the civilization games would have
you believe, grasslands are the dry ones, and plains are the nice and green pasture ones.
Grasslands share a lot of similarities to how deserts operate, but with a lot more emphasis
on big nomadic groups, horse warlords, big game hunting, more rivers and lakes, and easier travel
across them because they're not as dry. It's significant that the Mongols brought the Black
Death across Asia along the Central Asian steppe, and that the large sub-Saharan civilizations grew
well along the Sahel region, as once again these relatively harsh and dry areas actually become
important highways and population centers when the conditions are right. This is a convenient point
for me to note that it's easier for pre-modern civilizations to expand and conquer into similar
environments as their homelands. Like the Mongol homeland is all dry grassland, deserts, mountains,
and forests. The Mongols were adapted to warfare in these conditions, which are shared by most of
the territory they conquered in Asia. Southern China was one of their most bloody and difficult
campaigns, and the Mongols failed to defeat the Delhi Sultanate in India. These are, at least in
part, due to geography. People from the dry steppes have real hurdles in going into subtropical areas.
The plains are interesting because it's a rather unscientific description, but plain denotes that
it's relatively flat and not too densely forested. That makes them pretty good for agriculture,
as long as they have long growing seasons and enough consistent rain. The main thing is that
farming in such a large space not being replenished by rivers or perhaps volcanic ash is going to
deplete the soil faster, especially in drier regions like the Levant. So farmers will have
to use more techniques like crop rotations, fallow fields, and fertilizers. A great example
of plains farmers forming cities can be found at Cahokia in modern Illinois, a city that arose in
the flood plains of the Missouri River. On a map, one would think that this is the perfect place for
a giant farming city. Archaeologists trace its development from a normal village, to a town,
to a city, and then a slow decline and eventual abandonment, all in the span of 300 years.
Cahokia rose into the region's central city, where trade, ritual activity, monumental mound
building, and administration could take place. It had about a 50 year window of its highest
population density, but it seems that it began to decline possibly due to the overuse of the
region's environmental resources, climate change and drought, or perhaps in part to
over-administration and social unrest. But as this decline is starting, the Cahokians were
creating a new planned layout for the city and their ritual centers. But its prominence continued
to contract as people emigrated away. Eventually Cahokia had declined further, its way of
administration changed, they exercised control over a smaller area, and they constructed a
palisade wall to protect themselves. It continued on to be completely abandoned as people moved
elsewhere, and the region became less densely populated with villages and farming homesteads
This is fascinating because we see people experimenting with urbanization and ultimately
rejecting it. The Missouri floodplain and its rich soils may have been too little to sustain
its peak population during a drought or without the use of certain farming technologies. Scholars
debate about Cahokia non-stop, so there's less available information and concrete things I can
tell you than I'd like. But it's fascinating in world history to see a place where urbanism
independently rises to this scale just to prove unsustainable. Consider that when looking to
place your cities on the map. Now regarding already established urban plains, I think that
big, flat areas tend to breed more intense competition and cooperation between state
actors. Armies can rampage around flat areas easier, and the rivers here aren't as strong
as mountains as natural borders because they're quicker to cross with bridges, ferries, and
Looking across the river at the other side's farmland may be an attractive target for conquest.
When you look at China's warring states and early Three Kingdoms period, the North China
Plain is the hotbed of violence and fragmentation. And after the Tang Dynasty collapsed, the North
China Plain stayed unified, but the peripheral southern and Sichuan regions fought over the area
for its resources and political legitimacy, until Emperor Taizu could conquer them and establish
the Song Dynasty. And the North European Plain has been fought over from medieval times to WWII.
The inability for warlords and states to draw a concrete border is a lot more difficult without
just unifying the whole place entirely, and some people certainly tried to do that in Europe.
I also think this might contribute to these areas' focus on harmony and cooperation when
they are united or share common interests, whether it be through Chinese Confucianism
or the dictates of the Communist Party, or maybe even the European Union, because these areas are
large population centers that directly see how devastating turmoil here can be.
Now there's two disclaimers to make here. One, you might be saying, Jack, you're just
cherry picking examples. And yes, I am. I'll respond to that when we get to the criticisms.
And two, this does not make mountainous or hilly areas more naturally peaceful or harmonious.
The mountains of Greece saw populations that were isolated by rugged terrain, constantly fighting
over the limited farmland with flip-flopping alliance networks, until Philip came down from
Macedon and united them. Also, a broader side note that I've noticed that fragmented places
often get unified by people on the geographic and political edges, like with Macedonia,
Chin in the Warring States period, Assyria and Mesopotamia, and the swamp city of Tenochtitlan.
Maybe it's because these regions are less bound by the common politics and institutions of the
core region. Maybe their marginalization creates the impetus for aggressive innovation and expansion.
Maybe they learn new ways of statecraft from the other peoples around them. I don't know.
This is just a pattern you can get with cherry picked examples. I don't have the evidence to
back up this grossly overextending meta-narrative. It's just a fun thing that I've noticed.
Now let me turn our focus to plains waterways. Ukraine has a fascinating history around this.
The North European plain this far east is absolutely massive, so people here could live
autonomously and nomad groups could easily take charge. And since states are built on the
connections of large numbers of people, I would have expected this area to stay in tribal societies.
Well, enter the Dnieper and Volga rivers, the trade connections between the Norse,
steppe people, and Mediterranean, and the Kievan Rus. This trade network developed the
settlements here into larger cities, which consolidated into a powerful state that
unified many of the cities and local Slavic tribes. Whether you want to credit that to
the Slavs or Norse, that's an old scholarly debate wrapped up in nationalist interests.
The Kievan Rus formed as principalities around the cities until they were conquered by the Mongols,
and later Moscow rose to power as tax collecting subjects of the Golden Horde
and expanded as they declined. Now there's a solid geographic argument that this region's
sheer scale and flatness naturally pushes Russia to be extremely expansionistic into Europe.
Basically, Russia needs as much room between its core cities and potential invaders as possible.
If the border is way over there, they can fight the invaders and let the harsh Russian climate
deal damage to them before they get here to the imperial core. Napoleon and the German army
learned that the hard way. There's also the clear obsession with warm water ports, because Russia
wants access to the sea when its northern ports are frozen, so it has interest in going southwest
into Europe. Now some have said that's why Russia has always been super authoritarian,
so it can facilitate that expansion and crack down on the internal threats that its size
otherwise enables. That's up to you how to balance geography versus the legacy of plundering
authoritarian systems from the Mongols to Moscow, but it is clear that Russia's geography,
so large, flat, and northward, presents it with many, many unique challenges.
Forests are interesting. They're just about everywhere, they come in all sorts of shapes and
sizes, and they are pretty easy to clear with bronze tools. Unkempt forests do slow down and
obscure a large army, however a lot of states are naturally going to make roads through them,
but at least you can have some choke points to secure there. Timber is a great resource for
building ships, homes, and furniture, so large areas of forests get a boost on those fronts,
especially if they can ship it to other people who need it. It's always interested me how Lebanon
was famous for its cedar forests, as it shows up as a divine realm in the Epic of Gilgamesh,
and the biblical king Solomon imported cedar to build the first Jewish temple.
But forests also bring up a focus on sustainability. The Chinese philosopher
Meng Tzu wrote on this, as intensive agriculture and people's homesteading were depleting their
forest resources. Now, his main focus in his writing here is on human nature, morals,
and cosmology, so maybe I'm misinterpreting his message, but there is at least an undertone of
preserving the natural landscape and limiting human exploitation. Looking at other cultures'
worldviews with this same lens, like with the Yurok people who placed a lot of ritual and
spiritual prescriptions on cutting down a giant redwood tree, it starts to make a lot of material
sense that taking from the environment should have a spiritual importance to it to avoid overusing
it. The cold taiga forests that dominate the upper northern hemisphere latitudes present a lot of
challenges for developing large scale civilization. The soil here is quite poor and acidic,
they are not as fruitful as temperate or tropical forests, although there are temperate rainforests
that do look like taigas, and the long cold snowy seasons are not as conducive to large scale
agriculture. People in these regions are often pastoralists and hunters for these reasons.
However, I believe that cities develop here if they have another impetus for their economies,
such as trade in the Baltic or in Russia. Regarding Scandinavia, the harsh winters
created a local communal culture of the storage economy, with more emphasis on preparing for
harsh times and the ever-present fear of a grain shortage. Also, fun fact, overland trade in Sweden
was most possible during the snowy winter months with the use of sleds, leading to the development
of specialized winter roads. But the land's difficulties most notably turned Scandinavian
attention to the seas, as the accessible coastline and vast timber resources allowed them to
specialize in fishing, trade, and raiding in the early medieval period. That's what the vikings are,
and that maritime mobility is why you find the Norse being influential all around the coastal,
insular, and river systems of Europe at the time. Now rainforests are fascinating, and I imagine
we'll learn a lot in the coming decades as we dig deeper into these Amazonian city ruins we've found
with lidar scans. Very exciting stuff. Agriculture and rainforests are not mutually exclusive. A
giant hurdle here though is soil fertility, because the dense plant life eats it all up,
and it gets recycled really fast here. But rainforest peoples can often get around this
by using slash and burn agriculture, adding a lot of specialized fertilizer, or farming crops in the
wetlands. Now with all their biomass, rainforests offer a lot more resources than other biomes,
so wilderness gardens and forest management, fishing, and hunting may be a large part of
these societies. In fact, the Pacific Northwest region, which has a temperate rainforest,
was so productive in fish and forest food resources that they could support town-sized
settlements with smaller garden and natural forest management practices. Don't discount
fish and forest resources for the importance of civilizations, they've contributed to the growth
of many of them, but just aren't as reliable or controllable as human large-scale agriculture.
Rainforests can present another major problem, too much water. Medieval Cambodia would flood
during its rainy season, which is great for harvesting all sorts of aquatic resources,
but not so great during the dry season, and for flooding out the crops. People here would
create extensive waterworks that would divert and collect water to be used for irrigation,
and came to take on religious and cultural significance. All along South Asia, you'd see
systems where local groups as well as large authorities would put a lot of effort into
these waterworks as they were important for ensuring good crop yields. The construction
and maintenance of these reservoirs and waterworks created hierarchical systems that larger rulers
could either directly facilitate or inject themselves into with patronage. Waterworks also
applies the other way when there's not enough water, like with the Mayans, where the Yucatan
Peninsula is a bit drier than many imagine. It has inconsistent rainfall, and doesn't have large
scale bodies of water other than these big holes in the limestone called cenotes. In such harsh
conditions, Mayan city-states were often built around large systems of rain catchers, reservoirs,
and canals that kept areas productive during their dry season. On either end of these extremes,
too much water, too little water, we see how water management requires a lot of organized labor to
set up and maintain, and how that organization is at least a part of these civilizations' political
systems. Onto mountains. Mountains are fascinating because their different elevations carry a
multitude of climate zones along them. It's difficult to farm in these regions, as arable
farmland might be scarce, soil viability varies a lot, and often the terrain is just too rugged
or rocky. In Tibet, you'll mostly find a little farmland in certain valleys with small irrigation
coming from the mountain streams. More emphasis is placed on pastoralism, with people moving their
herds up the mountains in the summer to take advantage of the seasonal grass. In the Andes
Mountains, people became especially adept at testing soil to see if it was appropriate for
certain crops, and figuring out which crops could go along which parts of the mountains.
The Inca's national origin story even features its protagonists testing the soil with a golden
staff to see where they should settle. And the most prevalent Andean god also carries two staves,
which I could not find anything confirming if this had to do with the staff testing soil,
but if it does, then it's another example of religion adhering to environment-specific
practices of people groups. Now, I've heard an argument that tropical peoples tend to form
urban civilization up in the mountains where the climate may be more temperate, and where they
could escape diseases from wetlands and the forests. Some examples may be how the Mexica
civilization formed in the mountains of Mesoamerica, or Andean civilization in the Andes. I
personally don't buy into this argument much, as there are plenty of tropical rainforest
civilizations centered in the lowlands. Particularly in my focus is Southeast Asia,
Majapahit in Indonesia, the Khmer Empire, but even here we see the Lanna and Lansang states
rise over the mountains, though they were never really the strongest in their regions,
so this argument, like much of this video, is more a matter of what subjects you wish to focus on.
Now, I can fully believe this argument in arid areas where mountain elevations allow for more
green temperate zones, like with the Ethiopian highlands giving rise to the powerful states of
Axum and Abyssinia, where if these highlands didn't exist it would otherwise be desert and
savannah. For most peoples, mountains are a major barrier for travel and expansion.
India is shielded on its eastern flank by the Himalayas, which is why all its pre-modern invaders
came down from its northwest. The Caucasus separate the Russians from the Iranians and
other groups. The Alps are protective of Italy until someone's brave enough to cross them with
elephants. Mountains are a very strong argument to make when saying that geography determines
human civilization. In most cases mountainous areas tend to be sort of backwaters compared to
the densely populated lowlands nearby. Think China and Tibet, or England and Scotland. It's true that
mountains tend to have fewer resources to accommodate large populations, though they
might get by with pastoralism, farming in valleys, or even collecting the unique plants that grow at
high altitudes that can make medicine or perfume. There are still people who live in these areas
though, and they can grow to be quite powerful. The Tibetan empire still astonishes me a bit, and I
hope to one day look into their history more. Mountains are also refuges for people who need
to escape society. Think monks living in isolation, or even Mao Zedong on his long march through the
mountains of Yunnan. But I've been thinking recently a lot about Iran's geography, being a very
mountainous and arid plateau that has given rise to one of the most impactful civilizations in
human history. It is encapsulated by the massive Zagros mountains in its west, the Elbers mountains
in its north, and smaller ranges in its east. In ancient history the state of Elam grew around the
foothills and valleys of the southern Zagros mountains. It consisted of a mix of foothill
and mountain valley agricultural settlements and nomadic populations of the interior. Much later
on came the Median empire, which we know depressingly little about. Although the Assyrians earlier
described them in quite nomadic terms, they had cities, but they also were great horsemen that
would flee into the mountains at trouble. Iran's position seems to mix the culture and politics of
Mesopotamian urbanized society with that of the nomadic groups that would frequently migrate
in from Central Asia. It's a protected plateau at a crossroads between these urban and nomadic
societies, and I personally think that that kind of long-term interaction was a factor in creating
this unique, innovative, and strong civilization. Now, can we attribute the political and empire
building innovations of the later Achaemenid Empire to this kind of urban nomad interaction?
I really don't know. Maybe it has nothing to do with geography, but it would make an interesting
study. Jumping all the way back to the Andes, I first want to look at Tiwanaku, a city on the
Altiplano Plateau's Lake Titicaca. Tiwanaku relied heavily on the freshwater resources of the lake,
and irrigated their crops from it and its surrounding rivers. It created here a powerful
state of its own, although scholars debate if it was an expansive empire like the Wari Empire to
their north, and this can be in part attributed to their geography, as their position let them
control trade from the river valleys of the dry Peruvian coast to the Amazon. Tiwanaku's monumental
architecture emphasized their position as a hub for trade, as its massive gates would have posed
a strong visual argument for their power and prestige in the region. But there's no mountainous
civilization quite like that of the Incas. If Andean civilization didn't exist, I never would
have been able to guess that such a society could arise in these conditions, where for most,
mountains are a barrier to the Incas, the Andes, where they're beating heart and arteries.
The variation in mountainous climate zones allows for there to be patches of similar climate and
soil all along the Andes, despite South America going from rainforest down to desert with latitude,
and with a lot of variation by elevation, they could grow multiple crops on different levels
up and down the mountains, where latitude would otherwise not allow. It makes the Incan Empire
stand out as probably the only vertically oriented pre-modern empire on the map,
but taming this rough landscape was still a communal effort that required a lot of labor.
The construction of terraces, aqueducts, large-scale architecture, and roads and bridges
had them levying taxes in the form of conscripted labor. A state's authority does not just emanate
from having the biggest military, but also organizing its population to be productive
and innovative in how it leverages its resources. A powerful state will be able to do that well,
completing beneficial projects of scale that would otherwise be unfeasible.
Now, when living in the mountains, travel is obviously an extremely difficult barrier to
overcome. Andean people solved this by creating a very developed network of roads, bridges,
and travel accommodations. The road network was particularly important for the Incas,
as their messenger system carried with it special protections and privileges,
and they put a lot of effort into creating and maintaining this system.
States, civilizations, and empires arise around the connectedness of regions to the imperial core,
because you need your regions to be accessible for trade, labor, and military conquest for you
to exert any control whatsoever. The Incas are probably the strongest argument for my thesis
here, problems posed by the environment, interconnectivity being the foundation of
a civilization's reach. Their civilizational projects highlight both of these things
amazingly, probably because it conspicuously took so much effort to do.
Okay, we've talked almost exclusively about biomes, terrain, and river features up until this
point, but all over the world we see areas where insufficient land resources turn people to the
seas. The ocean presents incredible interconnectivity of faraway lands, as long as
people have the technology to use them. Think of how the Roman Empire developed around the sea
networks of the Mediterranean, and had a more difficult time holding peripheral areas that
weren't connected to these networks. Maritime life is even more important for societies living
on islands. Developing on an island presents many unique circumstances, it might limit how
much usable land you have, many islands are mountainous and difficult to work, having a
strong navy becomes necessary for protecting your homeland, and any large-scale trade or
politics will necessitate seafaring. In a past video, I've argued that developing on a large
island gives a state more impetus for controlling its entire island before controlling any mainland
territories, as this would secure your cities by land. And that may be true, the Tokugawa Shogun
did unite the southern three Japanese islands before turning its attention to Korea, but there
are enough counter-examples to make me doubt this, such as the Angevin and Majapite Empires,
which did not control the entirety of their central islands, while having territories on
other islands and their mainland. The Angevins alone suffered from several wars from the
opportunistic Scots, so this argument I made may be a geography-based ideal that doesn't hold up
when the politics, legal institutions, and maritime incentives are taken into consideration.
We've already talked about why the Scandinavians took to the sea and created the Viking period of
trading and raiding, but we can see Greece taking a similar trajectory. The Greek peninsula had
limited farmland, intense competition for resources, and the easily navigable Aegean
Islands, which pushed them to engage in more trade and sending people out to found colonies,
oftentimes when the home city was overpopulated or they needed to get rid of a troublesome group.
Austronesian peoples by 1000 BC had already settled in Melanesia and Fiji, and living on
islands with a lot of oceanic resources pushed the later Polynesians to become some of the
sailors of the pre-modern world, colonizing the most remote areas of the Pacific and even likely
reaching South America. Carthage, in turn, had one of the best starting positions as a Phoenician
colony. It had abundant fertile land and sat on a strategic central position for trade between
Africa and Southern Europe. Carthage's expansion as an empire was rooted in their geographic
prosperity, but was motivated by control of these trade routes and the productive lands around them.
Also, just a side note, Carthage's geography trumps Punic-era Rome's geography any day of the
week. I think it would be silly to argue about geography for the Punic Wars though, instead of
focusing on state and military institutions, values, and systematic innovations in this case.
However, geography certainly dictated how and why the Punic Wars were fought,
since even looking at a map of the first Punic War can tell you where they'd come into conflict,
the giant breadbasket island between them. Societies developing a strong maritime tradition
would also have more benefits to raiding, especially to sail long distances to attack
different people who have different resources and valuables. We see this not only in the Vikings,
but in the Haida people in the maritime Pacific Northwest, who would fight sea battles in their
canoes and raid coastal peoples for plunder and slaves. This isn't to say that the Norse and Haida
did not attack and raid each other, small scale communities in neighboring states frequently do
that, but it is beneficial to a region to take plunder and captives from people they don't live
next door to. The configuration and placement of land is vitally important for maritime trade.
Any islands or peninsulas in the middle of a large body of water immediately become important,
as ships need a place to resupply, repair damage, and take a break. So places like Hawaii, Malta,
Carthage become important pitstops for merchants and militaries on these trade routes.
Venice has an interesting position here, as it was on the halfway mark of the Mediterranean,
but sequestered here at the top of the Adriatic Sea. Venice's geography as a little swamp island
led its people to turn to the sea, but its position on the continent allowed it to act
as a gateway of trade from the Mediterranean sea routes into Austria and Southern Germany.
After it received tax exemptions for trading in the Byzantine Empire, it expanded to control
much of the Balkan and Greek coast, and had a lot of control over trade with the entire region.
Trade based societies like Venice are often quite multicultural and wealthy,
as the trade routes bring in people from all over, and the moneyed interest of the merchant
class play a large, maybe even dominating role in their politics. And of course, any cities founded
on choke points of maritime trade can easily tax and control the trade routes that go through it.
Byzantium, Gibraltar, Copenhagen, Aden, Nagapattinam in South India, Malacca. Even if
these places don't control the narrow straits themselves, it's significant to be a nearby
pitstop where everyone's gonna go to. But even without this amazing advantage,
simply being a port city gateway between land and sea trade routes is enough. As this developed,
the Swahili city-states on the East African coast, which brought the bountiful resources
of inland Africa to the Indian Ocean networks. This mixture of the present African peoples
and Arab merchants and settlers created a whole new cosmopolitan culture, the region's
lingua franca of Swahili, and a unique political circumstance where merchant-slaver warlords would
conquer the inland to control the production of its resources. Especially as you get into the
modern period, geography's relationship with trade and global shipping networks works its way
into just about everyone's lives. Trade, transportation, and the movement of ideas
is foundationally important to a society's wealth, culture, and technological development.
The Arabian Peninsula sits at the crossroads of the Mediterranean Sea and overland trade from
North Africa, the Caucasus, and Central Asia. Arab merchants dominated in the medieval period
and oversaw the traveling of new crops, goods, and people from all around these trade routes
into the Middle East. And later, the Portuguese and Spanish ushered in the Age of Exploration,
with gradual improvements to the sailing technology that was being used by North African
merchants. With Portugal especially being an Atlantic Maritime Society, once these kingdoms
figured out the tech to sail deep into this ocean, it was no longer a giant death zone,
but a highway, ushering in globalization, western colonization, and the Colombian exchange. Cultural
exchange that happens on trade routes is, in my opinion, imperative for the development of
massive civilizations. Okay, especially talking about European colonization brings me to an
important topic, historians' criticisms of geographic determinism. To be precise,
geographic determinism is the idea that a society's growth and characteristics are the
direct result of its underlying geography. This is an attractive way to look at things because
it convincingly makes history and human behavior a kind of multi-faceted math equation of environmental
pressures. But it's a controversial perspective that historians are rightfully very critical of.
Let's take Jared Diamond's best-selling book, Guns, Germs, and Steel, for example.
Diamond's argument is roughly that Eurasian powers became dominant by a handful of geographic
preconditions. Eurasia's large east-west orientation lets it share expansive climate
zones all along it. This allowed for the spread of more food crops and domesticable animals,
which among other factors led to larger cities, militaries, trade routes, and development of lethal
plagues which the Americas didn't have any immunity to. And that more geographically split
up regions like Europe gave rise to different states and competition, which pushed them to
compete and colonize for natural resources on other continents.
Within the lens of geographic determinism, I don't see a ton wrong with Diamond's thesis.
It's the exact same stuff we're talking about here today, and it's definitely a step up from
the idea that Europe dominated by any inherent moral or intellectual superiority. But the problem
is this lens of geographic determinism. For one, historians criticize Diamond for cherry-picking
examples to paint geography as deterministic of certain outcomes. And yes, I am painfully aware
that this is what this entire video is doing. It is the only way to globally see how geographies
determine civilization at large. But that is an inherent, major flaw of geographic determinism
and trying to de-emphasize the human elements of human history. You can't accurately tell the story
of Britain or Spain's colonization of the Americas without diving deep into how they embedded
themselves into the native political structures, how medieval Christianities created the impetus
for expansion, or how European monarchs ideologically understood their relationship
with their subjects and how to accumulate wealth for their kingdoms. Now, you could
argue that all of these have their roots in geography too. Maybe Europe's maritime geography
allowed for the connections that created the political, religious, and economic moment.
But I could argue that it was only the technology, politics, and institutions that made this
geography usable in this way too. This YouTuber Kraut painted geographic determinism as a
chicken and egg dilemma, and I think that's a good term for it, because geography is only usable
insofar as your technology and society allows you to use it, and vice versa. Think, if your
civilization found a literal El Dorado city of gold in your backyard, that geography could open
up the opportunity to be the richest civilization on earth. But that only works if you can get there,
you can mine the gold, your society already highly values gold, and you don't inflate your
own gold economy to be worthless. Civilization-less grows out of a particular geography, and more does
a push and pull dance with its geography. Now, clearly geography is still an important
factor in the development of states and societies. No civilization is divorced from its geographical
reality, but let's not use it to create some overall meta-narrative where it 100% explains
the rise and fall of civilizations. That takes away the choices, politics, technology, institutions,
ideologies, and pure chance that are foundational to analyzing history. It's telling that Jared
is professionally an evolutionary biologist and ecologist, which might blind him to these
particularly human facets of why things happen. I think the best way to look at it is simply,
geography poses humans with both challenges and opportunities, and humans work together
and innovate new technologies in response, which creates new challenges and opportunities,
which we respond to again and again and again. Remember to check out worldanvil.com with the
code STONEWORKS for 51% off an entire year. Thanks for watching everyone.
