Reviving What Was Lost - Conserving General Hamilton - Episode 3

Legacy Conservatory
14 followers
#AntiqueRestoration"For the final episode in this series the painting is reassembled both structurally and with respect to the image. Care is taken to preserve the previously hidden inscription and the retouching is executed with reversible materials in a manner that's more respectful of the painting. And after all the work we finally see what General Hamilton looked like standing proud in his battle armor for his grand portrait.
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores to marketing tools
and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence
and run your business. An ad and sponsorship free version of this video is available through
my Patreon, in addition to my entire back catalog, ad and sponsorship free, as well as behind the
scenes content, Q&As, and a whole bunch of other stuff. So, if you're at all curious, head on over
to my Patreon to check it out. In episode 2, we saw the removal and reversal of old work, and now
in the final episode, we're going to see the painting get put back together. But before I can
do much else, I need to first take care of the canvas. And while the canvas is in pretty good
condition, it's not great, and I want to take action to make sure that it's stable and sound.
So I'm going to be doing an adhesive impregnation. This will strengthen the canvas and give it more
fidelity, much like a lining would, but it will preserve the inscription's visibility. And not
only was that inscription really a fun discovery, but it's a super important part of this painting's
provenance, because now we know that this is not Prince George of Hesse-Darmstadt. In fact, it's
General Hamilton. And at the same time that I was doing some research and reaching out to some
scholars to inquire about which Hamilton this may be, I was surprised and encouraged to see so many
viewers of this video doing the same. And I received dozens of links from viewers to websites
full of esoteric information on Hamiltons, on Scotland, on the royal family's genealogy and
portrait painters. And frankly, none of that would have been possible had those people not put their
passions and their interests on the web for everyone to see. And so it's a clear example of
why a website could be of benefit to you. Yeah, you. So head over to Squarespace, where with the
click of a button, you can have a website up and running almost instantly. And it's the easiest way
to give your idea, your passion, your expertise wings. And one of the great things about Squarespace
is that their websites are all modular. So you can start off with a single page, pretty basic.
But if your idea or your passion grows and you need a blog, or you want to add a gallery, you can
do that too. And if it grows even further and turns into a business, well, you can add an online
marketplace and do online bookings and scheduling. So just like your passion knows no limits,
neither will your website, as long as it's Squarespace, of course. So head over to
to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Now the adhesive is first heated up
and allowed to get into a more liquid state. And this facilitates an easy application to the back
of the painting with a roller. And when it's in this more liquid state, it can penetrate into and
through the canvas. I'll then let that cool and dry and transfer the painting over to the hot table.
Now I'm going to put the painting on a piece of silicone release film and then cover it with
another piece of silicone release film. Otherwise I could inadvertently end up gluing the painting
to the table. And don't ask me how I know that to be the case. I can then create the envelope
that's going to secure the painting to the table. And those cotton webbings will help extract the
air from that envelope. I'll tape it down to make sure that there's a good air seal. And then I'll
turn on the hot table, turn on the vacuum and allow it to do its work. Now this process generally
takes a couple of hours to complete from start to finish because of course the table has to heat up
and then it has to cool down. Determining the right amount of pressure onto a painting is really
a delicate art. For too much pressure, if we remember, can cause flattening of the paint film or
like on this painting, melting of the varnish layer and flattening. So once the painting has cooled,
I can remove it from that envelope and I can transfer it over to the table where I can start
taking care of the tears that we found. Now it looks pretty scary to transfer a painting like this
but actually if you do it enough you realize that it's not that complicated and letting the canvas
go where it wants to is their best course of action. Now rather than applying a new lining
to deal with these tears or even a patch, I'm going to be doing a technique called bridging.
And bridging is a fairly simple approach to mending a tear. Now we have to keep in mind that
this canvas isn't under such extreme tension like a stocking that a tear or a hole could run.
But we do need to make sure that that canvas stays flat and doesn't open up, otherwise the
fill-in medium that I'll apply later will crack. So by taking small strands of Belgian linen,
dipping them into a conservation adhesive, and placing them perpendicularly across the tear,
I can bridge that tear. And these little strips of Belgian linen will hold that tear in place,
make sure that it doesn't open, and give a little bit more structural support to an otherwise
weakened area. I can cover it with silicone release film, some felt, and then some weights,
and leave it for a day or two, or as long as it needs to dry and set up. After the adhesive
has dried, I can remove the weights and the felt, and I can take a look at my handiwork,
just to make sure that it's how I want. Now at this point, if any of the fibers have distorted
or I'm not satisfied, I can remove that. But in this case, everything looks like it's come
out exactly how I anticipated. So I can move on to the next step, which is preparing the canvas
for a strip lining. Even though it wasn't necessary to do a full lining, the tacking
edges of the original canvas are really in bad shape where they exist at all, and they're just
not strong enough to handle the process of stretching, or even to hold the tacks that
are going to be put in. So I have to add some more meat, so to speak. And so by using strips
of Belgian linen, I can not only add fidelity to the crease where the canvas goes around the
I can make sure that the tacks don't pull through that canvas, and I can give myself
a little bit more material to pull on when I'm stretching the painting.
This approach is a nice compromise between doing too much, in this case a full lining,
and nothing at all, which would undoubtedly be bad for the painting. This adds support and
strength where it's needed, while still allowing the rest of the canvas to be viewed in its original
state. So it's the best choice for this particular project. In addition to cutting the canvas, I'll
cut several strips of adhesive film. The same adhesive that I used in the impregnation is used
in the strip lining process, and that ensures that there is a very, very strong bond between the new
canvas and the old canvas. Now once all of the strips have been cut, I'll fray the edges, and
this serves a couple of purposes. One, it creates a softer edge that has less chance of leaving a
mark or a ghost on the front of the painting if the canvas is thin. Not such a big concern if the
original canvas is very thick or there's a lot of paint, but on some paintings like this one, where
it's thinly painted and a fairly thin canvas, this is critically important. In addition, fraying the
edge provides more surface area for the adhesive film to bond to, and that's just going to make
sure that the bond is extra strong. Now one of the things I really like about using this adhesive
film when strip lining is that it's fairly easy to apply. The adhesive film has one layer, the paper
backing removed, it's laid down onto the canvas, and then ironed on and allowed to cool. It's that
simple. Once cooled, I can peel back the top layer of release film, and then the adhesive is on the
painting and ready for the canvas to be set down onto it. It does not require a ton of heat, and
I've placed some silicone release film underneath the painting just in case there is a little bit
of extra adhesive on the front or hanging off the edge so that it doesn't bond the painting to the
table. Now applying the strip lining is really just as simple as applying the adhesive. Lay it down,
iron it on, put a weight, move over. But the weight is critically important because even though this
material is all dry, it's not devoid of moisture. There's still ambient moisture in this fabric,
and so anybody who's ironed a shirt will know that even if you don't spray any water on it,
there is still moisture in it, and you can hear that steam created when you apply a warm or hot
iron. And that's not really all that interesting or important. What is important is that when that
turns into steam, it causes this canvas to expand, and then when it dries, it contracts. And so having
it under weights makes sure that it doesn't distort not only the strip lining canvas, but the
original canvas as well. Now I'll cut off the fray up to the edge of the original canvas because this
will just get in the way and be messy, and if I don't do it now, it's harder to do later. And now
on to preparing the stretcher. I will square up this stretcher using a square, and using some nails
in each of the corners, I'll make sure that it doesn't deform as I'm handling it. I've removed as much
of the paper tape and white glue as possible, and there are some remnants still there, but it's
always a fine balance between really scraping off all of the oxidization and weathering and wear
on the stretcher just to have a clean support. This stretcher support is fine. It's stable, it's
strong enough for the painting, and ultimately it is going to be covered by the strip lining canvas
and a backing board. Now I was recently asked if I'm ever terrified that I will drop a painting,
and my response was, well, aren't you always terrified when you pick up a baby that you will
and to which the response was, of course. And so when I'm picking up a painting, I am hyper-aware
of where I'm moving and how I'm moving so that I don't drop the painting. Now, paintings aren't
really as important as babies, and if I dropped one, I could definitely fix it, but, you know, I'm
trying to avoid that. Now, I noticed when I put the painting on the support that the inscription is
covered by the crossbar, which indicates to me that this is not the original support.
So I remove the painting from the crossbar and I take a photograph of it for posterity.
I also noticed that the painting didn't fit on the support. Now, I had squared up this support to
make sure that the painting would fit, but it turns out that the painting was actually painted
crooked. Yeah, that's right. The original painting is not square. It's a parallelogram.
So I have to modify this stretcher, again, not the original stretcher, to fit this odd shape.
There is an argument to be made for cropping the painting to a square proportion to facilitate
easier framing and handling, but that means that part of the original painting is going to get
cropped off, and there are going to be slivers of raw canvas that then need to be overpainted.
I'm not okay with either of those. I don't want any of the original to be cropped off,
and I don't want to have to do an excess amount of overpainting or inpainting. It's just not
something that I'm good with. So I'm going to unsquare this stretcher support and make it
wonky to fit the painting. And once I have it wonky, I am going to secure everything in place
with a couple of clips and some acid-free blotter paper just to protect the painting. I'll go around
to make sure that this stretcher is exactly how I want, make sure that none of the image is cropped
off, and then I'll remove those clips, I'll flip the stretcher over, and I'll secure it into its
new goofy shape with nails in the corner. And you can see just how crooked this painting
originally was. That's a big difference. But it's what the painting calls for, so it's what I'm
going to do. This is not very common, but when it happens, I think this is the best approach.
Now, if there were no stretcher and we needed to procure one for the painting,
I may argue of making the painting larger and then framing it in a way that covers up those
gaps of raw canvas. But that's not the case. We have a stretcher support, so we're going to use
what we have. Incidentally, when I was looking at this stretcher support, not only is it not the
original, but the top edge was cut down to fit this painting by about an inch and a half or two
compared to the bottom edge. So whomever worked on this painting last really took a lot of
liberties in their decision making about what was best for the painting, and I suspect those decisions
were made based on what was best for the conservator, which I'm not sure I agree with.
Now, before I can really get started on the stretching, I have to secure the middle of each
side, and that creates a nice anchor point that will make sure that when I stretch it,
and nothing deviates or distorts. A common misconception is that I'm going to create
ripples in the canvas as I stretch it, and so this facilitates moving those ripples to the edges.
Well, that's true if you're working with a raw canvas or one that's just been primed, but when
there's paint on it, you really aren't putting that much tension on the canvas to create ripples,
and if you are, you're probably doing it wrong. The stretching process is really just to get the
painting set and somewhat tight on the support. We're not looking to make it like a drum, and if
we need to add more tension afterwards, well, that's what the keys are for. So here, I'm not
over-tightening the support. I'm just looking to give it an even amount of tension all the way
across to make sure that it's well secured to the stretcher, and compared to the number of staples
that were used to secure this painting to the stretcher, I'm using comparatively few tacks,
one every inch and a half or so. It's really not necessary to put a tack every centimeter or every
half inch. It doesn't provide any benefit above less tacks, and it just compromises the support
and the strip lining canvas. Basically, we want to use as many as we have to while using as few
as we need to. That make sense? I think so. Now, as I come to the end of the edge of the canvas,
I like to tuck in the strip lining and tack it right at the edge, and it looks tidy, but it also
helps ensure that that canvas doesn't fray. It may look as if I'm using a lot of force to drive
these tacks in, but really, I'm letting the weight of the hammer do most of the work. I'm not trying
to pound these in and really stress out the stretcher support. I want to drive them in with
as little force as necessary. When I reach the end, I cut off the excess and trim it, because
it just gets in the way if it's too long, and then, again, I'll tuck that canvas in and make
sure that it's tidy and tight. It's little things like these that make a big difference in ensuring
the longevity of the work that I do. And of course, any time I do a strip lining, there is
excess canvas that needs to be dealt with. Other people may glue this down or staple it. I prefer
to use tacks, because I think, again, it looks good and it's easy to remove if ever that is the
case. And when I come to the end, I cut off the excess and I fold it all under and make it tidy.
Again, this is just something that I have developed as a practice, because it works for me,
my clients seem to be receptive towards it, and I haven't yet found any other way that is better
to do this. If, indeed, I do find a better way, well, then I'll switch, because, of course, I am in service
of the painting and the highest quality of work. Deciding on what tacks to use is relative to the
materials that I'm working with. So a larger painting may get heavier weight tacks, or a
thinner canvas may get lighter weight tacks, because using a four-ounce tack on a very light, thin canvas
isn't really appropriate. It's too aggressive. Conversely, using a one-and-a-half-ounce tack
on a very heavy canvas is ineffective. So for each canvas, each application, there is a proper
material. To secure this painting to the stretcher, I'm using a three-ounce tack, and to secure this
strip lining to the back, I'm using a one-and-a-half-ounce tack, just in case anyone was curious.
Now, there are some keys that were original to this stretcher, and I'm lucky that I have them,
because some were missing. So I can take the originals, and I can trace them onto a piece of
wood, and I can recreate them. The original keys are fine, they do their job well, and they are a
great model for what would be appropriate, period correct, to this support. I have thought about
staining or oxidizing the wood that I use, but that will happen over time. Nature will take its
course, so it's not anything that I need to do right away. I'll stack a bunch of pieces of wood
together and trim them on the bandsaw, make quick work of it, and it ensures that they're all the
same size. There's nothing terribly complicated or complex here, it's just kind of basic stuff,
but using keys that match in size not only ensures that they provide the adequate
tensioning for the stretcher, it also looks good, and it's a sign that detail and attention
was paid to this painting's conservation. I often say that it's not when people are looking
that your best work is judged, it's when nobody's looking. And generally, nobody's looking at the
back of the painting, and so that's a pretty good point to start to see if the work that was done
by the previous conservator or the person who worked on the painting last was quality work,
if they cared about the details, if they paid attention to the little things, like making sure
the replacement keys were the same size as the originals. I'm going to drill some holes in all
of these keys so that I can facilitate the securing of them to the stretcher support.
Luckily, none of these keys split, and sometimes that happens with these old
keys that are really brittle or warped, but I got lucky this time, so yay me.
The function of these keys is to expand the stretcher support, and so I'll place them into
the little mortises for which they are designed, and I'll tap them in just gently. Again, I'm not
really doing much tapping, and I'm not trying to bang them in and really stretch out the support.
I want to go around the canvas multiple times and add a little bit of tension at each point,
and once I've successfully gone around a couple of times and ensured that the canvas is nice and
taut and that the pressure is even, I can secure these keys in place. And through those holes that
I drilled, I will feed some fishing wire, and I will secure it to another tack that I've placed
in the corner. I'll wrap it around, hammer the tack in, and then I will trim off the excess
fishing line. There are many ways to secure keys in place. I really don't have an opinion one way
or the other on which is best. Actually, I do. I think fishing line is the best. String seems
to break, wire is a little bit too rigid, and using nails just doesn't do it. Either way,
making sure that they're secure is important so that we don't, A, lose them, and B, that they
don't fall in between the canvas and create a bulge. So now, because we did have some paint loss,
particularly in the areas where there were tears and holes, we have to fill in those gaps. We can't
just add paint because we will see a divot. Using a white chalk-based reversible infill medium,
I can go over the areas where the paint was lost, apply the medium liberally, and then let it dry.
In the past, I have used tinted fill-in material, and there is a time and a place for that,
particularly on old master paintings where the ground may be red. But in this case,
the ground was not red, and the white will enable me to see the fill-in really clearly.
If I were to tint this brown or black, which I have done in the past, I have found that it
becomes so difficult to see where the fill-in medium was applied that it makes the retouching
process a little bit more difficult. It's kind of counterintuitive that if the fill-in medium
blends in better, it makes the retouching harder. Now, most of this tacking edge area is going to
be covered by the frame rabbet, but that doesn't mean that I can leave it alone. I'm still going
to fill in all of those areas. And once the fill-in has been allowed to dry, I'll go over
it with a swab, and I'll start to remove the excess, because of course we only want the areas
where the paint is lost to be filled in. It's not okay to overfill and leave all of that excess
fill-in material, because that's covering the original paint, and that's the artist's original
hand. And if we remember this area of the tear, it was heavily overpainted, and we could still see
the tear, because it was never filled in. Nobody took this step to ensure that the area was smooth.
Now, I'll remove as much as I can with the swab, but sometimes the swab isn't the right tool. It
can pick up too much. So I'll take a piece of sponge that's dry, and cut small, and I'll rub
it over the surface of the fill-in. The sponge is just abrasive enough that it can pick up some of
the fill-in that's standing proud, effectively sanding it, but it's not so abrasive that it
Now, on to retouching.
We are very lucky, or I am very lucky, you guys maybe not so much, that this painting does not
require a profound amount of retouching, because that means it's going to be fairly straightforward
and, frankly, kind of easy. And some days, that's exactly what you want. Now, there is a very
prominent tear right across this gentleman's face, and while some have commented that it is pretty
badass and makes him look tough, I don't think we want to keep it. In fact, I'm 100% sure my client
does not want this tear visible. So the first thing that I do is start to mix a base color,
just something to cover up the white, kind of give me a reference point. If it's too orange,
or too brown, or it needs to be cooler, and some blue or black needs to be added.
And from that base color, I can move left or right. I can move warmer or cooler, lighter or darker.
And that's a lot easier to do than starting off with the lightest color, or starting off with
the darkest color. By starting in the middle, I can go both ways, and it just makes the retouching
process that much easier. Now, that doesn't always work, but for an area of color like this, where
it is relatively constrained and just about in the same family, it is an approach that works
wonderfully. Unlike the past retouching, which was really kind of just an overpainting of this whole
area, I am doing very little. Attentive viewers may notice that no isolation layer was applied
before the retouching. That's for a couple of reasons. One, I know that this paint layer is safe
when used with these retouching paints and the solvents required to remove them, so removing
this retouching won't harm the painting. But more importantly, I want to brush varnish this painting,
and I want to do a varnish technique called brushing out. And I can't do that if there is an
isolation layer, because I need to apply the final varnish via spray. So I'm using a cotton ball with
mineral spirits to simulate the application of an isolation layer. When this mineral spirits is
applied to the painting, it darkens the color, saturates them up, and makes them look as if they
have a varnish applied. I can then start the retouching process. Every now and again, I'll
reapply some mineral spirits to check the colors to make sure that they're still accurate. And then,
when it comes time to varnish, I won't have to worry about brushing out the varnish and lifting
off any retouching that's sitting atop that isolation layer. Now, this tear was completely
overpainted. It looked as if somebody took a one-inch brush and just liberally applied paint
over this whole area and painted it dark brown. But this isn't a dark brown area. There are curls
of the sitter's hair here. There are highlights and lowlights, there are mid-tones, and there's
actually some definition of form. So, by being more attentive and just retouching what's necessary,
not only can we make the tear disappear better, we can ensure that the continuity of the image remains.
And thanks to the magic of high-speed video, we can see this retouching come together quickly.
I'll apply some paint, then apply some more mineral spirits to check to see if that paint
is matching in form and color, and then I'll do it again until I've reached a point where I'm
satisfied with the retouching. As I finish up this retouching and put the final dabs of color on,
and we take a look at it before the retouching, we can see that there's quite a difference.
Now, as we come to another area of the painting that requires retouching,
these areas where I'm pointing to with the back of my brush, they were over-cleaned. During the
last conservation, perhaps the solvent was too strong or too much pressure was used and
some of the original paint was lifted off the canvas. Unlike a tear or a little hole that has
a defined area requiring retouching, an area where you know that you don't need to apply paint because
the original is still there, this area is different because some of the original is there,
it's a light sketch, a suggestion, but it's not what was there. And so it requires a different
type of retouching, and that's where glazing comes into play. Glazing is the technique of
taking a very thin, semi-transparent paint and applying it across the area of damage.
And what we're really trying to do here, again, is just blend this damage away. Make it so that
it's not so prominent and that our eye passes over this area and sees it as a whole picture.
Now, there are differing opinions about glazing. Some conservators never do it,
some conservators have no problem doing it. It is a technique that has been used throughout
conservation historically, so it is not forbidden or verboten. And I am fairly agnostic
on this approach, and I take my cues from my clients. But one of the good things about using
reversible paints is that if the next conservator or next client doesn't like this, they can simply
wipe it off. While my client would like this, and I believe that this is a benefit to the image,
it's not permanent, so the stakes are actually very low. How's that look, Jillian? Looks good?
All right, let's go varnish it. Now, you remember when I started the retouching, I mentioned that
there was no isolation layer on this painting because I wanted to do a specific technique
of varnishing called brushing out, and an isolation layer would complicate that.
So the first thing I do is mix my varnish, and in this case it's going to be a fairly glossy varnish.
And the next thing I'll do is I'll add my HALS, my Hindered Amine Light Stabilizer.
And this is a resin that prevents ultraviolet light from corrupting the varnish or even
penetrating through the varnish to the painting surface. Now, I'm using a four-inch-wide natural
bristle brush because it holds a ton of varnish. And I always start by going around the perimeter
of the painting. And I've thought about this, and I think it's a combination of my printmaking days
and laying on ink on lithograph stones, and also how I saw my father do it. And I've come to realize
that the reason I do it is by depositing the majority of the varnish on the edges. Whenever
my brush crosses it, it picks up some of that varnish and recharges it, and means that I don't
have to go back to the jar so often. In addition, it means that I don't have to hit the edge of the
I don't have to go all the way off the edge and make a mess splashing varnish around the studio,
or drip that varnish onto the tacking edges. And so I'm going to make this first pass and just
deposit the varnish. I'm not really all that concerned about brush marks or where the varnish
is going. I just want to get the whole painting covered in varnish. And then, after I've covered
the entire painting, I can start changing directions and evening out this first application
of varnish. I started going with short lengths, and now I'm going to go the long way, overlapping
my strokes, going fairly fast, moving across the entire surface of the painting, making sure that
every area has been hit with varnish and is smooth and even. As I go along the way, if I see a little
fuzz or a little hair from the varnish brush, I'll pick it up and get rid of it. Now, as this varnish
is drying, I am going to continue to brush it out. And that means that as the solvent evaporates from
this resin and it starts to get stiffer and tackier, as I brush it out, the friction is going
to create a microtexture on the surface of that varnish. And so I can take a fairly glossy varnish
and I can keep brushing it out, and it creates a glittery effect. It's not quite satin because
it's a little bit shinier, but it's not full gloss that could look plastic. It's a really
beautiful technique that I've started to perfect. Got a long way to go, but I think it looks fantastic.
Now, I'm taking my badger hair brush, and I'm just going to distress some of these areas that are
a little bit slicker or shinier than others. And this happens sometimes when there's retouching
or sometimes when the paint application is different than another area. And just by
distressing it a little bit, I can create another level of microtexture that helps when the light
hits it so that it's not so smooth and it doesn't look so slick. And all that remains is to get this
painting into the frame. And I'm going to skip over a lot of what I'm doing here because it's
really not all that interesting to talk about. But the question remains, who is this guy?
We know it's not Prince George of Hesse-Darmstadt. It says General Hamilton on the back.
But which General Hamilton? In Scotland, Hamilton is probably the most common name,
and there are so many General Hamiltons who are old white guys who look a little bit heavy and
have wigs and armor and are posing in front of castles for grand royal portraits. You could
throw a dart and land on a General Hamilton that fits the bill. So who is it? Well, I reached out
to some scholars, some art historians, and had tons of emails from viewers who felt like they
had figured it out. And generally the consensus was that this is James Hamilton, the fourth Duke
of Hamilton. Now, is it him? Or is it somebody else? We may never know because the artist never
signed the work. There is no date. And aside from General Hamilton, there is no other inscription
and no provenance to go with the painting. And it's an interesting question because how could
a grand royal painting of a fairly important person be lost to history? I mean, we have the
painting, so it's not completely lost, but all of the provenance, all of the story kind of vanished
into thin air. So while it's a fun dinner party exercise to debate who it is, we may actually
never know. Now, some historian may come along and figure it out, but until that day, well,
this is General Hamilton. Artist unknown, provenance unknown. But what we do know
is that before the painting came into the studio, it was not in its best condition. There was some
bad structural work. The painting was yellowed and dirty. You could see the tears that had been
poorly repaired and that inscription was covered. But by reversing all of that work, taking off the
old lining, we revealed the original canvas and the inscription. So now we know it's General
Hamilton. And by removing all that old varnish, we were able to see the beauty of the armor,
the highlights, and to see the sitter's expression and facial features better. So while we may never
know who he really is, at least he's in a better condition than he was before he arrived.
So thanks as always for coming along on this project and witnessing the transformation of
Prince George of Hesse-Darmstadt to General Hamilton. The twist I didn't see coming. And
there is an ad and sponsor free version of this video up on my Patreon. And Patreon members
actually saw this video yesterday. So if you're all curious for what's available,
go check it out. There's some cool stuff that I have to offer.
