What were Frans Hals' earliest paintings? | Behind the Scenes with Conservation | National Gallery

Legacy Conservatory
14 followers
#AntiqueRoyal"A pair of 400-year-old portraits were separated for nearly two centuries, and are now held in two different collections: The Barber Institute of Fine Arts and the Devonshire Collections at Chatsworth.
Larry Keith, the Head of Conservation, meets Alice Martin from Chatsworth House to discuss how the conservation team conserved these two marriage portraits by Frans Hals, bringing them together for 'The Credit Suisse Exhibition: Frans Hals'."
So some unsuspecting tree in the early 1600s in the Netherlands has ended up here and these
have been separated for almost 200 years and now they're coming back together. That's extraordinary.
So we're here to look at a couple of paintings by Frans Hals, one from Chatsworth and one from
the Barber Institute and the working theory is that they were painted as a pair and they
belong together and they've been separated for a long time. Yeah I mean it's so exciting for
us because this portrait which usually hangs at Chatsworth in the Great Dining Room but she's
become over time almost part of this sort of faux pennant hang. So I think what's really
fascinating for us is to get an opportunity for her not to actually not only to sit next door who
maybe she was meant to but also to just find out a bit more about the painting's history
and a little bit more about her provenance. They're very important to the exhibition that
we're organising on Frans Hals because they're among the earliest known works by the artist
and they will you know be central to the first room of the exhibition where we'd like to introduce
the artist's earliest work and the mystery there that's what these do fantastically. The mystery
is there what early Frans Hals, what young Frans Hals actually did because he's
quite old already you know compared to most artists when he paints these and yet these are the earliest
known works that we have. How old would he be? About 26, 27 maybe even 28. He's still sort of beyond the age
that most artists start to make a mark so we don't know what early Frans Hals did and yet these
portraits are completely you know they're fully formed portraits. This is someone who knows what
he's doing completely and in fact when we look at for example her her cap or indeed his ruff
or his cuffs or the frilly bits you can see already that he is you know Frans Hals already
the one that we know him for in his later work and especially the cap the feathery brushwork is quite
it's quite amazing. Well I was struck by seeing them together that they really work thematically
that this idea that the message that life is temporary and transient and you obviously get
that from the skull but it wouldn't be as clear with somebody just holding the gold to show off
the wealth. Yes I mean it's a perfect example of how separating pendants has its problems. Yeah.
Because it diminishes their meaning. I mean for me it's always slightly terrifying to see
things out of frame but I'm sure you're very very used to that. I kind of think it's quite they always
feel like they're fresh like they've just been painted. And as a conservator it's really
thrilling to work on the two together and bring them into kind of harmony again well particularly
as they come from different collections with different conservation histories. We can see
already on the back if I spin them around I mean she is a lovely bit of oak. You can see
quite clearly the very unusual grain occasioned by it being such a wide board
possibly near a branch of the bottom of the tree. I love these labels as well. Yeah.
And I think she's had some sort of coating rubbed in the back we'll be looking into that maybe a
little bit of red lead paint. Whereas he as you can see has had a very typical 19th century early
20th century panel treatment called the cradle where the panel has been thinned and planed and
made smooth. So this is the original surface with the beveling and then the structure applied to the
reverse in an attempt to keep it flat. It's not something we do now but that's where we are. I
mean that's just the most obvious sign of a different conservation history in terms of
structural work and I'm sure as we work we'll find differences in the approach to previous
cleanings and restorations as well. That's the fascinating thing isn't it it's the lives of
these works you know in themselves you know she's quietly hung on a wall you know probably
not being disturbed very often whereas he's probably had a bit more of an active life
moving around a bit. It's a hidden history as well that conservators get quite excited about
when we have monographic shows I know a lot of people think well here this is from the teens
and this is from the 20s and this is interesting the style of all we also as conservators wander
around looking at oh that comes from this collection and look at that varnish and that
one has had this happen to it and I can see that and how they felt about cleaning and retouching
the various things we look at that as well and it's part of the history of what you see in it
you are looking through the interpretation of a conservator generally when you look at an
old master painting and I hope a conservator who is as discreet as possible but that's not always
the case. No and that's the same for us I mean across the country houses have different levels
that they take conservation to and that runs across everything from sculpture to textiles
to paintings because you want the whole to be seamless you know it's something that grows
and lives side by side with each other so you have to almost keep everything in balance
so this must be quite interesting because you're trying to balance things from very different worlds
but I think what's lovely is just this light coming back into the picture and the fact that
you know her skin tone's almost starting to glow just from that already. It's often with
degraded varnishes it's not just the yellowing sometimes the more telling thing is that foggy
you know net curtain obscuring a hazy loss of saturation and dark tones and you get that back
as you see I started to do some cleaning here it's a huge difference and all these things are
going to be here and here it's the volume I think of the folds and the kind of the weight and mass
and how she's going to actually stand out. So it almost makes her 3D in the sections that you've
done she's really sort of stepping out of a kind of much more sort of 2D kind of nature.
I mean there's a famous letter from Vincent van Gogh to his brother Theo where he stood in front
of one of the group pieces in the Rijksmuseum and just wrote about Franz Hall's ability to
paint black yeah he counted however many different tones he could see yeah and I can see that I can
see why that would be just extraordinary. I mean that pleating and what you've cleared there even
in the basic way is incredible I never noticed it before I probably walk past it every day.
You really pretty much can't see it so I think that would be wonderful. I can't wait to see it.
You can see rather than being made up of two or three planks they're one plank and if you
look against the light they've really got you know pretty crazy grain very distinctive and
you can already see without doing all that research they look like they come from the
same source and that's pretty fascinating already. And sorry can I just absolutely clear are you
saying that they might actually be from the same tree? Yeah that's well that's how it looks in the
report. Not just from a tree at the same period but they might actually be from the same tree.
That's so exciting I don't know why that's so exciting. So we've learned that as I said we know
the date of the felling of the tree is consistent with where we believe the pictures to be painted
we know they're from the same tree and in fact you can see they call it bookmatched in other words
from the same block of oak and you can see a little structural issue with a crack coming down
here and one here so you imagine these two boards were one large board like that split and then
unfolded to make the two panels. So some unsuspecting tree in the early 1600s in the
almost you know 200 years and now they're coming back together that's extraordinary. There's a
kind of poetry in the idea of wedding pair being from the same tree but I'm not sure it was intended
that way. So should we have a look in UV? Yeah I'd love to. Okay here we go pop these on
and don't I'll make sure you don't look into the beam but you can see the the old
discoloured varnishes fluoresce this kind of yellow colour and as I move across you can see
the difference where the varnishes have been largely removed a little bit left just taking
them down gradually. I mean that's pretty fantastic to see a white highlight it's actually
white yeah and these these will definitely not nicotine yeah these these will dance and sparkle
it's all there just not as easy to see. I mean thinking as I do about how to bring them together
visually now I also wonder how they came to be a part. Yeah I mean the honest answer is we don't
know but really from when he died up until the sort of very early 19th century he wasn't hugely
rated and it was only sort of after you know in the sort of mid well early to mid 19th century
that he became you know such a cool celeb again and actually that his works are now some of the
most treasured in museum and gallery collections but after his death his works were kind of
In the 20th century we certainly appreciate you know brushwork that has a life of its own
and I wonder if that has something to do with the general interest in him. I think it's I think also
it's that that modern taste about story and about personality and you know they've got such strong
gazes and that they seem so relatable in a way that many other works you know by Rubens aren't
as sort of personally human relatable in the same way. Yes this is going to be one of those
great moments with an exhibition that you can show to a larger audience the fruits of all that
research and labor that goes into to treating these pictures and make them look at their
their past yeah and as close as possible to what they originally looked like.
They're so powerful it's really nice to kind of unlock what's there.
