Stanford Medicine Alumni Awards 2016: Paul Modrich

Basic Applied Science
14 followers
To me, the wonder of science is in the problem solving.
It's love for the method.
How you choose to address the problem experimentally.
Paul, as a very innovative scientist,
he can certainly tackle any question he wants.
And it's a matter of what he feels
In many ways, I think there are many similarities
between being an artist and being a scientist.
You essentially start with nothing.
You start with an idea.
There are almost an infinite number of things
that you could do, many, many questions
that you could pursue.
You have to choose an important topic to work on.
It may take 40 years to solve it,
but it is important, it's worth it.
The significance of the problem was critical for him.
As an experimentalist, as a scientist,
he'd had this very important quality
of being able to focus laser-like
onto the problem that he was going to work on,
to the exclusion of almost anything else.
As children, we had to learn to entertain ourselves.
We didn't have television.
Paul comes from a small town in New Mexico, Raton.
My father was a coach, but he was also a biology teacher.
When I was 14 or 15, I was reading a Scientific American,
and there was an ad in the back for radioisotopes,
radioactive compounds, that you could,
in those days, you could actually possess
certain amounts without a license.
And so I talked my dad into ordering them for me,
which he did.
He got a call at the high school one afternoon
from the train station saying,
Mr. Modric, we have a package here for you that says,
radioactive, do not stand within 15 feet of this partial
unless absolutely necessary.
But he went down and picked it up and brought it home to me.
He then moved from Raton High School to MIT,
where he majored in biology.
One can imagine the cultural shock
that Paul might have experienced
in going from Raton to Boston and the MIT environment.
I was interested in many things at MIT,
but I was just amazed at the molecular elegance
of what was known at that time
about genetic regulatory systems,
the manner in which genetic information is maintained
and utilized in selected ways.
My advisor was Salvador Luria,
who was one of the founders of molecular biology.
He got me a job in Ethan Signer's lab,
initially washing glassware, that was my responsibility.
But they were studying recombination,
genetic recombination in a bacterial virus.
It became very clear to me
that this was what the kind of thing,
I wanted to be like these guys.
I applied to several places for graduate school,
but the place I really wanted to go was Stanford
because that was the center of the universe
for DNA biochemistry.
Because of my interest in recombination,
I decided that I really wanted to work with Bob Lehman.
Paul wanted to work in my laboratory
specifically on DNA ligase,
an enzyme that had been discovered in my laboratory
and which turned out to be an important component
of the systems involved in DNA replication,
recombination, repair,
and of course, in genetic engineering.
It splices DNA chains together.
And his research, his thesis research,
which was, I have to say, brilliant,
really elucidated the tailed chemical mechanism
of this very complicated reaction
that the enzyme catalyzes.
I really learned to be a scientist working in Bob's lab,
not only from the experimental perspective,
but how he chooses to pursue certain,
what questions one chooses to pursue.
I had a tremendous amount of freedom
and it was the perfect environment for me.
Paul, during the five years in my lab,
published six manuscripts, important manuscripts,
quite a rarity these days,
where one or two will fulfill the requirements for the PhD.
The first work that we did
that was directly relevant to mismatch repair
was begun here at Duke, the year I came here, 1976.
The thing that he devoted his life to
since the time he began his own laboratory
was to understand in detail
how proteins can identify
and bind to specific sequences in the DNA molecule.
Mind you, proteins are rather small.
DNA molecules are very long.
How do these proteins find those specific sequences?
Paul set out being a good biochemist,
systematically purified the proteins,
and through a series of beautiful papers,
he described how they work.
As you probably know, as DNA is replicated,
occasionally, but very infrequently, mistakes are made.
The enzymatic machinery is not perfect.
If those mistakes persist, this results in a mutation
which can have very deleterious consequences.
A lot of the hereditary disease,
sometimes we call it rare disease,
came from the mutation that happened
during the replication of those cells.
Paul figured out in E. coli
how the mismatch is recognized
and how it is removed in exquisite detail
and reconstituted the entire system with purified protein.
And that's as beautiful as it gets.
He said, I'll take the next step
and start working with human mismatch repair.
Shortly after that, it was found that humans
that have defect in mismatch repair
have high incidence of some cancer.
Really an amazing accomplishment.
He really single-handedly did.
Solved the mechanism of mismatch repair,
and this is rare in science.
I called Paul the day that I learned
that he had won the Nobel Prize.
He was sort of overwhelmed.
He certainly didn't expect it.
He's a very modest guy.
He is and has been very modest.
On the other hand, he's also very demanding
in terms of the rigor of the science.
He wanted his student to be at the forefront of the science
instead of follow other people's steps.
I remember when I completed my thesis defense
and Paul took me out to dinner.
And I was saying, well, Paul, what should I do?
And he said, be yourself and do the best you can be.
And I still remember that advice he gave to me.
Paul would not publish something unless it's 100% sure.
In my case, 80% I would publish it.
It is a matter of personality.
I would publish it because I say as a scientist,
we are entitled to be wrong every now and then
as long as we're honest with our presentation,
we may make the wrong conclusion,
but Paul wanted to make sure he had
absolute right conclusion.
And so that was another aspect of Paul that I admired.
I considered him a scientist.
Even as a graduate student,
I considered him to be a colleague.
He was at that level.
Paul's great success in elucidating
the tail mechanism of mismatch repair
and then the discovery of its application to human health
was must have been an important factor
in the decision that led to his award
of the Nobel Prize in 2015.
I certainly say that he is probably one of the greatest
student come out of that department.
And that is a tremendous accomplishment on his side,
but I also recognize that the Stanford department
since Arthur Kompar was in the center
of those elegant DNA enzymology.
You know, if you look at the Stanford
biochemistry department,
the faculty in that department have each of them
a history of a lifelong set of contributions.
They were flashes in the pan.
I've been fortunate in that way.
I mean that my lab has been funded since 1974.
And in order to do that,
you have to keep producing something
that is viewed by others as useful knowledge.
To me, the really wonderful part has been
simply knowing that others value what you have done.
