Nobel Laureate, Sir Fraser Stoddart, Speaking at 2016 IIN Symposium

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
My name is Chad Merkin. I'm the director of the IIN,
something that obviously we're very proud of, and I want to welcome you to the 13th Annual Symposium. This has been an event that
has been building momentum through the years. Every year seems to be bigger and better, and this is no exception.
In large part, that has to do with the
people that we attract to campus and the incredible group of speakers that we have lined up for you today. Now,
we've had, obviously, a lot of exciting news, and we've adjusted the schedule today because we've got the good fortune of
sharing with you,
of course, the news firsthand of the Nobel Prize,
and, in fact, the winner here, or one of the winners here, to present to you and talk a little bit about that incredible accomplishment.
To introduce the speaker and our special guest, I'm going to invite Sam Stoop on stage.
Sam's been a great partner in the development of nanotechnology at Northwestern.
He's the board of trustees professor of material science,
chemistry, and medicine, and director of the Simpson Query Institute for biomedicine,
and he will take a few minutes to share with you
some of the facts about our special speaker. Thank you.
Well, thank you, Chad. Good morning, everybody.
So, as Chad mentioned,
we did get very exciting news yesterday. So, in the wee hours of the morning,
Wednesday morning, probably around 4 a.m.,
the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences
announced that Northwestern molecular nanotechnology pioneer, Sir Fraser Stoddart,
was being awarded the
2016 Nobel Prize in chemistry.
He shared the prize with Jean-Pierre Sauvage from the University of Strasbourg,
who actually has been a frequent visitor at Northwestern,
and Ben Faringa from the University of Groningen in the Netherlands.
The Swedish Academy awarded the Nobel Prize in chemistry this year
for the development of the first examples of molecular machines
by these three
outstanding scientists.
So, imagine, I guess it's difficult to understand what a molecular machine is, but now imagine a dumbbell,
the type that you use at the gym when you're working out, and you have these two giant heads at both ends, and
then by the magic of chemistry, a tiny ring
gets threaded onto the dumbbell. Now, it's trapped, can't get out, and
but it can shuttle to different positions,
desperately trying to get out. So, this is not a bond between the dumbbell and the ring, not a chemical bond,
but it is a mechanical bond. So, this shuttling, by design,
can emulate, for example, the function of a switch.
It can also, in other forms,
create a molecular construct that actually
expands and contracts,
emulating the function of a muscle in our bodies. And yet, other forms,
we might even think of emulating the functions in a computer chip.
So, Fraser
has been a pioneer in this very exciting
new field in chemistry, and
he has been particularly a pioneer in the fundamental understanding of how these molecular constructs
can behave as machines.
Now, like so many
scientists in the U.S., including me,
Fraser is
an immigrant, and
he was brought up in
Edgelow Farm in Scotland,
where he did not enjoy, I mean, I've heard this from him many times,
the joys of electricity until he was 17 years old.
He received his early education at a local village in Scotland
before going to Melville College in the beautiful city of Edinburgh, and
he received all the degrees, all his degrees,
from the University of Edinburgh. Now, moving forward,
several decades of great achievements and
recognition
about, I think, eight years ago, Chad Merkin and
President Emeritus Henry Beenan
were instrumental in winning him to Northwestern from UCLA, where he was my alma mater, if I may say.
And since
that time, you know, since he joined us, since we were lucky to have him as a colleague eight years ago,
he has been a
very important member of the faculty at IIN and
member of the steering committee, and has done lots of things for the development of IIN.
I don't have the time to tell you about
all the honors and awards that he has received. They have come from around the world,
all continents almost, and
of course, here at home, he's been honored, and in his homeland,
he's been honored by the Queen, right? So Queen Elizabeth
honored him as well. And you can go to the web if you would like and enjoy
learning about all the awards and recognition that Fraser Stoddard has received.
What I want to tell you briefly is
the things that you won't find in the web.
And so the fact, I mean, is that he's not only a brilliant scientist,
I know this firsthand because I have worked with him, I have published with him, I have had joint students with him,
but also he is an incredible human being.
As they say in Scotland, he's a mensch, an amazing colleague.
He is 24-7 about science, but he's also 24-7 about being a good colleague.
He's always there to be supportive. Whenever you need him, he's there.
Anyway, I
personally have loved every minute that I've interacted with Fraser here at Northwestern over the past eight years.
This amazing, ultimate recognition in science could not have been given to a better person.
So it's great to rejoice, of course, for what this means to Northwestern,
but it is really wonderful to rejoice because it happened to Fraser,
the great
Fraser Stoddard. So ladies and gentlemen, please help me to welcome the amazing person,
my dear colleague, Fraser Stoddard, Nobel Laureate in Chemistry 2016.
Well, thank you ever so much, Sam. I will have to ask you sometime what a mensch is.
So it's my great honor to be standing here today. I am humbled by the events of yesterday.
I'm,
however,
nonetheless going to
try and entertain you for a very short time
with a story about
being in the fast lane
on the road to Stockholm.
Yesterday, I made some off-the-cuff remarks. Today, I'm going to be back on message.
So
Sam has set the stage.
There's the dumbbell that he mentioned in the Rotaxane. Here is the catenine with two interlocked rings.
So it was back in the early 1950s that Professor Frisch at
the State University of New York
coined the term the mechanical bond.
Since there's no covalent bond between the components, the blue and the red here, for example, in a catenine,
the linkage has been called a mechanical bond.
If we go to the Rotaxane, and one of the very
fundamental messages I've got to get over to you is that this entity is a molecule. Even Wikipedia will get it right.
So it's about time that the chemists and other scientists did as well.
And again, this is Wikipedia's definition of catenine, and you can see these words come from Latin.
Down here, you see a very familiar
counting device that the Chinese in the audience will
recognize right away. And up here, of course, we've just been treated this summer to
an event in Rio that reminds you of the Olympic rings. And I
parenthetically will say they
inspired us to make a 5-catenine back in the 1990s.
I won't go into it so much today, but symbolism and art has had a huge
influence in my design of my science.
You will not be able to read this slide.
But
what I will point out is that the action, because this is really new chemistry, and
the point I want to make today is chemistry is maybe the youngest science of the lot.
Don't think about it as the old
science. It's the new one.
And this is very true in terms of the mechanical bond. So it was around about 1980 that my
1983, to be more precise, colleague
Jean-Pierre Sauvage went along a route that took us down here,
using as a source of molecular recognition to make the mechanical bond transition metals.
A little later on, we came along, and we went along this route using donor-acceptor interactions.
And then here at Northwestern, in 2010, we had a major breakthrough in the use of
radical pairing, the use of radicals to bring the
components together to make catenines and ritaxines and other mechanically interlocked molecules.
Now, I just want to make a
comment. History is a habit of repeating itself. When I was an undergraduate
student at Edinburgh, we learned about the chair-chair flip of cyclohexane.
It was followed by NMR spectroscopy.
Later on, at the end of the 80s, we made our first degenerate 2-catenine, where
the A and B of these red rings swap places.
So the only way you can tell this is happening, as you can with that process up there, is by going to an NMR spectrometer.
Likewise, the molecular shuttle, as this ring darts from the left-hand
station, if we might call it that, to the right-hand one.
So how do you make these molecules?
It's really extremely simple once you find out how to do it, but it took a decade to find out.
So we take this dicatine, we take this dibromide, we mix them together in acetonitrile with
silver tetrafluorophosphate,
wait for a week, and in a modest 32% yield, we isolate this
turotaxine, or molecular shuttle.
But what I want to get over here, and what the major principle is
that is important, is
that this leads to so-called template-directed synthesis, where you have this wonderful interplay between
covalent, non-covalent, and the mechanical bond.
So you start with components that don't even want to know each other.
You form one chemical bond, and they want to get together, and they get together by the blue coming and nestling inside the red.
Having got to this point, it's downhill.
More
and other chemical bond is formed here, and more of these non-covalent bond interactions
indicated by these vertical lines are switched on. But the excitement doesn't stop there, because you realize that you have switched on these
non-covalent bonds, and they can be then used to be switched on and off at will.
So another
representation from 91 of the molecular shuttle,
the ring darting back and forth between these two stations, at roughly a thousand times a second at room temperature.
Here's just a movie to
show you what's going on, not only in the
rotaxine that I've spoken about that is degenerate, but also in the degenerate catenate with
recognition sites. So there are points in the rings where they want to stop and,
as it were, interact with each other.
Moving on, we had to leave degeneracy and
introduce the
whole
situation that is, again, analogous to putting just one substituent on a cyclohexane ring.
You go from an equatorial to an axial component, and notice the very important two-to-one difference here. So now we've got two different,
we call them conformations.
Godfrey Chill, he might be the person who was forgotten by
Stockholm yesterday. He's still alive in the Black Forest. He made a huge contribution
through what was called covalent directed synthesis.
Anyway, that comment apart, I want to tell you he coined the term
translational isomers to describe now two isomeric forms, because a green station and a red station are going to be as different as
chocolates from cheese. And that is expressed in this
nine-to-one ratio in each case for a preference for the green station.
The green station, incidentally, turns out to be a tetrathiofolan site, and the red one a
dioxynapsulin. I don't have time to share all the structure with you.
But here you see a movie that is
trying to get the message across about the nature of the switch now. It's spending much more time
with the green than it is with the red.
Now,
yesterday I was bombarded with, well, what's it good for?
So in my UCLA days, I had the great good fortune to
collaborate with
one of the most amazing physical chemists, Jim Heath. And
over a decade,
working almost seamlessly together, we got to a point by 2007 where this ritaxate could be put into a
crossbar device,
40 wires by 40 wires, therefore
160,000 junctions to give us a 160 kilobit molecular
memory.
Testing of the bits, well, it could only be a very few of them, but that was enough to
putting a very high threshold on here, a good bit,
to show that at least a quarter of them, those yellow ones here,
functioned well. So there was some
loss of,
if you like, efficiency. But nonetheless, using the quarter, and by this time our
collaboration incidentally had started at UCLA, but Jim had moved to Caltech.
Actually, I'll tell a little story here. One day, the Los Angeles Times announced that
Gordon Moore of Intel had driven up to Pasadena with his wife with a check for 600 million dollars.
This is one of the most remarkable things about the United States.
It's this philanthropy that
drives very great institutions to have tremendous faculties to carry out
world-class research. And so, what was the result?
I no longer had a colleague at UCLA. Jim took off to Caltech. And so, in the ASCII 2 code, here is
California
Institute of Technology.
Molecular RAM at now 10 to 11 bits per square centimeter. And so, if you compare this
with the semiconductor roadmap, then it's well ahead of its time.
So finally, how do we go from switches to machines? And so, this brings us to the Northwestern era, where
after
thinking about it and
looking at what had been done in the literature, I could fairly say artificial molecular switches are a dime a dozen or ten a penny.
Artificial molecular machines are still few and far between. And this was back in 2012.
Machines need to perform work on their immediate environments. Switches don't do that. So, assembling and controlling synergistically,
artificial molecular machines housed in highly interactive and
robust architectural domains, heralds a game-changer for the
chemical synthesis and a defining moment for
nanotechnology, molecular nanotechnology. And so, if you're going to build an artificial switch on the nanoscale,
it's a very different challenge from what you would do in the macroscopic scale.
So, on the microscopic scale, if you were a physicist and you wanted to carry this particle from here up to there,
you just say it's a bicycle. You go over this mountain, down into this valley, over this mountain, and down into that valley.
No, you don't do this in a nano world.
What you have to do is, starting at the same place, you have to juggle around with the energy wells and the transition states.
And this juggling around act is a massive exercise in
design. It requires incredible
intellectual input, and I've been so fortunate to have around me students and postdocs with the
capacity and the ability to
design systems that work like this.
We are also inspired by nature. Nature uses the same principles. So, here you see bacterial
rhodopsin pumping protons across as a result of
taking down this
transition state,
having started over here,
to allow the proton to get into the middle here. And having got there,
decreasing this transition state to allow it to come out the other side.
So,
could we imitate this action with an artificial system?
Here is the dumbbell, and here is the ring. And to cut a long story short, it has a neutral green end and a charged
one positive charge on the right-hand side.
The ring has four positive charges. And what we were able to show is that
you can feed this ring on in a unidirectional way. We can have it come on from the left-hand side and
depart from the right-hand side. I don't have time to go into the details, but that was well and truly nailed down and is well
recorded. So again,
let me show you a movie just to get over the message. On from the left, off from the right.
But we've done no work. We take a ring out of solution, and we put it back again.
So, now finally, here is the design of a molecular pump, where we can bring a ring on
from the left-hand side. And this is where we use our radical chemistry discovered here at Northwestern
to
attract the ring on. And then
having attracted it on, we get it to go over thermally this barrier here, over the green door
I sometimes call it, and then have a collecting chain to collect the rings. And
if we can collect the rings here, then we're going into a high-energy state. And we're taking the state away from equilibrium.
So, one of the big challenges in this area is to do chemistry and
science away from equilibrium.
We were able to do this, and I just show you
some slides here. The first ring sits round about here, and then the
second ring that goes on pushes it over to the right, and the next one sits round about here. So,
you can actually tell where the rings sit.
Another movie. So, when you see the change from blue to purple, this is the formation of radicals that
attract the
rings on to what we call the molecular pump. And what you've seen here is them collecting over there on the right-hand side.
We'll just watch it once more, one more time.
And you notice how the first ring is trying to come back, but it's prevented from coming back by this green
barrier.
So, just to wind up,
what we're doing now is we're trying to be more efficient. We have pumps at both ends of a long polymer chain, and
we would like to use light
because that's very clean.
A sacrificial electron donor to a pump brings on two at a time.
We would like to be able to do it much faster than we can at the moment, and that's being addressed.
And if we can do that,
we can create a new form of matter. We can create a polymer
with sliding rings on it. These rings don't want to be on the polymer chain.
They will dance around, and there's every reason to believe that such
molecular species, when rendered in materials, these materials will have rather unique viscoelastic properties.
So, just a brief look at
the progress of this science. As I say, it is new chemistry. It took off in literally
1990. And the interesting thing is catenines always dominated the field to begin with, but eventually they were outstripped
by the rhotaxines. And I'll leave you to work out for yourselves why that might be.
Everything, of course, is on the rise.
Citations and the distribution of citations is the familiar situation. Great papers and not so great ones.
Where is the work done?
Well, a lot of it's been done in the United States,
but we really have to think about how we keep it going here because I'm not going to be here forever.
And I'm certainly not going to go back there, where
there is a lot of activity going on. But heavens, it's under threat, in my opinion, at the moment.
Japan, as you might expect. China is catching up, I would say, in another five years. This will be the darkest green on the map.
Okay, so if I haven't been very fluent, if I haven't got the message across,
around about the 24th of October, I heard this morning from John Wiley, they will publish a book,
The Nature of the Mechanical Bond,
From Molecules to Machines. It's a
six-chapter book with an introduction, a couple of chapters on synthesis, a
chapter on, oh,
chemical topology. This was never mentioned by Stockholm yesterday, but Jean-Pierre Servage and I have also
teamed up together and
put a huge amount of effort into chemical topology. And some of you may recall that on Tuesday, the physicists
shared the prize for
topology in a physical domain. So I think that was just a little bit of a lost opportunity in Stockholm. However,
they'll get an opportunity to make it up.
Stereochemistry, and then finally, in the last chapter, From Molecular
Switches to Molecular Machines, Using the Mechanical Bonds.
Now,
this was not my doing. I was a very
impressed spectator
by, and this is where I can link up with Sam's too, Carson Bruins.
Here he is.
Was a joint student
between Sam and myself. He's now a Miller Research Fellow at Berkeley.
He is one of the most accomplished
writers,
illustrators of science, and
he can, well, I can't illustrate in the way he can, but he can probably write about ten times faster than I can.
Amazing. And
what I would like today to say is, Carson is going to be on the market as an assistant professor, and
the comment I have is
Harvard, MIT,
Yale, Princeton,
Stanford,
Caltech, UCLA,
Northwestern,
Berkeley, what an opportunity. This man knows more about mechanical bond than I do.
Remarkable.
And just to finish up, a few images. They represent another
490, roughly,
graduate students and postdocs who've
moved this story along over 35, 40, 45 years,
starting in the UK, then at UCLA, and now here at Northwestern.
I do want to recognize a huge amount of funding that I've had in recent times from Saudi Arabia,
from the King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology.
Without this major fillip, I wouldn't be standing here today.
Thank you very much.
