Personal Fieldwork (Physical) - AQA Geography Paper 3

Archaeology Terrifying
3 followers
#paper3 #fieldwork #education #bristol #uk #school #exam #gcse #aqa #geography #teacher #geographyteacher #aqageography #gcsegeography #geographygcse
So I thought I'd do a bit of a video feedback for this just because it's a first time you've ever approached past exam questions for paper three.
And paper three is, whilst being the easiest paper, is also one of the hardest to get your head around.
I think it was shown in the kind of answers you gave. Some of you did extremely well.
Others sort of struggled more than you normally do.
And so here's a breakdown of what I was looking for.
OK, so question number one, you had a picture of figure 13 showing you parts of the river and its valley.
You have to give me one potential risk. It's basically asking you to talk about the risk assessment section of your field trip.
You could mention drowning, you could mention flooding, you could mention tripping, slipping, falling, getting lost.
That's plenty. Just name one. OK.
You then have study figure 14 highlighting cross profile of a river valley, different dates of the month, the approximate flow in cumecs, metres per second.
There was 13 different variables. You had to add them all up, divide by 13.
And you ended up with a what was the question here? The mean flow of five.
OK, so you got one mark for five, one mark for the workings. If you've got the workings wrong answer, you've got one mark.
You've got the workings in the right answer, two marks. Just give the right answer.
Potentially you might not get all two marks. OK.
Justified two primary data collection methods used in the geographical inquiry.
So here, the first thing I want to mention is the you notice here question eight is data collection.
Yeah. Question nine is data presentation. There are two completely different sections of your field trip.
OK, if here's a booklet you had, you scroll down the booklet.
OK, the key thing I wanted to highlight is it's literally written here.
Data collection. They're there. The qualitative and quantitative and data presentation.
They're here. You have to learn the name of them.
There's no way around that. If you do not know the name of them, it'll sound really wishy washy answer.
OK, the other way to look at it, data collection is how you collected all the facts.
It happened on the day of the trip during the trip itself at Blaise Castle.
That is data collection methods. Data presentation only happened in class at school after collecting the data.
Because you need the data collected to present it on a graph.
So data collection happened on the day of the trip. Data presentation happened in class straight after.
OK, do not mix them up, which happened for a few of you.
OK, so two primary data collection methods used in your physical geography inquiry.
For instance, you could have said one of the data collection method we use was a sketch.
OK, justify means you don't have to give pros and cons.
You just have to give the pros. Why did we pick them? Well, just field sketch.
Remember, you don't get any mark A01 for paper three. So if you just took field sketch, you don't get a mark.
One of the reasons we did a field sketch is really easy.
You need minimal equipment and it's pretty straightforward to do one A02 mark.
It's also a very good visual representation of what you saw for people who weren't there.
That is the second A02 mark, two out of four for now.
The second example could be the depth of the river. And why? Because you need very basic equipment for that.
You don't need much training, A02 mark or third mark.
And then you could say, well, it helped us to answer the Bradshaw model and see whether the depth changed as you travel downstream or upstream.
Brilliant. Second A02, you've got four marks. That's basically what you need to do to get four marks.
Two methods. You have to give me two reasons why they were good idea.
It was all in the video I've made summarising what we've done on the trip.
OK, then next one, you had to say pros and cons because it said assess the effectiveness of the data presentation methods.
OK, in this case here, the easiest way to do it is to give me three methods presentation and give me the why the good.
Because you're assessing it and why the bad? Because you're assessing it.
OK, again, you have to learn the name of the methods. But if you scroll down here, what do we have?
We had a bar graph, proportional symbols, long profile, cross sectional profile annotation.
So you could say one simple one. Well, actually, data presentation.
Bar graphs are really good visual representation of of data and allows us to compare between sites.
One A02 mark. OK, however, downside is if the data is inaccurate and give it a false impression of the results.
Oh, negative A03 mark. You can pick another one saying, well, actually using the proportional symbol is good for people who weren't there.
But the scale can be an issue and therefore can be able to hide some of it because it's a mean average to hide some anomalies.
OK, that's a four. You do that twice, three methods, pros and cons.
OK, and the big one, the nine marker was the biggest question.
There is the one that I think most people struggle with the most. It says here with reference to results and conclusions.
OK, so the first thing there is you have to have one paragraph and results.
One paragraph and conclusion suggests how the geographical inquiry could be improved.
Geographical inquiry is the trip itself. It's the research we did.
So our inquiry was whether the Hazelbrook fit the virtual model.
OK, so the whole inquiry process is the idea that we had a question.
We went to collect data and presented it. We analysed it. We came up with some results and conclusions.
OK, the whole link, the whole process. That's what your inquiry.
Our whole inquiry was checking to see whether the river fit the virtual model.
OK, so paragraph one on results. I want you to think about giving me reasons why our data collection and all presentation methods could be improved.
OK, and how they could be improved. For instance, you could say, well, velocity measuring the velocity.
Arguably, our results weren't very accurate because we had to use a orange or leaf.
We didn't have enough equipment and we certainly didn't have any.
We didn't have any technical, scientific. As a result, our data could have been a little bit inaccurate.
If we had to do the trip again, we probably would. Hopefully with more budget by HydroProp, which provides better market measurement of the flow of a river.
OK, you could also talk about the fact there wasn't much water in the river.
So you could you could have collected data on a different day, for instance, because you had better more, you know, would have more water than theoretically.
You could have talked about that. When we looked at the wetted perimeter, we use the rope and you had to put it on the base of the bed.
But it wasn't changed. It didn't go down with gravity. You had to physically put it. So arguably, it didn't actually give you the most accurate reading.
OK, again, tell me the limitations of this data collection and the result and tell me how it can be improved.
OK, that's your paragraph one. Paragraph two. I'd like you to think about the conclusions.
And our overall conclusions are that the Bradshaw, the river Hazelbrook does fit the Bradshaw model.
OK, however, our conclusions could be improved by we could have gone several times.
So we could have gone on that trip more than once. We'd have had a more reliable set of results and therefore draw better, more accurate conclusions.
We could have had collected data at more locations would have allowed us to gather more data, again, improve the reliability of our conclusions.
We could have gone to a more appropriate river with a bigger flow. OK, again, it would have improved.
So the conclusions I want to tell me, what are the conclusions? What did we find?
How could our findings be enhanced and improved in reliability in the long term? That's how I'd have planned your perfect landmark.
