045: Hellenistic Philosophy - Stoics & Stoicism

Ancient Explained - History Clearly Understood.
17 followers
8 Video Views·Oct 7, 2024
Hi there. You're listening to the Hellenistic Age Podcast.
Episode 45 Hellenistic Philosophy Stoics and Stoicism
Near the dark forests of the northern Danube, arguably the most powerful man during the late
2nd century AD, sat alone in his tent, writing in his diary. For the Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius,
the burden of rule was unusually heavy. Incursions by Germanic tribes, the worst plague in Roman
memory, and the loss of at least eight children despite access to the best doctors and midwives
in the entire empire put immense pressure upon the man as both a leader and a father. Yet for Marcus,
always a highly intelligent and introspective person, he could find some measure of solace
by engaging in philosophy. During his campaigns, the Emperor penned a series of philosophical
writings, often known as the Meditations, which were never intended for publication since they
were essentially diary entries written by Marcus for Marcus only, and served as sort of a self-help
guide. Yet, nearly 2,000 years later, they have survived, and remain one of the most famous and
widely read personal memoirs ever written, reflecting the core ideals of one of the main
pillars of Hellenistic philosophy, Stoicism. Arguably the most popular of the schools to
emerge during the period, Stoics were renowned for their adherence to living a virtuous life
through rationality and self-control. But they were also pioneers in the field of logic and
epistemology, which challenged and expanded upon the views of the dominant Platonic and
Aristotelian schools of thought. In this episode, we'll discuss the history, the doctrine, and the
legacy of Stoicism, in order to better understand why so many, like Marcus, were attracted to it.
The origins of Stoicism takes us once again to Athens in the early 3rd century BC.
This time, we stay in the heart of the city, and head to the northern part of the Agora,
where we will find and enter a covered walkway known as the Stoa Poikilae, the Painted Stoa.
Normally, you would see merchants hawking their goods and the gossiping of wealthy and poor
Athenians alike, but in one portion of the Stoa were a large number of people standing at attention
around a man who pontificated on things like virtue and logic. This man is named Zeno,
and his followers were known as Zenonians, but would later adopt the nickname of the Stoics,
deriving their name from their unorthodox classroom setting of the Stoa.
Zeno of Kittium was born at roughly 334-330 to a Phoenician merchant family in Cyprus,
and by the age of 30 he had moved from Kittium to Athens and began to pursue a life of philosophy.
There are a few stories explaining what led to his change in residency and career,
but according to the most famous, Zeno was browsing in the Athenian marketplace during
a commercial expedition and came upon the ancient equivalent of a bookstore.
He picked up a copy of the Memorabilia by Xenophon, a lesser known account compared to
the Dialogues of Plato, but nevertheless Zeno was fascinated by the figure known as Socrates.
Asking the bookseller where he must go to find more men like Socrates,
Zeno was pointed to Crates the Cynic, who happened to be passing by the shop,
and so Zeno began his career under the Cynic's tutelage.
Though he admired some of their teachings, Zeno also studied under the school of the Megarians
and the Platonic Academy, both of which considerably influenced his later teachings.
By 300, he had begun to amass a following by performing informal lectures at the Stoa,
which officially began the Stoic movement as we know it.
Following the death of Zeno in 262, the school had undergone an evolution in its ideas and
doctrine, and there was not much in the way of a strict orthodoxy in its beliefs.
Many of the students of Zeno, especially one Aristo, would critique or revise his ideas,
though not all of them would be accepted by later practitioners, but by the time of the
third head of the Stoa, that of Chrysippus of Soli, this quickly began to change.
Chrysippus was certainly the most important Stoic teacher following Zeno,
sometimes referred to as the Second Founder, and was responsible for systematizing Stoic
beliefs into the vast body of works he penned during his lifetime, especially in regards to
logic. Chrysippus possibly holds the distinction of one of the most unique deaths of all history.
Allegedly, according to one source, he might have died in a fit of laughter after observing a donkey
eating a bowl full of figs and cracking a joke about offering it some wine to wash down the figs.
It must have been funnier at the time, and it also may have just been satirical given the idea of a
Stoic laughing himself to death, but it's entertaining nevertheless. The actual structure
of the school of the Stoa, if you can call it that, is poorly understood. We know there was a
formal head, known as the Scolarch, and this position would be passed down following the
We also know that the lectures weren't free, and like the Sophists, the philosophers of the
Stoic were charged to teach the children of wealthy clients. The background of its members
varied dramatically, and the heads of the school reflected the cosmopolitan nature of the Hellenistic
period. Zeno was a Phoenician, Diogenes was from Babylon, and Chrysippus, Cleanthus, and Antipater
were all from various cities in Anatolia. For the Stoics, philosophy is the highest good,
largely because our goal as human beings is to achieve happiness and flourishing by
living in accordance with nature and being rational, which is achieved through the act
of philosophy. Based upon the observation of nature, there is a degree of rationality,
and humans are rational animals. Well, most of the time anyways. Stoic philosophy is structured
according to three aspects. Logic, which is the study of inference and deductive reasoning through
language, physics, and ethics. These aren't necessarily separate pieces, they are all
mutually interconnected and contribute to one another, and to the overall idea of Stoicism.
Diogenes Laertius gives us an extensive visual metaphor on the relationship.
They, referring to the Stoics, compare philosophy to an animal, likening logic to the bones and
sinews, ethics to the fleshier parts, and physics to the soul. Or again, they compare it to an
egg, for the outer parts, the shell, are logic, the next part, the white, is ethics, and the
inmost part, the yolk, is physics. Or to a productive field, of which logic is the walls
surrounding it, ethics is the fruit, and physics is the land and trees. Or to a city which is
beautifully fortified and administered according to reason. One of the most famous early admirers
of Stoicism was actually the Macedonian king, Antigonus II Gennatus, who was something of a
predecessor of Marcus Aurelius. He attended the lectures of Zeno during his education and stay
in Athens, and even offered Zeno a position at his court later on, though the philosopher politely
declined on the account of his age, and died shortly thereafter anyways. If you haven't
listened to episode 38 on the reign of Antigonus Gennatus, he is almost universally praised by
later writers as the closest example of a philosopher king during the Hellenistic period,
and taking embellishment and propaganda into consideration, that is quite impressive,
most attributing his good nature and humility to these very same Stoic teachings. Stoicism would
soon be brought to the Italian peninsula in approximately 155 BC, when a three-man
ambassadorial mission was sent from Athens to Rome, comprised of the heads of the Peripatetic
School, the Platonic Academy, and the Stoa. During his visit, the Stoic representative Diogenes
of Babylon lectured there and proved to be immensely popular, and although the institution
of the Stoa did not survive Sulla's sack of Athens in 86 BC, ironically, the greatest champion of
Stoicism proved to be its very conqueror. Many influential Romans would adopt Stoicism over the
centuries. Caesar's great rival, Cato the Younger, and the philosopher-tutor of the Emperor Nero,
Seneca, both were prominent Stoics, and both committed suicide under similar principles.
An ex-slave named Epictetus was a famous Stoic instructor, whose important work,
the Enchiridion, was preserved by his student Arian, the same historian of the Annovicus of
Alexander fame. Marcus Aurelius, as we've discussed earlier, was an ardent admirer of Epictetus,
and ultimately became the Stoic movement's most recognizable figurehead, and the last
remnants of a formal Stoic school closed by the 6th century AD, following the decrees of the
Emperor Justinian. But for the moment, I think we've covered enough of its history, and now we
should turn to the bread and butter of Stoic philosophical doctrine, starting out with the
Stoic philosophy is that, despite the vast corpus of works that were written by practitioners like
Chrysippus, who allegedly had over 700 volumes to his name alone, almost nothing survives from
the early and middle periods of Stoicism. Most of the work is summarized by the likes of Diogenes
Laertius, Cicero, and Sextus Empiricus, and we only start to get surviving accounts from later authors
like Seneca the Younger, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius in the 1st and 2nd centuries AD.
As we stated earlier, there was also a considerable degree of doctrinal dispute in
the Hellenistic period, so trying to determine what exactly are considered the fundamental
beliefs of the Stoics is somewhat of a challenge. To be sure, the Stoics were arguably the greatest
pioneers of logic in all of ancient philosophy, properly systematized thanks to Chrysippus,
its greatest contributor. Logic, according to the Greeks, was based around the concept of the
inference of knowledge, centered around the use of language to draw conclusions from.
This ranges from formal or dialectic logic, and the philosophy of language. The most famous example
is a syllogism, an argument that carries two premises and a conclusion. For example,
all A are B, all B are C, therefore, all A are C. This sort of reasoning,
while argumentatively sound, may lead to some rather bizarre conclusions that we know aren't
true. For instance, all humans are animals, some animals have wings, therefore, some humans have
wings. Aristotle was the primary pioneer of syllogisms, but his are largely concerned with
universals and terms, whereas the Stoics were preoccupied with the idea of particulars and
propositions. Let's step back for a second, and break everything down as to better understand
how the Stoics reached this conclusion. There are two broad aspects of Stoic formal logic,
assertables and arguments. Starting with the former, an assertable is, quote,
a self-complete sayable that can be stated as far as itself is concerned. That's a bit abstract,
but what this essentially means is that we can make a statement, independent of our input,
which is true or false depending on when they are asserted. For instance, I come up to you and say,
it is daytime. Depending on when you listen to this podcast, this assertion is true if you are
listening during the day, or false if you are listening at night. But it's important to note
that if I did tell you at night, at some point in the future this assertion will be true,
regardless of whether or not I told you at all. This is expanded into two types of assertables,
simple and complex. A simple assertable is pretty straightforward. For example,
it is snowing, something that can be definitively confirmed or denied. A complex one builds on this,
using the template, if x, then y. Following the previous example, if it is snowing,
then it is cold outside, which requires a conditional in order to be true,
the conditional reflected by the use of if. This also works in the inverse when we are looking at
a negative assertable, such as, if not x, then not y, or if not x, then y, such as,
if it is snowing, it is not hot outside. Going back earlier, this is the key difference between
Aristotelian and Stoic logic, where the former is concerned with the relationship of terms and
universals, and the latter on propositions that are more complicated development of reason.
This all shall come into play when you form arguments, the second half of formal logic.
Arguments are usually comprised of two premises and a conclusion, much like a syllogism, but in
this case, they incorporate assertables, and are therefore more complex and more valid, or sound
reasoning. While a syllogism is all A are B, all B are C, and thus all A are C, a Stoic argument
emphasizes if, and then, and therefore. For example, if it is snowing, then it is cold
outside. It is snowing, therefore, it must be cold outside. The argument can have a certain
value ascribed to it, described as soundness and validity. Validity is applicable if the argument
is constructed in such a way as to logically guarantee the conclusion. It doesn't mean that
the premises are true, but if they were, then the conclusion cannot be denied. Soundness is the next
step up, needing to be both valid and have the premises be true at the same time. There are more
elements to dialectic logic under the Stoic umbrella, but this is the general bare-bones
overview, and honestly, I don't think it's too effective or entertaining to dwell on it for too
long. But grasping the fundamentals is important to understanding the Stoic need for a more
rigorously developed system of reasoning, which we will explain in a little bit.
So we've learned how to formulate arguments based upon language and reason.
What about in regards to their epistemology, how they interpret knowledge? To start with,
Stoics conceived the mind or soul in a similar fashion to the tabula rasa of the 17th century
English philosopher, John Locke, a nearly blank slate lacking any innate or inborn knowledge,
and they fall into the camp of the empiricists with the emphasis on the senses and perception
providing us a way to gain knowledge about the world. However, since we are capable of
rationality, there is a process by which we can internalize these observations and develop our
knowledge base. All sensations are classified as fantasia or impressions, which refer to the
act of an observation imprinting upon our mind. Following the idea of a blank slate,
some earlier Stoic philosophers likened the mind to a wax tablet, and the impression as a seal or
stamp that makes an indentation into the malleable wax. This isn't meant to be taken too
seriously, since later Stoics had to clarify that the mind was capable of receiving more than one
imprint and form concepts, and we can also separate it from the things that are the product of our
imagination, known as phantasma, figments that do not impress upon our souls. Following this
impression, our mind turns it into a proposition. I see a bird on a tree branch, it imprints upon
my mind, and I make the statement, there is a bird in the tree. Pretty straightforward. But the
important part is not that I have made the proposition, it's that I have to discern whether
to accept it or reject it using reason. Unlike the Epicureans, who attempted to justify their trust
in the senses by claiming all perceptions are true, the Stoics argue that there are such things as
false impressions, and there is a process by which we can determine its validity. A true impression,
known as a graspable or cataleptic impression, arises from an existing object, accurately
represents that object, and makes an impression upon the mind. This means that there isn't any
sort of obstruction, failure of our sensory organs, or abnormalities of the object being perceived.
But how do we know if the object in question exists, or whether our senses are accurately
picking up the perception in the first place? Skeptics pointed out the problem in this reasoning,
since it could be possible that even an incorrect impression could still carry those same traits,
giving the example of the trouble one might face in determining the identity of an identical twin
from a distance, since both look exactly the same, yet are completely different beings,
and could be easily mistaken for one another. Indeed, if a cataleptic impression is the
criterion of truth, then how does it justify itself? Is the fact that it is a catalytic
impression inherently make it a criteria? This all seems a bit circular in logic.
In response, later Stoics added the fourth condition, that a cataleptic impression is
simply incapable of being false based upon overwhelming evidence. For instance,
if I stand outside at noontime and proclaim that it is night, this is unequivocally wrong,
because of the heat of the sun beating down on me, my vision illuminated by the bright light,
and the fact there are no stars visible in the sky. Admittedly, this counterargument is
pretty weak, but let us assume that we are following this line of thinking.
If it is indeed a graspable impression, then I assent to the proposition being real,
known as sumcata thesis. But does this mean I now have knowledge, a systematic concept of the world?
Not quite. You are engaging in some level of cognitive thought and reasoning,
but only one type of person truly possesses knowledge, the sage, which we will talk about
when we get to ethics. Having covered logic and epistemology, let us get into the second aspect
of Stoic philosophy, physics. In the conception of the universe, the Stoics have entrenched
themselves firmly in the camp of materialists. Like the Epicureans, they argue that for anything
to act or be acted upon, it needs to have a corporeal form, a.k.a. a body, and immaterial
objects do not exist in any capacity. Unlike the Epicureans, there is no sort of explanation
of atoms or the void to define the nature of objects as to whether they exist or not.
For Stoics, existence is not even the highest level or category that an object can be placed in.
This may sound a bit esoteric, but let me explain. There is one broad classification that everything
within the universe falls into, something, or reality. Within the scope of reality, there are
two major subcategories. The first are the corporeals, or somata, since they possess bodies
that allow them to act or to be acted upon. Plants, animals, and planetary bodies all fall into this
grouping, and are thought of as existing. Platonists would raise a counterpoint, though.
How do we account for items that aren't usually thought of as possessing a corporeal form?
This would be the soul or the mind, and abstract notions of justice, beauty, etc., which, despite
not having a physical presence, certainly do have some sort of effect on our lives.
This is where the second subcategory comes in. Stoics will not concede that immaterial objects
exist, and flatly deny the idea of universals, the platonic forms, but they are indeed something
within the broad scale of reality. Objects that do not possess corporeal forms are known as
incorporeals, or asomata, and fall into four types, void, time, place, and sayables, aka meanings.
Incorporeals are real, but do not exist. Rather, they subsist. This gives them a role within the
universe, but they certainly don't have a body to act on anything in particular. This carries over
to the conception of the universe and the cosmos as a whole. One major difference from the Epicureans,
who stress the presence of the void that separates atoms from one another as they continuously fell,
the Stoics believe that the universe itself is essentially one continuous sphere of finite
material. No void is present within it, but void does exist outside of it. There are two essential
principles for root composition of the cosmos. There is passive bodily matter, and there is an
active rational principle, which is often called God. In Stoic thought, God is the great rational
creator that imbues the properties of matter with their particular shape, though it is not quite the
same as a potter giving shape to clay. Based upon our definitions of corporeal forms, both possess
bodies, since one is capable of acting and the other is capable of being acted upon, but they
can occupy the same space. God is imbued within the shape of matter, largely because God is the
cosmos. The active principle of God is dependent upon the four elements, earth, air, water, and fire,
which all possess individual characteristics. Fire is hot, water is wet, air is cold, and earth is
dry. There are two explanations within the Stoic doctrine that offer differing opinions as to the
pre-eminence of certain elements. The early tradition of Zeno, drawn from the teachings of the
pre-Socratic philosopher Heraclitus, argues that fire is the most important, imbued with transformative
energies from which all other elements are derived. Fire can both create and destroy, though destroy is
probably not the best term. Instead of total annihilation, the properties are instead turned into
something else. The universe itself is said to undergo conflagration, which has all parts of the
cosmos transform into fire before it begins anew, and thus the cosmos is eternal, changing on a grand
scale, but not destroyed. The later explanation, probably derived from the work of Chrysippus,
argues instead of fire, it is an additional fifth element, pneuma, or breath, which is likely a
combination of fire and air. Pneuma is the life essence of all living beings, specifically the
essence of reason and rationality, a.k.a. the soul, and therefore pneuma embodies the active principle
for the cosmos because of its inherent rational characteristic. Pneuma itself has varying degrees
to which it appears, depending on the type of object it creates. Simple, non-living objects like
rocks or a puddle of water are merely held together or unified under hexis, or cohesion.
Plant life is a little more immense, but given its apparent lack of perception or movement,
it is restricted to usis, nature, meaning that it possesses a life source, and that's about it.
Animals, including humans, are the closest to the core traits of pneuma, possessing the soul,
which gives us our ability to reason and perceive. This is why that, despite the universe
ultimately being deterministic, since it occurs in cycles of conflagration and rebirth,
the Stoics emphasize the importance of free will and rational decision making.
So, this is all well and good if we believe in the idea of a rational god, but what if we don't?
What is the argument for a creator god that simultaneously shapes and encompasses the
universe? The syllogistic argument for the existence of a rational god is provided by
Zeno. What is rational is better than what is not rational. Nothing is better than the cosmos,
so the cosmos is rational. The same holds in regard of what is intelligent,
and also in regard of what partakes of being animate. He continues,
What emits a rational seed is itself rational. The cosmos emits a rational seed,
so the cosmos is rational. Zeno is arguing that the cosmos possesses a degree of divine intelligence
because rationality is the highest form of expression, and since we possess reason,
this had to be imparted by a source that also possesses reason, i.e. God. What is also
interesting are the possible interpretations of Stoic theology one might generate. It may be
perceived that, as an overarching deity that comprises one cosmos, Stoicism is arguing for
a monotheist outlook. On the other hand, it is fully possible to accept that traditional deities
like Zeus might be the representations of a larger singular god, thus advocating a henotheistic
belief. This is going to be a very important topic to discuss when we eventually talk about
the developments of religion during the Hellenistic period, but keep it in the back of your mind for
the time being, and I think it's finally time to move from physics to ethics and learn what it
means to live virtuously. How do we live ethically? For the Stoics, there is an emphasis on living in
accordance with nature, a carryover from Zeno's early experience under Cynic teachings. However,
this is modified more to fit the idea that human beings, the rational creatures that we are,
should live in accordance with our own nature, and the nature of the cosmos, i.e. we should live
virtuously, which is to be achieved by living rationally. Since we've already explained that the
cosmos is rational and well organized, then it is our duty to live according to those principles.
Now, all living beings seem to share one common desire, self-preservation. We consciously and
unconsciously tend to choose things that allow us to continue our existence. I eat when I'm hungry,
I drink when I am thirsty, and I sleep when I'm tired, and so on and so forth. The emphasis on
I am shows that this base instinct, called oikaiosis, allows individuals to understand their
self and their own needs, recognizing what is good and bad for our survival. This is different from
the Epicurean ideal, which argues the desire for pleasure rather than survival, but it does suggest
a degree of selfishness inherent to all people. However, oikaiosis is a very base form of rationality,
expressed mainly by children and animals, and as we develop into adults, so too does our capacity
for reason. We can see this in two main examples. A parent who nurtures the well-being of their
child, hopefully, does so because they genuinely care for them as individuals, which is also
compelled by their nature, because we may view our children as a biological extension of ourselves.
We also can recognize that humans are social animals, and it is largely because of this that
we are successful, which requires even a basic degree of altruism and cooperation to work. Since God
has given all animals and ourselves the instinct of self-preservation, it is important that we live
in accordance with this principle, and since humans are special because they seem to possess
the greatest capacity for reason, we therefore must take the next logical step, and view ourselves
not only as individuals, but as living within the larger community of the universe. We should move
from simpler desires, like food or shelter, towards higher purposes, i.e. virtuous living,
because it directly allows us to better ourselves in both our physical and mental well-being.
To the Stoic, things are ethically classified into three groupings. The first is the good,
the bad, and the indifferent. The vast majority of subjects fall into this indifference category,
and we might be surprised to learn that this also includes things that we might typically
view as good for us, such as friendship or healthy food, and it also includes things
that might be viewed as bad, such as poverty or sickness. Certain activities or states may
have precedents because of their implicit relations with our well-being. For instance,
we certainly would prefer not to be sick since it impedes our ability to flourish,
and we would rather be healthy because it gives us the power to do virtuous actions.
These things, however, shouldn't matter, and things that we might view as good,
such as wealth, may lead us to live an unvirtuous life, such as using our wealth to pay for a drug
addiction. The only thing that is truly good is virtue, and therefore the act of being virtuous,
and the only thing that's truly bad is when we go against this principle.
To explain further, it's not the act itself that carries a value, rather it's the fact that we,
as rational thinking beings, are purposefully, consciously choosing to be virtuous,
is what makes something good. Indeed, we should not be focused on things we cannot control,
but on what we can control. As its namesake implies, Stoicism also argues that in order
to live a virtuous, rational life, we must be masters of our emotions. Now, contrary to the
initial impression of a stony-faced individual, there's more depth to this argument. According
to the Stoics, emotion is a voluntary ascent following the observation and judgment of an
impression, making them something firmly within our control. However, it would be rather absurd
to claim you can actually banish all varieties of reactions, like a startle reflex when a fire
cracker explodes right behind you, and the Stoics take this fully into consideration.
Reflexes and unconscious reactions are not considered emotions, and they're largely out
of our control anyways, so we shouldn't be too concerned. Emotions are problematic because they
can lead us to living contrary to nature, by making either false judgments or undergoing
unnecessary stress. According to the Stoics, there are emotional states that are something to be
welcomed, but they're more developed from simpler ones. Instead of pleasure, we want to experience
joy, caution versus fear, and wishing instead of envying. Passions, as they are called, are
essentially emotional states that are caused by impulses that lead us to feelings of anger and
fear, pain or pleasure. Since they require our ascent, we can avoid them outright, even if we
cannot eliminate their presence. Okay, so you're suggesting that I should be conscious of my
decisions and emotional state, but how do I make the correct choice regarding what leads to virtuous
living? According to the Stoics, all creatures are born with a notion of the appropriate, an action
or decision that is natural to that animal that, when followed, would lead them to being in
accordance with nature. But this brings up a valid counterpoint. We said earlier that the Stoics
denied the existence of any innate knowledge, and stressed the idea of the blank slate. But how can
we be naturally inclined to goodness if there is no knowledge to tell us what such goodness is?
Seneca elaborates on this by claiming that we are not born with knowledge of what is good,
but rather an inclination or seeds that, when honed by natural observation of the external world,
will form a preconception of what the good is. In addition, virtue as a state is not a matter
of degrees. You are either virtuous or you are not. By choosing to follow your sense of reason,
you are ascenting to the pursuit of wisdom, and only then do you have the possibility of reaching
the state of virtue. Otherwise, you're corrupt. No ifs, ands, or buts. This doesn't mean that there
isn't a sense of progress, and that there is an instantaneous switch from corrupt to virtuous by
just deciding to follow your reason one day. Morality develops through experience and baby
steps. First, you start with the base instincts of self-preservation. Second is to grasp and
understand what things allow you to live in accordance with nature and those that don't.
Third is applying a method of rejection and selecting the things that allow us to live
in accordance. And fourth is to continuously follow that choice. Lastly, once you are
absolutely consistent in your choices, to the point where it's almost instinctual,
then you may be able to say that you're on the path of righteousness.
The ideal representation of the virtuous human is the stoic sage, the only person to possess
true knowledge of both human and cosmic affairs. Which doesn't mean that they're superhuman,
they have just hit the peak potential of the human condition. With this knowledge comes
unquestionable devotion to righteous living and rationality, never holding opinions nor
assenting to emotions and impulses. They are utterly in control, which means they are free
of any negative influences. This is essentially the bulk of the stoic doctrine as a whole.
And due to brevity's sake, I needed to condense quite a bit of these ideas. It's a challenging
philosophy to get at the root of, considering that the meditations of Marcus Aurelius are
so easily readable, and are often what I recommend to people who want to start out
when it comes to philosophy. But I hope you were able to get the general gist of it.
One last point of interest is the role of stoicism in politics. Contrary to the epicureans
who viewed politics and civic participation as getting in the way of virtuous living,
the stoics are more than willing to involve themselves in the political life. We sort of
touched upon this in the initial steps of the ethics discussion on how humans, like other
animals, are capable of altruism, often by viewing others as an extension of ourselves.
Admittedly, when the stoic sage helps another individual, they aren't really doing it for
the benefit of the person, but rather for themselves, in the sense that they commit
to virtue. Indeed, perhaps one of the successes of the stoic movement is its flexibility to
the more harsh realities of the ancient world. The stoics speak of a cosmic city that emphasizes
virtuous living together with your neighbors, under the rule of natural law, for the good
of the whole, with a stoic sage as the ideal candidate for rule, like the philosopher kings
of Plato's Republic. As expected, this can be attractive to kings and emperors because
of the expanded application of natural law into rule of law, which translates to their
rule of law. There are also issues regarding the emphasis of the mind rather than external
affairs. Rather infamously, slavery is not a subject that particularly vexed any stoic,
as a body may be enslaved, but a mind is not, so long as they are virtuous, at least according
to the theory. Despite this, the flexibility of the stoic movement kept it alive in the
framework of the Roman Empire, when the Epicurean and Skeptic movements declined in favor of
Neoplatonic and later Christian thoughts. The limited survival of any stoic text that
meticulously laid out their doctrine meant that they were just as susceptible to declining
popularity as their contemporaries, especially following the closures of the philosophical
schools in the 6th century AD. Much of medieval European and Islamic thought was still dominated
by Aristotle, and although during the Renaissance it began to be reintroduced to scholars by
way of Cicero, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius in Seneca, it didn't have the same degree
of promotion, partially because of its dicey relationship with Christian beliefs. Branches
like the Calvinists highly respected Stoicism, while others have expressed the difficulties
in reconciling the beliefs of a corporeal god and the mortality of the soul, along with
the notions of henotheism, pantheism, or perhaps even atheism, as some thinkers claimed.
There are also a number of problems with the framework that were directly attacked by the
more popular Platonic and Neoplatonic schools, such as questions on defining the qualification
of good, or their sometimes shaky grounds for epistemology and the rejection of inborn
knowledge. Still, Stoicism remained a respected institution, and did contribute to later philosophical
ideas. The philosophy of Immanuel Kant has very direct parallels to Stoic belief regarding
his categorical imperative and emphasis on the moral of the action, rather than the outcome
of said action, which is reflected in the Stoic emphasis on the act of pursuing virtue
is more important than the external thing we are focused upon. The conception of the
blank slate and predisposition towards a sort of a natural law is emulated by the likes
of John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, whether we have explicit evidence that they
borrowed from those ideas or not. The French essayist Michel de Montaigne in the 16th century,
though largely drawing from the skeptics, still paid homage to the Stoic philosopher
Epictetus by inscribing the following line in his library, quote,
That which worries men are not things, but that which they think about them.
And that's where we'll end our discussion on the Stoics. The next episode, on Skepticism,
might be the last in our series on Hellenistic philosophy, depending on how much material I
can pull out of it. I have to admit that much of this research can be quite dry at times,
and I will be ready and willing to move back to our usual style of episodes once we are done.
As a way to hold you over, I have interviews planned, and am looking to release some of
them before the end of this month, so that's something to look forward to if you're looking
for content more in line with what we are used to. I also want to thank all of you who bought
the bookmarks for my Etsy page. They should be all, or nearly all, shipped out by the time of
this episode's release, and I'm glad to hear that a couple have already received them. You can check
out my account page at Etsy by clicking the link in the podcast description if you wanted to buy
the bookmark, or by going to my website at www.HellenisticAgePodcast.wordpress.com,
where you can also find the list of sources used for this episode.
Once again, thank you all for listening, and I'll be back next time for another episode of
The Hellenistic Age Podcast.
