Here's how Iranian missile strikes could impact oil prices

Invest Insight
9 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 3, 2024
CNBC's Brian Sullivan and RBC's Helima Croft join 'The Exchange' to discuss the impact of Iran's missile strikes on global oil prices.
Iran's missile attack on Israel has oil prices spiking.
Let's bring in our own Brian Sullivan, along with RBC's head of global commodity strategy,
Halima Croft.
Brian, we see about a 5% pop at the moment.
Yeah, and I'm really eager to hear what Halima has to say about the geopolitics,
because she's one of my go-to sources, as you know, Kelly.
But let's just talk about the math.
This is the biggest oil move in just about a year's time.
We're up about 5.5%, but as of 4.5% now.
But as I said earlier on Money Movers, I think that oil could have been up 10% or 15%
had the U.S. not been in record oil production.
If we were at 8 or 9 million barrels a day, not 13.2 million like we are now,
this type of tension, this type of fear, this type of attack would have had a far
outsized move on the price of oil.
But because Iran is about 3% of daily production, about 12% of OPEC's daily production,
and the U.S. is doing 13.2 million a day, Kelly, I think that has mitigated.
We're not at 80.
We're at 70.
And I think given what we're seeing in terms of the missile attacks, a little surprising.
But the U.S. production muting that, I will say this, and this is where Halima knows a
lot more than I do, which is 20% of the world's oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz.
Iran tends to be the one to agitate, sometimes dropping mines, stealing ships, etc.
If they decide to get aggressive, to sort of force Saudi Arabia, the UAE and others
to come to the bargaining table, then we could see a much larger move than we are seeing
in oil right now.
But I want to hear Halima's take on this.
No, I think that's fair.
And Halima, as I bring you in, I also want to add to Brian's comment that
Saudi already indicating its decision as well to try to put more supplies into a market that
has been basically oversupplied probably mutes the impact that we could see here.
So I'm curious if you could address that issue as well, as Brian said,
an escalation that could start to involve the Strait of Hormuz.
Yeah, absolutely.
I mean, we do not have an undersupply situation in the market at present.
However, I think there has been a lot of complacency about this war.
A lot of oil market participants said we have not seen a disruption.
They did not believe there would be a disruption.
And hence, it was not priced in.
So the real question I think right now, Kelly, is what is the Israeli response?
Contessa mentioned 200 missiles thus far have been fired into Israel.
Do the Israelis respond in kind?
Do they potentially target the Iranian nuclear facilities?
And do they potentially target the Iranian oil facilities?
Iran is producing at a five year high over three million barrels a day.
I think we do need to think about a scenario where Iranian oil supplies are at risk.
And certainly in 2019, the Iranians did target significant regional energy infrastructure.
They hit tankers off the coast of UAE.
They hit key pipelines.
And most importantly, they hit Saudi Arabia's Abqaiq facility,
taking off half of that country's production in order to internationalize the cost of U.S.
sanctions.
So again, it's a very fluid situation.
But there is significant oil at stake if Iran wants to get involved in terms of raising the
cost for the West for this war.
Brian, I think that's part of what people are weighing at this hour is whether and whether
it's the Israelis, to what extent the U.S. is involved or tacitly supports this,
the striking of the nuclear facilities, of the oil facilities.
And if that takes place, would their next step then be something as Halima indicated
or with the Strait of Hormuz?
Iran has enough enriched uranium, about 60 percent toward a nuclear weapon.
They recently said they don't want to do a nuclear weapon.
We can believe them at face value or not.
But they continue to enrich uranium.
They continue to raise their oil exports, Kelly, because they're having more money.
I mean, they're technically under sanction and they've been selling more oil under sanctions.
So their foreign currency reserves, their financial ability to support the weaponization
of Hezbollah and Hamas has only increased over the last couple of years.
OK, so that's on the political side.
Back to the oil side, I think there is a measure of comfort and Halima can correct me if I'm
wrong in the market that Saudi Arabia has enough and it could easily throw another one
or two million barrels of oil back on the market relatively quickly if something were
to happen to the Iranian oil ports.
Like you saw Israel light up Yemen's port and oil receiving facility a couple of days
ago.
If Israel were to do something similar to Iran, I can guarantee there'll be some back
door communication with Saudi Arabia and maybe some others to say, listen, if we do this,
are you able to fill that global gap?
Right.
America can't do it.
Fill that global gap and replace any lost Iranian barrels on that market.
I can guarantee it.
This is Halima's world.
There's a lot of back channel communication going on right now because the one thing the
White House does not want is some kind of super spike in the price of gasoline one month
before an election.
Indeed.
Halima, add some context that if you can.
I mean, certainly we would expect the Biden administration to be calling the Saudis.
They are the ones sitting on the spare capacity that can be easily deployed.
So absolutely, that call would take place.
The real question now on this sort of unknown uncharted waters is what could happen in such
a situation?
Would Iran potentially then target other countries' regional energy infrastructure?
Saudi Arabia normalized relations with Iran in March of 2023.
I think that has protected Saudi Arabia from Iranian attacks on their infrastructure.
The Houthis have not attacked Saudi infrastructure.
And so the question is, how much do countries in the region want to be seen as weighing
into this war?
Again, we will ask Saudis to put on barrels.
The Saudis have been responsive to those requests.
But all these countries in the region are also going to have to weigh how much they
want to get caught in the crosshairs of this conflict.
Because again, in 2019, these countries themselves were targeted by Iran.
