FAA's Illusion Declared Boeing Somehow BETTER Than SpaceX while Dragon Rescue Starliner!?

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
Sep 29, 2024
it is it is I think launching these
Rockets is a safety issue into the Nas
and I think it's it's uh a situation
that that requires the same level of
Safety Management and safety culture
that we're working to implement at
Boeing needs that's exactly what the
head of the FAA the Aerospace regulator
just stated according to them Boeing is
the safety standard that SpaceX needs to
meet yeah you heard that right however
the performance of the two companies on
the ISS tells a different story in fact
spacex's dragon is set to rescue two
astronauts who were left Stranded by
Boeing's Starliner is this another FAA
misstep the controversy between the FAA
and the rest will certainly not stop
soon with the current situation recently
in a hearing California Congressman
Kevin Kylie directly questioned FAA
administrator Mike Whitaker the FAA
administrator repeatedly mentioned
safety issues and said that was the
reason they punished spacex's Falcon as
well as the delayed Starship Mike said I
think safety is in the public interest
and that's our primary focus uh it's the
only tool we have to uh get compliance
on safety matters interestingly in this
hearing Mike Whitaker pointed out many
unclear items that he said were spacex's
violations SpaceX then sent a letter to
Kevin Kylie to point out the FAA
administrator's wrong argu arguments
this shows that the FAA is not working
effectively from its leadership position
but what I think caused the most
controversy in Mike Whitaker's statement
is probably the opinion related to
Boeing which I showed at the beginning
of the video as he said SpaceX has not
ensured operational safety including the
problems with Starship and some recent
problems with falcony but that is
clearly absurd with Starship the rocket
is still in development so problems are
inevitable problems are inevitable if
the faa's argument appli to the entire
industry perhaps companies in the future
would be extremely hesitant to develop
Rockets with Falcon 9 its problems do
not affect Public Safety and do not
affect the flight Target regarding the
flight five delay the FAA said I think
the two-month delay is necessary to
comply with the the launch requirements
and I think that's an important part of
safety culture and it is ridiculous that
the FAA chose Boeing's culture as a
standard for safety Boeing needs to also
exist with commercial space Boeing was
indeed a giant in the past but entering
this entry this company gradually
declined in the aviation industry Boeing
sometimes had major failures resulting
in many losses of Life other failures
have usually happened on the Aerospace
side Starliner has certainly been the
industry's focus this year after years
of delays due to problems it launched
its cft1 mission in June but when it
launched and docked on the ISS this
spacecraft showed many problems like
helium leaks Thruster failures and more
thereby delaying its return turn
schedule causing chaos of the ISS and
eventually returning without astronauts
currently NASA and Boeing are still
struggling to analyze the Starliner
problems and have not provided any
further updates the next scheduled
flight Starliner 1 was pushed back to
the end of next year but this could be
delayed further if the problem is not
disclosed and Boeing is not granted a
launch certificate that could lead to
Boeing not being able to fulfill the
NASA contract I wonder if these are the
standards that the AA mentioned it's a
shame at least this time Boeing doesn't
deserve to be in that position and by
comparison SpaceX is clearly showing
that they operate much more safely and
efficiently than Boeing with the Falcon
rocket before some recent minor issues
SpaceX has been operating for nearly a
decade without any problems among them
the Falcon heavy has maintained a 100%
success rate since its launch regarding
the ISS dragon is also participating in
NASA's Supply program with Starliner but
in contrast to the core performance of
Boeing's spacecraft dragon is currently
reaching many achievements with nine
flights for NASA including a test
mission in addition they also carry out
many other private missions in the next
few days crew nine will be launched to
rescue the two astronauts left behind by
Starliner at the time of this video
Falcon 9 and dragon in this Mission just
completed the static fire test the two
astronauts Nick ha and Alexander gorinov
moved to the Launchpad and then basic
completed the full rehearsal test with
these two astronauts inside Dragon more
importantly mentioning safety we can see
that dragon is also absolutely
successful even with an unprecedented
Mission like the Polaris Dawn spacewalk
Dragon had also performed excellently it
can be said that just with these
comparisons we can see that SpaceX is
much safer than Boeing that is why the
FAA administrator statement received a
strong reaction from Elon Musk he
reposted the hearing along with a
message about Mike wh ER he needs to
resign obviously the more arguments the
more we see that the FAA is trying to
slow down SpaceX to favor other
companies the Starship delay is clearly
beneficial to Ula and blue origin after
these companies were delayed due to
their own problems and now when it comes
to Boeing perhaps this company is also
being favored by the FAA there is no
Intervention when that spacecraft
operates and returns with many problems
but perhaps they have not realized that
their regulations are also creating
opportunities for other countries
especially China to catch up even
surpass the US recently a statistic on
the launch results in the first quarter
once again showed the dominance of
SpaceX they launched
429,000 more than the competitor behind
them regarding flight 5 SpaceX recently
posted preparation images accompanied by
the message SpaceX Engineers have spent
years preparing and months testing for
the booster catch attempt on flight 5
with technicians pouring tens of
thousands of hours into building the
infrastructure to maximize our chances
for Success spacex's role is extremely
important obviously without SpaceX we
would really be surpassed by China in
many aspects so sad if we lost that
Advantage even the leading position due
to problems from within the country what
do you think about the FAA administrator
statement should Mike and his agency be
kicked out of the Aerospace industry
respond yes in the comment section if
you agree then be sure to like share the
video and subscribe to our channel to
continue following spacex's development
Journey despite facing many challenges
SpaceX continues to make impressive
strides with its Falcon 9 rocket at
12:01 a.m EDT on September 24th a falcon
9 lifted off from SLC 4E in California
marking the 64th starlink mission of the
year the booster for this Mission b1081
success landed on the of course I still
love you or ocis L drone ship completing
its 10th Mission this Landing was the
103rd for aasly and the 351st overall
for SpaceX boosters b1081 had previously
supported several notable missions
including two to the International Space
Station with crew 7 and CRS 29 two
climate monitoring satellites for NASA's
pacce and isa's Earth care and the
transporter 10 right share Mission more
significantly with this Mission SpaceX
achieved its 92nd launch of the Year
officially surpassing the previous
record set last year when combined with
one Falcon heavy Mission and two
Starship missions SpaceX has now
completed 95 missions in 2024 looking
ahead SpaceX has even more Milestones to
conquer they are just three launches
away from matching last year's total of
98 launches and need two more beyond
that to hit 100 launches for the year
Falcon 99 alone is eight missions away
from its own 100th launch with a goal of
148 launches for the year and over 3
months left to achieve it SpaceX remains
well on track records are breaking
continuously despite the obstacles the
launch schedule is growing tighter as
the year comes to a close so stay tuned
to follow spacex's upcoming Milestones
alongside SpaceX Firefly Aerospace has
also made significant strides this year
recently securing an important launch
contract NASA awarded Firefly a
texas-based company a contract on behalf
of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration or Noah through the
Venture class acquisition of dedicated
and R share or Vader launch Services
Vader launch Services Program Vader
allows NASA to offer fixed price
contracts for satellite launches under
this contract Firefly will launch quick
Sounder a prototype for Noah's Next
Generation environmental satellites in
low earth orbit although the value of
the award was not disclosed the Vader
program offers a Max maximum total value
of $300 million across all contracts
during its 5-year ordering period
according to the Noah web page quick
Sounder is part of Noah's near Earth
orbit Network or neon a new generation
of polar orbiting weather satellites its
mission is to collect critical weather
data for several organizations including
the National Weather Service as stated
on the Noah web page the quick Sounder
Mission will support Noah's Next
Generation satellite architecture for
its future low earth orbit program which
will provide Mission critical data for
the agency's National Weather Service
the nation's weather industry and other
users worldwide the launch is currently
scheduled for no earlier than February
of 2026 Noah in collaboration with NASA
is focusing on speeding up the
development of small to medium-sized
satellites to enhance weather
forecasting disaster management and
climate monitoring NASA will handle the
development and launch of these
satellites while Noah will provide
funding technical requirements and
manage postlaunch operations this
contract marks a valuable achievement
for Firefly offering an opportunity to
establish greater credibility in the
Aerospace industry historically Noah has
relied on highly Dependable companies
like SpaceX for its satellite launches
making this both an opportunity and a
challenge for Firefly it will be
interesting to see how they manag this
significant responsibility cancelling
Starliner is becoming an increasingly
real possibility and it may not be NASA
making the decision Boeing itself could
step away from the program but why why
would Boeing cancel Starliner and how
easy would it be for them to withdraw
what would this mean for NASA and the
Aerospace industry after nearly 3 months
stationed at the International Space
Station Boeing's Starliner capsule
finally returned to Earth without its
crew on board despite Boeing and NASA
labeling the return as a success it's
difficult to ignore the reality leaving
astronauts stranded in orbit is a
glaring failure this event further
erodes public and Industry confidence in
Boeing's Starline appr program which has
already been plagued by delays technical
issues and significant setbacks worse
yet Boeing itself appears increasingly
frustrated with the Starliner system all
signs suggest that the project May soon
come to an embarrassing and premature
end with Boeing potentially deciding to
cancel the Starliner program altogether
Boeing's growing dissatisfaction with
Starliner was made clear following the
recent Landing in what should have been
a routine press conference with NASA no
Boeing officials attended a highly
uncharacteristic IC move press briefings
are standard practice after significant
missions providing an opportunity to
update the public clarify results and
demonstrate accountability Boeing's
absence has raised questions were they
preoccupied with postm Mission
complications were they still upset over
previous decisions by NASA or more
simply were they too embarrassed by the
mission's outcome to face public
scrutiny whatever the reasoning their
decision not to appear at the Press
event sent a strong message of
frustration and possibly embarrass
embarrassment the financial burden
Starliner has placed on Boeing further
complicates the situation the company
has suffered enormous losses due to the
years of delays and Technical failures
in 2022 alone Boeing reported a
staggering $1.47 billion in losses
primarily from issues related to the
Starliner program these losses continued
into 2023 with the second quarter seeing
a $257 million hit due to problems with
flammable wiring and parachutes pushing
the crew flight test or CFT -1 mission
to 2024 most recently Boeing's Financial
reports show an additional $125 million
loss still tied to delays before the
cft1 mission bringing the total loss for
Starliner to a whopping 1.6 billion doar
these Financial setbacks combined with
technical challenges have delayed
Boeing's Starliner One mission to the
second half of 2025 The Continuous need
for repairs and adjustments to ensure
safety will undoubtedly consume more
time and resources potentially
increasing Boeing's losses even further
moreover with Boeing's current
trajectory is becoming increasingly
doubtful that they will be able to meet
NASA's requirement to complete six crude
flights as part of the commercial crew
program contract Boeing has spent nearly
a decade just trying to successfully
complete the crew test mission with
little to show for it Beyond mounting
losses and repeated delays time is
running out and the prospect of Boeing
completing one One mission per year to
fulfill the contract seems increasingly
unrealistic When comparing Boeing's
progress to spacex's achievements under
the same CCP contract the difference is
Stark SpaceX which also received funding
under the program has successfully
launched nine crew missions for NASA
including the crew test mission and they
are preparing to launch their 10th
Mission this month on top of that SpaceX
has conducted numerous private missions
including the high-profile Polaris Dawn
Mission which featured a commercial
spacewalk it's clear that while SpaceX
has excelled in developing and deploying
its Dragon spacecraft Boeing's Starliner
has struggled to keep up the
implications of Starliner failure extend
far beyond NASA's commercial crew
program the ongoing delays and issues
have tarnished Starliner reputation
making it unlikely that organizations
will opt to use the spacecraft for
future missions spacex's dragon has
become the Preferred Choice with proven
reliability and cost Effectiveness while
Starliner faces a dwindling market and a
grim future Boeing once a leading name
in Aerospace now finds itself grappling
with a spacecraft that lacks public
trust and Industry support without those
critical factors the viability of the
Starliner project is severely
compromised for Boeing the cancellation
of Starliner could relieve them of a
significant burden the company has
poured years of effort and billions of
dollars into a project that has yet to
yield successful results pulling the
plug might seem like the best option
especially as Financial losses continue
to mount however however the decision to
cancel Starliner would not be without
significant consequences firstly
cancelling Starliner would irreparably
damage Boeing's reputation for decades
Boeing has been a Cornerstone of the US
Aerospace industry contributing to
countless missions and projects across
various sectors to end the Starliner
program in such a humiliating way would
not only reflect poorly on the company
but could also tarnish the image of
American space exploration as a whole
secondly Boeing received substantial
financial support from NASA to the tune
of $4.5 billion this funding came from
taxpayers and Boeing would face immense
public and governmental scrutiny if the
project were canceled without delivering
on its promises NASA selected Boeing for
this critical role in the commercial
crew program placing significant trust
and expectations on the company a
failure to meet even the minimum
requirements of the contract would be a
major blow potentially leading to
repercussions for both Boeing and NASA
lastly the impact on the future of the
ISS and US space leadership would be
substantial Boeing's failure to deliver
a reliable crew transport vehicle could
place additional strain on NASA and
other private Partners to fill the Gap
left by Starliner Boeing would not only
lose face but also it's standing as a
reliable partner in future space
missions ultimately the question remains
will Boeing pull the plug on Starliner
or will they push forward despite the
mounting challenges with each delay and
technical issue the likelihood of
cancellation grows and while Boeing May
benefit from walking away it's clear
that such a decision would come with
far-reaching consequences for the
company NASA and the future of us space
exploration what do you think will
Boeing cancel Starliner or will they
find a way to salvage the project let us
know in the comments down below and if
you agree with this analysis make sure
to like share the video and subscribe to
our channel to stay updated on spacex's
development Journey indeed the future of
starlander ultimate hinges on NASA's
decision as the agency originally
created the project and selected Boeing
despite the recent setbacks NASA appears
to maintain a level of support for
Boeing Steve Stitch the manager of
NASA's commercial crew program recently
remarked we' had a crew on board the
spacecraft we would have flown the same
uh backway sequence from the space
station and the same deorbit burn and
executed the same entry and so it would
have been a safe successful Landing with
the crew on board yeah I think it's
always hard to have that retrospective
look you know we made the decision to
have an uncrewed flight based on what we
knew at the time and based on our
knowledge of the thrusters and based on
the modeling that we had and we you know
if we' have had a model that would have
predicted what we saw tonight perfectly
yeah it looks like an easy decision to
go say we could have had a crude flight
but we didn't have that this ongoing
support suggests that NASA might still
consider certifying star liner for crude
missions despite the uncrewed return
however this statement raises questions
about the contradiction between NASA's
confidence and Starliner safety and
their decision to return the spacecraft
uncrewed it's unclear whether NASA will
continue to support Starliner or if they
will push for more significant changes
for now both NASA and Boeing are likely
working to address the spacecraft's
issues and determine the next steps as
the situation evolves it will be
interesting to see how NASA's support
impacts starlander future what do you
think about NASA's stance share your
thoughts in the comment section down
below and Boeing's troubles extend
beyond the Starliner program notably
impacting the space launch system or SLS
project as well according to NASA's
office of Inspector General or oig
components of the SLS 1B core stage and
exploration upper stage or E slated for
Artemis 4 fail to meet quality standards
and posst risks to Future missions
Boeing May face corrective actions and
potential penalties as a result these
issues could delay Boeing's delivery
schedule potentially pushing the e
delivery to April of 2027 with emis
Force scheduled for September of 20128
this delay coupled with the increased
costs associated with the E which has
already reached $2.8 billion highlights
a pattern of expensive delayed and
inefficient performance the core stages
cost remains uncertain but is expected
to be substantial the similarities
between the problems with SLS and
Starline are both expensive and delayed
point to possible issues with outdated
technology and working practices this
raises concerns about further
disappointments once SLS is operational
Boeing could face being removed from the
project a scenario that would be as
humiliating as the potential
cancellation of Starliner and could
signal Boeing's exit from the Aerospace
Market however if NASA were to remove
Boeing from the SLS project finding a
replacement contractor could be
challenging and might lead to new delays
this brings up the possibility of NASA
cancelling the SLS altogether despite
its success in Artemis 1 the SLS faced
significant delays and cost overruns
which could make it advantageous for
NASA to focus on supporting SpaceX and
its Starship program which promises a
more efficient and costeffective
solution Boeing's future in the
Aerospace industry is uncertain and much
depends on the fate of Starliner and the
SLS the possibility of cancelling
Starliner is growing and decisions in
the coming months will be crucial in
determining Boeing's role moving forward
well folks that's about it for today's
episode thank you so much for tuning in
and as always this has been Kevin from
great SpaceX until next time keep
looking up
