The Stock Market Is Now A Coin Flip

Profit Playbook
12 followers
Sep 29, 2024
"00:00 Intro
01:30 Portfolio Update
04:40 The Coin Flip Market
10:20 Costco Earnings
18:38 Big Tech Valuations
28:14 Amazon Employees Want to Quit
30:44 I Don't Trust Sam Altman"
Welcome back everyone.
Today on the Joseph Carlson Show, the stock market continues to race up.
The S&P 500 this year is up 21%.
The Nasdaq as well is up 21%.
Most of us, if we've been investing well, have made major gains this year.
And one of Wall Street's biggest bulls, Tom Lee, has been bullish this entire year.
But he says over the next couple of months, it's a coin flip.
But what stocks do in the next month is a bit of a coin flip.
We'll be going over why he believes the next couple of months is a coin flip and what he
sees in the long term future.
We also have some other news to get to.
Asmat Damadoran recently did a breakdown of the valuation of big tech companies.
I hold many of these companies in my portfolio, but one of them that he talks about that I
do not own is Nvidia.
He feels strongly about the valuation of Nvidia, and we're going to take a look at it.
We also have news that Costco is down 1.7% on the day after they reported their earnings.
We're going to take a look at how many warehouses they opened, what their business looks like,
what the growth outlook looks like, what the renewal rate looks like after they implemented
price increases.
We'll even be looking at Costco weighing in on a claim that Diddy's lawyer made that Diddy
was buying a lot of baby oil in bulk from Costco.
We have even more news that 73% of Amazon workers are considering quitting after going
back into the office five days a week.
And of course, the mess that's going on with OpenAI and Sam Altman.
A lot of executives have left the company.
Sam Altman says that it's no big deal.
It's just the normal course of business.
We'll be looking at what's really going on with Sam Altman and why I don't trust him.
So we have a lot of news to get to in this episode, but we'll start off by turning first
to the story of the market going up this year over and over.
This has been a great year for the S&P 500 and the QQQ.
If you've invested wisely, this has been a great year, the type of year investors can
hope for.
When I look at my investments, I have to be satisfied with the way things are going.
Some of my largest investments in dominant financial companies continue to soar.
In the tech category, obviously big tech with Microsoft and Apple is doing great.
This year was a particularly good year for Apple.
If we look at Salesforce, even one of the companies that's been struggling has finally
worked its way back into the green.
Now it's in the green by just a hair, so it's teetering between the green and the red.
But this was just a short time ago, a $10,000 loss.
So by holding this company, adding a little bit more on dips, it's now back to a neutral position.
Salesforce was the only position I held that was in the red.
In the consumer category, my newest stock position, Booking Holdings, is off to a great
start.
It is a $53,000 position with already $7,000 in the green.
That's an 18% gain in a short amount of time.
If we look at Booking Holdings, it now trades at $4,200 per share.
It's been on an incredible run.
I added a lot to this position in August at a lower price because I saw that the drop
off after earnings was undeserved.
So I'm not surprised to see that the stock is now going up.
When I look at Booking Holdings today, I still see it as good value.
Texas Roadhouse continues to be a sleeping giant.
This company just grows and grows.
It gives returns in multiple ways.
The stock is up 47% year-to-date, not factoring in dividends.
If you price those in, it's up around 50%.
One of the interesting statistics that I give out about Texas Roadhouse, a statistic that's
true but sounds false, is that Texas Roadhouse, this restaurant, has outperformed Google year-to-date.
It's outperformed Google over the one year.
It's outperformed Google over the five years, and it's outperformed Google stock over the
past trailing 10 years.
It sounds crazy to say that this restaurant company is outperforming a top AI company,
a monopolistic company, but it has.
I now have as much gains in Texas Roadhouse as I do Costco.
It is now a $77,000 position with $42,000 in the green.
Texas Roadhouse and Costco have both done so well that they're now my third and fourth
largest holdings in my portfolio, beating out companies like Microsoft, Intuit, and Salesforce.
On top of the capital appreciation from these companies, the portfolio keeps compounding
in part because of the dividends.
Just from September 6th, I've received four major dividends.
One from Moody's Corporation, which is $86.
S&P Global paid me $188 on September 11th.
Microsoft paid me $122 on September 12th.
Texas Roadhouse paid a $265 dividend on September 24th.
So now I'm sitting with $1,000 in cash, all of that from dividends, that I get to spend
some time, look around at my holdings, and choose which one I want to reinvest in.
So overall, just as a brief summary, this has been a fun year.
Any investor should be happy about this year.
Companies are earning greater cash flows, they're paying investors more through share
Now a question for most investors, when we have times like this, where the market is
racing up, is what do you do in these situations?
A lot of investors stand to make mistakes.
They sell stocks too early, they exit, they go to cash, in the goal of selling high and
buying low.
But the market continues to race up after they sell.
So knowing what to do is easier said than done.
One person that's been more right than wrong on this issue is Tom Lee, and he gives some
perspective of why he thinks the next couple of months is a coin toss.
Well, you know, I think the Fed unleashed us on an easing cycle, and that's going to
be positive.
We know it's actually historically positive three months, six months out.
But what stocks do in the next month is a bit of a coin flip.
And I think that's what we're seeing, because there's some repositioning that took place.
And also we're now thinking about the 40 days into the election.
He notes that the Federal Reserve cutting interest rates is typically positive for the
stock market if you look out three to six months from those initial cuts.
So we just had the Federal Reserve cut interest rates by 50 basis points.
If we look out three to six months, we should be in the green from the time they cut.
Between those three to six months, we don't know.
And that's why he's saying the next couple of months is a coin flip.
Now, overall, I agree with this assessment.
I think it's accurate to say that cutting interest rates is good for the stock market.
It's mathematically beneficial for equity portfolios to have a lower cost of capital.
When companies borrow money, they get cheaper rates with lower interest rates.
It's mathematically beneficial for equity portfolios to have other alternative investments,
like fixed income and treasuries, to have a lower yield.
That means that you're not competing with the higher yield of treasuries.
So just from a mathematical standpoint, I agree with Tom Lee.
It makes sense for interest rate cuts to benefit stocks.
The only caveat I would give is in some cases when interest rates are cut, it's because
the economy is going into recession.
And obviously, a recession is not good for anyone.
So if we get into the scenario where the Fed is cutting interest rates because we're headed
into a recession, that's obviously not going to benefit stocks.
But outside of that one scenario of going into recession, this is beneficial for stocks.
Now, the other factor that he notes causing some uncertainty over the next couple of months
is of course the general election.
If the election is but 40 days away, sort of ruin the perfect scenario for stocks to
get that post-Fed bump?
I think it delays it.
Just because, you know, in the conferences that I've been speaking at and seeing wealth
managers and family offices, a lot don't want to commit capital until after Election Day.
And I don't think it matters who wins.
It's just they want to get that event behind them.
So you think we're going to have sort of a dash to the finish after Election Day is
out of the way?
Yeah.
And that's pretty typical.
You know, in fact, in election years, the November-December rallies are pretty tremendous.
And in fact, when markets are up more than 10% in the first half, you also get big rallies
November-December, sort of choppy through September.
Tom Lee's spot on here.
Investors don't like uncertainty.
And although the market has done well this election season, it is true that some companies
want to get past the elections before making investments.
In terms of who wins, I don't think businesses are making big decisions on that.
Both of them have their differences on tax policy.
Kamala wants to raise taxes on corporations.
Trump wants to raise taxes on tariffs.
But either way, most companies will likely do the exact same thing after the election
than they would have before.
They'll just wait until the election to do it.
Now, the next topic that he hits on is that scenario I brought up of potentially entering
into a recession.
The only thing that could ruin Tom Lee's prediction of markets being up three to six months after
the Fed cut is the economy entering into a recession.
Tom Lee's judging the sentiment of different companies.
And many business leaders are saying, hey, look, we're already in a recessionary territory.
They have all their different numbers and instruments they can base that off of.
I think we're in a recession if GDP turns negative and if unemployment rates start going
up.
So far, we've seen the unemployment rate start to go up, but GDP has remained positive.
So as of right now, I don't think we're technically in a recession.
But I do think we could get there quickly.
I'm confident about how we how markets behave into Election Day and not that I think we're
going to have a huge drawdown.
If we do have a big drawdown, you know, I'd be buying that dip.
But I also don't think we can make new highs and then and then see the market blast off
after Election Day.
So I'd rather sort of say things look a lot better after Election Day.
The message is simple.
Stay the course and buy the dip.
If you have a well thought out investment strategy of buying either an ETF, a basket
of companies, or the best companies in the world, any type of distressful times like
elections or uncertainty are typically buying opportunities.
I appreciate Tom Lee because I agree 100% with this investment strategy and I do the
same thing myself.
I'm not someone to just talk about it.
I also walk the walk.
If we have any big dip in the market leading up to elections or through the end of the
year, I will use it as opportunities to capitalize on companies I want to have a greater equity
stake in.
I'll be buying up some of the best companies in the world.
This has worked for me over the past seven years of investing and I think it will continue
to work in the future.
Now moving on, let's jump into some news here.
We have news that Costco just reported their earnings report.
The stock is down on the day because they missed on their revenue.
I want to play a brief clip on this earnings miss.
They are lower in overtime, but just over 4% at the moment after missing revenue estimates
when they reported just moments ago.
Joining us now to discuss is Arun Sundaram.
That's a bummer.
Costco's down 4.4% on the day after missing their revenue estimate.
Wait a minute, something feels off with this clip.
It says here Costco's $750.
Oh, I see the problem.
That's when Costco missed their revenue estimate six months ago.
They missed their revenue estimate six months ago.
The stock dropped 4.4% and that was at $750 per share.
Now today, fast forwarding six months, the stock is up $130 to $884 after again missing
their revenue estimate and having the stock drop a couple percent.
I followed companies like Costco for such a long period of time that I know the drill
by now.
Anytime a company like this has an earnings miss, they'll bring on an expert, they'll
discuss it.
In most cases, they remain positive on the company, but they give some perspective and
caution on it.
Overall, it gives you the feeling that you need to pay attention to these minute details.
In reality, as long as Costco remains Costco, the company's going to be okay.
This is a world-class company.
It is the best company in the world.
It's one that has a membership so loyal to it that people won't cancel their membership
even after price increases.
So while it's true that Costco had a slight revenue miss, that's not an indication of
how to trade this stock.
And if you're one of the investors that got cold feet and sold out of the stock at a revenue
miss in the past, you would have missed out on substantial gains over the past year.
Costco has been a massive winner, going up 36% year to date on top of paying a $16 per
share dividend at the start of the year.
It has doubled the returns of the S&P 500 and the QQQ this year.
If we look at the earnings report and the commentary from management, they said on the
earnings call that we also continue to see significant opportunities worldwide.
And our fiscal 2025 plan has 12 of our planned 29 openings coming outside of the U.S.
12 of the 29 new openings are outside the U.S.
And these are successful.
We've seen video after video of the openings outside the U.S. and there are lines outside
the door.
People love the Costco experience.
I've been there enough to know that that's not just a U.S. consumer thing.
It's general consensus that people like the experience of extra wide parking lots where
you have room between you and the next car.
People like the experience of ample walking room on the warehouse floor.
They like the experience of different merchandise every time you go there.
They like the experience of happy, well-trained staff and good return policies.
This type of thing has general appeal and you're seeing it show up in the numbers.
They also noted that their e-commerce business shouldn't be underestimated.
Costco logistics has had a remarkable year.
Appliances and furniture in big and bulky has led the way.
And logistics delivered over 4.5 million items this last year, up 29% over the prior year.
So Costco is gaining ground in delivery.
Now, the way that they compete with Amazon is they do a completely different focus.
Amazon focuses on small things, things they can get to you in two days.
These are little electronics, little house appliances, batteries, little things that
you order on a daily basis.
Amazon specializes in that and Costco knows they're not going to beat Amazon at Amazon's
game.
So Costco has maneuvered into big and bulky items.
This puts them in more competition with companies like Lowe's and Home Depot, but those are
easier competitors to go head to head with than Amazon.
The big and bulky items from Costco are getting better and better.
Their shipment times are getting better.
Their logistics are getting better.
Their customer service is getting better in that category.
Everything's improving with their online big and bulky items.
Now we know that Costco recently pushed forward a price increase on their membership.
This was a small enough price increase that I thought, in fact, I was very confident that
we'd see no meaningful change in membership renewal.
I think I even said beyond meaningful.
I said that I don't think a single person will cancel their membership because of the
price increase.
It was so small that it's just a non-factor.
Nobody's going to cancel a Costco membership because of a $5 per year price increase.
But we see it in the numbers here.
They say in terms of renewal rates, our Q4 end and the US and Canada renewal rate was
92.9% down one tenth of a percent from the end of Q3.
If we look at Qualtrim, we can see this mapped out.
If we go to renewal rates here, we can see it over time.
We look at that compared to the prior quarter and it's down from 93.
So one tenth of a percent.
Just two quarters ago, it was 92.9.
So basically the renewal rate went up a tiny bit, then it ebbed and flowed back down.
They actually note here the reason that it went down a tenth of a percent.
They say this slight decrease is related to online membership promotions that we ran for
a short period in fiscal year 2023, which resulted in over 200,000 new signups.
As those members entered the renewal rate calculation during Q4 fiscal 2024, the lower
renewal rate is for that cohort.
So they can track that the people that had a lower renewal rate was this promotional
group.
And they say specifically that outside of those signups, there were no meaningful changes
in U.S. renewal rate, meaning that increasing their price for their membership had no meaningful
changes in renewal rate.
Overall, there's a lot of reasons to be optimistic on a going forward basis of Costco's future.
The company obviously has things figured out.
They'll generate growing amounts of profits with growing amounts of membership and raising
prices.
Investors can stew over the Ford PE ratio.
The company trades at a high multiple.
The free cash flow yield looks a little better, around 1.9 percent.
I don't think Costco's at a still right now.
It's probably a company that should be put on the watch list and maybe looked at when
it dips down.
It does that from time to time.
But in my case, I continue to hold this company.
I'm not selling a single share.
Outside of Costco's earnings report, there was one other piece of news related to Costco
that I think was worth mentioning.
Costco was invoked by Diddy's lawyer.
He brought up Costco in an attempt to defend why Diddy had a thousand baby oil bottles.
This is just hilarious.
It's TMZ talking to Diddy's lawyer.
He basically tries to scorm his way out of this question.
How do you explain a thousand bottles of baby oil?
I think a reasonable question.
It's not every day you find someone that has a thousand bottles of baby oil in their house.
But apparently Diddy did.
It's a good question for the lawyer.
What is he going to say about this in terms of trying to defend the reputation of his
client?
Of course, the go-to answer for the lawyer is Costco.
It's a big house.
He buys in bulk.
I think they have Costco's in every place where he has a home.
He just answers Costco.
It's just too good.
I mean, I don't blame him.
A lot of people are like, this lawyer is an idiot.
This lawyer is so stupid.
The lawyer is doing his job.
He has a client that he's trying to get the best defense he can.
So he's trying to basically talk away any concern, any problem.
When it's brought up that Diddy has all these weird items in his house, he says, well, he
buys it in bulk.
He just bought a thousand containers of baby oil.
Now, obviously, the answer doesn't make sense.
The lawyer is trying his best, but it just doesn't make sense under any scenario.
When you look at buying in bulk, it's true that you might buy like 20 of something or
maybe even 50.
But what item are you buying a thousand of in bulk?
I shop at Costco all the time, and I don't know any single item that I buy a thousand
of in bulk.
Now, this news went so viral, it got so much attention online that apparently Diddy was
one of Costco's biggest customers.
He was a whale at the store just buying bulk items of baby oil that Costco actually responded
to it.
They corrected the record.
They reached out to TMZ and said specifically that this claim is obviously false because
Costco's don't carry baby oil.
So here we are in 2024.
We have Costco clapping back at Diddy's lawyer, correcting the record about the thousand bottles
of baby oil as reported on TMZ.
This is the type of headline that I would have never guessed in a million years.
But this is the reality we live in.
This is real life.
Now, anytime the market races up like it has over the past year or two, investors are concerned
about where to allocate new capital.
A lot of us have some money from our jobs that we're wanting to put in the market every
couple of weeks as we get paid.
And knowing where to put it becomes more difficult when everything seems to be going to the moon.
Well, Aswath Damodaran looks at the valuation of different companies, and he's done this
for big tech.
He gives a breakdown of where he sees value and where he doesn't.
I see the fact that these are the companies everybody wants to flock to.
But in the last few months, we've had reminders with each of these companies about the weakest
links.
With Nvidia, it was around the earnings announcement, which is you saw how high expectations have
been set and what looked like a good earnings report turned out to be a disappointment.
With Nvidia, he notes the power of expectations, that Nvidia had incredible earnings.
Every single metric of the company was going to the moon.
But the stock price didn't budge because of the power of expectations.
No matter how good a company is, if it's priced with even better expectations, the stock will
likely stay flat.
With Apple, we've lived from upgrade to upgrade now, 16 upgrades.
And I don't know why we're surprised.
One upgrade measures up to expectation, the next one doesn't.
With Apple, he notes the consensus right now is that the upgrade cycle is less and less
exciting every single cycle.
Now, there's a lot of people thinking that this one's going to be extra exciting because
of AI, that may be the case.
But Apple hasn't even put that in their devices.
So it's still a little bit more muted than we'd like.
With Google, we're still waiting for the next big business.
They still make so much of their money from the search box.
He is correct in noting that Google's search engine makes up the huge majority of their
revenue and operating income.
It's true that there's a weak spot or a bare thesis for every company.
But he turns his attention to one in particular, one company that he thinks is vastly overvalued
in this group.
I mean, rather than overvalued or undervalued, let's talk about investing odds.
If investing is a game of odds, with Nvidia, the odds are against you because of how high
a price you pay.
With Apple, the odds might be even odds.
With Alphabet and Meta, I think the odds are still with you because to the extent that
these companies can pull off something outside their core businesses, you're going to get
the bonus from that.
So he thinks Google and Meta are the best buys right now.
He thinks that Apple's neutral and Nvidia is a negative.
And he goes on to stress the type of odds you're betting on when you're investing in
Nvidia at this price point.
Now I'm biased on this point because I obviously agree with Aswath on this one.
I think Nvidia is a scary stock to be in right now for a couple of reasons.
While it's true that companies like Costco have a higher P.E. ratio than Nvidia and slower
growth, many people may point to that and say, hey, look, Costco is a far more expensive
company than Nvidia.
It's at a higher valuation and it has slower growth.
The big thing about Costco, though, is the steadiness of the company.
The revenue growth didn't happen overnight.
It wasn't an occurrence that came out of some marvelous invention.
It wasn't some new technology.
It's been proven time over time for literally decades.
Three to four decades now, Costco has been steadily increasing revenue year over year.
The map shows this over time.
It's really remarkable to see the consistency of the company.
And Costco makes the majority of its profits not by its revenue growth, but by its membership.
If you look at the membership growth, it's even more steady than the revenue.
The membership growth is how they make profits.
So Costco is at a high valuation, but it's a predictable company with a predictable outlook.
When you have a company that has a higher degree of predictability, you can lower the
With Nvidia, investors can't argue through the history of the company that this one is
as predictable as a company like Costco.
And it trades at a rather high valuation, 44 Ford P.E. ratio and a 1.5 percent free
cash flow yield.
So the free cash flow yield is very low.
The P.E. ratio is high.
And when we look at Nvidia, you'll notice a very different story over its history.
There is volatility in the revenue profile.
There are huge ebbs and flows.
There's massive cyclicality.
And there is, of course, the gigantic one-time spike from 2023.
Investors that extrapolate out the growth of Nvidia are extrapolating out that they
won't have the same type of history that they have in the future, that no longer will Nvidia,
this hardware maker, be a cyclical company, that they're going to build out tools of subscription-based
and Coda and other software programs that will remove the historical cyclicality of
the company.
And although that could be true, it's not nearly as predictable as a company like Costco.
And this is why it's important to look at more than just P.E. ratios and free cash flow
yields.
Trying to assess the durability, the ongoing predictability of the business and the competitive
landscape is more important.
Now, again, like I said, I'm biased on this subject.
Just two months ago, I came out with a video saying that I think that the A.I. bubble is
about to pop, that there's so much investments going into A.I. without any visible return,
and Nvidia is the poster child of the company benefiting from A.I. investments without returns.
So I thought that Nvidia is at a point now where the valuation is so high, there's so
much expected of the company, that no longer are we going to see the massive guides up
like we have through the past.
And this has been proven true through one earnings report.
Now, I don't know if this is going to continue, but so far, I hold the exact same view.
To me, the biggest concerns with Nvidia is the rapid growth, reliance on a one-time boom
in technology through A.I. and the historical volatility.
With Aswath Damodaran, it's mostly based off of what he calls the betting odds with the
implied expectations.
Well, I mean, but I'm, I'm, I want to address it as, as an investment to make because I,
you know, at 34 times, it's cheaper than it, than it has been for, for certain.
Secondly, we've heard from Jensen Wong recently, you know, as I don't know, within even the
last couple of weeks about the great demand that the company continues to see.
They have by all accounts what, you know, many would suggest to be not just a first
mover advantage, but in fact, a moat because of their installed base, much like we talk
about Apple.
Now before we get to Aswath's answer for this, we can interject and just bring up a few points.
First of all, he brings up the PE ratio to note the low valuation.
And this again is such a myopic view.
PE ratios are based on the next 12 months of earnings.
The next four earnings reports, analysts get together.
They predict what they think the next four quarters will look like.
And investors use that to judge purchasing a company trading at 30 plus times their next
four quarters.
So you're looking out 30 years and judging what that company's worth based on the next
four quarters.
It's just not enough.
You need way more context and history to judge buying a company where you're pricing in 30
years of earnings.
The other point is comparing the moat of Nvidia to Apple, which I think is just frankly wrong.
Nvidia does not have the same moat as Apple, and I would argue against anyone that tries
to make that claim.
Nvidia offers a very good product.
They are the best at what they do.
The chip architecture is far beyond what other people have done.
But we also said the same thing for Intel just 10 years ago until Apple stole their
employees, their best engineers, and built out Apple Silicon, which doubled their performance
within two years.
So we've seen this story of hardware makers be surpassed by other hardware makers in the
future.
If you steal the right talent, you can build the best chips.
If you make the right investments, you can surpass the leader.
Nvidia is the leader right now, but that does not give them a sustainable, unbreakable moat
in the way that Apple has done.
Apple has a moat not because they're the best at creating iPhones, but because they have
the ecosystem.
The ecosystem of software and their massive install base makes it virtually impossible
for someone else to come in and surpass them.
They'd have to create an entire app store on top of a phone, which is impossible to
do for new entrants.
That's why companies like Amazon, with the Amazon Fire phone, could not get enough developers
on their device.
So when looking at the moat analysis between Apple and Nvidia, I think Apple's moat right
now is significantly wider than Nvidia's.
Now Aswath takes a different approach.
He doesn't try to contest any of these points.
What if Nvidia is just cheap on a PE ratio basis?
What if Nvidia has an Apple-like moat?
Even in that scenario, Nvidia is overvalued, according to Aswath.
That would mean that you would need a trillion dollars in revenues and 70% margins to be
delivered 10 years from now, reverse engineering from the $3 trillion market cap.
So even if you took every word that Jensen Wang takes as the truth and you build it in,
I still have a tough time getting to $3 trillion.
I mean, this is a company that, if you look at the current numbers, has to have immense
growth and maintain 70% operating margins to deliver what you paid already up front
as a price.
That's what I mean about investing odds being against you.
You price this company to be the most amazing company of all time.
What's the upside left?
If it's just amazing rather than the most amazing company, that's a disappointment.
So I think this is something you're going to see the back and forth on in terms of expectations,
but the expectations at some point have to get reset.
So I agree with Aswath here.
There is upside for Nvidia, but the odds are against you.
Now, moving on, we get to this headline that there's a new survey showing that 73% of Amazon
workers are considering quitting after a five-day in-office mandate.
Amazon workers have until January before they'll be expected to be in corporate offices five
days a week, and they are enforcing this through scanning the badges.
So Amazon's going to make sure their employees are actually going into the office every single
day unless they have a reasonable excuse.
And of course, employees are not happy about this.
In a recent survey of 2,585 Amazon employees, an anonymous job report review site, Blind,
73% said that they are considering looking for a new job following CEO Andy Jassy's recent
memo announcing a full-time return to office.
Conversations on Blind tend to be critical of employers.
So I do like in this article that they point out that this survey, even though it looks
really gloomy, 73% of employees are considering quitting now after this statement, they
also point out that this is kind of a complainer's website.
You go to the website Blind not to give glowing reviews of your employer and how much you
love your boss and company, you kind of go there to complain in the first place.
So what this is called with surveying is sample bias.
You're looking at a group of employees that are already heavily biased to the negative.
But either way, there's a lot of employees obviously unhappy with this move.
They say that 80% of Amazon professionals polled reported that they know of a colleague
considering looking for another job because of the announcement.
If I was to critique Amazon, I believe that they made a mistake in only doing a negative.
They only did a negative with this change.
There's no positive you can look at from the employee perspective.
Employees are losing autonomy and flexibility with their schedule, and as far as they can
tell they're getting nothing in return.
If Amazon would have coupled this with a small pay increase, saying we're going to raise
That would have been small, but it would have been something to show, hey, we're requiring
you to come into the office and we're going to pay you a little bit more.
There's some redeeming quality to soften the blow, but Amazon announced this news as only
a negative, and I think that was their biggest problem.
Now there's some analysts saying that this strict attendance policy is a filter mechanism
to naturally have the people quit that you want gone from the company.
People that will complain about the schedule, that they don't want to be really bought in
with Amazon, they're going to be the first to leave the company.
So ultimately, we'll get to see what happens with this policy.
There's going to be a lot of eyes on it, whether they keep it over the next coming years or
whether they reverse it.
Now, moving on, we get to the story of Sam Altman and OpenAI and the continued overall
confusing disaster the operations of this company have been.
It's really been a mess overall, and they can't seem to keep drama out of their company.
The latest move is a massive shakeup of the company's executive team in combination at
the same time from the company transitioning from a nonprofit to a profit company.
But overall, the story is one that really makes me feel more confident in my position
of just not trusting Sam Altman.
Now, there's not many people I say that about that I just don't trust, but I think I have
enough actual information here to make that assessment.
The first red flag for trusting Sam Altman, I believe was the answer he gave to Congress
on why he's working on OpenAI.
You make a lot of money, do you?
I make, no, I paid enough for health insurance, I have no equity in OpenAI.
Really?
Yeah.
That's interesting.
You need a lawyer.
I need a what?
You need a lawyer or an agent.
I'm doing this because I love it.
Now, it is true that Sam Altman has made money previous to OpenAI, so he could feasibly be
doing this only because he loves it, but it just strikes me as sounding a little too good
to be true.
It's like he's trying to paint himself as someone that's only charitable, and he has
no ambition of making money in this company at all, which is very difficult for me to
believe.
It also didn't help that about a day after that meeting, there was a video that surfaced
showing him driving this car that's worth like a million dollars.
This is not the profile of someone that's doing something with no ambition of making
money.
Now again, there's no big thing that he's done to cause an extreme amount of criticism,
but overall, there's just a lot of little red flags, things that I noticed with Sam
Altman's history.
For example, the company that he's running, OpenAI, that he says he has no ambition of
making money in it, that he just does it because he loves it, is now transitioning
from a non-profit to a for-profit company.
That's not typically something you do if you don't want to make money with it, but maybe
this is a necessary change for OpenAI.
The company will be more attractive to investors, and apparently OpenAI does need funding.
They need more money as this company is currently unprofitable.
One thing that happened during this time period was OpenAI executives are seemingly far less
impressed with the plans.
On Wednesday afternoon, OpenAI's chief technology officers, we have the CTO of the company,
the VP of research, and the chief research officer all announced they would be leaving
the company.
So we have three executives all announcing that they're departing the company on the
exact same day, and the same day the company announces that it's going to a for-profit
company.
Sam Altman took to Twitter to explain that these changes are normal.
These are run-of-the-mill changes that every business goes through.
Leadership changes are a natural part of companies, especially companies that grow so quickly
and are so demanding.
This is a form of rewriting history or gaslighting the reader.
Changes like this are not normal for any company.
I've worked at startup companies, and it is true that changes in leadership are a natural
part of companies, but having three top executives all quit on the same day during the news of
a major announcement is not the natural part of companies.
That's not something that normally happens in the course of business.
That is, in fact, the exact opposite.
It's unnatural.
It's unusual.
It should draw attention and perhaps some inquiry of what happened.
Instead of Sam Altman being forthright and actually explaining what happened, the reasons
they're leaving, what's going on, and how he's going to fix it, he instead takes the
route of trying to downplay it and minimize it.
He did give the caveat here that, quote, I obviously won't pretend it's natural for this
one to be so abrupt, but we are not a normal company.
This excuse makes no sense.
OpenAI is not a normal company.
What does that even mean?
What is implied by that?
Because they're making an unusual technology?
There's lots of companies making the exact same technology.
Microsoft is working on it.
You have Meta making their own version of an LLM, their own version of AI.
You have Amazon making the same thing.
And of course, you have Google making the same thing.
And none of them have had multiple of their top executives quit all on the same day.
So again, instead of remaining transparent with what's actually going on with the company,
he tries to downplay it, minimize it, and remain opaque.
And overall, it's just the same story again and again with Sam Altman.
There's some disastrous thing that happens to people close to him.
If you recall, it wasn't that long ago that these same people that quit were the ones
that fired him.
The board of OpenAI canned Sam Altman, and then investors complained, and he was rehired
within five days.
On November 17th, 2023, OpenAI's board of directors ousted the company's founder and
chief executive, Sam Altman, after the board had no confidence in his leadership.
The removal was caused by concerns about his handling of artificial intelligence, safety,
and allegations of abusive behavior.
Is that just abnormal because OpenAI is an abnormal company?
Or is there something else going on?
The product that the OpenAI team has created is great, but the problems with the management
are apparent, and I think they're going to continue as long as Sam Altman is running
the company.
I predict that these ongoing shakeups, the revolving door of executives, the problems
with employees close to him, are going to continue as long as he's around.
Now that's going to be it for this episode.
I hope you enjoyed, and I'll see you in the next one.
