Parkside Performance 12V Hammer Drill vs Milwaukee M12 Sub Compact SDS-Plus Hammer

The Tech Toolbox
1 follower
Sep 26, 2024
"Parkside named its new Performance model ""12V cordless hammer drill"". Milwaukee calls the M12 CH model ""sub compact SDS plus hammer"". Well, lets see if there is any real difference between those two.
Parkside Performance PBHAP 12 A1 vs Milwaukee M12 CH-0."
Hello Parkside lovers and welcome to another Parkside vs Milwaukee battle.
In today's video I will compare the reputable Milwaukee M12 CH hammer drill and it's brand
new counterpart, the Parkside Performance PBHA P12 A1.
Visually the tools look quite identical, they are quite identical in characteristics also
and that's the main reason why I'm comparing them.
Maybe Parkside is copying Milwaukee design, maybe it's paying a license for it, or probably
something else, I don't know, I don't have internal information, as you might know I
am not in the best relationship with Lidl.
Without further ado, let me share with you some of the characteristics of the tools.
Both of them are rated 1.1 joules of impact energy per stroke.
Both of them have absolutely the same no load rotation speed, ranging from 0 up to 900 rpm
and they share absolutely the same maximum impact rate of 6575 beats per minute.
The drilling capacity again is the same, in steel 10 mm and in concrete 13 mm.
Without a battery Parkside is 1.3 kg, while Milwaukee is a little bit heavier, 1.4 kg.
The two machines are equipped with an SDS plus chuck.
Parkside comes with an attachable keyless drill chuck for round shank drill bits and
some other accessories, such as some SDS plus drill bits and some screwdriver bits.
Milwaukee on the other side, depending on the configuration, might come with an additional
hand lever.
You can see the extended part of the body, where you can attach it, unfortunately it's
really a rare accessory.
Parkside is not offering anything similar.
Milwaukee features two work modes, drilling and hammer drilling, while Parkside has an
additional third mode, chiseling.
Let's hear their voices in the loudest work mode, hammer drilling.
I think Milwaukee is a little bit louder.
The machines are equipped with a variable trigger, but on Parkside it's combined with
soft start and that makes the things really annoying.
On Parkside the variable trigger is far less responsive than on Milwaukee.
Let me demonstrate you a properly working variable trigger.
Take a look at the variable trigger of Parkside.
It's more like a two speed trigger than a variable trigger.
Not to mention that combining this with soft start, working in all three modes is completely
idiotic.
This thing comes with screwdriver bits, well, try having a proper control over the screwing
process with soft start and some poorly responsive trigger.
I really hope Parkside engineers ain't screwing their girlfriends in the same fashion
as they develop power tools, the pool girls.
The internals of the tools and you can clearly see the difference.
The hammering mechanism of Milwaukee is self-contained, while on Parkside it's supported by the outside
plastics.
The design is really close to the 20V green Parkside hammer drill.
The design on Milwaukee is completely different and I'm pretty sure it will be way more durable.
As usual, Parkside is using brushless motor without Hall sensor.
Milwaukee is using a brushless motor with Hall sensor.
I like the design of the control board on Parkside, it has a nicely sized radiator.
Same goes for Milwaukee, enormous radiator just below the MOSFETs.
As you know, the hammering mechanisms generate a lot of heat.
So I guess if you're using Parkside for too long, you probably might encounter some problems
with the plastics.
Being encapsulated in aluminium, the hammering mechanism of Milwaukee will have way better
heat dissipation.
Of course, the tools are not intended for drilling 3m thick concrete wall.
So I guess for some moderate usage, Parkside will perform perfectly fine.
Let's do some drilling tests.
I have attached 2.5kg to each drill.
This weight will be the only force pushing the drills downwards.
I will be using my finger only for squeezing the trigger and guiding the drills.
I will be using 10cm long Parkside drill bit that is 8mm in diameter.
This is a 15cm thick solid granite.
Another day, another drill bit.
Today I will be using 20cm long drill bit manufactured by Bosch, SDS Plus 5X.
Again, 8mm in diameter.
Finally, let's do some more drilling with a 10mm in diameter drill bit, while measuring
the temperature of the machines.
The temperature on Parkside, the highest is about 28 degrees Celsius.
This is after drilling one hole with the 20cm long drill bit.
The battery is fully charged.
After making those 3 holes, the highest temperature on Parkside is about 41-42 degrees Celsius.
And the battery is still at 3 bars.
After making one hole with the 20cm long drill bit, the highest temperature on Milwaukee
is about 30 degrees Celsius.
Its battery is fully charged.
3 holes with Milwaukee and it has a slightly higher temperature, about 45 degrees, where
the mode selecting knob is.
The gearbox.
After making those 3 holes, Milwaukee is on 2 bars out of 4.
But remember that the battery indicator on Milwaukee is more accurate.
It has 4 bars, not only 3, as on Parkside.
Well, as it goes for hammer drilling, the two machines are performing quite equally.
Parkside definitely didn't lie about the impact energy their machine is delivering.
It's the same as on Milwaukee, 1.1 Joules.
As it goes for longevity, Milwaukee has a gearbox and a hammering mechanism enclosed
in aluminum casing and most definitely will outlive the mechanisms of Parkside.
Of course, the price of Milwaukee is almost 4 times higher.
I have to admit, I am surprised from the performance model.
It's doing better than its green brother.
I was expecting them to be quite equal.
Except for the gearbox, other drawbacks on the new model are the soft start and the off-load
trigger.
Parkside needs to do some work on those.
Well, I think I've managed to cover all the important aspects of the new machine.
I was thinking of doing some chiseling and normal drilling, but now I see no point.
If you find this video informative, you know what to do.
Bye for now guys and see you soon.
